On January 12 2014 10:24 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
you also said you'd be fine with a xatalos lynch so do you think:
xatalos
rayn
marv
alakaslam

are all scum?

I'd say all town but dunno about xata. I just realized that i've posted almost no reads

naughty list

xata
koshi
derrida

nice list

rayn
yamato
kush/vayne
alakaslam
DrH
gumshoe
blazinghand
WoS

Blazinghand

United States25562 Posts

January 12 2014 01:30 GMT

#942

let me have a chance to perhaps convince you. surely my logic about one of r+m being town is correct, right? it wouldn't make sense for BOTH of them to go rolefishing.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

January 12 2014 01:32 GMT

#943

so I'm mafia because i found something in your filter that made me think you were mason, and rayn is mafia because he asked you after I mentioned it to him?

Are you a total moron?

DoctorHelvetica

United States15034 Posts

January 12 2014 01:32 GMT

#944

they're both town imo the fact that you'd think they'd both be fine targets for a mad hatter is ridiculous at the very least as town you'd put in the effort to try to figure out which one is which and advise me to change a bomb, you never mentioned the rolefishing before you never mentioned your suspicions about anyone in thread that i can recall except:
xatalos

and that's ONLY because I asked you. and then you dropped it completely.

you might play like a clown but i don't know you to be the kind of player to not pursue his own reads and to avoid tunneling at all costs. it's because you have no arguments. besides "hey guys....role fishing?"

Captain Obvious

33 Posts

January 12 2014 01:33 GMT

#945

On January 12 2014 10:30 Blazinghand wrote:
let me have a chance to perhaps convince you. surely my logic about one of r+m being town is correct, right? it wouldn't make sense for BOTH of them to go rolefishing.

Your logic is most sound, faithful citizen! If they are mafia together it would certainly be odd for both to attempt to find out his partner!

Blazinghand

United States25562 Posts

January 12 2014 01:34 GMT

#946

man i dont' even think xatalos is that good a lynch after correcting for bias. it's like nobody here is reading my posts

and you don't have bombs on anyone anyways since it's d1. zzz

DoctorHelvetica

United States15034 Posts

January 12 2014 01:34 GMT

#947

On January 12 2014 10:34 Blazinghand wrote:
man i dont' even think xatalos is that good a lynch after correcting for bias. it's like nobody here is reading my posts

and you don't have bombs on anyone anyways since it's d1. zzz

im also not a madhatter

Blazinghand

United States25562 Posts

January 12 2014 01:35 GMT

#948

On January 12 2014 10:32 marvellosity wrote:
so I'm mafia because i found something in your filter that made me think you were mason, and rayn is mafia because he asked you after I mentioned it to him?

Are you a total moron?

I do not believe that both you and rayn are mafia. I have explicitly stated that at least one of you is town. you are not both mafia.

I do nto believe both marv and rayn are mafia

I do not believe both marv and rayn are mafia

I do not believe both marv and rayn are mafia

is this clear

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

January 12 2014 01:36 GMT

#949

that's not what i said. i get that much.

I'm asking if you're a moron because me seeing something that made you look like mason and asking you about it does not in any way make me mafia, and if you think it does, you've had a prefrontal lobotomy.

Aquanim

Australia2849 Posts

January 12 2014 01:37 GMT

#950

@BH: In the hypothetical scenario where we were to make you mayor right now who would you lynch?

Blazinghand

United States25562 Posts

January 12 2014 01:38 GMT

#951

like shit man what kind of case is this? let me break it down why this case is bad: the problem is that my scumreads are slam, xat, rayn and marv, and the fact that i pushed a kush lynch then moved to drh?

but i don't think xat and slam are scum. i've said as much. I don't think both rayn and marv are scum, but i find it suspicious that they were rolefishing. when drh talked about the placement of his bombs, i said it was reasonable because marv and rayn both are strong town and he's only getting shot if they're both scum! then i got some weird rolefishing pms and I was like "hm i guess they can't both be scum, one of them coudl be" and i said that. i shared myt houghts! jesus guys

Blazinghand

United States25562 Posts

January 12 2014 01:39 GMT

#952

On January 12 2014 10:36 marvellosity wrote:
that's not what i said. i get that much.

I'm asking if you're a moron because me seeing something that made you look like mason and asking you about it does not in any way make me mafia, and if you think it does, you've had a prefrontal lobotomy.

You're asking if i'm a moron? No I am not a moron, I have pretty normal intelligence level. I am glad to have answered your query.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

January 12 2014 01:39 GMT

#953

bombs on me and rayn are not reasonable under any circumstances, what a terribly dumb thing to say

Blazinghand

United States25562 Posts

January 12 2014 01:40 GMT

#954

On January 12 2014 10:37 Aquanim wrote:
@BH: In the hypothetical scenario where we were to make you mayor right now who would you lynch?

coag. you hosted extractor trick with me and you know why. and yes, i know this answer doesn't give me any towncred, but THAT DOESN'T MAKE IT NOT THE RIGHT ANSWER.

Blazinghand

United States25562 Posts

January 12 2014 01:40 GMT

#955

On January 12 2014 10:39 marvellosity wrote:
bombs on me and rayn are not reasonable under any circumstances, what a terribly dumb thing to say

but... not a scummy thing, right?

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

January 12 2014 01:40 GMT

#956

it's scummy because all your reasoning so far has been gash.

DoctorHelvetica

United States15034 Posts

January 12 2014 01:41 GMT

#957

he doesn't have real reads because he's making exclusively private reads to people and they're all different people.

course of action:
1. ask for policy lynch on a player whose alignment you have no opinion on
2. say that no matter who is mayor you will push for this lynch
3. vote for a mayor who says they will not lynch kush and suspects BH himself of being scum
4. provide scumread on xatalos when asked by me on the second half of the day, doesn't push it
5. privately provides scumread to xatalos on alakaslam, doesn't push it in thread
6. privately provides split moderate scumreads on rayn/marvellosity to me in private, says putting madhatter bombs on them is a good idea, doesn't push either player in thread or in his PMs with other people, when asked about it only talks about how he only thinks one can be scum
7. votes for me again after i ask for him to be lynched

he's playing intentionally and brazenly anti-town. I don't care how "bad" blazinghand is. What better to do as scum at this point than to collapse completely and shit in the thread?

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

January 12 2014 01:41 GMT

#958

wait, no

it's scummy because you're slyly bitching about me/rayn in PMs to DrH instead of doing anything proactively in thread.

yamato77

11589 Posts

January 12 2014 01:42 GMT

#959

On January 12 2014 10:40 marvellosity wrote:
it's scummy because all your reasoning so far has been gash.

bingo

DoctorHelvetica

United States15034 Posts

January 12 2014 01:43 GMT

#960

he said he was hyped for this game. so you're doing this and only reading in private like obviously you havet houghts about this game but you don't want to provide them unless you are ASKED for them you are only acting when you are under pressure because you don't give a shit about contributing to this game, you're providing as little info as possible.

what town player can only defend their actions and reasoning through fucking meta ......lol he can't even explain his intentions because they're bold faced scummy so he just defaults to "don't pay attention to me i'm bad DrH very good

" . If I'm so good and he is town why do I want him dead day 1? That makes no sense. How can any town player think I'm the best choice for mayor when I disagree with their lynch choice whole-heartedly AND want them lynched? It's illogical.