Golden Sun: The Broken Seal Mini Mafia - Page 2

On September 12 2013 18:56 Koshi wrote:
He pushes and advocates good and transparant posting/scumhunting.

On September 12 2013 21:10 raynpelikoneet wrote:

Uhh, we just talked about OP's post and his questions and you agreed with me they look bad. Are you now disagreeing again? Why?
Do you think there is something useful he says in his post? If there is, can you point out what that is.

On September 12 2013 21:39 blubbdavid wrote:

Fair enough.
May I have your opinion on Grack?

On September 12 2013 07:58 VayneAuthority wrote:
sup nerds, few concerns

why did blubbdavid come into the thread and say hi then peace completely? he was here yet had nothing to contribute to the game.

SnB is town, get votes off him. just played scum with him and this is obvious already

On September 13 2013 00:05 raynpelikoneet wrote:
How's Grack generating discussion? The way i see it is that he is the topic of discussion.

On September 12 2013 22:53 raynpelikoneet wrote:

Yes i disagree, here is Grackaroni's post:

Vayne's reasoning is right there. In the post Grack quoted. The question is worthless in the first place.
How can you not accept that someone can have strong reads early on in the first place? Instead of thinking this as a possibility Grack calls VA scum for having a strong read (when in fact VA just plays differently). There is nothing suspicious in Vayne having a read. Grack never calls out Vayne's reasoning, he calls out the read.

TLDR; He is saying "you can't have this read and therefore you are scum" until many people point out that's stupid. Then he covers it up by saying "oh, he just plays differently than i do". Like what? When you enter a game do you assume everyone has the same mindset you do?

1Pandain came into the thread with a long constructed post but he didn't analyze shit.
2He gave out some town reads that agreed with town sentiment.
3His reasoning for S&B being town is absolute bull. (S&B saw Debears post in a newbie game currently in signups, HOW DOES THAT EQUATE TO S&B GOING OUTSIDE THE GAME AND LOOKING FOR MAFIA??)
4He writes to a whole lot of nothing about OP (why did you even include that if you've made no conclusion off of it?
5And to top it off he then says that me and kush are BAD players so we are the top lynch choices
6Now when I called him out on him being more interested in lynching people for being bad than scum he says that we should focus on lurkers.

On September 13 2013 00:52 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Sno_man and Grack: Could you go through Pandain's & Old Partner's posts and tell me which one of those guys has shared more thoughts that contribute towards this game?

On September 13 2013 00:54 raynpelikoneet wrote:
EBWOP:

He seems like an over-zealous townie to me who is calling you & Koshi scum for wrong reasons.

On September 13 2013 01:00 raynpelikoneet wrote:
This is the same thing i feel about Axlegreaser...

On September 13 2013 01:00 raynpelikoneet wrote:

yeah yeah, could you just answer the questions, that was a part of it only.


This is the same thing i feel about Axlegreaser. Still, every time i read his posts multiple times and every time i can't understand anything he says. Trust me, this is way easier..

On September 13 2013 00:48 raynpelikoneet wrote:

I agree with some points he brought up against you:

1. I agree with him. Pandain analyzed people and gave opinions.
2. I'm interested in hearing from both of you & Blubb about this:
2a) You: What you say is incorrect. Pandain did not give town reads that agreed with thread sentiment. Btw why do you use wording "town sentiment"?
2b) Blubb: Why did you not comment on this point at all? This is probably the strongest point in your case against Grack?
3. I don't understand Blubb and i agree with you, Pandain's reasoning for SnB being town is shit.
4. Actually there is a conclusion, it's "watch out for this guy", i agree with the concusion Pandain came to, because that's exactly how i felt when i read Old Partner's posts.
5. That's certainly not what Pandain said.
6. This is wrong because that was not the point in the first place. I dunno however why Pandain did not correct you, or why Blubb is not bringing this up in his case.

Other than what i said, Blubb's case is crap. Anything else is nothing alignment indicative and is a pre-flip association that's bad. Does not make either one of you scum though.

Could you elaborate on my point (2), as i assked you to earlier?

On September 13 2013 01:03 raynpelikoneet wrote:

The way he approaches the game. Aggressively and calling people out with weak reasons, not being afraid of drawing attention to himself. He's either town or very good scum. I think the former, do you know if he's good as scum?

On September 13 2013 01:11 raynpelikoneet wrote:

Oh sorry, i missed this post:

I don't think you are right.
His read on VA is not following the thread sentiment, for example you yourself think VA is not necessarily town, as do other people. His read on GK is not following the thread sentiment, most people thought GK was scummy because of that comment, i agree with Pandain. His reasoning for the read on SnB is shit as said earlier. His read on OP is golden imo. Everybody should vote for that guy. His read on you is not following the thread sentiment, i can understand why he thinks what he says about you, i do not agree with him though. I am not even gonna go to the kush read. Kush needs to be given time. He either starts playing, if he does not, we lynch/vig him. Discussing/pressuring him does nothing good. I can however understand his policy.