|
Hi guys!
So, howyoudoing?
Nice game for town (well...I didn't read it anyway lol). That Hari Seldon "crack the code" thing seemed fun.
Anyways, as you may know, this game featured the spreadsheet thingy here:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AnAskN6iBIGBdHQzTHdXQzNxODZ1a2wtdVF5eC0xQmc#gid=2
It was nice that (barring some minor stuff, also barring the secret Hari Seldon votes), everything worked correctly there.
But I'd like some feedback from you guys, as well as thrawn+cohosts
Hosts:
1) Did you encounter any problems, or inconveniences in creating, or setting up the spreadsheet?
2) Did you find anything bothersome about having to manage it as the game went along? Is there anything you might change about it?
3) Did you find it useful for other activities? For example, keeping up a vote tally, keeping the records of what happened each cycle (barring night actions), etc?
4) Any other comments?
Players:
This is for the players of the game to answer (although observers are allowed as well I guess)
Poll: Did you use the spreadsheet at any time?Yes, I used it the whole game (0) 0% I used it sparingly, here and there (0) 0% I think I checked it once, nothing more. (2) 40% I didn't know it existed, or I never opened it (3) 60% 5 total votes Your vote: Did you use the spreadsheet at any time? (Vote): Yes, I used it the whole game
(Vote): I used it sparingly, here and there
(Vote): I think I checked it once, nothing more.
(Vote): I didn't know it existed, or I never opened it
Poll: Did you find it useful while the game was running?Yes, it was useful to me while I was playing the game (0) 0% Didn't pay much attention to it, or barely used it, etc. (1) 20% No, I didn't use it or didn't find it that useful. (4) 80% 5 total votes Your vote: Did you find it useful while the game was running? (Vote): Yes, it was useful to me while I was playing the game
(Vote): Didn't pay much attention to it, or barely used it, etc.
(Vote): No, I didn't use it or didn't find it that useful.
Poll: What feature did you like the most?Automatic votecount (0) 0% Time remaining before deadline (0) 0% Player list (filters, flips, etc) (0) 0% General info (link to the thread, filters of the hosts, information about the current cycle) (0) 0% Record of what happened each phase (who died, who was lynched, end result of votes, etc) (0) 0% Liked more than one, don't have a favourite (0) 0% Don't really have a strong opinion about it. (3) 100% 3 total votes Your vote: What feature did you like the most? (Vote): Automatic votecount
(Vote): Time remaining before deadline
(Vote): Player list (filters, flips, etc)
(Vote): General info (link to the thread, filters of the hosts, information about the current cycle)
(Vote): Record of what happened each phase (who died, who was lynched, end result of votes, etc)
(Vote): Liked more than one, don't have a favourite
(Vote): Don't really have a strong opinion about it.
Poll: What conclusions do you have about said features?I liked them all, they are very useful for a mafia game (0) 0% I liked some of them, others were less useful, or I didn't bother that much with them (1) 50% I liked only one, didn't bother with or didn't like the rest (0) 0% I didn't really pay much attention to any of them (1) 50% I don't really like any (0) 0% 2 total votes Your vote: What conclusions do you have about said features? (Vote): I liked them all, they are very useful for a mafia game
(Vote): I liked some of them, others were less useful, or I didn't bother that much with them
(Vote): I liked only one, didn't bother with or didn't like the rest
(Vote): I didn't really pay much attention to any of them
(Vote): I don't really like any
Poll: What do you think of the management of the spreadsheets by the hosts?The hosts managed it very well, don't have any complaints (0) 0% So so. They did ok, but could have done better. (0) 0% Don't really think they managed it okay. (0) 0% I didn't pay much attention to the management of it (2) 100% 2 total votes Your vote: What do you think of the management of the spreadsheets by the hosts? (Vote): The hosts managed it very well, don't have any complaints
(Vote): So so. They did ok, but could have done better.
(Vote): Don't really think they managed it okay.
(Vote): I didn't pay much attention to the management of it
(btw I suck at doing polls so bear with me >_> )
Any other comments?
What would you want to see changed or added to the spreadsheet based on your experience of it this game?
Was this spreadsheet good for you, depending on your alignment? I.e, was it good for you as town, or good for you as mafia)?
|
Wish I could have used it effectively from my phone
|
11589 Posts
You mean scum could fake being me and they didn't do it? Lol, I thought I had an OP role hut scum just did nothing to stop me apparently.
I pretty much knew Grack was mafia when he went "Yeah Hari is an OP role" or something like that. Just screamed scum to me. A townie would either try to figure my role out (Palmar and Boone did a decent job of this D3) or question the validity of my claims/messages (also something Palmar did). They would be interested in the new info.
Plus, he did nothing but troll the whole game away, which is exactly what he does as scum.
Never understood why people thought Boone/Temp/Rob were scummy. I had them all as town D1.
|
Well i could fake being you once. That does not really help..
Because you can clear yourself the next night.
|
Rayn
Do not h8 me but I shall beat dead horse
With the mule role I would have been over the moon
"Zeal Palace" would be running through my head as I thought up all the SVENGALI I could pull, the town looks I could pull off by being uninformed and not deciding the NK, the way I would save messing with HARI SELDON, and heck- I know I couldn't have emulated my current play, but HARI was wrong! I could have used that for Svengali, I could have done exactly what I do as town- wrote him off entirely as host WIFOM, (heck that might have been towncred!) it seems so bamcis a role
I would probably looked TOO happy and devious and got lynched d1 XD
Finally, as it was you basically had me fooled
...
I am serious you did
|
Rob was always pretty townie agreed. Dandel/Jat/Oats did a great job of looking really town too.
|
And slam too, really a ton of people looked really town.
|
Hari seldon should probably have been auto-murdered at some point with Rayn knowing WHEN exacctly he would be murdered like... rayn is scheduled to take part in a planned assasination 2 weeks from today (night4) where he can't use any actions besides the hari seldon related ones or something like that.
|
I still don't understand the austin kill. Why kill someone everyone is suspicious of?
|
Like Yamato, let's say you do bamcis with SELDON up to this point. Then I (literally) SVENGALI your entire next post to say that today's lynch proves your BAMCIS COP CHECK POWERS
and I use that to say PALMAR REDCHECK. REPEAT PALMAR REDCHECK.
|
11589 Posts
My cop check would have been mod confirmed on D4 though.
|
gg folks.
Really enjoyed this one. I really like the idea behind having a half-player in Hari, who can do some stuff, but not everything, and maybe isn't trustworthy. I liked silent nights + QTs. I think in the same vein as having scum powers to mess with Hari's interaction with thread, a different spin on this game might give scum powers to mess with the QTs. Either to make sure a scummer was in the main QT one day, or for one person to be able to pull in another if ever put into a QT. Something to make the QTs a bit minigame-ish, where they can really try and influence townie thought in the QTs.
rayn you are a dirty liar, and I can't believe I forgot to tell Boone that you'd claimed cop to me and to watch you.
|
If i knew Hari Seldon was someone not in the players i would have totally framed Slam.
I was flip-flopping between myself, Palmar and Killing and ended up framing Killing (because i thought he gets checked and the cop will at least soft-defend him on D2 as he gets a green check).
|
On March 12 2014 08:38 raynpelikoneet wrote:
I still don't understand the austin kill. Why kill someone everyone is suspicious of?
Almost everyone was moving away from austin at the time I think, he posted pretty good stuff later on in the day.
|
That's fucking weird that I'm the only one who read Austin town. What fucking mafia takes however fucking long it took him to write a long ass post on what someone (VE) could be mafia (the case wasn't even that good) after saying "i don't know why you want me to do this" insinuating that he was going to be voting Joey anyway.
|
On March 12 2014 08:38 raynpelikoneet wrote:
I still don't understand the austin kill. Why kill someone everyone is suspicious of? I don't remember people being suspicious of me at the end of the day. A little boone suspicion, and slam was on me, but otherwise hadn't everyone moved off?
Pretty sure that the end of D1 looked really townie for me.
|
On March 12 2014 08:42 austinmcc wrote:Show nested quote +On March 12 2014 08:38 raynpelikoneet wrote:
I still don't understand the austin kill. Why kill someone everyone is suspicious of? I don't remember people being suspicious of me at the end of the day. A little boone suspicion, and slam was on me, but otherwise hadn't everyone moved off? Pretty sure that the end of D1 looked really townie for me.
Pretty much this.
|
On March 12 2014 08:42 IAmRobik wrote:
That's fucking weird that I'm the only one who read Austin town. What fucking mafia takes however fucking long it took him to write a long ass post on what someone (VE) could be mafia (the case wasn't even that good) after saying "i don't know why you want me to do this" insinuating that he was going to be voting Joey anyway.
Because it's a fluff post that does not matter and possibly counts as a "contribution".
|
On March 12 2014 08:42 austinmcc wrote:Show nested quote +On March 12 2014 08:38 raynpelikoneet wrote:
I still don't understand the austin kill. Why kill someone everyone is suspicious of? I don't remember people being suspicious of me at the end of the day. A little boone suspicion, and slam was on me, but otherwise hadn't everyone moved off? Pretty sure that the end of D1 looked really townie for me.
Yes. But if I had seen what you wrote about me in your little qt I wouldn't have trusted you!
|
On March 12 2014 08:42 IAmRobik wrote:
That's fucking weird that I'm the only one who read Austin town. What fucking mafia takes however fucking long it took him to write a long ass post on what someone (VE) could be mafia (the case wasn't even that good) after saying "i don't know why you want me to do this" insinuating that he was going to be voting Joey anyway.
You need to chill out dude!
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
