I'm not completely sure myself I'm just sick of hearing people say that.

Right now i want to kill Skan/CR. 3rd scum could be any of HF/BH/Onegu/Raynoshi. I'm on my phone not sure if I'm leaving anyone out. I'll look over everyone more the next day.

Grackaroni

United States9846 Posts

October 25 2013 02:08 GMT

#4143

I don't see how my case is lacking logic compared to anything you/BH say on him. Maybe I need to work on making my writing understandable.

Grackaroni

United States9846 Posts

October 25 2013 02:10 GMT

#4146

ATTENTION ALL BLAZINGHANDS
heal the Sn0 Man, and try not to melt him.

Grackaroni

United States9846 Posts

October 25 2013 02:11 GMT

#4148

I was probably pretty annoyed when I wrote it that my lynch didn't go through.

Grackaroni

United States9846 Posts

October 25 2013 02:37 GMT

#4154

Basically, he had a strong scum read on Yamato with some decent evidence to back it up. Then it faded away. When he was asked what happened to it he said he liked Yamato's defense - which is fine. It's not fine, however, that he comes back later on in day2 pushing Yamato, saying that he had a scum read on him the whole time and that Yamato's defense did nothing to change his mind.

On day2 he shows up at the last minute and moves his vote off of Yamato and on to Stutters because they are equally scummy and CR could contribute. But he seemed to prefer Yamato over Stutters before,

On October 21 2013 06:32 Skanjab1s wrote:

Show nested quote +

What about yamato!

The possibility of CR contributing doesn't seem like a realistic reason for him to switch his mind because he made it clear that he wouldn't let scum reads get away for being useful. It seemed like a very weak justification for a vote change and his reasoning for Stutters being scum that he gave after the lynch was also much weaker than his Yamato reasoning.

Don't forget the lynch was very close and townies will generally make their presence known in the thread during a deadline. There is potential scum motivation for Skanjab1s not to show he is in the thread. (assuming a Yamato-Skanjab1s scum team) If he is in the thread he has to either convince people that Yamato is the correct lynch and risk going down to 2 mafia members or back track on his previous reasoning on Yamato and lose all of the town-cred he could have gotten for being on the Yamato wagon by pushing Stutters. It's likely (and even more likely with the secret vote being town) Skanjab1s was waiting in the QT watching the thread unfold, and hoping Stutters will get lynched without him intervening. At least this was what I did when I was in this scenario.

I think all of these 3 things together make a Skanjab1s/Yamato scum team likely.

Grackaroni

United States9846 Posts

October 25 2013 02:39 GMT

#4155

It probably would be pretty silly for us to completely ignore the red check on Raynoshi.

Only 3 real likely possibilities: JAT is Mafia. Raynoshi/Cephiro was framed n2. Raynoshi is Mafia.

Grackaroni

United States9846 Posts

October 25 2013 02:43 GMT

#4158

lol Skan which case is better. Mine or Mocsta's!? Only you can settle this...

Grackaroni

United States9846 Posts

October 25 2013 02:44 GMT

#4159

Or you can say which one is worse. That seems fairer.

Grackaroni

United States9846 Posts

October 25 2013 02:46 GMT

#4161

On October 25 2013 11:45 raynpelikonoshi wrote:
Grackaroni i am waiting for the case.

Holyflare, riddle me this:

Show nested quote +

You seem to be sure i am scum. Correctly identify my scumtraits and tell the thread.
(hint: whenever someone has tried to do this and i have been town they have been scum -- but by all means, as you are so confident as you claimed on D1, go ahead -- stand behind your words)

On a sidenote. I will be re-reading the whole game tomorrow and Saturday, then i will tell the thread who is scum. I've never been mislynched - even with a fucked up check - and i do not intend to start now. kthxbye.

-rayn

That was you that was making promises of a case not me. I'd prefer it if you would just comment on Skanjab1s/CR.

Grackaroni

United States9846 Posts

October 25 2013 02:52 GMT

#4166

Mafia will probably kill of JAT.

Grackaroni

United States9846 Posts

October 25 2013 02:53 GMT

#4167

Oh everyone's invulnerable. I could actually get killed.

Grackaroni

United States9846 Posts

October 25 2013 02:58 GMT

#4171

On October 25 2013 11:55 raynpelikonoshi wrote:
Hey Grack, did you vote for Palmar D1?

-rayn

Of course.

Grackaroni

United States9846 Posts

October 25 2013 03:03 GMT

#4173

On October 25 2013 12:01 raynpelikonoshi wrote:
Oh God. I thought you can read him?

-rayn

haha I said that in the Huffle QT. It's Palmar's fault. Syllo wasn't against a Palmar kill and eventually even Marv jumped on the wagon.

Grackaroni

United States9846 Posts

October 25 2013 03:19 GMT

#4176

On September 29 2013 05:06 Palmar wrote:
On phone will do later.

Short version is: the worst player in the game gets lynched day 1 . Regardless of alignment.

To quote the man himself.

Marv is a much better Palmar reader than myself. I'd still like to believe his play makes more sense from a Palmar who had rolled scum for the 2nd time in a row than for a Palmar playing his first town game in months.

Grackaroni

United States9846 Posts

October 25 2013 03:43 GMT

#4186

I see your point in that if there was 1 mafia in each house then gryffindor with knowledge of a house cop then gryffindor is the sensible frame.

I will try to look more into HF tomorrow.

Grackaroni

United States9846 Posts

October 25 2013 03:44 GMT

#4187

except gryffindor*

Grackaroni

United States9846 Posts

October 25 2013 15:25 GMT

#4264

CR did seem like he was out to get FT yesterday. Maybe he will go back to finish the job.

Grackaroni

United States9846 Posts