Newbie Mini Mafia LV - Page 60

On May 09 2014 07:00 iamperfection wrote:

Day 4

mtamburini the Helix Worshiper is dead.

You have 48 hours

On May 09 2014 07:22 MysteryMeat1 wrote:
Its pretty dangerous to assume there is only 3 mafia. And i dont' mind mtam's ploy. He survives a lynch, and gets roleblocked. Pretty good for a vanilla town. I like how you say dfs is indefensible when i'm the one who brought up that dfs was mafia, and i've pushed the hardest for him since the very begining. Throwing someone under the bus, when i have absolutely nothing to gain?

On May 09 2014 10:53 MysteryMeat1 wrote:
@bunnies, why would you roleblock the person you were going to kill?

On May 09 2014 12:08 MysteryMeat1 wrote:
well for now confirmed town would be

bunnies
me
yell0w

fenced
epi
eden

scum
dfs
ahs

On May 09 2014 11:43 MysteryMeat1 wrote:
ya, im really wondering why i was the one who got roleblocked. I thought it would make sense if they are going to kill him, but now im soo lost as to why they used it on me again...

On May 09 2014 16:08 dfs wrote:

NOW you're wondering why you were roleblocked? Because during the day you were pretty convinced you were the best target.

Also, that guy...

On May 08 2014 11:11 Eden1892 wrote:
You should shoot Yell0w because his play has been cowardly, which is a mafia trait. He's been very reactive; he only gets involved when someone else is accusing him or voting for him, he doesn't push for his candidate to get killed and he hasn't shown any initiative in trying to find mafia. He's the only player who has never voted for a player who's flipped yet, which is a huge black mark in my book because it betrays a reticence to be on the record. Town don't have a particular motive to be on the record, but scum have a powerful incentive NOT to be on the record, as the fewer the number of confirmed players they've weighed in on, the more flexible they can be in their search for a lynch. Furthermore, the reason he's been off the record so far is that he keeps parking his vote on outlying candidates (dfs last night, mtamburini d2). People who are consistently on outliers, like Yell0w is, and who aren't arguing for their candidate strongly and making cases for them, like Yell0w hasn't, are more likely to be scum, because again, they don't want to be on the record. It's forgivable to be off the record if you're pushing your cases hard and simply not convincing people. It's not forgivable to be off the record and not making an effort to get on the record by getting your preferred candidate lynched. Yell0w is in the latter category, and it's time to stop forgiving him.

My second choice is ahswtini because I don't feel his votes have matched up with his story. The main thing I'm noticing is that while he voted to kill dravernor late, the whole time he was arguing for meat and dfs to be killed. dfs would have been a viable third wagon if he had switched, but he didn't. meat was a viable second wagon until the end, and ahswtini wasn't on it at all. I don't understand why he would name two other players as his main suspects and then vote for dravernor instead. But my issue is that I don't understand it as either alignment. As town, why is he on someone he doesn't name as his 1st or 2nd suspect, when both of them were viable counterwagons? As mafia, why did he kill his teammate instead of sticking with his story and trying to kill one of the others? I guess it's possible ahs/meat/dfs/drav was the scumteam, but I don't buy that at all. ahs is also the least townie of the non-Yell0w others in the game; I think Eden/Epishade/bunnies are all obvtown at this point, meat's probably town, and dfs is probably town because Yell0w was pushing him so hard over drav. So by POE if you don't kill Yell0w I'd rather ahs over the rest.

But I really want Yell0w.