EPT
..
whenever i get home ill revote cus u guys dont wanna kill him.
im feeling jrkirby is the better lynch, I'll case it later.
Newbie Mini Mafia XLIV - Page 29
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
Rainbows
Germany1217 Posts
.. whenever i get home ill revote cus u guys dont wanna kill him. im feeling jrkirby is the better lynch, I'll case it later. | ||
|
hzflank
United Kingdom2991 Posts
On July 14 2013 07:39 Umasi wrote: Are you still going to stick with Gotard when there are more compelling cases out there to be on? (At least, ones that I think are more compelling) Let's not let Gotard off of the hook that easily. He still has not given us a firm scum read with reasoning behind it. | ||
|
Umasi
United States1399 Posts
| ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38799 Posts
The joking one. I didn't say it was good. I am just saying that he is willing to do so. | ||
|
Hurricane Sponge
868 Posts
| ||
|
Hurricane Sponge
868 Posts
On July 14 2013 08:02 Koshi wrote: The joking one. I didn't say it was good. I am just saying that he is willing to do so. Wow. Even if you interpret a joke post as evidence that someone is capable of making a serious case (/eyeroll), then that's actually evidence that he's NOT willing to do so, because he hasn't made a case yet in the actual game. I question your judgement, Koshi. Is that the leading reason you're leaning Town on kirby? Or is it because he's lurking, and you apparently find that to be a pro-town move? | ||
|
Umasi
United States1399 Posts
Koshi, I have no idea what to think of you but you make me laugh sometimes yeah, it's not necessarily an "or" as in which one is scum, the other is town more like, who are we lynching? btw, I plan to be on Superfluous unless the day would end in a no lynch, in which case I'd switch to a target that would return a lynch. (or something else changes my opinion of Superfluous/whoever the fuck) | ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38799 Posts
1) Super 2) kirby 3) Gotard 4) no lynch unless everybody really wants Stim. | ||
|
Hurricane Sponge
868 Posts
On July 14 2013 08:07 Koshi wrote: I am not leaning Town on kirby AT ALL. But I am saying that I like the Super case much better. If there was a lynch right now I would go: 1) Super 2) kirby 3) Gotard 4) no lynch unless everybody really wants Stim. Fine. I want you to address your train of thought on why someone posting a jokepost and then nothing gives you confidence that they will make serious cases in the future. I also want you to comment on why you think lurking makes someone more pro-town. | ||
|
Xzavier
United States393 Posts
On July 14 2013 06:09 Umasi wrote: @XZAVIER Spoil me, who's your largest scum read? Have you mentioned it and I totally missed it? Super at the moment. but im catching up on thread now. Lunch just started. | ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38799 Posts
Kirby came in this game with a bang, if he isn't going to follow up on this near then end of Day 1. Sure, I completely agree that he looks scummy. The only thing that I dislike at this moment about kirby is that he was very rude towards StiM in 2 posts while the 2 posts before that he was comforting him without any judgement. All of us said: "StiM, please come back IF you are town, or "prove that you are town' but kirby just said "StiM you are town, the others are scum that are annoying you." Which is very humane, but don't tell him he is an idiot twice right after. But I like that he pointed out that first sentence in your opening post. It sparks conversation. Nothing wrong there. Same with the joke analysis. | ||
|
Gotard
Poland446 Posts
Why not Superfluous? He isn't afraid to share his strong reads. His posts aren't full of useless crap (Hello Rainbows!) even when he isn't 100% right which concerns me. More pro town that jrkirby in general feel. Why Jrkirby? I don't see him making pro town content. His post claiming that hzflank is mafia was awkward and then he defended himself saying that it was only a joke/pressure combo. Then posing useless lurker list (seems like every newbie game needs one). But as far as his interaction with stim goes I think you are overthinking it. ##vote: jrkirby. | ||
|
Xzavier
United States393 Posts
But right now super & jkirby both blink bright red on my scumdar. super has talked of policy then threw a halfass vote at me when asked to vote. didnt even try to convince people to vote with him. Wasting a vote is a horrible thing. | ||
|
Hurricane Sponge
868 Posts
On July 14 2013 08:22 Gotard wrote: Jrkirby looks like a better lynch than Superfluous right now. Why not Superfluous? He isn't afraid to share his strong reads. His posts aren't full of useless crap (Hello Rainbows!) even when he isn't 100% right which concerns me. More pro town that jrkirby in general feel. Why Jrkirby? I don't see him making pro town content. His post claiming that hzflank is mafia was awkward and then he defended himself saying that it was only a joke/pressure combo. Then posing useless lurker list (seems like every newbie game needs one). But as far as his interaction with stim goes I think you are overthinking it. ##vote: jrkirby. Do you think Superfluous is Town? | ||
|
Xzavier
United States393 Posts
| ||
|
Umasi
United States1399 Posts
And if so, why? | ||
|
cloud-9
United States4 Posts
| ||
|
Umasi
United States1399 Posts
You should be in a situation where you can post now xzav, what are your thoughts? | ||
|
Chromatically
United States1700 Posts
To conclude, Super's priorities seem to be 1) Stay Alive 2) Find a person to vote for 3) Find justifications for voting This is literally a list of objectives as either alignment. Town obviously wants to stay alive. Finding a person to vote for with reasoning is also town. The difference between the alignments is that town want to find scum, and mafia doesn't actually want to. Super looks like he's honestly trying to find scum. In particular, I really like these two posts: On July 14 2013 04:29 Superfluous wrote: Going back through the posts, I'm a little alarmed at Hurricane Sponge's change of tone.In this post he disagrees with my opinion and says it casts suspicion on me, but doesnt state that I'm a huge scumread or anything. Here I interpreted his post as acknowledging that while we disagree, I was still trying to state my opinion and reasons for having that view. He then says some weird things here though. For instance, he says that he agrees with others' view of me who had semi-defended me, and in the same list puts me as the only scum read. I realize his view may have changed, but it strikes me especially considering in the second post I listed he acknowledged the possibility of a bandwagon on me just because of differing opinions. We also have a mutual disagreement on reads as well. I don't see how hzflank and xzavier have contributed substantially more than me. While knowing everyone's scum reads is good, I don't like it when people show up, say their scum reads, then expect other people to act on them. As for Stim I think he's more likely bad town then mafia. Then again everyone else is saying the same thing, so could be mafia excuse for not lynching him. On July 14 2013 04:37 Superfluous wrote: Also, idk what is up with jrkirby. If there was a third party that'd be my guess for him, right now just null read I guess though. This is because his play has been somewhat erratic with no clear goal to me other than tunneling on Sponge, which didn't really do much. He strikes me as the type of player who could be dangerous late game for us because he seems hard to read. Im curious jrkirby, what has been your goal with your posts thus far? Super wasn't under any pressure when he posted these. He's actively reading the thread, looking for scum, and most importantly sharing his thought process with the thread. This is very, very genuine and townie. Basically: Super is trying to find scum, even if it doesn't look like it at first glance. Kirby is NOT trying to find scum, but he's trying to look like he is. | ||
|
Chromatically
United States1700 Posts
| ||
| ||
