• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EDT 06:10
CEST 12:10
KST 19:10
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
BGE Stara Zagora 2025: Info & Preview27Code S RO12 Preview: GuMiho, Bunny, SHIN, ByuN3The Memories We Share - Facing the Final(?) GSL47Code S RO12 Preview: Cure, Zoun, Solar, Creator4[ASL19] Finals Preview: Daunting Task30
Community News
Weekly Cups (June 2-8): herO doubles down1[BSL20] ProLeague: Bracket Stage & Dates9GSL Ro4 and Finals moved to Sunday June 15th13Weekly Cups (May 27-June 1): ByuN goes back-to-back0EWC 2025 Regional Qualifier Results26
StarCraft 2
General
The SCII GOAT: A statistical Evaluation StarCraft 1 & 2 Added to Xbox Game Pass Jim claims he and Firefly were involved in match-fixing CN community: Firefly accused of suspicious activities How does the number of casters affect your enjoyment of esports?
Tourneys
Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond) Bellum Gens Elite: Stara Zagora 2025 $3,500 WardiTV European League 2025 Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament SOOPer7s Showmatches 2025
Strategy
[G] Darkgrid Layout Simple Questions Simple Answers [G] PvT Cheese: 13 Gate Proxy Robo
Custom Maps
[UMS] Zillion Zerglings
External Content
Mutation # 477 Slow and Steady Mutation # 476 Charnel House Mutation # 475 Hard Target Mutation # 474 Futile Resistance
Brood War
General
FlaSh Witnesses SCV Pull Off the Impossible vs Shu BW General Discussion StarCraft & BroodWar Campaign Speedrun Quest BGH auto balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/ Will foreigners ever be able to challenge Koreans?
Tourneys
[ASL19] Grand Finals NA Team League 6/8/2025 [Megathread] Daily Proleagues [BSL20] ProLeague Bracket Stage - Day 2
Strategy
I am doing this better than progamers do. [G] How to get started on ladder as a new Z player
Other Games
General Games
Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread What do you want from future RTS games? Armies of Exigo - YesYes? Nintendo Switch Thread Path of Exile
Dota 2
Official 'what is Dota anymore' discussion
League of Legends
LiquidLegends to reintegrate into TL.net
Heroes of the Storm
Simple Questions, Simple Answers Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Heroes of StarCraft mini-set
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread Vanilla Mini Mafia
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Vape Nation Thread European Politico-economics QA Mega-thread
Fan Clubs
Maru Fan Club Serral Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Korean Music Discussion [Manga] One Piece
Sports
2024 - 2025 Football Thread Formula 1 Discussion NHL Playoffs 2024
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List
Blogs
A Better Routine For Progame…
TrAiDoS
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Heero Yuy & the Tax…
KrillinFromwales
I was completely wrong ab…
jameswatts
Need Your Help/Advice
Glider
Trip to the Zoo
micronesia
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 40753 users

[N][M] Normal Ass Normal Game

Forum Index > TL Mafia
Post a Reply
Normal
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 09 2014 08:41 GMT
#44
/in
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 09 2014 08:42 GMT
#45
We lynch town D1
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 09 2014 09:27 GMT
#48
On April 09 2014 18:26 geript wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 09 2014 18:00 Eden1892 wrote:
On April 09 2014 11:47 kushm4sta wrote:
eden a girl?

deductive reasoning skills: expert

It's ok. Despite being heterosexual he's quiet afraid of the opposite sex. Marv's the same way but heterosexually challenged; he thinks they have cooties still.


SO much wat
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
Last Edited: 2014-04-09 18:02:18
April 09 2014 18:01 GMT
#55
On April 09 2014 20:08 Promethelax wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 09 2014 18:27 Vivax wrote:
On April 09 2014 18:26 geript wrote:
On April 09 2014 18:00 Eden1892 wrote:
On April 09 2014 11:47 kushm4sta wrote:
eden a girl?

deductive reasoning skills: expert

It's ok. Despite being heterosexual he's quiet afraid of the opposite sex. Marv's the same way but heterosexually challenged; he thinks they have cooties still.


SO much wat


Kush is bad with girls. Marv is bad with girls but also a homosexual so it is acceptable for him to be bad with girls,

I thought it was pretty clear.


Ok, so heterosexually challenged is the new political correct word for gay? We don't learn for mafia we learn for life.

Also huge lol at dat sentinel post.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
Last Edited: 2014-04-14 10:21:09
April 14 2014 10:20 GMT
#105
It's becoming so tedious to get a game filled.

Hope we both roll town Koshiboy :>

(Not asking to be town, I still need to hone my mafia skillz and now I got 2 weeks lotsa time)
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 16 2014 19:39 GMT
#518
Current status of reads. Reasoning pending, but ask me about a specific one if you want me to explain it first:

Townies: Koshi, Djagu, Cava, thrawn, (~Kush fwiw)

Today's lynch candidates (by PoE and cause there is some stuff I don't like): FT, Omni, OTW, OO, mderg

Also HI GUYS =D . Rejoice that you got me and not that crazy grush fac-simile
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 16 2014 19:45 GMT
#521
On April 17 2014 04:41 OneThousandWords wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 17 2014 04:39 Vivax wrote:
Current status of reads. Reasoning pending, but ask me about a specific one if you want me to explain it first:

Townies: Koshi, Djagu, Cava, thrawn, (~Kush fwiw)

Today's lynch candidates (by PoE and cause there is some stuff I don't like): FT, Omni, OTW, OO, mderg

Also HI GUYS =D . Rejoice that you got me and not that crazy grush fac-simile


Can you elaborate on these....?


Any preferences? Which ones you disagree with? Why so unspecific?
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 16 2014 19:53 GMT
#528
Thrawn if you're here I still got one thing bugging me about you and it's this I would like you to explain:

On April 16 2014 15:49 thrawn2112 wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 16 2014 06:09 FirmTofu wrote:
Djagulingu is fairly unimpressive. His activity is commendable, but altogether useless. Most of his posts are one-liners that seek to aggravate or provoke. I see a lot of unsubstantiated accusations in his filter. He's running around trying to piss everyone off all at once without any attempt at substantive discussion. His focus on his own meta is especially interesting and reflective of an egotistical personality. For that reason, I believe his aggressive behavior in thread so far is due to a heightened sense of superiority rather than something alignment-indicative. That is to say, he'd be acting like a douche whether he was mafia or town.



lmao


On April 16 2014 15:52 thrawn2112 wrote:
lets lynch mderg


You clearly find that post "funny", I suppose cause it's so inconclusive and achieves absolutely nothing saying a lot of stuff which is my opinion about it, why not dig for more and go straight only for mderg?
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 16 2014 19:55 GMT
#532
On April 17 2014 04:50 OneThousandWords wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 17 2014 04:45 Vivax wrote:
On April 17 2014 04:41 OneThousandWords wrote:
On April 17 2014 04:39 Vivax wrote:
Current status of reads. Reasoning pending, but ask me about a specific one if you want me to explain it first:

Townies: Koshi, Djagu, Cava, thrawn, (~Kush fwiw)

Today's lynch candidates (by PoE and cause there is some stuff I don't like): FT, Omni, OTW, OO, mderg

Also HI GUYS =D . Rejoice that you got me and not that crazy grush fac-simile


Can you elaborate on these....?


Any preferences? Which ones you disagree with? Why so unspecific?


Why do I have to be specific? You replaced a player who has said nothing but spam in the thread so I'd like to know why you think what you do so I can see if what you think aligns with what has happened so far, rather than it being a random list of names with no factual basis.


Yeah but you got to have scumreads, right? Townreads? You see the post with my current conclusions about the game and prefer to see me talking about anything I want rather than adjusting your request to your own preferences. Why is that?
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 16 2014 20:36 GMT
#549
On April 17 2014 05:05 mderg wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 17 2014 04:39 Vivax wrote:
Current status of reads. Reasoning pending, but ask me about a specific one if you want me to explain it first:

Townies: Koshi, Djagu, Cava, thrawn, (~Kush fwiw)

Today's lynch candidates (by PoE and cause there is some stuff I don't like): FT, Omni, OTW, OO, mderg

Also HI GUYS =D . Rejoice that you got me and not that crazy grush fac-simile

I´d like to know the reasoning for Cav, thrawn and OTW. To me Cav is null, thrawn is slightly scummy and OTW seems like town.


Nice, that's the reaction I expected from a townie. You get townie points.

I found the reaction Cav displayed towards OTW townie:

I have three posts and you're scumreading me off them. That doesn't make any sense. I'd actually argue, but you have no real information to determine my alignment one way or the other. (Though, in all fairness, I have been somewhat inactive.)


It's firm, it's not apologetic, it's reasonable, aligns with my thoughts. When I see a dude not posting much about the game, I'd rather ask him about something ("Hey read this dude and tell me plz") and not simply point to him as possible scum cause he's not done much.

Solving the game also involves finding townies, not only pointing to possible scum based on little things. That is what scum does, which is also the reason I'm suspicious of OTW, looking over his posts I see quite the reluctance to clear people. Additionally he simply asked me about my list of reads and said "Elaborate", that could easily display a lack of his own opinions.

Ad thrawn: He's lurky as scum. Here he seems reasnably active and calls stuff out he finds scummy, while at the same time doing some simple conversation about other stuff without trying to look tryhard.

There are also things that bug me however and it's the fact that he is kinda focusing on little things rather than the overall picture (on kush and mderg, but I can't tell if it's simply his own way of finding scum) , and the thing with FT's post he simply skipped over, explanation pending.

I'd actually rather put thrawn as a townread in parentheses for now.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 16 2014 20:39 GMT
#550
Mderg can you tell me why you think OTW is town?
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 16 2014 20:47 GMT
#552
On April 17 2014 05:44 mderg wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 17 2014 05:39 Vivax wrote:
Mderg can you tell me why you think OTW is town?

Because he´s pretty much all over the place and every read is has a basis, not that I agree with everything he said. In general this doesn´t seem scummy to me but rather something a town player would do.


Can you specify what you agree and disagree with?
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 16 2014 21:20 GMT
#557
@ OO

PoE AND posts like this:

On April 16 2014 03:46 ObviousOne wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 15 2014 21:23 kushm4sta wrote:
Haven't read newest shit but

Oo why you want to plynch Akaka if you have no problem town reading him?
Why you gotta shit town read thrawn based on bullshit?

I wouldn't say that his activity is the only way to read him and it's subjective anyhow, I basically caught him through POE and that was the best reason I could come up with in Toy Story, he exhibited both behaviors there so I'm going to use the guideline until it no longer works (i.e. he steps up and plays the game). He's a policy lynch because I have no idea what the fuck he is saying 99% of the time. He seems to have the goal of being unreadable in every game he plays and that puts him in my "ok to policy lynch" group because I'd hate to lose to him (again, lol).

re: thrawn, how would you suggest I eliminate people from the lynch based on their behavior if not on some basic first post instinct when the game is like 20 minutes in? I've opened lines of communication when in the past things have been not so great between us, unless I recall incorrectly. The last game we played together I wanted to lynch him and he ended up being town, so I'm trying a new approach so I don't immediately put him in a category labeled "people I want to lynch because I hate"

Gotta re-read after I get some coffee in me. Only other thought I had for the moment is I didn't immediately want to lynch Koshi which is standing out to me. I think he's more actively participating (rather than posting for what looks like the sake of posting) than in other games I've read/played with him in them. Maybe that's some kind of themed-level-Koshi and I haven't seen a normal ass game Koshi in recent memory?


Let's split this into three text blocks. First block is a huge answer about Kaslam. That's ok, that's not my beef, kush asked you a question.
The second block is defensive in my opinion. What is your intention here since according to kush you townread thrawn? Btw point me to what you're replying cause thrawn didn't even ask you anything O_o (I don't think I've missed such a thing while looking for it).
The third block is meh. Says something semi-conclusive, ends up with a question to yourself. You still got trouble getting a conclusion about Koshi?


On April 17 2014 06:00 mderg wrote:
+ Show Spoiler +
On April 15 2014 21:42 OneThousandWords wrote:
Djagulingu, you describe your town play as:

Show nested quote +
My town play is really stalk heavy. I watch all of you. All of you, when you post, when you sleep, when you work, when you eat. I might come out of nowhere with random people to lynch for random reasons. They did come out true though.

I would define my town play as systematic instead of impulsive, I don't care about collateral damage, sharp and decisive over overly cautious.


In this game you have already called 2 people scum for supposed scum slips. Am I to assume that you have now 180° on your own meta so quickly? This doesn't look very systematic to me, it looks like the complete opposite. You jump on people and call them scum without much basis and state that you are helping the town by making a pro-town atmosphere of sophisticated discussion when, instead, you are steering people in a very specific direction on a point of view that seems entirely skewed on pushing an agenda.

I don´t agree with this case on Djagulingu. It´s purely based on Djagu´s self meta which I think is always difficult to base a case on.


+ Show Spoiler +
On April 16 2014 07:23 OneThousandWords wrote:
I also find it odd how Cavalinho has chosen to respond to posts in the thread. His chose his first posts of the game to say hi and that he isn't going to comment on anything because nothing has happened. I find this in and of itself strange. When people first start the game they usually start to converse with people or even talk about policy, however, Cavalinho decided not to have any part of the conversation whatsoever.

Show nested quote +
On April 15 2014 14:36 Cavalinho wrote:
On April 15 2014 14:32 ObviousOne wrote:
On April 15 2014 13:54 Cavalinho wrote:
Hi.

Right on, right on. What you thinking about right now?


Nothing has happened yet.

So...Nothing.


Now, understandably we do not know the circumstances and I'd like to hear more from him but then he returns to the thread after quite some time to post, well, nothing. His only real post is a post to jump on discrediting OmniEulogy (whether justly or not).

Show nested quote +
On April 16 2014 04:05 Cavalinho wrote:
On April 16 2014 03:57 OmniEulogy wrote:
I'm not even tunneling you. If I thought you were scum I'd vote for you. Are you scummy to me? yes.


Uhh.

Also I don't get the points in your post at all.


I find this an odd behavioural tidbit because IMO this is not a townies mindset.

I agree with this case on cav


+ Show Spoiler +
On April 16 2014 23:54 OneThousandWords wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 16 2014 19:22 Koshi wrote:
OneThousandWords
Did absolutely NOTHING.

Went in an argument with me defending the fact that skanjab HAS TO CLAIM RB OR IS MAFIA ON D2 while OTW himself didn't believe the Vig claim.

Then he made some halfassed case on Cavalinho which simply isn't enough for a smurf. Even if Cavalinho is suspicious, it doesn't change the fact OTW has done nothing. Just some silly quotes enabling him to fly under radar.


This is categorically false. Where do I state that I don't believe he could be vig? Also, I've seen the word smurf thrown around. If it's used in the same way as MOBA games then you're wrong, I was invited here by a friend from another mafia site.

Here is wherein the real problem lies. All the people that you seemingly "like" for things that they have done have quite simply started from posts that I have made.

Thrawn's main contributions this game:

Show nested quote +
On April 16 2014 15:52 thrawn2112 wrote:
lets lynch mderg

Show nested quote +
On April 16 2014 16:20 thrawn2112 wrote:
No. He made a huge post that doesn't contribute anything. He didn't say a single thing that is relevant to the lynch. It's even worse than no scumreads, there are no reads of any kind. He argued his points without giving any indication that he was forming reads based off of the things he was arguing against.



This is his first contribution into the thread other than the non-sensical replies to longer posts earlier in his filter and it's just piggybacking off a post that I made earlier in the thread here. This is a relatively easy thing to do as mafia because:

A) It lets people appear to be contributing.

B) If worded differently but similar it enables people to pocket the other people that made the original case because they have seemingly similar reads.

C) To the people that didn't read it they are fooled into believing it is original content.

Now, on it's own I know this is not enough, however, thrawn's behaviour is not your typical town behaviour! He flits from one lynch to the next with little explanation. He practically wants to lynch half the game!

I've mentioned Mderg before.

Here he wants to lynch Kush. + Show Spoiler +
On April 16 2014 17:53 thrawn2112 wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 16 2014 17:36 Koshi wrote:
I am pretty meh on Kush atm.
Very meh.


same for me. becasue of this post

Show nested quote +
On April 16 2014 04:48 kushm4sta wrote:
T-5 hours until you both realize each other are town (regardless of if you are or not)



He wants to lynch ME which is somewhat of a kick in the teeth seeing as he is the one that is sheeping MY point of view on mderg. What could be the reason for this? Is he not reading what i've written? Nope. It's something about skan and nothing about the actual player that he got his read from. + Show Spoiler +
On April 16 2014 19:26 thrawn2112 wrote:
100words is probably my 2nd lynch choice. i almost voted for him instead of that other guy. what stood out to me is how his main talking point was skan's claim and how pointless it was to talk about the claim yet he did nothing but talk about the claim

koshi i'll fully read and respond to that meta when i wake up. too tired/tipsy for that right now. but i did skim one of the links and I notice that he likes to argue about stuff without thinking about alignments. so my preliminary answer to you question is yes, the meta does sorta make me uncertain about lnyching him.



He wants to policy lynch an AFK player who is talking about nonsense (Alakaslam).

He wants to also look into OE who he also says is scummy before even looking into him. This is not what I expect a typical person to do. Usually it's:

I'll look into a player ----> Here is why he is scummy.

Thrawn's view is.

This is a somewhat scummy player ----> Going to go look into him after I've already made my decision about whether he is scummy or not!


In conclusion thrawn is a person who, while talking a lot, seems to be a person of fleeting wishes. He is keen to hop onto anyone he can push a lynch onto. He hasn't "read the thread" and pushes others reads as his own. He calls the person he got his case for on his vote choice scum based on early conversation in a time where nothing was happening.



##Vote Thrawn2112

Here I agree on the part about thrawns first contribution being the case on me is scummy. I don´t think thrawn was sheeping OTW, though.




If you agree with his case on Cava why does he stay null for you when you ask me about the reads? Be honest, did you just go look for OTW's cases when I asked you?
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 16 2014 21:22 GMT
#559
Wait dude, answer the question first. Your life might depend on it.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 16 2014 21:56 GMT
#564
Kush is that a townread? Do you agree with some of his cases or what else is that supposed to mean?

OO can you look at my list of reads and pick the ones you disagree with?
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 16 2014 21:59 GMT
#568
On April 17 2014 06:57 OneThousandWords wrote:
Oh, I won't be around for deadline, is anyone around? I'd like to talk about things so that we can get an idea of who to lynch because Kush is not a good lynch.


Yeah, I think you could be scum cause you post cases left and right but don't seem to have a bigger picture of the game, ie you post a lot of points about people being scum but don't seem to want to clear people. So tell me, who are your townreads?
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 16 2014 22:02 GMT
#569
On April 17 2014 06:59 Koshi wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 17 2014 04:39 Vivax wrote:
Current status of reads. Reasoning pending, but ask me about a specific one if you want me to explain it first:

Townies: Koshi, Djagu, Cava, thrawn, (~Kush fwiw)

Today's lynch candidates (by PoE and cause there is some stuff I don't like): FT, Omni, OTW, OO, mderg

Also HI GUYS =D . Rejoice that you got me and not that crazy grush fac-simile

I am looking at those 5 possible scummers and I can't say you are completely crazy so I am going to believe you. Alakaslam hopefully didn't replace out as scum again...

Are you planning on pushing a target today?


Why is Kush not scum? I don't see it. Kush is scummy as scum btw.


I just played against Kush as scum, I'm kinda confident I found out about how he plays scum. Specifically, the way he pushes his reads.

He tends to attach onto cases on townies, add some of his own points and show extraordinary confidence about his fake reads while doing very little besides that, I didn't see that pattern yet in this game.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 16 2014 22:17 GMT
#574
Koshi, if you think Kush is scum give me a bunch of convincing reasons please. Looking through your filter I find it hard to find something that conclusively deduces from his posts that he's scum.

On April 17 2014 07:09 OneThousandWords wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 17 2014 06:59 Vivax wrote:
On April 17 2014 06:57 OneThousandWords wrote:
Oh, I won't be around for deadline, is anyone around? I'd like to talk about things so that we can get an idea of who to lynch because Kush is not a good lynch.


Yeah, I think you could be scum cause you post cases left and right but don't seem to have a bigger picture of the game, ie you post a lot of points about people being scum but don't seem to want to clear people. So tell me, who are your townreads?


If you think this you are not reading anything I say at all.


Please, just your current townreads besides the one on the vigi claim. I don't want a shitfight you're attempting to start.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 16 2014 22:36 GMT
#584
@ OO

Cav I explained, Djag is cause his initial posts are "fuck yeah, I'm town, let's fuck scum" with hints of some sort of roleplay and his posts about weird traps for scum. Stuff like that is usually hard for scum to make up.

@ Koshi

On April 17 2014 07:30 Koshi wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 16 2014 23:35 OmniEulogy wrote:
the problem I'm having right now Koshi is that between Kush, Cavalinho, Slam, FirmTofu, and even still mderg I have no reason to think that any of them are town. I'm also undecided about OTW and OO but they give me a better feeling than the others. given that I'd rather vote for Thrawn even if he is voting on Kush because to me Kush blends in more with the others making me doubt if we'll really lynch scum if we lynch him.

This post. Interesting?


I'd like OE to explain the last bit with kush, thrawn and the blending in. That reeks a bit like bullshit reasoning.
As for who to vote, I need to talk more to reach a more definite conclusion, if you gotta sleep, vote for who you feel is scum I guess.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 16 2014 22:41 GMT
#587
On April 17 2014 07:33 OneThousandWords wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 17 2014 07:17 Vivax wrote:
Koshi, if you think Kush is scum give me a bunch of convincing reasons please. Looking through your filter I find it hard to find something that conclusively deduces from his posts that he's scum.

On April 17 2014 07:09 OneThousandWords wrote:
On April 17 2014 06:59 Vivax wrote:
On April 17 2014 06:57 OneThousandWords wrote:
Oh, I won't be around for deadline, is anyone around? I'd like to talk about things so that we can get an idea of who to lynch because Kush is not a good lynch.


Yeah, I think you could be scum cause you post cases left and right but don't seem to have a bigger picture of the game, ie you post a lot of points about people being scum but don't seem to want to clear people. So tell me, who are your townreads?


If you think this you are not reading anything I say at all.


Please, just your current townreads besides the one on the vigi claim. I don't want a shitfight you're attempting to start.


What do you mean a shit fight? You've accused me of being scum and don't expect a retort? I've only been pointing out things that seem suspicious or scummy to me and drawing attention to them and trying to discuss them with people. It's people like koshi that completely shut them down with the reason "i'm not going to read anything about my town reads".

I don't have many town reads really just the people that have interacted like I think a towny would:

Kush, Cav to an extent (although I'm slightly aprehensive), I also like Omni despite what people have said (he's posted what he's been thinking and no sane scum would try and call a claimed vig scum IMO)


Do you think Koshi is scummy for skipping over your points about his townreads?

Do you think that what Omni has been thinking in the post Koshi brought up looks particularly townie?

What are your reasons for townreading Cav and Kush?
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 16 2014 22:54 GMT
#591
On April 17 2014 07:39 Koshi wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 16 2014 03:57 OmniEulogy wrote:
I'm not even tunneling you. If I thought you were scum I'd vote for you. Are you scummy to me? yes.

This entire conversation happened because Koshi was asking me questions about you though so the idea that I'm tunneling you because I'm answering Koshi's questions is pretty amusing. It's on page 12 by the way, not even that long ago.

So far you've made an association case and then asked everybody else for something you failed to answer yourself because you've only played one game. Oh and blatantly lied about your town meta in that same post and proceeded to answer that accusation from OTW by telling him to read a book...

You just don't strike me as doing anything beneficial for any reason for town right now.
Koshi seems lost in half his questions/posts.
+ Show Spoiler +
On April 15 2014 18:03 Koshi wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 15 2014 18:00 OmniEulogy wrote:
yo man I'm all about that nova war random tangent video, how can you not enjoy this flavor. Also no, I'm not really concerned if Koshi is town right now. Town objective is not to find other townies it's to find scum. Finding townies is just a bi-product of catching the scum or do you spend all your time trying to identify town in mafia and I've been learning to do things backwards?

Are you scumslipping I am town or am I not reading this propperly?


+ Show Spoiler +
On April 15 2014 21:35 Koshi wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 15 2014 21:28 kushm4sta wrote:
K I read the newest stuff.
Inb4 getript tries to ban skanjab.

Also Kochi you are talking alot without content. Does that not mean you are scum by your own self meta?

No. I don't self meta. I don't know where you read me self metaing.
Show nested quote +
On April 15 2014 21:29 kushm4sta wrote:
Koshi, true or false?
Skans claim almost never is coming from scum.

I don't care. It is probably unlikely but there was so much wrong with that post. I want to know why he made it in 24 hours.


^ scumhunting so hard he ignores likely town behavior and calls him scum. I can really feel how much you care about who is scum and who is town Koshi.
+ Show Spoiler +
On April 15 2014 18:07 Koshi wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 15 2014 18:04 OmniEulogy wrote:
On April 15 2014 18:03 Koshi wrote:
On April 15 2014 18:00 OmniEulogy wrote:
yo man I'm all about that nova war random tangent video, how can you not enjoy this flavor. Also no, I'm not really concerned if Koshi is town right now. Town objective is not to find other townies it's to find scum. Finding townies is just a bi-product of catching the scum or do you spend all your time trying to identify town in mafia and I've been learning to do things backwards?

Are you scumslipping I am town or am I not reading this propperly?


not reading it properly.

All right then. I prefer to work with PoE. If I can find obvious town I am as happy as when I find possible mafia.

especially after that. Ignore signs to go to the much less likely option to call somebody scum.
+ Show Spoiler +
On April 15 2014 20:19 Koshi wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 15 2014 20:15 Skanjab1s wrote:
On April 15 2014 19:56 Koshi wrote:
You don't think he is scum?


No, I don't, he's a townie through and through. Do you think he's scum?

I see no reason to think he is town.


so happy you make your reasons known so you can go after other people. And yeah there's no reason to think anybody is town with their first 4~ posts as the game started. I thank you for your knowledge.

+ Show Spoiler +
On April 16 2014 03:26 Koshi wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 16 2014 03:16 OmniEulogy wrote:
On April 16 2014 03:09 Koshi wrote:
I don't understand.
The guy has literally 0 scumgames.

And you blame him for playing the newbie card on how many scumgames he played.


No, I blame him for playing it period.


Also
On April 16 2014 01:38 Koshi wrote:
You must have missed his pretty hard "I played 1 game and caught all scum" post then.

The irky feeling was the soft newbie claim?


you say it yourself. Somehow you missed it while you were typing it I guess. It has nothing to do with his amount of scum games he's played. Could be one now and it wouldn't stop him from saying he's never played as scum before.

You blame him for playing it when it suits him, a big difference. It didn't suit him at all. What is the scum motivation saying he only played 1 game before so he couldn't self meta?

And it was super casual. He dropped it because the subject about self meta was in the thread. He didn't gained anything.

Anyway, my vote is on the right person.



Scum motivation is not having to talk about how they are going to play this very game. Especially after he's already completely off the town play he said he has in that very same post. How do you not get that?

+ Show Spoiler +
On April 15 2014 23:31 OmniEulogy wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 15 2014 22:38 Djagulingu wrote:
On April 15 2014 21:42 OneThousandWords wrote:
Djagulingu, you describe your town play as:

My town play is really stalk heavy. I watch all of you. All of you, when you post, when you sleep, when you work, when you eat. I might come out of nowhere with random people to lynch for random reasons. They did come out true though.

I would define my town play as systematic instead of impulsive, I don't care about collateral damage, sharp and decisive over overly cautious.


In this game you have already called 2 people scum for supposed scum slips. Am I to assume that you have now 180° on your own meta so quickly? This doesn't look very systematic to me, it looks like the complete opposite. You jump on people and call them scum without much basis and state that you are helping the town by making a pro-town atmosphere of sophisticated discussion when, instead, you are steering people in a very specific direction on a point of view that seems entirely skewed on pushing an agenda.

You would understand if you have read Hunter Book: Wayward. But I like your sharpness. You're like Peleus in that book. This is how God45 defines Peleus:

And so I found him. The prodigal problem child. Alleyman. Peleus.

The sniper was a little resitant to my ideas. That's understandable. I was actually pleased that he didn't take to them so quickly. Enlightenment shouldn't come immediately. It took me a long time to discover the truth. We can't all be Paul on the road to Damascus.

He had the methods down. He's messy and he leaves too much of himself behind, but he's efficient. His numbers are great. And I appreciate his attitude toward others of our kind. He won't tolerate their whiny, backstabbing bullshit. Their opinions are threefold- they can help, they can get out of the way or they try to find their way out of a body bag. He doesn't know the words for it yet, but somewhere in there he knows that if you're not curing the cancer, you are the cancer. There's no in between.


unless you are roleplaying as somebody in your book I fail to see how it changes what he said and how this answers none of it =/

My previous mention of it Koshi and OTW's post which Djag completely blows off by telling OTW if he had read the book he'd get it.


sorry kush <3 I feel that last point is pretty important though.

Vivax. Your opinion on this post?


Idk lol. It's confusing. I don't get what he's trying to accomplish by bringing up all those points about you. I actually don't know if he wants to paint you in a better or worse light, and why it's relevant in his reply to Djago since he doesn't show any signs of having a scumread on you afterwards.

I would like to hear OE's intentions behind this post.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 16 2014 22:58 GMT
#594
On April 17 2014 07:56 OneThousandWords wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 17 2014 07:55 thrawn2112 wrote:
OTW are you a smurf? I don't need to know who. Just tell me if you are. And tell me if you've played with me before.


I've already said no, I was invited here by a friend to play.


How's the weather on the barbados?
Rainy with chance of turtles?
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 16 2014 23:01 GMT
#599
Wait a moment Koshi. Two quick things before you put your weight on the lynch and going to bed.

1. How do you conclusively gain from those posts that OE must be scum before confronting him with it? Frankly I would want to hear that first.

2. OTW just called you scummy for ignoring his counter-case on your scumread. What was the reason for that and do you think that's a valid reason for calling you scum?
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 16 2014 23:27 GMT
#608
Kush still waiting for you to answer my question, please. What was that supposed to mean about OTW.

I could roll with an Omni lynch unless he pops in here and shines townie when clarifying the intent behind those posts, but OTW somewhat still rubs me the wrong way with his answers.

I don't even know why I my opinion on that post is a condition to you giving yours, it's like I have to pull the stuff out of your mouth cause you're angry or something. Or do you have a scumread on me or what is wrong with you? Can't you just answer a question like a normal human being?
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 16 2014 23:37 GMT
#613
On April 17 2014 08:30 OneThousandWords wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 17 2014 08:27 Vivax wrote:
Kush still waiting for you to answer my question, please. What was that supposed to mean about OTW.

I could roll with an Omni lynch unless he pops in here and shines townie when clarifying the intent behind those posts, but OTW somewhat still rubs me the wrong way with his answers.

I don't even know why I my opinion on that post is a condition to you giving yours, it's like I have to pull the stuff out of your mouth cause you're angry or something. Or do you have a scumread on me or what is wrong with you? Can't you just answer a question like a normal human being?


A player specifically asks another player for a read on a post, that player in question then asks ME for that read rather than responding himself. Do you not see how silly that would be for me to do? What if the player in question was trying to form a read based on your response, I've posted a lot in the thread while you have not so why would I not want to let myself and others hear responses from you?


I posted my opinion. It looks confusing and doesn't make much sense, ie it could be made up.

Now that you got it, what gives?
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 16 2014 23:37 GMT
#614
On April 17 2014 08:28 kushm4sta wrote:
doesn't mean i have a strong townread on him


So what is it? A weak townread? Why did you say that.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 17 2014 01:20 GMT
#655
On April 17 2014 09:23 OmniEulogy wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 17 2014 07:54 Vivax wrote:
On April 17 2014 07:39 Koshi wrote:
On April 16 2014 03:57 OmniEulogy wrote:
I'm not even tunneling you. If I thought you were scum I'd vote for you. Are you scummy to me? yes.

This entire conversation happened because Koshi was asking me questions about you though so the idea that I'm tunneling you because I'm answering Koshi's questions is pretty amusing. It's on page 12 by the way, not even that long ago.

So far you've made an association case and then asked everybody else for something you failed to answer yourself because you've only played one game. Oh and blatantly lied about your town meta in that same post and proceeded to answer that accusation from OTW by telling him to read a book...

You just don't strike me as doing anything beneficial for any reason for town right now.
Koshi seems lost in half his questions/posts.
+ Show Spoiler +
On April 15 2014 18:03 Koshi wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 15 2014 18:00 OmniEulogy wrote:
yo man I'm all about that nova war random tangent video, how can you not enjoy this flavor. Also no, I'm not really concerned if Koshi is town right now. Town objective is not to find other townies it's to find scum. Finding townies is just a bi-product of catching the scum or do you spend all your time trying to identify town in mafia and I've been learning to do things backwards?

Are you scumslipping I am town or am I not reading this propperly?


+ Show Spoiler +
On April 15 2014 21:35 Koshi wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 15 2014 21:28 kushm4sta wrote:
K I read the newest stuff.
Inb4 getript tries to ban skanjab.

Also Kochi you are talking alot without content. Does that not mean you are scum by your own self meta?

No. I don't self meta. I don't know where you read me self metaing.
Show nested quote +
On April 15 2014 21:29 kushm4sta wrote:
Koshi, true or false?
Skans claim almost never is coming from scum.

I don't care. It is probably unlikely but there was so much wrong with that post. I want to know why he made it in 24 hours.


^ scumhunting so hard he ignores likely town behavior and calls him scum. I can really feel how much you care about who is scum and who is town Koshi.
+ Show Spoiler +
On April 15 2014 18:07 Koshi wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 15 2014 18:04 OmniEulogy wrote:
On April 15 2014 18:03 Koshi wrote:
On April 15 2014 18:00 OmniEulogy wrote:
yo man I'm all about that nova war random tangent video, how can you not enjoy this flavor. Also no, I'm not really concerned if Koshi is town right now. Town objective is not to find other townies it's to find scum. Finding townies is just a bi-product of catching the scum or do you spend all your time trying to identify town in mafia and I've been learning to do things backwards?

Are you scumslipping I am town or am I not reading this propperly?


not reading it properly.

All right then. I prefer to work with PoE. If I can find obvious town I am as happy as when I find possible mafia.

especially after that. Ignore signs to go to the much less likely option to call somebody scum.
+ Show Spoiler +
On April 15 2014 20:19 Koshi wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 15 2014 20:15 Skanjab1s wrote:
On April 15 2014 19:56 Koshi wrote:
You don't think he is scum?


No, I don't, he's a townie through and through. Do you think he's scum?

I see no reason to think he is town.


so happy you make your reasons known so you can go after other people. And yeah there's no reason to think anybody is town with their first 4~ posts as the game started. I thank you for your knowledge.

+ Show Spoiler +
On April 16 2014 03:26 Koshi wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 16 2014 03:16 OmniEulogy wrote:
On April 16 2014 03:09 Koshi wrote:
I don't understand.
The guy has literally 0 scumgames.

And you blame him for playing the newbie card on how many scumgames he played.


No, I blame him for playing it period.


Also
On April 16 2014 01:38 Koshi wrote:
You must have missed his pretty hard "I played 1 game and caught all scum" post then.

The irky feeling was the soft newbie claim?


you say it yourself. Somehow you missed it while you were typing it I guess. It has nothing to do with his amount of scum games he's played. Could be one now and it wouldn't stop him from saying he's never played as scum before.

You blame him for playing it when it suits him, a big difference. It didn't suit him at all. What is the scum motivation saying he only played 1 game before so he couldn't self meta?

And it was super casual. He dropped it because the subject about self meta was in the thread. He didn't gained anything.

Anyway, my vote is on the right person.



Scum motivation is not having to talk about how they are going to play this very game. Especially after he's already completely off the town play he said he has in that very same post. How do you not get that?

+ Show Spoiler +
On April 15 2014 23:31 OmniEulogy wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 15 2014 22:38 Djagulingu wrote:
On April 15 2014 21:42 OneThousandWords wrote:
Djagulingu, you describe your town play as:

My town play is really stalk heavy. I watch all of you. All of you, when you post, when you sleep, when you work, when you eat. I might come out of nowhere with random people to lynch for random reasons. They did come out true though.

I would define my town play as systematic instead of impulsive, I don't care about collateral damage, sharp and decisive over overly cautious.


In this game you have already called 2 people scum for supposed scum slips. Am I to assume that you have now 180° on your own meta so quickly? This doesn't look very systematic to me, it looks like the complete opposite. You jump on people and call them scum without much basis and state that you are helping the town by making a pro-town atmosphere of sophisticated discussion when, instead, you are steering people in a very specific direction on a point of view that seems entirely skewed on pushing an agenda.

You would understand if you have read Hunter Book: Wayward. But I like your sharpness. You're like Peleus in that book. This is how God45 defines Peleus:

And so I found him. The prodigal problem child. Alleyman. Peleus.

The sniper was a little resitant to my ideas. That's understandable. I was actually pleased that he didn't take to them so quickly. Enlightenment shouldn't come immediately. It took me a long time to discover the truth. We can't all be Paul on the road to Damascus.

He had the methods down. He's messy and he leaves too much of himself behind, but he's efficient. His numbers are great. And I appreciate his attitude toward others of our kind. He won't tolerate their whiny, backstabbing bullshit. Their opinions are threefold- they can help, they can get out of the way or they try to find their way out of a body bag. He doesn't know the words for it yet, but somewhere in there he knows that if you're not curing the cancer, you are the cancer. There's no in between.


unless you are roleplaying as somebody in your book I fail to see how it changes what he said and how this answers none of it =/

My previous mention of it Koshi and OTW's post which Djag completely blows off by telling OTW if he had read the book he'd get it.


sorry kush <3 I feel that last point is pretty important though.

Vivax. Your opinion on this post?


Idk lol. It's confusing. I don't get what he's trying to accomplish by bringing up all those points about you. I actually don't know if he wants to paint you in a better or worse light, and why it's relevant in his reply to Djago since he doesn't show any signs of having a scumread on you afterwards.

I would like to hear OE's intentions behind this post.


at no point in that case do I call Koshi scum, I tried to discredit his ridiculous thinking for sure considering everything he was doing and saying made absolutely no sense, I was also a bit irritated with him because I think I had to repeat myself for him twice at that point within a short period of time.

Just because I was upset with Koshi didn't mean I thought he was scum, just that he was extremely wrong with his thought process. Which he still is but w/e

As far as the Thrawn / Kush thing goes, I meant Kush and the other lurkers more or less all seemed as likely as candidates for scum and why would I vote for one of four people when Thrawn stood out to me? I explained it earlier. I'd rather lynch somebody I think is scum as opposed to one of multiple people who are just scummy. At the time Thrawn's contributions were literally asking for a policy lynch and voting for a lurker who had said he had no time to play that day.


Who did you think was scum at the time? Djago, right?
Cause it's odd you spend time writing all that stuff to discredit Koshi when in fact you said before that another dude was scum.

That's why I specifically asked you about your intentions. What I see lacking in that post is the intention to either push or find out more about your scumread. I don't know which townie talks to his scumread (Djago) about something and then proceeds to post multiple points about somebody trying to discredit him even though he doesn't think he's scum. Usually you would only do that when you feel very much like some guy is dangerous to you. That's a rather scummy mindset.

Thrawn (and anyone else), do you disagree with this?

- Not figuring out Djago and instead
- discredit a not-scumread cause
- he felt cornered by Koshi

Conclusion: Scum

I initially wasn't even sure what he was trying to achieve with Koshi cause apparently a lot of his remarks on his posts were sarcastic. I'll leave my vote on him unless I discover something better, but I doubt it.


##Vote OmniEulogy


On April 17 2014 10:07 FirmTofu wrote:
Another interesting observation: Vivax has been ignoring me this entire game. Not responding to my questions and not commenting on me at all, aside from the "lmao" post from thrawn.

@Vivax Why must you ignore me so?


PoE mostly and the posts or playstyle which didn't make me add them to the townie list.
Also posted some stuff on OTW previously, I think you missed that cause it would answer half of your question.

As for the other half, OmniEulogy, my conclusion is right above this post. You're encouraged to post your opinion, especially since you're not cleared in my book and the "Oh look Vivax is ignoring me, hmmm, interesting" doesn't make you look much better. Do you think I could be scum?

Also answer me this: The reason you think OTW could be scum is that his case on thrawn looks bad as far as I can gain from your filter. How do you discern if it's a bad townie making it or scum? Cause that case alone isn't enough of an argument, so how did you conclude scum? My arguments for him being possible scum were different.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 17 2014 01:29 GMT
#660
On April 17 2014 10:22 thrawn2112 wrote:
vivax I already said that I thought that post OE made about koshi was strange. but based on the tone of his recent posts I don't think he's mafia. his confusion seems real.


He's saying he has no scumreads, do you mean that?

On April 16 2014 22:30 OmniEulogy wrote:
I'm awake, sorry I went to sleep at like 7pm EST last night.

Quick couple of things

Much less convinced of Djag scum after reading the last 7~ pages.

I think Mderg lynch is a god awful idea D1, if he didn't have time he didn't have time as he's saying. (also what he has posted while I made this post, good to see him around)

My scum hunting came down to the fact that there were three of us active in the thread and I did push Djag on what he had done up to that point. Admittedly mostly on a post made by OTW.

Skan's vote on mderg looks pretty bad although so does Koshi's and especially thrawns. The difference of these three is that Skan has not really given reads on the people he changes his votes for.

Thrawn contributed very little (suggesting a policy lynch on slam) before targeting mderg for inactivity which may or may not be due to time constraints.

Essentially Thrawn calls me out, votes for mderg, questions Djag about his scum reads changing, goes after OTW, back to calling me scummy, and finally goes to Kush when nothing has changed for mderg.

To me Thrawn it seems like you go for the people who would be easy to lynch so you have a place to put your vote. On top of that it seems like you don't really care who we lynch based on how you picked your targets.

The biggest thing I have against you though is you trying to convince town to lynch mderg. I can't see any town motivation behind that given what he has said over other people in the game
.


He thought at some point, that your actions make you scummy. Now I ask you, how do you think the mafia would react if a guy they previously called out is opposed to their lynch?

Would they still call him scum?
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 17 2014 01:37 GMT
#667
On April 17 2014 10:32 OmniEulogy wrote:
All I can say Vivax is that Djag was figured out at that point for everything he had said and then I went to sleep and he made more posts. What can ya do, people continue to talk even when you're not there.


If you were town you would have to have some suspects. Why aren't you mentioning thrawn after your previous points on him if not cause he's defending you right now?

Also what do you mean by figured out? You mean you were so sure he was scum and he became townie to you cause of his later posts? If so, you should be able to elaborate on the posts that changed your mind and the reasons for it. If so, you should have found out more stuff about Djag, asked him stuff. All I can see is that you blamed him for saying he never played scum and the meta thingy.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 17 2014 01:55 GMT
#680
I actually missed the post where Omni agreed with the case on thrawn being town (Koshi posted it), so I retract the point assuming his evolution of read was opportunistic.

Still, I think that cause of his post on Koshi and Djag he's a better lynch than any of the other possible scummers :/ , but I could also lynch FT for that big but void post thrawn lold about.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 17 2014 02:09 GMT
#691
On April 17 2014 10:33 FirmTofu wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 17 2014 10:20 Vivax wrote:
[truncated]

PoE mostly and the posts or playstyle which didn't make me add them to the townie list.
Also posted some stuff on OTW previously, I think you missed that cause it would answer half of your question.

As for the other half, OmniEulogy, my conclusion is right above this post. You're encouraged to post your opinion, especially since you're not cleared in my book and the "Oh look Vivax is ignoring me, hmmm, interesting" doesn't make you look much better. Do you think I could be scum?

Also answer me this: The reason you think OTW could be scum is that his case on thrawn looks bad as far as I can gain from your filter. How do you discern if it's a bad townie making it or scum? Cause that case alone isn't enough of an argument, so how did you conclude scum? My arguments for him being possible scum were different.

Not really considering you as scum just yet. I just wanted to hear from you. I like this case on OE.

I think OTW is scummy for a variety of different, small reasons. His attitude has been generally defensive, his responses to your questions were less than impressive, and his vote on me is pure OMGUS. I don't have a case on him yet, persay, but I wouldn't mind lynching him, that much is certain.


Actually I thought his answers to me made him look a little better cause he wasn't afraid of pissing me off which is something I wouldn't expect from newb scum (if he is who he claims to be which I'm not sure if I should believe), my main concern though is the way he pushed people early in the game. It looked like plain scum aggressiveness, not figuring out people. Hence why I was suspicious of his lack of townreads. I could lynch him too. Hell, I could lynch everybody I said I would lynch initially except for the german dude cause of the way he replied to me.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 17 2014 03:03 GMT
#725
On April 17 2014 11:19 thrawn2112 wrote:
yeah ok. there's been enough times in the last couple hours where FT has posted somethin that makes me think he's town for be to be willing to unvote him


Thrawn, now I got two issues with your play.

One, you defend lynch candidates, you don't push scumreads. This is the worst possible play at deadline. We need a lynch, we need a lynch with at least some reasoning, you don't present such a thing.

Two, you keep asking people stuff about your townreads instead of simply putting aside that discussion by saying WHY we shouldn't vote for them today.

Unless you want to vote for the guy who is going to be modkilled and thus basically force a no-lynch, crank out a case on somebody you think is scum.

Next issue is this Cava wagon. I said why I think he's town. Now all those people I find scummy or not supertownie start a wagon on him, you put coals into the fire.

THERE IS NO PROPER CASE ON CAVALINHO. HELLO? ALARM BELLS? WHERE IS THIS LYNCH HEADING TO?
The only "case" I've seen so far is Kush's case based on a case construction meta argument.
Cavalinho didn't even respond to any accusations.

Those are the best lynches, the lynches where the lynchee isn't even present. The best lynches for scum to push. This wagon stinks.

On April 17 2014 11:10 FirmTofu wrote:
I'm going to move my vote to Cava. I think we need to be looking into him further. OE, if you continue to ignore me, I'll leave my vote on you.
##Vote: Cavalinho


Look at this. This is the reasoning some individuals are using to get onto his wagon.

"I'm going to vote this dude, I think we should look at him".
Is that an argument for Cava being scum?

Why did OE even bring up the tidbit with me being scum cause I'm a replacement. Why does he even imply I would justify a mislynch later when we're not even that far. Why does he say i play like scum but I'm not his scumread.

Lots of stuff going wrong right now and I don't even know where to start but the thing I can tell is that I'm suspicious of thrawn right now and FT and OE both ride the Cava wagon while at the same time calling each other as secondary scumreads.

Now I want either FT or OE lynched for sure.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 17 2014 03:07 GMT
#728
lol what. Take this game seriously. Answer the questions. When deadline approaches your scumreads turn to townreads and you help push the lynch onto a guy who isn't even here, explain that thrawn.

Am I the only one seeing the pattern?
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 17 2014 03:08 GMT
#730
Yeah let's lynch a guy who might get modkilled and isn't even here, cause well, cause we need to look into him.

Welcome to the state of the game.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 17 2014 03:09 GMT
#732
Explain what exactly made you change your mind on those guys. So far you've only been asking questions, never explaining, and never pushing an own scumread.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 17 2014 03:10 GMT
#734
On April 17 2014 12:09 thrawn2112 wrote:
vivax please explain how turning my scumreads into townreads as the lynch deadline approaches is a scum agenda. that's the dumbest thing that's been posted in the thread so far


Only if they are both town, which you either can't know or they simply aren't.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 17 2014 03:14 GMT
#736
On April 17 2014 12:11 kushm4sta wrote:
vivax you can pressure thrawn after the lynch if you want.
Do you disagree strongly with this cava lynch? why
who should we be lynching instead? why


I disagree cause I trust my own townread and most importantly I'm reluctant to lynch guys who didn't get a chance to defend themselves first, and who are pushed by scummy people with no arguments, close to deadline, who have each other as secondary scumreads just cause of a coincidence, and basically say "Hey dude if you don't do x I will vote for you".

Lynch OE or FT. And when we're done with them we kick thrawn's ass.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 17 2014 03:15 GMT
#737
Look at thrawn. He townreads them and he refuses to give me reasons not to lynch em just because ?????

But he sure felt entitled to demand answers.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 17 2014 03:22 GMT
#739
Kush why does OE want to lynch Fderg?
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 17 2014 03:24 GMT
#741
And why is Cava scum, thrawn?
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 17 2014 03:43 GMT
#761
Question 1: Why does scum add the bolded to a post when they've already explained who they want to lynch?

On April 16 2014 13:27 Cavalinho wrote:
Looking through FT's filter, I see a big post that discredits Omni without actually coming to any conclusion aside from trying to make him look bad, a long post on skab that boils down to "he claimed vig, so he's probably town," and a big post that doesn't go anywhere.

I think it's really easy to look like you're doing something in a game like this, where there's little content and big posts look good, but even a quick glance reveals that he isn't actually doing anything in his posts. The only exception is his sole townread which is needlessly long and has already been discussed by other players.

##Vote FirmTofu

Thrawn's filter is shitty too, but it's shitty in a blatant way rather than a way where he looks like he's doing something but he isn't. I'd like to hear more from him as well.


Question 2: The point he makes about kush is actually quite valid if the representation is correct.

On April 17 2014 03:33 Cavalinho wrote:
Your whole reasoning for voting me is that I'm focusing on FT rather than mderg. Guess what? I think mderg is scummy too. I just wanted to bring FT's actions into the spotlight rather than mderg's because more people were focusing on mderg.

Also, I have a question for you kush. Why is it that you ask me a question, and when you don't receive an answer due to me not being anywhere near the thread for some time, you vote me and say that I'm just focusing on FT? That's scummy. It's like you were planning on voting me regardless of my answer.


On April 17 2014 03:37 Cavalinho wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 17 2014 03:34 kushm4sta wrote:
On April 17 2014 03:33 Cavalinho wrote:
Your whole reasoning for voting me is that I'm focusing on FT rather than mderg. Guess what? I think mderg is scummy too. I just wanted to bring FT's actions into the spotlight rather than mderg's because more people were focusing on mderg.

Also, I have a question for you kush. Why is it that you ask me a question, and when you don't receive an answer due to me not being anywhere near the thread for some time, you vote me and say that I'm just focusing on FT? That's scummy. It's like you were planning on voting me regardless of my answer.


How is that my only reason for thinking you are scummy? That is one of many reasons.


From my point of view, it looks like that's what it boils down to. If there are more reasons, tell me what they are, because I don't see it.

Also, what's up with my handle? >.>


On April 17 2014 03:50 Cavalinho wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 17 2014 03:43 kushm4sta wrote:
my case on cavalinho outlined

1. you think FT is scummy for answering a question thoroughly, rather than just saying "im null on that guy

2 you are calling FT scummy for one very unspecific, generic reason: He is writing a lot while not doing anything, basically. And you keep saying that in different words over and over again.

3 it looks nothing like your town game, where the reasoning behind your reads are much more in depth.

4 You are scumreading FT, when what you are scum reading them for, not taking a stance, mberg does much worse. Oh you had a secret scumread on mberg, ok...


1) It's not because he answered a question thoroughly. He didn't answer it thoroughly. He made a post that looked like he was doing analysis which boiled down to an analysis with no definitive conclusion.

2) His filter is less than a page long. He doesn't answer my questions and doesn't really respond to/deny accusations. It's possible he's genuinely afk, but I'm going to keep my vote on him until he convinces me otherwise.

3) Newbie games and regular games are two completely different things. Just because my reads aren't as elaborate as they were, that doesn't mean my reads were necessarily better then. The key difference is that I was outing my reads as a whole, rather than just scumreads.

4) You act like I was supposed to ignore mderg so I would look scummy, and then I admit I have a scumread on him too. This makes me scummy...How, exactly? I don't understand your logic.


1) His thoughts on FT: My thoughts
2) One more reason for his FT read.
3) He disarms the meta argument with something that sounds reasonable.
4) Here kush says he's scum for admitting to having a scumread on mberg when asked. How is that scummy?

You guys don't even look at his defense, don't even reply to it. This wagon stinks of scum. And FT says "we should look into him" LOL. Still waiting on that miracle.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 17 2014 03:45 GMT
#766
On April 17 2014 12:44 FirmTofu wrote:
I'm more interested in Vivax rushing to a last minute defense of Cava.


I'm more interested into you looking at him which you didn't do after your vote. It couldn't possibly be more half-assed than that.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 17 2014 04:00 GMT
#779
It's cute how you two try to milk the cred before this dude flips scum.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 17 2014 04:02 GMT
#783
On April 17 2014 13:01 OmniEulogy wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 17 2014 13:00 Vivax wrote:
It's cute how you two try to milk the cred before this dude flips scum.


it's cute how you continue to look down on people and be hypocritical


Hypocritical? Cause I get the credz once he does? Thx for the information scum.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 17 2014 04:05 GMT
#793
I'm bad at this game and need to reread.
Sorry tofu , hope you stick around.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 18 2014 19:01 GMT
#1089
If there is a cop and you got a check, claim it now. You are one-shot, you can only benefit from claiming.

I want to know from Skanja why he fakeclaimed vig cause I can't fathom the townie motivation behind that lie.

Next, I want you guys to tell me your thoughts about those posts by OO, and if you see what I see:

+ Show Spoiler +

On April 16 2014 03:46 ObviousOne wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 15 2014 21:23 kushm4sta wrote:
Haven't read newest shit but

Oo why you want to plynch Akaka if you have no problem town reading him?
Why you gotta shit town read thrawn based on bullshit?

I wouldn't say that his activity is the only way to read him and it's subjective anyhow, I basically caught him through POE and that was the best reason I could come up with in Toy Story, he exhibited both behaviors there so I'm going to use the guideline until it no longer works (i.e. he steps up and plays the game). He's a policy lynch because I have no idea what the fuck he is saying 99% of the time. He seems to have the goal of being unreadable in every game he plays and that puts him in my "ok to policy lynch" group because I'd hate to lose to him (again, lol).

re: thrawn, how would you suggest I eliminate people from the lynch based on their behavior if not on some basic first post instinct when the game is like 20 minutes in? I've opened lines of communication when in the past things have been not so great between us, unless I recall incorrectly. The last game we played together I wanted to lynch him and he ended up being town, so I'm trying a new approach so I don't immediately put him in a category labeled "people I want to lynch because I hate"

Gotta re-read after I get some coffee in me. Only other thought I had for the moment is I didn't immediately want to lynch Koshi which is standing out to me. I think he's more actively participating (rather than posting for what looks like the sake of posting) than in other games I've read/played with him in them. Maybe that's some kind of themed-level-Koshi and I haven't seen a normal ass game Koshi in recent memory?


On April 16 2014 14:22 ObviousOne wrote:

-snipped-

@mderg - not a single thing he's written comes to mind, so I go look and remember he had a single post. Pretty insightful post, if his claim to not having much time is true. One-liners are a part of the current meta-game so you're going to have to deal with it. Have you come up with any scum reads yet?



On April 17 2014 05:36 ObviousOne wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 17 2014 05:15 mderg wrote:
On April 17 2014 04:57 ObviousOne wrote:
Kush giving me the town boner as of his return this second half.

Thank fuck we have a replacement, hello vivax please explain why I am on your POE or what you didn't like about me.

mderg's main, perhaps only, focus is a vig claim / scumminess of claiming a near-verifable role D1? That's... concerning, he's getting my vote for now. No reason to be pushing to lynch blue claims unless there's a cc. He's even sticking with it despite talking to others and defending his position which, with a tiny bit of critical thought should be an intractable one.

##vote: mderg

@FT: Koshi reads town to me only because he's all over the place and active. I'm more familiar with his "go forth and do work for me" town-meta that I think he uses in themed games but I'm not as aware of his regular town-game meta. My distant memory from back when Titanic 1 was a thing was that his scum game was pretty focused, but I'm bad with the memory thing sometimes so if you have something contradictory that would be useful today I'd like to see that.
On April 17 2014 04:32 FirmTofu wrote:
I don't like Koshi's insistence on pushing kush. Kush has a decent past few pages and his pressure of Cavalinho seems genuine.

Although Kush brings up some good points on Cavalinho, I'm not entirely convinced. Cavalinho looks like he doesn't understand that people sometimes give out null reads in order to promote discussion on a player. Fundamentally, he doesn't understand the purpose of my post: to explain to Koshi why Dja was not the appropriate use of our time in the thread.

@kush+Koshi Tell me what you think of OmniEulogy so far. I'm curious to hear your thoughts.


Did you even read my posts? The claim is the one thing that makes Skan look less scummy. The claim was never my focus, it was everything besides that. I´m also having a hard time understanding the rest of the paragraph about me. Would it be possible to rephrase that?

Any potential vigilante situation is self-solving. Either a shot is called and made, called a missed, not called and claimed later, or never called but the vigilante dies. Giving any amount of effort towards discussing how much you do or don't believe it and arguing about it or using it to defend someone before any of those events happen is ridiculous.

So to say it another way; having a read on a player solely for their power claim is ridiculous because we know that mafia can fake claim, we know that a power role who claims early can get their role blocked, they can be simply shot, and other corner cases where it leads into some kind of big play (which I would discount but in the interests of trying to be thorough I add it here).

So if he's actually blue then you pushing for his lynch is pointless endeavour for anyone thinking with a town mindset. With so few potential power roles in a normal game (something you may not be aware of). You can just accept for one day that he's got something useful to contribute outside of his lack of conversational contribution and focus on real lynch candidate possibilities instead until it can be established he's lying or he is caught in a sure-fire situation where he knows something that he shouldn't.

That is why I think your vote is wasted and you've given him the possibility of being town for his role but you refuse to accept what that means for the overarching scheme of the game when you pursue him as a potential lynch candidate.


On April 17 2014 06:19 mderg wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 17 2014 05:36 ObviousOne wrote:
On April 17 2014 05:15 mderg wrote:
On April 17 2014 04:57 ObviousOne wrote:
Kush giving me the town boner as of his return this second half.

Thank fuck we have a replacement, hello vivax please explain why I am on your POE or what you didn't like about me.

mderg's main, perhaps only, focus is a vig claim / scumminess of claiming a near-verifable role D1? That's... concerning, he's getting my vote for now. No reason to be pushing to lynch blue claims unless there's a cc. He's even sticking with it despite talking to others and defending his position which, with a tiny bit of critical thought should be an intractable one.

##vote: mderg

@FT: Koshi reads town to me only because he's all over the place and active. I'm more familiar with his "go forth and do work for me" town-meta that I think he uses in themed games but I'm not as aware of his regular town-game meta. My distant memory from back when Titanic 1 was a thing was that his scum game was pretty focused, but I'm bad with the memory thing sometimes so if you have something contradictory that would be useful today I'd like to see that.
On April 17 2014 04:32 FirmTofu wrote:
I don't like Koshi's insistence on pushing kush. Kush has a decent past few pages and his pressure of Cavalinho seems genuine.

Although Kush brings up some good points on Cavalinho, I'm not entirely convinced. Cavalinho looks like he doesn't understand that people sometimes give out null reads in order to promote discussion on a player. Fundamentally, he doesn't understand the purpose of my post: to explain to Koshi why Dja was not the appropriate use of our time in the thread.

@kush+Koshi Tell me what you think of OmniEulogy so far. I'm curious to hear your thoughts.


Did you even read my posts? The claim is the one thing that makes Skan look less scummy. The claim was never my focus, it was everything besides that. I´m also having a hard time understanding the rest of the paragraph about me. Would it be possible to rephrase that?

Any potential vigilante situation is self-solving. Either a shot is called and made, called a missed, not called and claimed later, or never called but the vigilante dies. Giving any amount of effort towards discussing how much you do or don't believe it and arguing about it or using it to defend someone before any of those events happen is ridiculous.

So to say it another way; having a read on a player solely for their power claim is ridiculous because we know that mafia can fake claim, we know that a power role who claims early can get their role blocked, they can be simply shot, and other corner cases where it leads into some kind of big play (which I would discount but in the interests of trying to be thorough I add it here).

So if he's actually blue then you pushing for his lynch is pointless endeavour for anyone thinking with a town mindset. With so few potential power roles in a normal game (something you may not be aware of). You can just accept for one day that he's got something useful to contribute outside of his lack of conversational contribution and focus on real lynch candidate possibilities instead until it can be established he's lying or he is caught in a sure-fire situation where he knows something that he shouldn't.

That is why I think your vote is wasted and you've given him the possibility of being town for his role but you refuse to accept what that means for the overarching scheme of the game when you pursue him as a potential lynch candidate.

Doesn´t change the fact that Skan looks scummy to me but it definitely speaks against lynching him on day 1.



##vote: FirmTofu
Because his analysis on Skan and Djagu doesn´t say anything and I think his case on OTW is bad. I especially don´t like this post:
Show nested quote +
On April 17 2014 05:04 FirmTofu wrote:
@OTW
Okay, so thrawn is repeating a lot of things previously stated in thread. This is a valid point. However, I don't see this as necessarily scummy. Town players repeat points too and this is a perfectly valid one to reiterate. You'll need better points to convince me thrawn is scum.

Also, your recent responses to Vivax and I are not helping your case.

In this post he gives OTW´s case some credit. Before this post he said that the case was awful. This change of his opinion contradicts the vote on OTW right after the post.


On April 17 2014 07:31 ObviousOne wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 17 2014 07:24 thrawn2112 wrote:
hey guys what's up? on pg 22 right now. only thing I can really conclude from what I've read is that I think mderg is town. probably kush too

I don't really know who I would vote for if not mderg. I think kush is probably town, but fuck me if I could prove it without a doubt. I keep conflating djag and cav in my mind for some reason. Djag seems to have been all gung-ho about playing super townie but spent half the day discussing that concept in various ways somehow.
Show nested quote +
On April 15 2014 20:31 Djagulingu wrote:
On April 15 2014 20:29 Koshi wrote:
On April 15 2014 20:28 Djagulingu wrote:
On April 15 2014 20:25 Koshi wrote:
I am awaiting his response first.

It was as scumslip as "100%"

I don't see what you are seeing tbh.
I can guess somewhere what you are thinking but it kinda thin.

We will see.

You have no idea what I'm thinking lol.

Seems to be a theme for his game. I'm really not sure what he's thinking lol. He has it out for Cav.



Cav is also on the mderg-probably-town boat with you but he's played the filter length card against FT when his own filter is less than a page as well. Which is hilarious and stuff but by his own reasons for calling FT scum he is scum to himself. Not very fleshed out reasons for why FT is scum plus a short filter.

Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 18 2014 19:02 GMT
#1090
Not that you'll have to look much cause I bolded the relevant stuff to make it easier
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 18 2014 21:03 GMT
#1094
On April 19 2014 04:38 Koshi wrote:
Also pls take a look at the conversation between skanjab and mrderg.


He semi-calls you scummy for defending mderg, looks like the paranoia I got pre-deadline about thrawn, OE and FT, but it can also be faked.

Otherwise I don't see anything of particular interest in that conversation, he responds to mderg point by point. THe conversation in itself isn't particularly alignment indicative in my opinion.

What WOULD be alignment indicative is why he would fakeclaim, and I'm interested into the way he gave priorities to his D1 reads. His scumreads went like mderg -> kush -> mderg (+ koshi?) -> FT and I have yet to see what he's doing to push his reads or find out if they are right. So far he's only been the attachy type of player. Agrees with thrawn on kush and mderg, agrees on FT. Not much of his own out there. Possibly scum.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 18 2014 21:27 GMT
#1096
On April 19 2014 06:25 Koshi wrote:
can theyboth be scum in your experience?


I don't think mderg is scum, you wanted to get at something connection-y?
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 18 2014 22:35 GMT
#1098
On April 19 2014 06:56 Koshi wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 19 2014 06:27 Vivax wrote:
On April 19 2014 06:25 Koshi wrote:
can theyboth be scum in your experience?


I don't think mderg is scum, you wanted to get at something connection-y?

No I wonder if you think that conversation can be done scum/scum. At that time in the game. 50% of both their filter.


It's possible. I didn't really doubt the vig claim cause I figured it would get sorted out at a later point, but if your scumbuddy knows you're fakeclaiming you might feel like putting in an early attack on the claimer for a later gain, however I'm currently comfortable believing that mderg is town.

If you look at the quotes from OO you will notice that he called mderg scummy for wanting to lynch skanja at that point, mderg obliged and switched, OO didn't take that into account later and kept his vote on him, didn't deliver an own interpretation of that which is what I want him to do now and is one of the things I wanted you to notice. Also, that's the only reason he voted for mderg.

Additionally, if you look at the first post you will notice how it's wall-of-text-like with very little information, I mentioned that earlier in D1.

We should lynch Skanja or OO today and they both should be starting to contribute if they don't want that to happen. Still got questions open for you.

Additionally, I have a question for OE: Are you the vigilante? Cause earlier you said that Skanja's claim was likely fake.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 18 2014 23:11 GMT
#1100
On April 19 2014 07:50 Koshi wrote:
He claimed vig right before daypost.


Bleh I missed that post lol
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 20 2014 00:03 GMT
#1128
That last post by OO just screams scum and I'm actually starting to think I could have been wrong on mderg.

Huge post and fucking off is what I would expect from a scum giving up and since then we didn't hear anything from our german fellow. Given the current time in EU i doubt he will drop a post before the deadline.

Mderg's inactivity IS scummy if OO is indeed scum which at this point is very likely. In this scenario a demoralized scum team is what we're expecting today, a scum team only doing half-assed efforts to win the game, and that also brings me to Skanja dropping a post claiming he has no time.

If we analyze Skanja's fakeclaim and the subsequent reactions, imagining that his team disapproved, we can also imagine how they were angry at him and lost motivation to play the game. This would also explain the early attack from mderg on skanja when everybody was just treating that claim as unimportant.

If mderg HAD the extra information, and saw skanja dicking around and playing risky, then that would explain the overall low activity, especially now that it matters, and his desire for that extensive early attack on Skanja.

Most of this is connection based for the moment but we shouldn't just lean back and lynch OO without planning the next steps.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 20 2014 00:04 GMT
#1129
Koshi since you asked me earlier about that precise conversation, can you elaborate what it was you were seeing?
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 20 2014 09:30 GMT
#1142
Kush, there's one thing making me doubt that mderg might be scum and it's the fact that it's the only guy OO ever really pushed, and he started with him first iirc.

You think it's that likely that OO busses his buddy right at the start?

Also you got to explain to me how you put skanja last in your list, AFTER ME. That doesn't make any fucking sense. He's a guy who fakeclaimed and doesn't play the game, whereas I'm town and playing like town like the majority already realized.

That said, I'd put skanja ahead of mderg in the to-lynch list.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 20 2014 10:51 GMT
#1145
On April 20 2014 19:28 thrawn2112 wrote:
vivax you aren't really as townie as you say you are. you haven't done much lately.


No, that's the wrong measure. What I do is what makes me town or scum not what I don't do during a day where the lynch was rather obvious and people refused to discuss the other scum with me.

If I were scum you would be able to find information in my filter that proves it, so go ahead and review it.
While you're at it, also review kush's evolution of his read on me. It follows thread sentiment if you look at the context.

U scum kush?
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 20 2014 11:04 GMT
#1147
Idk man, it's not transparent at all how he goes from town- to scumreading me, and it always happens when somebody else is calling me town or scum.

Additionally the way he pushed Cava reminds me of his scumplay in Dr Who where he basically got 100 % scum on one dude then started to taunt him and shit.

On April 18 2014 12:38 kushm4sta wrote:
scum list in case I die:

cavalinho
vivax
oo
mderg


On April 18 2014 12:45 kushm4sta wrote:
nvm i strongly believe that vivax is town after reviewing his filter


On April 20 2014 11:15 kushm4sta wrote:
i agree koshi. vivax is the scummiest player not in the PoE group (mderg, skan, oo, OTW)
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 20 2014 11:08 GMT
#1149
Then there's this which is also bugging, does it look like he's doing ANYTHING about OO after saying he wasn't looking townie?

On April 16 2014 23:41 kushm4sta wrote:
Kochi can you chill the fuck out? I don't get why you went crazy when people started voting mberg.

You have to realize this game is half noobs. If they got scum and came into the game late, it's very hard for them to look town.
Mberg or ft are both very possibly scum.

Kochi acting weird.
Oo not looking townie.

More coming within the next few hours.

Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 20 2014 11:21 GMT
#1152
On April 20 2014 20:15 thrawn2112 wrote:
you ask too many leading questions. i dont like it.


Sorry for trying to have some fucking CONVERSATION. Come on thrawn, stop avoiding drawing conclusions. Do you think it's normal for kush to mention that one dude is scummy who actually was scum and then 100 % lock on Cava and ignore everything else?
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 20 2014 11:22 GMT
#1153
On April 20 2014 20:15 thrawn2112 wrote:
also i am paranoid that djag died because you are pro blue hunter


Wat
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 20 2014 11:24 GMT
#1155
On April 20 2014 20:23 thrawn2112 wrote:
i don't know. but he's town.


Persuade me cause right now I'm seeing things that make it possible he's not.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 20 2014 11:35 GMT
#1157
On April 20 2014 20:26 thrawn2112 wrote:
i dont even understand your accusation. you are basicalyl accusing him of making a correct read and then changing hsi mind or forgetting about it? i dont see how that's as scummy as you're making it.


I want to know how his reads evolved, cause given that OO flipped scum and kush calls him out without a reason and then forgets about him to push a lynch on a townie without other questions asked, it could easily fit into the pattern of kush wanting to be right somewhere.

His read on me that he constantly changes when people call me something´is what actually should motivate you to take a better look at him.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 20 2014 11:55 GMT
#1160
On April 20 2014 20:54 kushm4sta wrote:
talk to me about it vivax.


It's your turn to talk.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 20 2014 11:59 GMT
#1162
On April 20 2014 20:56 kushm4sta wrote:
why did my read of you change?
it's a little something called reading your filter and seeing all the shit you were saying.
Do i remember anythign specific? no.

I said OO "did not look town", That meant he wasn't doing anythign that was giving me a townread on him. I thought there was a greatly probability cav was going to flip scum. After cav, OO was the first person I wanted to lynch.


What in my filter made you change my read to scum, to town and to scum again?
Read it again if you don't remember.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 20 2014 12:15 GMT
#1164
That looks rather reasonableas answer, but remove me one curiosity: Why is Skanja last on your to-lynch list? Is there anything that makes you think he could be town after that fakeclaim?
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 21 2014 05:47 GMT
#1242
On April 20 2014 21:31 kushm4sta wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 20 2014 21:15 Vivax wrote:
That looks rather reasonableas answer, but remove me one curiosity: Why is Skanja last on your to-lynch list? Is there anything that makes you think he could be town after that fakeclaim?


I think the fake claim itself leans town. I don't find his tone scummy.


This doesn't make any sense and doesn't align with anything I've seen you doing in the last game where you were town.

I claimed miller at the start of D1 and you went "I'll treat it as null cause Vivax has history of ballsy claims as scum". When skanja fakeclaims you see it as townie. You really gotta explain HOW in the world a dude fakeclaiming gets any town points for it, and it better be a good explanation.

This game must not end up like British Empire II, or that last game on OMGUS. It's at danger of becoming another epithome of stupidity. British: Dandel trolls all game long and goes unnoticed for too long. On Omgus Alakaslam doesn't do shit all game long except jump on townie wagons and post his usual rubbish and I get lynched (by thrawn and kush) instead of him after claiming miller and we lose the game.
And I was always there talking to a wall cause people just prefer to adher to a complex version of events where they end up making up by themselves why a townie is scum and a troll is town.

In summary, we should lynch Skanja to not repeat the same mistake other stupid towns did, and figure out who the last scum is. And it's one of mderg or kush. If it's anyone outside of them they deserve to win.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 21 2014 06:42 GMT
#1244
On April 21 2014 14:52 kushm4sta wrote:
all the scummy mother fuckers want to lynch skan. that is not a good sign.


Sure, when the Cava lynch was averted you concluded it was scum swaying the wagon. Now that it can't fit any more as a reason to push your reads, it's scum wanting to lynch skan, a guy who you say is townie FOR his fakeclaim which is completely bogus unless you can find an explanation for him to do that as town.

There's this guy not playing the game fakeclaiming cause he says he can't or doesn't want to play the game and he must be town for the fakeclaim.

Try to explain how that makes sense. How do you townread Skan? What's the reason? Find it in his filter. Prove that you're not making everything up, cause that's what it looks like right now. Even your read on me which looked reasonable at glance has the weakness that your reasons for me being town far outweigh the reasons for me being scum, which are PoE, claiming you don't know my meta which is bullshit given how much we've played together, and trying hard being scummy in your eyes.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 21 2014 11:03 GMT
#1250
On April 21 2014 19:39 Skanjab1s wrote:
From what I've read so far, everyone is just focusing on a Vivax/Me team. Who do you think would be scum if I had to flip green? You should account for this and not just focus so hard on Vivax/Me being scum that once I'm lynched you get stuck not knowing who the last scum is.


You tell us we should look for the last scum while at the same time not trying to guess who it could possibly be.
So, any guesses?
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 22 2014 01:10 GMT
#1295
I'm voting Skanja and going to bed. If you really have to flip me before the liar, you know what to do afterwards. Lynch him and either kush or mderg, I'm still not sure on the both of them.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 22 2014 14:50 GMT
#1304
Of course I bring up the mistakes bad townies make cause of my strong personal involvement in those games.
I pushed Dandel in british. I wanted to lynch Alakaslam for being unreadable in Toy Story, other townies actually thought I was scummy for pushing those targets who turned out to be scum, same is happening with you cause I'm pushing Skanja.

This game is no different and people like you don't learn from their mistakes so I have to remind them.
No, I'm not sure between Kush and mderg as the last scum. If it were so easy I would be sure, hence why we have to lynch skanja. He is by no means acting townie as you say.

Kush gave him a townread cause skanja said what he wanted to hear. He perfectly and completely imitated kush and thrawn's point of view in his townread post (Kush and thrawn town, everybody else scum). The fact that he mentions a flipped guy and a claimed vig among his townreads only displays that he's writing ANYTHING to appease people and give his scumbuddy a reason to townread him.

His reasons for the fakeclaim are complete bullshit:

On April 22 2014 06:48 Skanjab1s wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 22 2014 06:22 OneThousandWords wrote:
On April 22 2014 05:23 Skanjab1s wrote:
On April 22 2014 01:11 OneThousandWords wrote:
On April 21 2014 21:13 kushm4sta wrote:
Skan I agree with you.
See skan is the only one realistically thinking about the scum team. All the other possible scums are hinting at people like me because they know they need lynches outside the poe to win.


Well that's just not true. It's the most simplistic thing in the world to give a list of names with no reasoning like skan has done and I strongly think Vivax is town. The only thing you've brought up is his questioning of your lynch order and that's mediocre at best compared to the entire filter of Skanjabs!


What in my filter is scummy, specifically?


I already posted about everyone, this is my point exactly! Nobody is reading the thread and the game right now feels a lot like the day 1 lynch where everyone is saying the name of who they want to lynch but not actually giving reasons!

I honestly do not think Vivax is scum at all and the fact everyone is pushing him as scummy over people like skanjab1s and mderg when vivax was pretty much one of the top town reads for a lot of people is really odd. Vivax is the only one that tried to get discussion going in regards to the day 1 lynch and tried to get people to post reasons for their lynch he was also the only one to start discussions on the next few days when it was very quiet only to get shut down and called scum!

If there's one thing I can be right about this game is that this feels really odd.

Skanjab1s, I have you as scum for claiming vig as an excuse to cover up your lack of activity. You were very defensive on day 1 over everything and only mentioned FirmTofu once and then afk voted him only to return the next day and claim roleblock.

If you are town which for some reason people say you are and aren't giving reasons you should be realising that things are wrong too!


I claimed vig in the hopes that I'd get nk'd, because of my impending lack of activity.It would be a terrible scum tactic to claim vig to cover up lack of activity if, when I become inactive, I don't hold onto the vig claim. The vig claim would only help then if people still thought I was the vig.

I'm not sure what you mean about being defensive over everything. I wasn't defensive at all, except for when I was responding to mderg's accusations. I thought there was way more time in the day when I voted firmtofu (I actually realised that I had voted him after the deadline when thrawn said so). It was supposed to be a pressuring vote to hear more from him, but I did think he was scum, I didn't know why he would fake knowing what I'd do as scum if he hadn't seen my scumgame.


The bolded is a perfect example of a bullshit reason. Why is it bullshit? Cause no matter if he claimed vig as town or scum, the effects would still be the same at this point, making his claim an advantage for a town skanja as well as a scum skanja, yet he turns it around saying that cause he has that advantage he has to be town while he wouldn't have it as scum...for what reasons??? No logic behind this post. It's another lie from a liar.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 22 2014 15:04 GMT
#1306
Kush magically gets a townread from somebody like skanja only cause he writes "you and your thrawn buddy town, others scum". I don't buy that shit.

Vixax is not this bad and if he were town he'd be able to see how obviously townie kush is.


No, activity is roughly the same as in Dr Who and he started to emanate the same sort of bullshit confidence he did in that game. His reasons for townreading skanja are complete bogus and he should never be that confident that skanja could be town. Nobody else is and that should raise red flags.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 22 2014 15:14 GMT
#1308
On April 23 2014 00:02 thrawn2112 wrote:
vivax why do you think OTW is super town?


Cause he reads me as town and skanja as scum.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 22 2014 15:18 GMT
#1310
Is that all you have to say?
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 22 2014 15:57 GMT
#1315
On April 23 2014 00:42 Skanjab1s wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 22 2014 14:03 thrawn2112 wrote:
On April 22 2014 08:01 OmniEulogy wrote:
On April 20 2014 20:44 thrawn2112 wrote:
well talk to him about it and not me. idk why you are expecting me to either accept your read on him or be able to fill in the gaps in his reads. because that is something i cannot do unless i am kush and i am town


Anyway I took the above as meaning if Kush was town but I'm just making sure as it could also be interpreted as it was something you couldn't do because you aren't town. It drew a flag but I ignored it as I had you as town and I still do but I just want to make sure that I read this in particular correctly.


yes you read it right.

On April 22 2014 10:10 Vivax wrote:
I'm voting Skanja and going to bed. If you really have to flip me before the liar, you know what to do afterwards. Lynch him and either kush or mderg, I'm still not sure on the both of them.


posts like this are why i want to lynch vivax.

so from a town vivax's point of view, this would be the best he can come up with? i don't buy it.

The first major problem is that vivax isn't considering OTW as possible scum. He's not worried about OTW's alignment at all. In fact he hasn't mentioned OTW since D1. This doesn't have mean anything regarding OTW's alignment, my point is that vivax is not considering all possible suspects.

I really really hate this post:

On April 21 2014 14:47 Vivax wrote:
On April 20 2014 21:31 kushm4sta wrote:
On April 20 2014 21:15 Vivax wrote:
That looks rather reasonableas answer, but remove me one curiosity: Why is Skanja last on your to-lynch list? Is there anything that makes you think he could be town after that fakeclaim?


I think the fake claim itself leans town. I don't find his tone scummy.


This doesn't make any sense and doesn't align with anything I've seen you doing in the last game where you were town.

I claimed miller at the start of D1 and you went "I'll treat it as null cause Vivax has history of ballsy claims as scum". When skanja fakeclaims you see it as townie. You really gotta explain HOW in the world a dude fakeclaiming gets any town points for it, and it better be a good explanation.

This game must not end up like British Empire II, or that last game on OMGUS. It's at danger of becoming another epithome of stupidity. British: Dandel trolls all game long and goes unnoticed for too long. On Omgus Alakaslam doesn't do shit all game long except jump on townie wagons and post his usual rubbish and I get lynched (by thrawn and kush) instead of him after claiming miller and we lose the game.
And I was always there talking to a wall cause people just prefer to adher to a complex version of events where they end up making up by themselves why a townie is scum and a troll is town.

In summary, we should lynch Skanja to not repeat the same mistake other stupid towns did, and figure out who the last scum is. And it's one of mderg or kush. If it's anyone outside of them they deserve to win.


BE II and the omgus toy story game have nothing to do with skan's alignment. Here Vivax is appealing to the emotions of the people who lost BEII/TSM.


In addition to this, what I also find interesting, is that in the beginning of this, Vivax is equating me with him in the OMGUS game for our claims, where he claimed miller, and was lynched, and flipped town. And now, to stop a repeat of this happening he wants to lynch me (who fakeclaimed vig) because i'll flip...scum? That logic doesn't really add up.
Show nested quote +
On April 22 2014 23:50 Vivax wrote:
Of course I bring up the mistakes bad townies make cause of my strong personal involvement in those games.
I pushed Dandel in british. I wanted to lynch Alakaslam for being unreadable in Toy Story, other townies actually thought I was scummy for pushing those targets who turned out to be scum, same is happening with you cause I'm pushing Skanja.

This game is no different and people like you don't learn from their mistakes so I have to remind them.
No, I'm not sure between Kush and mderg as the last scum. If it were so easy I would be sure, hence why we have to lynch skanja. He is by no means acting townie as you say.

Kush gave him a townread cause skanja said what he wanted to hear. He perfectly and completely imitated kush and thrawn's point of view in his townread post (Kush and thrawn town, everybody else scum). The fact that he mentions a flipped guy and a claimed vig among his townreads only displays that he's writing ANYTHING to appease people and give his scumbuddy a reason to townread him.

His reasons for the fakeclaim are complete bullshit:

On April 22 2014 06:48 Skanjab1s wrote:
On April 22 2014 06:22 OneThousandWords wrote:
On April 22 2014 05:23 Skanjab1s wrote:
On April 22 2014 01:11 OneThousandWords wrote:
On April 21 2014 21:13 kushm4sta wrote:
Skan I agree with you.
See skan is the only one realistically thinking about the scum team. All the other possible scums are hinting at people like me because they know they need lynches outside the poe to win.


Well that's just not true. It's the most simplistic thing in the world to give a list of names with no reasoning like skan has done and I strongly think Vivax is town. The only thing you've brought up is his questioning of your lynch order and that's mediocre at best compared to the entire filter of Skanjabs!


What in my filter is scummy, specifically?


I already posted about everyone, this is my point exactly! Nobody is reading the thread and the game right now feels a lot like the day 1 lynch where everyone is saying the name of who they want to lynch but not actually giving reasons!

I honestly do not think Vivax is scum at all and the fact everyone is pushing him as scummy over people like skanjab1s and mderg when vivax was pretty much one of the top town reads for a lot of people is really odd. Vivax is the only one that tried to get discussion going in regards to the day 1 lynch and tried to get people to post reasons for their lynch he was also the only one to start discussions on the next few days when it was very quiet only to get shut down and called scum!

If there's one thing I can be right about this game is that this feels really odd.

Skanjab1s, I have you as scum for claiming vig as an excuse to cover up your lack of activity. You were very defensive on day 1 over everything and only mentioned FirmTofu once and then afk voted him only to return the next day and claim roleblock.

If you are town which for some reason people say you are and aren't giving reasons you should be realising that things are wrong too!


I claimed vig in the hopes that I'd get nk'd, because of my impending lack of activity.It would be a terrible scum tactic to claim vig to cover up lack of activity if, when I become inactive, I don't hold onto the vig claim. The vig claim would only help then if people still thought I was the vig.

I'm not sure what you mean about being defensive over everything. I wasn't defensive at all, except for when I was responding to mderg's accusations. I thought there was way more time in the day when I voted firmtofu (I actually realised that I had voted him after the deadline when thrawn said so). It was supposed to be a pressuring vote to hear more from him, but I did think he was scum, I didn't know why he would fake knowing what I'd do as scum if he hadn't seen my scumgame.


The bolded is a perfect example of a bullshit reason. Why is it bullshit? Cause no matter if he claimed vig as town or scum, the effects would still be the same at this point, making his claim an advantage for a town skanja as well as a scum skanja, yet he turns it around saying that cause he has that advantage he has to be town while he wouldn't have it as scum...for what reasons??? No logic behind this post. It's another lie from a liar.

Okay, explain how there is an advantage of me fake-claiming vig as scum, at this point in the game. Because this is the only reason you are able to give as to why I'm scum. That doesn't sound like much of an advantage at all. Also, please explain how my logic here is bullshit?


My miller claim was real. Yours was fake. On omgus I got lynched over Alakaslam,now I'm at danger at getting lynched over a liar who never was of any help to the game, who never tried to take influence over a lynch for good or for bad.

Claiming vig will not get you NKd and you should know that. The only reason you would do that is to get a CC or do it yourself, fake a shot using scum KP like I did in some games, get a free pass D1 on top of everything.

You say the vig fakeclaim would be terrible scum play. So, what would be different at this point between the version where you're scum and the version where you're town? How didn't the vig claim work out for you? Do nothing D1, get a chance of finding out who the vig is D1, say you hoped to get NKd when it turns out your claim was fake.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 22 2014 16:11 GMT
#1318
You would understand why I said that if you understood what I wrote about kush bullshit reading skanja for the exact same reason. Seeing how thick you are in realizing we both did the exact same thing, you are henceforth ignored, thrawn.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 22 2014 16:35 GMT
#1319
On April 23 2014 00:55 Skanjab1s wrote:
It's one of OTW/mderg. And it's basically just PoE, I have strong townreads on everyone else in the game and they're the ones that I haven't had any town-feels from.


What made you change your mind about your D1 read on kush?

What posts.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 22 2014 17:25 GMT
#1321
Explain me this: Why would a town Skanja who has clearly time to play D1 fake vig claim in order to cover up inactivity?

Why didn't he simply tell us he would be busy soon? Why fakeclaim? Scum holds back roleblock N1 and if town had no vig he would have gotten away with it.

It simply makes no sense to fakeclaim for such a triviality.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 22 2014 17:31 GMT
#1322
Seriously, reread Day1. Look how skanjabis calls out mderg and kush scum, does nothing to push his reads, then when asked by thrawn to switch to FT, he makes up aquick reason and switches:

On April 17 2014 19:18 Skanjab1s wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 17 2014 18:02 thrawn2112 wrote:
On April 17 2014 17:33 Skanjab1s wrote:
On April 17 2014 03:59 FirmTofu wrote:
On April 16 2014 18:52 Skanjab1s wrote:
Rejoice, I have woken up to so many pages, I'm gonna go through them and respond to everything.
On April 16 2014 03:56 ObviousOne wrote:
On April 15 2014 18:56 Skanjab1s wrote:
Hey guys, I'm the Vig. I've only got 3 days to play this game, so claiming now is the best option. I will use my 1 shot tonight on whoever i deem worthy of it. So far, that person is OO, for insulting my honor.

This is tweek right?

Yes!
On April 16 2014 05:56 FirmTofu wrote:
On April 15 2014 18:56 Skanjab1s wrote:
Hey guys, I'm the Vig. I've only got 3 days to play this game, so claiming now is the best option. I will use my 1 shot tonight on whoever i deem worthy of it. So far, that person is OO, for insulting my honor.

Skanjab has said little of value, but his roleclaim is an important milestone in this game. Firstly, I think his roleclaim is genuine. Mafia claiming this early is an insane risk. The potential benefits of claiming vig as mafia are far outweighed by the cost of losing 1/3 of their team. From what I know of skanjab, he's not the type of player to take huge risks like this as mafia, where other people are directly dependent on his survival.

I'm going to take this claim at face value and assume for the time being that it is genuine.

All that being said, I think this vig claim is a terrible play from Skanjab. Not only did he claim to be one of a handful of blue roles we have, he also wants to shoot immediately and has already stated a potential target.

So, @Skanjab: Please keep your intended target to yourself. Why did you think claiming was a good idea? How do you intend to proceed throughout the day? We need to hear more from you and you need to start actively scumhunting so you can choose the best possible target.



I will keep my target to myself, don't worry. I'm going to carry on scumhunting (more actively as of now) and just proceed as usual. I always find the beginnings of days hard to actually contribute to, now that we've got lots of pages of stuff I'll be better.

FirmTofu, just out of curiosity, do you play on omgus? How many games have you played with me?

No, I've never played with you on omgus. It's good that you're back. Gonna finish catching up now.

But, if the only games you've played with me are on here, where I have never rolled scum, how do you know I wouldn't take a big risk like this as mafia? You say 'he's not the type of player to take huge risks like this as mafia', but you've never seen my mafia game.


i'd sheep that.

hey skan do you wanna lynch FT? i'm down.


Yeah, I do. This feels like he knows that I'm town, but needed to make up a reason to believe that in the thread, so he made up some generic nonsense about what kind of player I am, when he hasn't actually seen my games. I don't know why a town FT would do this.


Afterwards his scumread on kush disappears, when kush and thrawn start pushing me he townreads them and scumreads everybody else cause PoE.

There is only an apparent evolution of his reads D1 in his filter, zero intention to steer a lynch, jumping on the easiest wagons for the smallest reasons.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 22 2014 18:32 GMT
#1329
On April 23 2014 02:42 Skanjab1s wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 23 2014 02:31 Vivax wrote:
Seriously, reread Day1. Look how skanjabis calls out mderg and kush scum, does nothing to push his reads, then when asked by thrawn to switch to FT, he makes up aquick reason and switches:

On April 17 2014 19:18 Skanjab1s wrote:
On April 17 2014 18:02 thrawn2112 wrote:
On April 17 2014 17:33 Skanjab1s wrote:
On April 17 2014 03:59 FirmTofu wrote:
On April 16 2014 18:52 Skanjab1s wrote:
Rejoice, I have woken up to so many pages, I'm gonna go through them and respond to everything.
On April 16 2014 03:56 ObviousOne wrote:
On April 15 2014 18:56 Skanjab1s wrote:
Hey guys, I'm the Vig. I've only got 3 days to play this game, so claiming now is the best option. I will use my 1 shot tonight on whoever i deem worthy of it. So far, that person is OO, for insulting my honor.

This is tweek right?

Yes!
On April 16 2014 05:56 FirmTofu wrote:
On April 15 2014 18:56 Skanjab1s wrote:
Hey guys, I'm the Vig. I've only got 3 days to play this game, so claiming now is the best option. I will use my 1 shot tonight on whoever i deem worthy of it. So far, that person is OO, for insulting my honor.

Skanjab has said little of value, but his roleclaim is an important milestone in this game. Firstly, I think his roleclaim is genuine. Mafia claiming this early is an insane risk. The potential benefits of claiming vig as mafia are far outweighed by the cost of losing 1/3 of their team. From what I know of skanjab, he's not the type of player to take huge risks like this as mafia, where other people are directly dependent on his survival.

I'm going to take this claim at face value and assume for the time being that it is genuine.

All that being said, I think this vig claim is a terrible play from Skanjab. Not only did he claim to be one of a handful of blue roles we have, he also wants to shoot immediately and has already stated a potential target.

So, @Skanjab: Please keep your intended target to yourself. Why did you think claiming was a good idea? How do you intend to proceed throughout the day? We need to hear more from you and you need to start actively scumhunting so you can choose the best possible target.



I will keep my target to myself, don't worry. I'm going to carry on scumhunting (more actively as of now) and just proceed as usual. I always find the beginnings of days hard to actually contribute to, now that we've got lots of pages of stuff I'll be better.

FirmTofu, just out of curiosity, do you play on omgus? How many games have you played with me?

No, I've never played with you on omgus. It's good that you're back. Gonna finish catching up now.

But, if the only games you've played with me are on here, where I have never rolled scum, how do you know I wouldn't take a big risk like this as mafia? You say 'he's not the type of player to take huge risks like this as mafia', but you've never seen my mafia game.


i'd sheep that.

hey skan do you wanna lynch FT? i'm down.


Yeah, I do. This feels like he knows that I'm town, but needed to make up a reason to believe that in the thread, so he made up some generic nonsense about what kind of player I am, when he hasn't actually seen my games. I don't know why a town FT would do this.


Afterwards his scumread on kush disappears, when kush and thrawn start pushing me he townreads them and scumreads everybody else cause PoE.

There is only an apparent evolution of his reads D1 in his filter, zero intention to steer a lynch, jumping on the easiest wagons for the smallest reasons.


Yeah, I thought kush was scummy for his early D1 play, then I changed my mind with his later play. You also forget that I voted for FirmTofu after he was actually lynched. I wasn't even aware that the day was close to ending, let alone that it was actually night already. But you can clearly see the progression of my read on FT. I saw him say something I thought was scummy, then questioned him on it and placed a vote on him, hoping for him to respond. That is how I progress with my scumreads.


Oh jesus, it was actually the night vote.

On April 17 2014 17:33 Skanjab1s wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 17 2014 03:59 FirmTofu wrote:
On April 16 2014 18:52 Skanjab1s wrote:
Rejoice, I have woken up to so many pages, I'm gonna go through them and respond to everything.
On April 16 2014 03:56 ObviousOne wrote:
On April 15 2014 18:56 Skanjab1s wrote:
Hey guys, I'm the Vig. I've only got 3 days to play this game, so claiming now is the best option. I will use my 1 shot tonight on whoever i deem worthy of it. So far, that person is OO, for insulting my honor.

This is tweek right?

Yes!
On April 16 2014 05:56 FirmTofu wrote:
On April 15 2014 18:56 Skanjab1s wrote:
Hey guys, I'm the Vig. I've only got 3 days to play this game, so claiming now is the best option. I will use my 1 shot tonight on whoever i deem worthy of it. So far, that person is OO, for insulting my honor.

Skanjab has said little of value, but his roleclaim is an important milestone in this game. Firstly, I think his roleclaim is genuine. Mafia claiming this early is an insane risk. The potential benefits of claiming vig as mafia are far outweighed by the cost of losing 1/3 of their team. From what I know of skanjab, he's not the type of player to take huge risks like this as mafia, where other people are directly dependent on his survival.

I'm going to take this claim at face value and assume for the time being that it is genuine.

All that being said, I think this vig claim is a terrible play from Skanjab. Not only did he claim to be one of a handful of blue roles we have, he also wants to shoot immediately and has already stated a potential target.

So, @Skanjab: Please keep your intended target to yourself. Why did you think claiming was a good idea? How do you intend to proceed throughout the day? We need to hear more from you and you need to start actively scumhunting so you can choose the best possible target.



I will keep my target to myself, don't worry. I'm going to carry on scumhunting (more actively as of now) and just proceed as usual. I always find the beginnings of days hard to actually contribute to, now that we've got lots of pages of stuff I'll be better.

FirmTofu, just out of curiosity, do you play on omgus? How many games have you played with me?

No, I've never played with you on omgus. It's good that you're back. Gonna finish catching up now.

But, if the only games you've played with me are on here, where I have never rolled scum, how do you know I wouldn't take a big risk like this as mafia? You say 'he's not the type of player to take huge risks like this as mafia', but you've never seen my mafia game.


On April 17 2014 19:18 Skanjab1s wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 17 2014 18:02 thrawn2112 wrote:
On April 17 2014 17:33 Skanjab1s wrote:
On April 17 2014 03:59 FirmTofu wrote:
On April 16 2014 18:52 Skanjab1s wrote:
Rejoice, I have woken up to so many pages, I'm gonna go through them and respond to everything.
On April 16 2014 03:56 ObviousOne wrote:
On April 15 2014 18:56 Skanjab1s wrote:
Hey guys, I'm the Vig. I've only got 3 days to play this game, so claiming now is the best option. I will use my 1 shot tonight on whoever i deem worthy of it. So far, that person is OO, for insulting my honor.

This is tweek right?

Yes!
On April 16 2014 05:56 FirmTofu wrote:
On April 15 2014 18:56 Skanjab1s wrote:
Hey guys, I'm the Vig. I've only got 3 days to play this game, so claiming now is the best option. I will use my 1 shot tonight on whoever i deem worthy of it. So far, that person is OO, for insulting my honor.

Skanjab has said little of value, but his roleclaim is an important milestone in this game. Firstly, I think his roleclaim is genuine. Mafia claiming this early is an insane risk. The potential benefits of claiming vig as mafia are far outweighed by the cost of losing 1/3 of their team. From what I know of skanjab, he's not the type of player to take huge risks like this as mafia, where other people are directly dependent on his survival.

I'm going to take this claim at face value and assume for the time being that it is genuine.

All that being said, I think this vig claim is a terrible play from Skanjab. Not only did he claim to be one of a handful of blue roles we have, he also wants to shoot immediately and has already stated a potential target.

So, @Skanjab: Please keep your intended target to yourself. Why did you think claiming was a good idea? How do you intend to proceed throughout the day? We need to hear more from you and you need to start actively scumhunting so you can choose the best possible target.



I will keep my target to myself, don't worry. I'm going to carry on scumhunting (more actively as of now) and just proceed as usual. I always find the beginnings of days hard to actually contribute to, now that we've got lots of pages of stuff I'll be better.

FirmTofu, just out of curiosity, do you play on omgus? How many games have you played with me?

No, I've never played with you on omgus. It's good that you're back. Gonna finish catching up now.

But, if the only games you've played with me are on here, where I have never rolled scum, how do you know I wouldn't take a big risk like this as mafia? You say 'he's not the type of player to take huge risks like this as mafia', but you've never seen my mafia game.


i'd sheep that.

hey skan do you wanna lynch FT? i'm down.


Yeah, I do. This feels like he knows that I'm town, but needed to make up a reason to believe that in the thread, so he made up some generic nonsense about what kind of player I am, when he hasn't actually seen my games. I don't know why a town FT would do this.


Ok, let's put that mistake aside for a moment cause it could happen to town as well as to scum, or even could be a strategy to look as useless as possible.
But if you look at the reasons you used to argue that FT is scum, it's those:

- FT asks you questions
- You ask if he played with you
- replies no
- You say he's scum cause he somehow knows your play makes you town, when he

1. said nothing of you being town and the same could be applied to anyone else besides mderg, who you said IS SCUM when he was the only guy calling you scum. Damned if I do damned if I don't.

2. Asked you questions that were most likely hinting at him not immediately buying your claim.

@ Kush

Why am I supertown now? Spell it out plz.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 22 2014 19:08 GMT
#1331
Skanja, did FT never play a game with you on TL? Cause he said
No, I've never played with you on omgus. It's good that you're back. Gonna finish catching up now.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 22 2014 22:45 GMT
#1379
Mderg I think the reasons skanja gave us for suspecting FT are legit, I would have suspected FT myself for the same reasons.
There's just this doubt nagging at the back of my head that he's pro scum and made up that mistake on purpose but for today I'm not lynching him cause I liked our conversation.

Also checking his games he never rolled scum in the 4 or 5 of them. FT so-hosted a game where skanja was town so there's that, confirmed truthful argument.

And neither might I be lynching Kush IF HE EXPLAINS WHY HE SUDDENLY TOWNREADS ME. Cause in my experience scumkush doesn't townread his main scumread out of the blue, he didn't in Dr Who, but I want to know if it's serious and has a reason, cause else I'll just assume it was bullshitting.

I don't like how he's skipped over me on the basis that I town read him though, that seems like a strange thing to do for someone in the dark on alignments


I townread you for other reasons, but now I'm not so sure if they're valid anymore cause there's you and mderg, and maybe kush left as possible scum.
That post was just a way of copying what kush did and see how thrawn reacts. Conclusion drawn: Tunneled as fuck, put on ignore.
The "angry lines" were me thinking it was deadline day already. Tired gaming.


He also was set on vivax being scum but then out of the blue started calling him town after posts that were in my eyes, questionable. He seems to be playing the game backwards.


Now that you're at this I would like you to tell me what was questionable about my posts, and have a chat about it with kush to see why you get to different conclusions.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 22 2014 22:56 GMT
#1386
On April 23 2014 07:21 OmniEulogy wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 23 2014 07:17 thrawn2112 wrote:
omni wasn't/isn't proving original content


Exactly! And to keep on that.

Show nested quote +
On April 21 2014 11:11 Koshi wrote:
On April 21 2014 10:46 OneThousandWords wrote:
On April 21 2014 10:42 thrawn2112 wrote:
i dont really have any right now

everyone that isn't kush/koshi are about the same level of scuminess and I could lynch any of them. hopefully we will know more after the deadline.

skan/vivax are who i most want to lynch.

i have no idea how to read OTW and i still don't see why mderg is so scummy


Well I've never rolled scum in all 2 of the forum mafia games I've played so that's a start!

Can someone explain the vivax lynch because he looks really towny from his filter and koshi brought up that he was scum based on one really small point and seems to be super certain of it all of a sudden. I still don't understand because he never elaborated.

Vivax is a pretty good player, so I expect that he knows who is scum by now. Or at least has a couple names. Just like yourself, you think it is Mderg/Koshi/Skanjab.

But Vivax in response of Kush made it quite obvious he didn't have a clue who to push. That's extremely scummy because as scum you don't have a "scumhunting storyline" or you don't really feel who you got to push because you are playing reactionary to the thread.

So when Kush had Vivax as 4th scum. Vivax made a problem of this. This means that Vivax doesn't think that the scummers were with the first 3. But a couple minutes later Vivax even claimed he had Kush as scum. So that's 4 scummers right there. So who the fuck does Vivax think is scum?

Vivax doesn't know who is scum. Vivax is scum.


Granted vivax was 3rd not 4th but semantics. I still haven't seen Vivax address this post at all. He's dead but it's not like you can avoid what he's said because he's gone.


I don't even know what the hell the 3s and 4s are supposed to mean. At the time people I wanted to lynch were mderg and skanja and then kush flipped his read on me for the xth time when somebody else gave the same read on me. He did it again and now I want reasons...again. He's like unable to call me null or something.

And Koshi somehow concluded that I had no scumreads from that, as if I already had ticked in my reads for good.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 22 2014 23:14 GMT
#1395
On April 23 2014 07:48 thrawn2112 wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 23 2014 07:45 Vivax wrote:
Mderg I think the reasons skanja gave us for suspecting FT are legit, I would have suspected FT myself for the same reasons.
There's just this doubt nagging at the back of my head that he's pro scum and made up that mistake on purpose but for today I'm not lynching him cause I liked our conversation.

Also checking his games he never rolled scum in the 4 or 5 of them. FT so-hosted a game where skanja was town so there's that, confirmed truthful argument.

And neither might I be lynching Kush IF HE EXPLAINS WHY HE SUDDENLY TOWNREADS ME. Cause in my experience scumkush doesn't townread his main scumread out of the blue, he didn't in Dr Who, but I want to know if it's serious and has a reason, cause else I'll just assume it was bullshitting.

I don't like how he's skipped over me on the basis that I town read him though, that seems like a strange thing to do for someone in the dark on alignments


I townread you for other reasons, but now I'm not so sure if they're valid anymore cause there's you and mderg, and maybe kush left as possible scum.
That post was just a way of copying what kush did and see how thrawn reacts. Conclusion drawn: Tunneled as fuck, put on ignore.
The "angry lines" were me thinking it was deadline day already. Tired gaming.


He also was set on vivax being scum but then out of the blue started calling him town after posts that were in my eyes, questionable. He seems to be playing the game backwards.


Now that you're at this I would like you to tell me what was questionable about my posts, and have a chat about it with kush to see why you get to different conclusions.


i'm not sure if I understood this. but are you saying skan is town?


D1 you ask a question. it gets answered post-lynch. You are scum, you don't read the game, you don't look up the flip, you just read and find the answer and call it out. No, it doesn't make sense unless he's playing the sloppy townie card as scum, which is something I can't exclude. But he definitely got townie points for that convo and paranoia comes last in my judgment.

The judgment for today is: We lynch mderg, kush or OTW, and if we didn't win by then we lynch skanja.
Will decide after I talked to them a bit, if kush doesn't answer my questions my vote and my wrath ends up on him for his reads on me.

This is how he justified his earlier ones:

On April 20 2014 21:06 kushm4sta wrote:
what made me read you as town?
You are very engaged, with contradicts my perception of your scum meta.
You give a lot of reasons for things.
You look like you are trying to figure shit out.

what made me change my mind?
well i'm still not 100% on you being scum, but mostly..
PoE (aka townreads on other players)
your recent inappropriately try hard posts
the realization that I don't know your meta that well

I do not have specific examples really, because i didn't close read you filter. I merely skimmed it.


I'm curious about the new.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 22 2014 23:23 GMT
#1398
Mderg what do you think of my analysis on skanja?

Do you scumread kush or what else do you mean by this:

kush: I kinda agree on him but my focus would be more on him just posting reads left and right the last pages, without giving any clear line of thought.
Vivax
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
21959 Posts
April 25 2014 20:23 GMT
#1487
On April 19 2014 23:29 ObviousOne wrote:

-snip-

Kush should tweek know better about you or is he not good at reading you? He had a scum read on you probably based mostly around your first-half of d1 absence and I don't know when/if he's checking back in. Was his intent to get you lynched okay to you, or is there some backstory I'm missing where he should be able to tell by the end of the day and just never got around to changing his read? Would be helpful if he would check up on that as I mentioned above.

Skan MIA means I don't know what he's thinking related to kush and between that and his fake claim he's my top lynch candidate for today. Second maybe Mderg, seems pretty blunt in his responses which seems like a "safe" way to play as saying as little as possible reveals as little as necessary. No real narrative to his filter.


I think Skanja is probably town, there's the blooper where he answers to a D1 FT reply and this post by OO is worded in a way that suggests OO thinks of him as a townie when talking to kush.

Speaking of that, Kush's moment of irrational confidence pushing Cavalinho N1 is another point in favour of kush being scum, and OO prefers to ask him a bunch of irrelevant, very diplomatic stuff.

As for OTW, I thought he was town for effort and a couple other reasons, but by PoE he's scum, very active scum.

Can't exclude that Skanja is scum 100% yet but I'm pretty confident kush is, will have time to decide definitely tomorrow after he flipped.

##Vote: Kush

Now excuse me, had a long day and need to sleep.
Normal
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
Replay Cast
10:00
StarCraft Evolution League #13
CranKy Ducklings41
LiquipediaDiscussion
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
OGKoka 232
ProTech83
EnDerr 10
StarCraft: Brood War
Britney 31940
Sea 4714
Jaedong 1204
Pusan 313
Bisu 308
actioN 239
BeSt 222
EffOrt 213
Stork 147
Leta 126
[ Show more ]
Dewaltoss 82
ZerO 69
Sharp 68
Light 64
GoRush 58
Mong 52
ToSsGirL 38
Hyun 29
Movie 28
Mind 25
Backho 25
Sacsri 16
sSak 8
Dota 2
XcaliburYe618
BananaSlamJamma402
XaKoH 358
League of Legends
JimRising 463
Counter-Strike
shoxiejesuss1392
Stewie2K896
x6flipin298
allub151
Other Games
ceh9606
Happy414
singsing356
crisheroes298
Mew2King248
Pyrionflax150
ZerO(Twitch)6
Organizations
Dota 2
PGL Dota 2 - Secondary Stream4896
Other Games
gamesdonequick637
StarCraft: Brood War
lovetv 8
StarCraft 2
Blizzard YouTube
StarCraft: Brood War
BSLTrovo
sctven
[ Show 17 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• LUISG 30
• IndyKCrew
• Migwel
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• sooper7s
• intothetv
• Kozan
• LaughNgamezSOOP
StarCraft: Brood War
• Rasowy 4
• Airneanach3
• iopq 2
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
• BSLYoutube
Dota 2
• lizZardDota296
League of Legends
• Stunt576
Other Games
• WagamamaTV104
Upcoming Events
WardiTV Invitational
50m
PiGosaur Monday
13h 50m
GSL Code S
23h 20m
Rogue vs GuMiho
Maru vs Solar
Online Event
1d 13h
Replay Cast
1d 15h
GSL Code S
1d 23h
herO vs Zoun
Classic vs Bunny
The PondCast
1d 23h
Replay Cast
2 days
WardiTV Invitational
3 days
OSC
3 days
[ Show More ]
Korean StarCraft League
3 days
CranKy Ducklings
3 days
WardiTV Invitational
4 days
Cheesadelphia
4 days
CSO Cup
4 days
GSL Code S
4 days
Sparkling Tuna Cup
4 days
Replay Cast
5 days
Wardi Open
6 days
Replay Cast
6 days
Replay Cast
6 days
RSL Revival
6 days
Cure vs Percival
ByuN vs Spirit
Liquipedia Results

Completed

CSL Season 17: Qualifier 2
BGE Stara Zagora 2025
Heroes 10 EU

Ongoing

JPL Season 2
BSL 2v2 Season 3
BSL Season 20
KCM Race Survival 2025 Season 2
NPSL S3
Rose Open S1
CSL 17: 2025 SUMMER
2025 GSL S2
BLAST.tv Austin Major 2025
ESL Impact League Season 7
IEM Dallas 2025
PGL Astana 2025
Asian Champions League '25
BLAST Rivals Spring 2025
MESA Nomadic Masters
CCT Season 2 Global Finals
IEM Melbourne 2025
YaLLa Compass Qatar 2025
PGL Bucharest 2025
BLAST Open Spring 2025

Upcoming

Copa Latinoamericana 4
CSLPRO Last Chance 2025
CSLPRO Chat StarLAN 3
K-Championship
SEL Season 2 Championship
Esports World Cup 2025
HSC XXVII
Championship of Russia 2025
Murky Cup #2
Esports World Cup 2025
BLAST Bounty Fall 2025
BLAST Bounty Fall Qual
IEM Cologne 2025
FISSURE Playground #1
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2025 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.