Campus Mafia (New/Newish Players Welcome) - Page 7

On November 05 2014 13:07 sicklucker wrote:
elvis drop this its not productive and your not gonna convince anyone because your going against the logic of thousands of mafia games. Theres also this. Theres a 66% chance that there is a town watcher in the game heres a description of this role

Every night, you may choose a player other than yourself to watch. You will learn the names of every player that visits your target the same night. You win with the town.

So all the town has to do is keep checking him and when hes role blocked or killed we know who it is and we get a 1 for 1 trade (they cant leave a confirmed cop in the game) no matter what unless they fake claim cop or something crazy.

This is my first mafia game and I noticed this so im sure everyone has figured it out I know Breshke already said the same thing indirectly about his horrible vote. Anyway move on. Think im gonna head to bed

On November 07 2014 12:07 Elvis! wrote:
well if you say you agree 100% I kinda think you agree with everything up until that point am I wrong?

On November 07 2014 12:14 Elvis! wrote:
(There's a hefty discussion going on in the scum QT I assume, since there's easy questions and noone answers)

On November 07 2014 14:55 kushm4sta wrote:
dun lynch me bros

On November 07 2014 21:52 Serejai wrote:
Immaterial is really bothering me.

On one hand I think he's scum and want to lynch him. On the other hand he's going to be modkilled, so that would be a wasted lynch.

Or is he? Maybe he is scum and he's going to be replaced instead of modkilled, in which case the game would pretty much be over because we would have just let a very obvious scum live two days in a row for no good reason.

There's also the chance that he decides to show up 5 minutes before voting ends to cast his vote, in which case that kind of solidifies he's scum but it would be too late for us to do anything about it at that point.

On November 08 2014 04:51 Superbia wrote:
Neither you nor Serejai are getting lynched today. Kelsier is getting lynched today.

Kush should start doing shit tomorrow or he should have himself get MKed or replaced.

Imma should get MKed or replaced.

Elvis town.

Serejai town.

sicklucker leaning scum. The fact that I can't resonate with the logic behind his posts makes it incredibly hard for me to read him at this point in time. Seems very fixated on claiming town and being read town, which is why I'm reading him as possible scum.

batsnacks maybe town. Confirmed town if Kelsier flips scum.

Sentinel still scum. Scum read him d1, since then he has: 1. lynched the cop. 2. done nothing. Lynch for tomorrow.

FecalFeast still leaning scum. Hasn't really done much today except change vote from kelsier to a lurker (kush), which does not hold up well if kelsier ends up flipping scum. Why the fuck are you going after a lurker again on d2? No information to be gained from the lynch, no real reason behind the lynch, easy target. Priority target (alongside Sentinel) if kelsier flips scum.

Breshke leaning scum. Pushes on lurker (kush), which is scummy for the reasons described under FF. This post is also scummy or at best donkey town:


Let me get this straight: it's revealed that cop is being lynched a few minutes before EoD and the right number of people don't move their votes, so the cop ends up dying. Do you think this is fucking random or something? Scum had so much to gain from that lynch. Analyzing the votes is the way to gain information, especially in this case. For sure there was scum on LS. For sure there was scum who did not change their votes (in time). Guess what? You were among those who had their votes on LS in the end. This combined with the fact that you're basically telling us "not to analyze the votes too much" is pretty fucking scummy. Your tunnel on kush today is also a waste of time because we have essentially no information regarding kush.

On November 08 2014 05:09 Superbia wrote:


This is the massive problem with leaving Kelsier alive. We don't know for sure if he's a correct lynch, but he's going to be an easy lynch for the rest of the game. His presence will FUCK US UP during MYLO/LYLO. I'm not convinced that sicklucker will flip scum. Moreover, we get very little information from his lynch, because he has been in the game for essentially 1 day. Moreover, he was not part of the votes yesterday, which gives us even less information. Not the correct lynch. Lynch should be Kelsier.

On November 08 2014 05:10 Elvis! wrote:
But Breshke is he hurting town atm?
Why not lynch him later, we can't lynch them all at once?
Also what do you think about his excuse OR him being lazy town OR him being lurking town OR him being lazy PR OR him being lurking PR.
Don't you feel the possibility of a mislynch is too high?

On November 08 2014 05:10 sicklucker wrote:
Bresh what do you think of a scum team of kush Serejai + one. Who would your one be?

On November 08 2014 05:18 Superbia wrote:


I'm honestly expecting him to be replaced if he doesn't become more active. Also lurkers come out of their shells when the players reduce because there is no way to hide. You can't lurk yourself to victory regardless of alignment. It's a losing strategy for either alignment.

On November 08 2014 05:15 Elvis! wrote:
Breshke and Superbia:
Both your targets have barely posted.
Both of them are easy lynches later on.
Both of them don't hurt town atm and are less likely to hurt town than sicklucker.

Please let us lynch sicklucker, a person where you should look at his filter again, try to find out his alignment and then decide.
We can discuss in which order we lynch KSC/kush tomorrow and see if they were just lurking.

On November 08 2014 05:20 Elvis! wrote:
He might just be agree with me because he wants to pocket me. He also posted earlier "wagons are fun", which might be the point in time where he decided to bus his scum mate.
I won't have his posts influence my vote.
If he wants to bus his teammate, he can.
So atm I read him leaning scum.