[T] Nuclear Winter Mafia - Page 114

On July 12 2013 02:28 FirmTofu wrote:
@strongandbig
If you are gonna claim, then claim. Don't fucking soft-claim and let everyone talk about it for 2 hours before you come out and own up to it. Fuck.

On July 12 2013 02:21 austinmcc wrote:
Read through, not entirely processed.

I don't think someone being immune one = them being town. I actually thought Onegu was crumbing some kind of radiation medic, he seemed to know how radiation worked, how it killed, but claimed no nuke. That role seemed very townie to me.

For no raisin, I'm assuming that with some of these roles that exist in multiples, some of there were assigned to scum. But if we start seeing 3 people claiming 48-hour unstable nukes, immune ones, defense grids, etc. then I think it's ALMOST a listcheck saying someone in that bunch is scum. Immune one a perfectly fine mafia role tbh, if they have any radiation nukes they can drop em on townies OR on a known immune one and use it as extra KP from thereon out, irradiating people.

As best as I can tell...Ace is not nuked anymore, and was given a nuke by an unknown. Maju had a nuke, and used it on jampi? He did not claim it until recently, and did not say whether he has had it the whole time or how it came into being? And also...sentinel nuked DI/XigXag, but did not claim from whence his nuke came? Is that...the nuking story as it sits right now?

On July 12 2013 02:34 FirmTofu wrote:

I might as well address this...
1. Nope, not really. Yeah, last game I was a bit more active early on but that was because there was so much less to read. In this game, it takes me a lot longer to catch up and form reads.
2. You might want to expand on this. I am doing a good job at finding reads(Vayne and jampi) and pushing them as evidenced by my fervor to tunnel both of them to oblivion.
3. Role fishing? Where? Please point me to one post where I role fish. I will address it directly.
4. This isn't even a point against me.

You yourself said that you don't use meta to form reads but all I see in this accusation are meta arguments. Do you have a better reason to accuse me or are you simply defending your scumbuddy Ace?

On July 12 2013 02:19 Xatalos wrote:


Hm. On the other hand, town MajuGarzett would want to nuke his own scumread (VA), not your scumread (jampidampi).

On July 12 2013 02:26 geript wrote:

You people make me sad.... but I like this post. I had the idea of a using the roles as a listcheck, but I'm pretty sure artanis is a bastard host so it wouldn't be that worthwhile.

On July 12 2013 02:26 FirmTofu wrote:

Town MajuGarzett could do either, I think. An unconfident Town Maju would rely on other people's reads because he doesn't trust himself to be good enough at the game. He might also think that if he listens to others, people might back off the lynch on him. A confident Town Maju would go with the VA lynch.

I just don't see any reason to believe that Maju is an experienced, confident player.

On July 12 2013 02:41 Xatalos wrote:


I guess it goes like this (MG and VA likely not scum together - MG and jampidampi likely not scum together):

Option 1
MajuGarzett
VayneAuthority
jampidampi

Option 2
MajuGarzett
VayneAuthority
jampidampi

Option 3
MajuGarzett
VayneAuthority
jampidampi

Option 4
MajuGarzett
VayneAuthority
jampidampi

Correct me if I'm wrong, but it seems like
A) if we lynch MajuGarzett, we should save jampidampi
B) if we lynch VayneAuthority, it's arguable if we should save jampidampi or not

I'd really like some input on this since I have conflicting feelings on which of these options is correct.