EPTCatastrophe Mafia - Page 147
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
sandroba
Canada4998 Posts
| ||
|
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On April 06 2014 02:45 sandroba wrote: Clearly it wasn't me. It was marv actually. Both of you are responsible. | ||
|
IAmRobik
United States5878 Posts
On April 06 2014 02:45 sandroba wrote: Clearly it wasn't me. It was marv actually. I think people were following you,not marv. Already know marv is town. Trying to find nore people to clear | ||
|
sandroba
Canada4998 Posts
| ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36156 Posts
On April 06 2014 02:55 sandroba wrote: Apparently noone knows when I'm joking to dodge the bad lynch. Yes I know it was my fault, dammit Everyone knows, we just want to relentlessly hammer you for it anyway <3 | ||
|
Keirathi
United States4679 Posts
On April 06 2014 02:55 sandroba wrote: Apparently noone knows when I'm joking to dodge the bad lynch. Yes I know it was my fault, dammit Nuh uh, it was totally my fault. | ||
|
IAmRobik
United States5878 Posts
On April 06 2014 02:55 sandroba wrote: Apparently noone knows when I'm joking to dodge the bad lynch. Yes I know it was my fault, dammit Leading a lynch on townie the way you did is townie. It would only be scummy if it was me who led a mislynch | ||
|
IAmRobik
United States5878 Posts
| ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38797 Posts
On April 06 2014 02:39 sandroba wrote: koshi can you talk in the qt? ofc I can | ||
yamato77
11589 Posts
Starting with Syllo So, the best way I've found to read Syllo is how he pushes lynches/suspicions. As either alignment, he is capable of looking inquisitive and as if he's trying to figure out the game. However, if he's town, his mafia reads are much more fleshed out and he pursues them obviously throughout. On April 03 2014 17:31 syllogism wrote: This post feels awkward to me even as a troll. In the subsequent post you postulate that, based on your video mafia experience, robik is really excited as town and you aren't seeing that here yet. You have at least some previous forum mafia experience, so I've a hard time believing that you can't see the difference between the formats. Was your genuine expectation that Robik's post would immediately convey the same kind of excitement and do you actually think that he has "quit"? That is, do you think that Robik was serious when he said he "would be back on day 2"? Here is his first post, and what I think is his first read. Obviously it isn't a strong one, but I wonder if he follows up. On April 03 2014 21:43 syllogism wrote: It takes no effort at all. In fact, if you go here, copy paste his post and choose "flip wording", you get a perfectly normal post with no errors at all, spacing and all. That suggests it was done automatically rather than manually. Did this not occur to you? It is reasonable to believe that Greymist would realize such tools are available and I don't think it's likely he that would make a role with a posting restriction that takes no effort on the part of the person with the role. It also just makes the game more annoying to read and as far as I know, there are no previous Greymist roles with posting restrictions. If you agree, do you think this says something about Paperscraps? He offers up more information here, similar to his first post, but fails to come to any conclusions of his own. He's being "helpful", but I don't see any direction with his posting. On April 03 2014 23:07 syllogism wrote: You are clearly smart so you know mafia is a game of incomplete information and thus townie attempting to lynch a townie is unavoidable. So why are you saying something like this? It looks off to me; something a carleess mafia is more likely to say than a smart townie. As for the rest, the best way to win as either alignment is by making friends, even if just for the duration of the game. There's a few posts like this in his filter where it's just "general game advice". He seems to suggest there in the bolded that Robik could be "careless mafia" for this, yet I don't understand the tone of the rest of this post (and it's predecessor, also aimed at Robik) with that read in mind. On April 04 2014 17:28 syllogism wrote: This looks strange given that Oats is/was one of your strongest town reads. What were you hoping to gain from asking this question? Robik: As I understand it, you are a bit more familiar with tehpoofter's play. He understandably was fixated on you early on, but hasn't really been doing anything since then besides asking, from my perspective, unfocused questions. On the other hand, he seems carefree; what do you think? Here he follows up on both threads so far, somewhat, by asking Robik what he thinks of Poof. I suppose this counts as continuity, at least. On April 05 2014 02:41 syllogism wrote: The difference in effort Gumshoe has put in cell mini and this game is drastic. Him saying that he sometimes decides to be lazy if a game doesn't interest him isn't sufficient given the contrast. Does his QT content look any better? Gumshoe: I'm not expecting miracles from your answer, but could you attempt to enunciate as to why this game doesn't interest you? Obviously angling for a gumshoe vote. On April 05 2014 04:46 syllogism wrote: Gumshoe has made 39 posts in the other game since his last one in here and the lynch deadline in that game isn't even today. I'm leaving in 30 minutes and it doesn't look like paperscraps lynch needs any help to reach majority, so that's where my vote is going. ##vote Gumshoe This seems off, especially with the bolded. On April 05 2014 05:05 syllogism wrote: No, paperscraps is a good lynch, but that remark was in the context of the best use of my vote given that that lynch isn't going to need any help and I won't be here to switch later. Consistent, but still iffy. Why wouldn't he just vote for the majority? On April 05 2014 05:02 syllogism wrote: Kita is right about the discrepancy between gumshoe's activity in cell mini/doctor who being almost as large as in here/cell. Hard to contextualize the activity, but it does weaken my point. Perhaps tehpoofter is a better lynch. We see the beginnings of a switch, but he doesn't commit here. On April 05 2014 05:57 syllogism wrote: His initial Robik read also feels disingenuous. This was very early into the game and the bolded doesn't actually have anything to do with this game. Could he have genuinely felt that robik had started giving out town reads, but then quit doing that at that stage of the game? That just seems like a blatant misrepresentation. ##unvote ##vote Tehpoofter Again, we see his vote leaving the majority pack and heading off to no-man's-land. Why would he switch now instead of earlier, when he noted the weakness of his gumshoe read and the possibility of poofter being a better lynch? Overall, I don't feel that he's made a strong read on any one person. His attempts at finding a lynch seem weak, and I don't like the timing of his voting. Fairly suspicious of syllo right now. | ||
|
Killing
Canada530 Posts
| ||
|
Paperscraps
United States639 Posts
!questions hard the asking start to need We | ||
|
IAmRobik
United States5878 Posts
| ||
|
Tehpoofter
United States2911 Posts
On April 06 2014 02:51 IAmRobik wrote: I think people were following you,not marv. Already know marv is town. Trying to find nore people to clear ^^more town posts like this please robik so I can stop feeling uneasy about you (note this is a read on robik only cause this is how he talks in these definite statements and he does as town play to clear town first) On April 05 2014 18:33 Holyflare wrote: Pretty odd that gumshoe got a majority in 20 mins that was higher than the majority on paperscraps that was there all day. I wasn't around at EoD or I probably would have voted gumshoe to just get a lynch for information so not going to fault people that were getting a lynch done. I'd like to know people that did jump on the gumshoe train and not paperscrapes what was the main reason for selecting gum over paper? I think its odd what HF says that there was a lynch for most of the day with a strong showing and someone like marv pushing it (who I read as town now since I think I might be reading robik more town I no longer get that associative read on marv) What was people's hesitance? The easy solution is paperscraps is scum and his partners didn't want to bus him early. My only problem with that is if a strong player like marv is putting heat on a teammate who is posting backwards (im guessing as a troll) its not a huge loss to your team to bus at that point in a setup like this cause you gain some townie cred for getting maf day 1. Now ideally you wouldn't want to bus but if you can say "hey I was the 15th vote guys on the scum gg I'm confirmed" afterwards its harder to lynch you. TLDR: 1) Ez game Paper is scum and his team didn't want to bus 2) Paper is town and the case wasn't strong enough so mafia felt nervous jumping on and hammering. Also I don't get the whole horses thing. Its not a mechanic I'm use to and put me in this camp On April 06 2014 00:44 Killing wrote: We should have just lynched Amiko so we could get his role pm and find out wtf horses do. Lastly: + Show Spoiler + On April 06 2014 01:52 Palmar wrote: Also here is an interesting tidbit. I know for a fact based on information I have from the mod regarding my role that there are no showers here. However Balla said something about a shower at some point in the game. There is no showers and now no rayn.... how will we clean out any radiation that hits the town. /end bad pun. | ||
|
yamato77
11589 Posts
My first impression says that he's town. At the very least, I want to confirm this and also see if there is anything in his filter I can use to point me in the right direction. On April 04 2014 09:55 sandroba wrote: I'm supposed to be, but I can't tell either way so far. I'll see if he does something useful tomorrow besides coaching people on anger management, if he doesn't there is reason to be worried. I get it that palmar wants to spam the thread and I'm not sure if he is mafia for it yet, but holy enabling him feels out of character from the little I've seen from him. Marv just seems flat out useless so far. I really like this post from sandro. Just, everything about it seems good. I like that it reinforces my idea of what to think about syllo as well. On April 04 2014 10:10 sandroba wrote: Besides the palmar thing, his "reads" are for the most part opposite of mine and he is supposed to be good at this game. Also he has done nothing other than spam one liners with apparently very little thought put into them. It may be somehow minor, but I remember him being quite proud of his mafia playing abilities and his comment downplaying himself with oats seems like scum behavior to me. I like that he seems so weary of Holy. I caught the same feelings early on and I definitely think there's something worth looking at there. Going to filter HF next for sure. On April 06 2014 02:21 sandroba wrote: LSB I think is auto scum every time he posts in any game I've been in. I feel that way this game too. Maybe you better ask someone who can actually read the dude correctly. I totally forgot LSB exists. He called me mafia early on, Going to have to look at that guy too. If it isn't obvious, I think Sand is town. The posts I point out aren't even the whole story, but just a casual read of his filter is evidence enough. He's definitely trying to figure the game out, and is definitely playing in an unmistakably townie mindset. | ||
|
Tehpoofter
United States2911 Posts
On April 06 2014 03:25 Killing wrote: ooooooooooo do me @killing no thanks. Secondly you want to lynch Amiko cause hes 3p? Do you have a scum read you'd like to lynch? | ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38797 Posts
On April 06 2014 03:34 Tehpoofter wrote: I finally caught up with the thread. I can't decide if Robik started playing like hes town because hes town or because I called him out on not playing his town game. so mafia | ||
|
Tehpoofter
United States2911 Posts
I don't think he is mafia anymore by the way hes playing this is what I expected from his town so I disagree that he is mafia. | ||
|
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On April 06 2014 03:47 Tehpoofter wrote: I don't think he is mafia anymore by the way hes playing this is what I expected from his town so I disagree that he is mafia. Yeah... I doubt he was talking about Robik here. | ||
|
Palmar
Iceland22631 Posts
Rapunzel can be seen entering the castle in frozen on Elsa's coronation day. | ||
| ||
