Thug Life Mini Mafia - Page 134

On September 30 2013 00:40 Palmar wrote:
Probably Town

Koshi - Probably town, if scum he played getting hit by the RNG pretty well.
VisceraEyes - Keep an eye out on how much of a leadership role he takes. He was very townie early on in day 1, but I'm somewhat unsure how much of a role he truly played in the yamato lynch. I need to re-read. If he starts fading into the background reconsider, but for now town.
Oatsmaster - Confrontational and an asshole, completely useless too, so that kinda fits him being town
Blazinghand - Probably town, needs to be more in the forefront.
WaveofShadow - Too active, too free-flowing and engages easily with people to be scum.
Pandain - His case was ok. If he keeps trying he's town. Pandain is awful as scum anyway so he'll fuck up sooner or later if he is.

Haven't analysed/read at all:

Chairman Ray
Mr. Cheesecake
VayneAuthority
austinmcc

Only done a quick read/null:

strongandbig - if I die he's less likely (only slightly) to be scum (unlikely his scumteam would shoot me after he spends time creating a case on me), but I have no idea really, I think his case was wrong because of bads, not because of malicious.

ShiaoPi - One of the best candidates for re-reading. He hasn't done anything worth noting all game, at least that I noticed. I'm going to look into him when I have time.

raynpelikoneet - Don't really know.
Grackaroni - Again, read some, no conclusion

Scummy people

hiro protagonist - His start was awfully conservative. I still haven't spent time looking at his later posts, but yeah.
RebirthOfLeGenD - Said he'd catch up, didn't.
FirmTofu - See my earlier analysis. Haven't paid attention to him since.

-------------------

please don't take this list as gospel, my reads on night 1 (especially with a weekend start) are okay, but not great. I'm prety sure most of the scum is in my null/scum zone, but if someone does something stupid, don't let the come back and go "BUT PALMAR SAID I WAS TOWN".

Anyway, I won't have time to play much today. Writing this in case I can't be back before deadline.

On October 02 2013 22:59 Palmar wrote:
I really don't know anymore.

A few quick thoughts.

I'm less sure in my early townreads and more sure in my later ones. Especially I think Koshi, Chairman Ray and Grack are very unlikely scum. VE, Oats, Pandain, WoS more likely than before (but still nowhere near lynch territory, let's say I'm leaning town on them.

A quick note on WoS, for someone that was willing to enter an argument early in the game about his proficiency at mafia I don't feel like he is having the influence his own perception of his skill should warrant. If you think you're so good why aren't you trying to lead us?

I have still to read CC and the replacements through. I'm assuming at least one if not two scum in there because that's kind of what I do, I always ignore the lay-low scum.

SnB still hasn't done jack shit, good candidate for lynching tomorrow. I still think Hiro's entrance into the thread was really awkward and he's not doing much at all, another good lynch.

Rayn is a bit of a question mark, he's super reckless (to the point of being willing to die just to make a point, I don't know if he anticipated no one going along with it, or if he just doesn't care). He's doing stupid things, not taking an active stance about anything for the most part except me. I don't really know if all this makes him ballsy scum or reckless town, in both cases he's being very useless.

Vayne is another question mark. He's being an asshole about being awful at the game. I have no idea why. He also indicated he's been playing this a long time, which is important because he would probably be pretty towny if he was new to mafia.

FT remains a good lynch.