|
On November 03 2013 07:38 Mig wrote:
Asinine you are definitely grasping at straws with your LJ analysis. Do you really think LJ is a better lynch than someone like Oats? What are your thoughts on Oats?
I am here now Pandain!
I'm not grasping at straws. Read my post. I'll post about Oats in a minute. I think he's a good bet for scum too.
|
mb, JJD. i'm responding to this post:
On November 03 2013 07:17 Pandain wrote:Show nested quote +On November 03 2013 07:17 Bereft wrote:On November 03 2013 07:02 Pandain wrote:
Don't you think mafia would, as a whole, take a backwards stance to this. Ideally just step back from the conflict? After all, I was the one who had to lead a counter lynch to lynch fuba. Scum don't want to be defending him, nor do they want to be prosecuting him. It would all be indirect. Biggest reasoning as to why me and Grack are town. i think whether they choose to prosecute him really depends on how they're evaluating risk/reward in the scenario. obviously as you and grack were the ones that put hard pressure where none previously existed you are town, unless that was some fucking brilliant play. but to the voters who followed you, no, i don't see avoiding the conflict entirely as the obvious overarching mafia strategy here. Do you agree JarJar is town for being the fourth to follow and therefore really pushing him into the limelight?
|
United States1302 Posts
On November 03 2013 07:51 Mig wrote:
With nearly 1/3rd of the players in this game being mafia I think it is pretty optimistic to think that none of the mafia voted for Fuba (unless hermeane's replacement ends up being mafia). OK but I highly doubt more that 1 scum voted for him. So we definately need to lynch into the group that didn't vote for him because we're probably looking @ 2/5 instead of 1/7 (probably 1/6 after tonight)
|
United States4714 Posts
Yea unquestionably we need to be lynching into the non fuba voters group on day2.
|
JJD, mig - who are your top candidates for tomorrow's lynch?
|
what are your thoughts on my asinine / LJ reads?
On November 02 2013 15:53 Bereft wrote:fwiw (which i know is not much) i had no intention of actually leaving my vote on pandain - thought i'd have time to come back before the deadline  . am aware of what a total cop out afk vote it looks like and i understand the suspicion. right now, asinine and laughing jack are my top 2 lynch candidates for tomorrow. re: asinine while i don't find it scummy that he would push for hz over fuba (since that's actually in line with his main read for the entirety of day 1), he defends fuba instead of going on the offense on hz. i.e. he doesn't advocate why hz is a more solid lynch candidate or why hz is more probable scum. his long post mainly articulates why he doesn't like how quickly votes are piling on without a good case, which as a stand alone might be fair, but then it's followed up with this: Show nested quote +On November 02 2013 08:05 Asinine wrote:
I would also like to clarify that I'm not saying fuba is town. I'm saying all the cases that have been presented to me regarding fuba are either weak(Pandain) or malevolent cherry-picking(hzflank). to me this implies he thinks fuba might be scum -- which then makes it weird that he was not at all open to fuba as a lynch candidate for consideration. the one thing that gives me pause is why he would fight so hard to defend an absent scum buddy. seems incredibly ballsy. re: laughing jack i don't quite buy his #idgaf attitude. if he were a newbie, sure. as a smurf vet - i don't think it'd be at all hard to feign. he initially says he has no read on hz but would want to vote hz since hz's flip would reveal the most information. but he doesn't change his vote and before he disappears appears to change his stance from lynch candidate of "active townie with many interactions" to "a more-than-1-liner lurker". Show nested quote +On November 02 2013 04:04 Laughing Jack wrote:
I took a break from the thread and I'll be unexpectedly going to a party tonight, I'll try to find some corner and read up on the thread and vote later tonight. I probably want to lynch into the first three quarters of of the day lurkers, but not 1-posters. fuba would be much more fitting of this description than hz. but then he comes back and votes hz right as the 07 train is gaining steam and pulling out of the station. i'm crashing now, but it's finally the weekend so i'll be around tomorrow.
|
United States4714 Posts
Oats - 0 scum hunting, votes for pandain never pushes him and goes afk and he has continued to be useless during the night.
Asinine - obvious reasons
|
In 40 minutes we will know for sure whether Grack is scum. If Oats dies, lynch Grack.
|
United States4714 Posts
Asinine I agree with. For LJ I would like to see more from him, I was ok with most of his posts leading up to the hz lynch.
|
United States4714 Posts
On November 03 2013 08:22 hzflank wrote:
In 40 minutes we will know for sure whether Grack is scum. If Oats dies, lynch Grack.
Why?
|
On November 03 2013 08:23 Mig wrote:Show nested quote +On November 03 2013 08:22 hzflank wrote:
In 40 minutes we will know for sure whether Grack is scum. If Oats dies, lynch Grack. Why?
It was a joke. That's what I do sometimes to signal that I am lurking in the thread in case anyone wants to ask me anything.
|
Not gonna lie your jokes have no punchlines
|
Blame the British sense of humour (spelled with a u ofcourse).
|
So Bereft wants to lynch the same two people that I wanted to lynch, for roughly the same reasons. I feel like I have already posted those reasons in the thread also. That makes Bereft's post completely null to me.
It's good that we are thinking on similar lines, which should make me lean town. But his reasoning does not seem original to me so I cannot actually read into it. Ofcourse I cannot really expect all reasoning to be original based on the content that we have. Null on that.
|
ha, so basically you're saying my entire post is null.
|
Yeah but you do have some original reasoning about people in some of your other recent posts (eg, regarding Stutters).
The big post is good for the purpose of making your position clear, I just cannot read you from it.
|
Bereft, what do you think of Odin? You have not yet mention him this game.
|
Day 2
Oatsmaster the Mafia Goon and hzflank the Vanilla Townie are dead.
The day will last for until 01:00 GMT (+00:00). I'm not entirely sure if I did the DST change correctly, so just treat it as 49 hours from this post.
|
United States4714 Posts
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
