no they were quite ok. I'm quite happy with what I said.

Unexplainable townread and refusal to vote mafia? Yep happy with that
On Palmar for no good reason, weakly on day 2? Yep seems pretty valid.
Overdefence of Caller into voting him? Not at all unhappy with this, seems pretty fine
Mafia VE has threatened to shoot people for accusing him before? Well that's just fact
Generic 3-suspect post which isn't properly followed up? Yes, also quite a decent point

None of these things are bad at all. I probably shouldn't talk about them or I'll end up believing them again.

Alakaslam

United States17336 Posts

May 12 2014 14:29 GMT

#1888

On May 12 2014 17:54 Palmar wrote:
If I'm mafia I would be trying to win the game. If I'm town, you're equally guilty as me of not trying to win the game by being a whiny baby about some random votes. I'm not even voting you atm, I'm trying to kill poofter for bullshit shot.

Oh and did you see his defense "It happened 3 days ago so you can't lynch me for it anymore". I was like "say what bro?"

Benghazi?

What difference does it make?!??

Palmar confirmed republican

VisceraEyes

United States21170 Posts

May 12 2014 14:30 GMT

#1889

Those are all bad reasons because you fail to consider that I could and have and DID do those things as town. There's a townie motivation for everything you accused me of, but you ignore that fact and just call me scum for it. THIS is why I was convinced that it made you scum - because I thought a town marv would have considered a townie motivation before trying to get people to lynch me.

If you're town, clearly I was mistaken. But yes, your reasons are bad. Oh, only scum make "generic 3-suspect posts" and don't "properly follow up" on them? Okay, so that's a bad point. Mafia VE has threatened to shoot people for accusing him huh? So has third party VE and so has town VE! So that's a terrible point too! Having an early opinion on players after giving supporting reasoning for it is absolutely a surefire scum-tell isn't it marv? That definitely WASN'T a terrible point, nope. Oh wait, yeah it was.

Like, I don't care if you start believing them again because I'll just fucking dunk you if you come after me with this shit again. I'm telling you the reasons are bad, now, when I think you're town because the reasons ARE FUCKING BAD MARV.

VisceraEyes

United States21170 Posts

May 12 2014 14:34 GMT

#1890

Oh, also you made kinda a big deal about trusting Fool's townreads. I was a townread of Fool. Another reason I was suspicious of you.

Palmar

Iceland22632 Posts

May 12 2014 14:40 GMT

#1891

::::::::::::::..........::::::::::::...::...::::::...:::.:..:::::.......:::..............::..::...:::::::::..:::....:::::::::.....::::::

we should probably not lynch VE, he may be scum but w/e

VisceraEyes

United States21170 Posts

May 12 2014 14:43 GMT

#1892

On May 12 2014 23:40 Palmar wrote:
::::::::::::::..........::::::::::::...::...::::::...:::.:..:::::.......:::..............::..::...:::::::::..:::....:::::::::.....::::::

we should probably not lynch VE, he may be scum but w/e

I'll probably regret this, but can you explain what you mean?

VisceraEyes

United States21170 Posts

May 12 2014 14:44 GMT

#1893

Like if you think I'm scum, why would you /not/ lynch me?

Alakaslam

United States17336 Posts

May 12 2014 14:48 GMT

#1894

Just lynch ace

What objection do you have?

marvellosity

United Kingdom36160 Posts

May 12 2014 16:15 GMT

#1895

On May 12 2014 23:34 VisceraEyes wrote:
Oh, also you made kinda a big deal about trusting Fool's townreads. I was a townread of Fool. Another reason I was suspicious of you.

that's kinda understandable I guess, although I don't remember seeing a strong townread of you in his filter. More QT stuffs? In any case, I've also now gone against Fool's townread of poofter, don't forget :p

marvellosity

United Kingdom36160 Posts

May 12 2014 16:17 GMT

#1896

On May 12 2014 23:30 VisceraEyes wrote:
Those are all bad reasons because you fail to consider that I could and have and DID do those things as town. There's a townie motivation for everything you accused me of, but you ignore that fact and just call me scum for it. THIS is why I was convinced that it made you scum - because I thought a town marv would have considered a townie motivation before trying to get people to lynch me.

If you're town, clearly I was mistaken. But yes, your reasons are bad. Oh, only scum make "generic 3-suspect posts" and don't "properly follow up" on them? Okay, so that's a bad point. Mafia VE has threatened to shoot people for accusing him huh? So has third party VE and so has town VE! So that's a terrible point too! Having an early opinion on players after giving supporting reasoning for it is absolutely a surefire scum-tell isn't it marv? That definitely WASN'T a terrible point, nope. Oh wait, yeah it was.

Like, I don't care if you start believing them again because I'll just fucking dunk you if you come after me with this shit again. I'm telling you the reasons are bad, now, when I think you're town because the reasons ARE FUCKING BAD MARV.

Anyone can do almost anything as town or as mafia, it's a matter of interpretation, and my interpretation of those events were not unfair nor bad.

What a silly reason to call any reason to call reasons for lynching people bad.

"Can VE do these scummy things as town too?"

Well of course he fucking can. But obviously on balance I considered that the scummy things made you scum rather than town. Woe is you or woe is me. Delete as applicable.

In short, no u.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36160 Posts

May 12 2014 16:23 GMT

#1897

no-one is saying to lynch VE right now.

Also btw, if you are mafia this game, I am never letting you slide by in any game making no effort again, I will policy you every single time.

Mostly making this post so I can quote it in future games.

To those of you reading this quote in future games: yes, I would absolutely policy Palmar when I'm town, as evidenced by the fact that I am writing this as town in this game. So you better believe this vote is serious. I want Palmar dead today, and that's that. Actually policy lynching Palmar is not alignment indicative, so you better just accept I'm doing it and move on. Thank you for your cooperation.