|
On September 02 2013 12:48 Felkyr wrote:
Dude... that's like 'ages' before stuff happened, and you don't give an alignment opinion there either. It is before you said you can't determine his alignment based on the rig. You haven't given a decent alignment opinion yourself. And still you attack Cakepie for the same reason. You don't make sense to me.
##Vote: HirePro
I agree that Hiro is scummy.
Tell me why in a bullet list so I know why you're voting him.
|
On September 02 2013 12:55 austinmcc wrote:
gg dead bros.
VE died and flipped black but no role. This is portant. Could everybody in Black Mesa QT please post, and people report back to thread if any pseudonyms don't show up? Gives us a clue of someone who was unknown and in BM, and maybe indicated that BM don't flip with roles? Will do what I can to set aside paranoia concerning that for now, but if VE was the guy who claimed 3P in BM chat, that seems kinda nice.
If everyone in BM shows up, we know there's some other faction, but if someone specific is missing, we maybe know that VE was BM and maybe BM don't flip (could be someone in BM just not posting to make it seem like they're VE, which would be mean).
Still minorly interested in geript's thought process. I'll read hiro and some other folks when I'm more functional. Been scum with scumhiro a couple times, don't know that I have any super insight into him though.
I bolded everything that doesn't help us find mafia.
|
Hiro spent the latter part of day 1 shitting on BH. If Hiro is mafia, he knows BH is about to flip because either him and geript are mafia and he knows geript's powers, or Hiro knows geript is town and geript isn't lying. Does mafia Hiro take an E-dump all over BH before he flips town? Wifom?
Reading between the brown, I think the Cakepie idea has some merit and I'm willing to give it some thought. Cheesecake > Cake > Pie btw.
|
On September 02 2013 13:12 austinmcc wrote:
Last aperture had both red and black mafia factions. Black Mesa is apparently no longer another mafia faction, but I'd like to know if we can figure out what it do. Plus, I hear that people not flipping at all ain't bueno. If dude who claimed 3P in BM chat no longer around, makes it more likely VE's no flip is connected to that and he was 3P, not some other faction.
Go read that last game. Black Mesa was a mafia faction that functioned around repositioning people in the player list. We have people who reposition people on the player list in Black Mesa this time around. If we can figure out whether we have multiple mafia factions or just VE as some unknown 3P, is good. Plus you are a dessert.
I don't think it's worth speculating on until we have something conrete. If someone from BM comes screaming in the thread about Tyranny and 3p's and multiple mafia factions then so be it. But let's not 3p speculate or whatever just yet -- kill a scum dude first plx.
|
I didn't read last Aperture, but it's good to know it was a multiple mafia fact game. Something to keep in mind but it's not at the forefront.
|
On September 02 2013 12:48 Felkyr wrote:
Dude... that's like 'ages' before stuff happened, and you don't give an alignment opinion there either. It is before you said you can't determine his alignment based on the rig. You haven't given a decent alignment opinion yourself. And still you attack Cakepie for the same reason. You don't make sense to me.
##Vote: HirePro
I still want to know the exact reasons for why you are voting Hiro, please give me them at your earlier convenience. From what I can tell it has something to do with the Cakepie case and the Geript situation.
If you truly want to lynch him you're going to have to convince peeps.
|
The fact that debears is considering lynching himself for the sake of town means he is one million percent town. Lynch evil alakaslam and another dude i dont like plz.
|
Debears, the hero we deserve.
|
On September 02 2013 23:56 Clarity_nl wrote:
You can say a lot about greymist games and how crazy shit is, but despite all of that, when the smoke clears, they are actually fairly balanced. Nothing is so broken that it ruins the game.
Someone who can switch every single vote to a person of their choosing once, okay that's strong. Someone who can do it more than once? That ruins games. Why are we even considering that he can?
debears, make a big play when it's single lynch after you make yourself readable. At the moment I don't have a read on you at all, your role might as well be a scum role and you're currently posturing with a terrible idea.
I agree it could easily be a scum role but he's giving town the option to lynch him and geript 100%. Thats suicide if hes scum... Well suicide if town as well but his team wouldnt let him go yolo on this.
|
On September 02 2013 23:58 Clarity_nl wrote:Show nested quote +On September 02 2013 23:54 Mr. Cheesecake wrote:
The fact that debears is considering lynching himself for the sake of town means he is one million percent town. Lynch evil alakaslam and another dude i dont like plz. You've never seen scum fake martyr? What's with the rash conclusion? Other than the martyr what has he done?
It's not martyring. He's giving town a chance to lynch another dude with him. Why even suggest thst as dcum its so bad?
|
On September 03 2013 00:02 Clarity_nl wrote:Show nested quote +On September 03 2013 00:01 Mr. Cheesecake wrote:On September 02 2013 23:58 Clarity_nl wrote:On September 02 2013 23:54 Mr. Cheesecake wrote:
The fact that debears is considering lynching himself for the sake of town means he is one million percent town. Lynch evil alakaslam and another dude i dont like plz. You've never seen scum fake martyr? What's with the rash conclusion? Other than the martyr what has he done? It's not martyring. He's giving town a chance to lynch another dude with him. Why even suggest thst as dcum its so bad? It's such a terrible idea, why would anyone agree with it? debears is a better player than that.
Town typically come up with the stupidest ideas. Not scum. Anyway, I see you're voting alakaslam. Can i sheep you?
Or kill someone else with fire?
|
I think Mr. Z is a bad lynch for today. I also don't like the Hiro lynch despite the trollyness.
Double lynch useless dudes. Alakaslam / Risen / Shaio / Felkyr pick two.
|
On September 03 2013 01:00 Mr. Cheesecake wrote:
I think Mr. Z is a bad lynch for today. I also don't like the Hiro lynch despite the trollyness.
Double lynch useless dudes. Alakaslam / Risen / Shaio / Felkyr pick two.
Add Oats to this, I get bad feelers from him.
|
##Vote: Alakaslam
Because why not?
|
On September 03 2013 01:04 MrZentor wrote:
Actually, I would really like to kill oats..
Why should I over Alakunreadable?
I've played with town Oats and mafia Oats before. Problem is, as both alignment he seems to give more fucks about the game.
|
On September 03 2013 01:13 AxleGreaser wrote:Show nested quote +On September 03 2013 01:04 Mr. Cheesecake wrote:
##Vote: Alakaslam
Because why not? I am getting pretty tired but as i remember things because you have not and neither has anyone else on Alak explained why he did that as scum. Note my previous estimates of Alaks capabilities had to be lowered somewhat to get any possibility that as scum or town he would simply shuffle the items in a fit of pique because a town BH got lynched. But I haven't seen a suggestion I could understand how he or his scum team would have thought his actions were wise as a scum play. Not sold on Alak being a good lynch at all.
I'm not so much a fan of speculating this item thing or why he did what as what alignment because I don't even know exactly what this supposed item does. Lynch cus troll.
I don't want to lynch Hiro because some scummy reads are on it namely Felkyr and Shaio.
On September 03 2013 01:13 MrZentor wrote:Show nested quote +On September 03 2013 01:07 Mr. Cheesecake wrote:On September 03 2013 01:04 MrZentor wrote:
Actually, I would really like to kill oats.. Why should I over Alakunreadable? I've played with town Oats and mafia Oats before. Problem is, as both alignment he seems to give more fucks about the game. I just don't see any motive for Alakaslam to say that he was the one who shuffled the items as mafia. It just seems more like a thing a stupid townie would do. + Show Spoiler +
"But what if he expected you to think that way?" you ask.
It still would have been safer for him as mafia to simply not tell anybody than to hope that we don't kill him for what he did.
Yeah Z, it's a bunch of wifom either way. I just can't think of a reason to not lynch alakaslam :D So is the Hiro attacking BH thing, but that we actually have a flip on.
|
On September 03 2013 01:16 Onegu wrote:
Post from Black Mesa
Our claimed third party would like me to pass along the message that
I've got following role on Shiao: He is Kanti, Lord of the Black Flames.
Also there is a green check on shiao pi.
Oh that's good. Questions:
1) How can I trust Black Mesa, and who claims this green check?
2) Providing this green check isn't fake, how do we know it wasn't fucked with at night?
|
Okay so basically we have a flavor name on Shaio and a ?green check?
|
I'll admit Alakaslam is stupid if he's mafia. He hasn't show me any evidence that he isn't stupid, however.
|
I can't take the green check seriously considering this is a greymist game where 30 people have roles and someone probably got moved around 100 times before that check landed or something.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
