| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31494 Posts
On April 23 2013 23:56 Palmar wrote: BC's town meta is to be awful at day 1, then get lynched. I'd like to not lynch him later. VE is still scum. Palmar, do you consider BC's play so far to be awful? | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31494 Posts
On April 24 2013 05:34 Palmar wrote: yep, and I think he's crazy wanting to lynch yamato. You've mentioned you didn't want to lynch him D1; what would it take for you to actually find him scummy and lynch-worthy? Is it simply one of those cases where 'if he is alive past x days, he is scum?' | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31494 Posts
Any thoughts on yamato/Oats since you seem to have conveniently missed it entirely? Updated thoughts on Rayn/Shiao? | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31494 Posts
On April 24 2013 06:29 raynpelikoneet wrote: WoS why does it matter what Sharrant thinks about Oats? Because I'd like to hear his opinion on arguably the most important thing that has gone down in the thread thus far. | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31494 Posts
On April 24 2013 06:38 Vivax wrote: Yeah, move on, I'm curious to see what you will deliver to Rayn's question. You'll feel my breath in your neck this game. Made me thing of this. Warning: kinda icky. + Show Spoiler + http://www.homeescapade.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/03/stoma-on-the-neck.jpg | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31494 Posts
On April 24 2013 06:59 grush57 wrote: sais tube sais grush | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31494 Posts
On April 24 2013 07:17 raynpelikoneet wrote: It doesn't really matter what he says about Oats as he already knows the results and it's his genuine thoughts or WIFOM and you have no way of telling which is it. Nonetheless, I'd still like to hear it. Why do you feel the need to prevent me from scumhunting? | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31494 Posts
Oh, and I probably would have already used it. | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31494 Posts
I think BC is more likely to be scum than Clarity. Because I feel like specifically asking Sharrant those questions. I can ask whoever I want, whatever I want. | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31494 Posts
On April 24 2013 13:49 raynpelikoneet wrote: My townread on Sharrant has weakened very much at this point. When i look at his posts i see several things where i can't understand how his thinking process works. I will point them out later on today, too tired atm. There are also a couple of things i totally do not understand, like why does he take TRN's comment about me (the lynchbait comment) at face value, when at that time TRN is his scumread. No questioning about it.. nothing. And how did it end up, i had never said so in the first plce, yet it's a reason to strengthen his scumread on me.. Another thing i find odd: How the hell WoS can ask Sharrant's updated read on ShiaoPi? From what i can tell Sharrant has never said what he thinks about ShiaoPi, only scumreads he has given out are me/Hopeless. Wtf is this shit? ![[image loading]](http://julialachman.com/pics/desert/08reaching_hand1.jpg) | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31494 Posts
On April 24 2013 23:11 Sharrant wrote: Okay, let's get this started with the most important part: Clarity should be lynched tomorrow, a few people have made cases on why, and they're quite right. He apparently spent 4 hours reading the thread and came up with not even half a case on me, and refused to comment on the lynch that was happening right in front of his eyes all the while flip flopping on the amount of time and effort he supposedly put in. He's obvious enough at this point that everyone should be on board with his lynch, I don't think there's more that needs to be said about him. Responses to cases and stuff: @Clarity There's nothing in your case to respond to. You obviously just skimmed my filter and tried to pick out what you could skew to look mafia oriented, and you failed miserably at that. @Rayne + Show Spoiler + On April 24 2013 15:57 raynpelikoneet wrote: About Sharrant: First he makes a case on TRN. The case in itself is not bad if you have never seen how TRN plays. But there is this question: I call him out for this question which i find to be scummy. Sharrant's answer is: Sharrant later on calls me out for saying; "So you say TRN is actually not attempting to discern who in the thread are the mafia, but you still have a town read on him. Townies should scum hunt, yes?". This is correct, mainly because Sharrant and Vivax both attacked TRN early on in the game, after that TRN went defensive and answered their questions. Sharrant is even adding more fuel into the fire by asking TRN to point him to his games on TL. Why do you think it is TRN's (or anyone other than yours) job to guide you into his past games? And why do you call me out for poining out the fact (as i have witnessed it myself) that TRN is easy to sidetrack from what he is supposed to do -> find mafia? Next thing. Sharrant's case on me. His points against me are; BM-policy lynch discussion (understandable as i failed to explain myself clearly enough) and that i called him scummy for asking TRN to point him to his last games. Which i still think is scummy. Next i explain him my BM vote, he is pleased with my answer, at least that reads so to me. + Show Spoiler + On April 22 2013 08:40 Sharrant wrote: I see. I'll wait until Bill Murray is back in the thread before I say anything more about this then, if I feel the need to say anything more. Let's give ourselves another topic then. Pick a player who you would like to discuss with me, and I will read their filter while I cook and eat. I would suggest Mr. Cheesecake, but I would prefer it if you picked the candidate for discussion. In the same quote he asks me to pick a player to discuss. Why do you want me, your scumread to pick a player to discuss? If i thought you were scum i would be damn sure i wanted to pick the people we discuss (other scummy people). After that we discuss WoS and GiygaS. I also ask him about geript. I am the one asking all the questions. Note that Sharrant would have liked to discuss Mr.Cheesecake. If i am your scumread, why do you allow me to drive the discussion between us? Why do you not want to find out my scumbuddies when talking with me? Then Sharrant suddenly changes his scumread on TRN into null/leaning town. The reason is TRN saying i have told him i would use weak townies as town-credit-collectors by defending them. Sharrant takes this at face value. TRN was your scumread at that time, why didn't you take any action to figure out if he was telling the truth or not, as he wasn't? Then comes in his theory (based on what TRN said) about me trying to gain town-credit for TRN's lynch. The theory is ridiculous in the first place, if people can't see why idk what to say. He also makes a big post about it: + Show Spoiler + On April 22 2013 13:26 Sharrant wrote: It was part of the thought process that got me to look at you in the first place. Obviously TRN is not getting lynched so there is no credit for you to gain from it anymore. It is even, apparently, something you told TRN that you would do as mafia (though you did not state you would do it specifically to him). You seem to be misinterpreting my definition of small chance. Small chance of being mafia still meant a greater chance than anyone elses actions in the thread. At that point I figured he probably had about a 40 percent chance of being mafia, if I were to assign a value to it. A small chance, but still greater than I felt anyone else had. So I went after him because he was the strongest scum read I had. When Rayn made these two posts: That was a lot more effort than anyone took to explain TRN. Everyone that commented on him, or I asked to comment on him, just stated they thought he was a noob town, but generally people had to be prodded into action. Rayn came in attacking me with a very weak case because of my case on TRN. At this point, I am very happy because I am sure I have at least one mafia in these 2 players. I am sure after that attack and defense that Rayn is mafia either defending a mafia to deflect a bandwagon before it can start, or defending someone he sees will be lynched later and thus he would be able to go "Hey look, I knew he was town allt he way back then and I defended him!" regardless of whether he was lynched today, or tomorrow, or a week from now. At this point I am 100% sure of Rayn, and 50/50 on TRN. When TRN came in and said that he had a town read on Rayn despite the inconsistincies myself and others had pointed out, I had TRN down as very likely to be scum. But when he later mentioned how Rayn had told him that he planned to do this exact same thing as scum before, and subsequently moved him to a null read, that was when I was pretty sure that TRN was town. At this point I am less sure about Rayn being scum than I was then, because his conversations with other players has generally been good since that time, but he's still in my top 3 to lynch. I just haven't decided if there's someone I'd rather lynch more, like say Hopeless. Any more questions? At the end of that post he also says his scumread on me has weakened. After that i vote for Sharrant. This is his answer to the case: + Show Spoiler + On April 23 2013 00:02 Sharrant wrote: It's a good try, Rayne, but no. Let's get this out of the way quickly because I have to leave, and there's more important things to do when I'm back. The reason I looked into you is because of your chainsaw defense of TRN. That fit exactly what I was looking for, so I went through your filter. I am not trying to lynch you on the merit of you defending TRN, get that through your head. I am going to get you lynched because you are scum. You claim that after posting several times about how miller claims should be a policy lynch, you say that it's not a policy lynch you're pushing on BM. The closest you come to make to a case is "This isn't a miller lynch policy, I'm lynching him because he claimed miller which is scummy" which is exactly the same as saying "No, this isn't a lurker lynch, I'm just lynching because his low activity is scummy". It's just attempting to disguise that you were trying to policy lynch him. The post I voted for you details exactly why I have you as a scum read. The possibility that you were a townie who made some crazy defense on TRN went out the window when I read through your filter. If you can't understand that, I can't help you. Now, suddenly i am 100% scum again. But no more is my town-credit-gaining a reason why i am scum. It's all back to the point that i "disguised my policy lynch vote on BM into something else". But he was already okay with my answer. Hell, he does not even answer anything to my case. Why did you make a big post about the theory of me trying to gain credit from defending town!TRN, if it isn't even part of the case against me, what's the point? TLDR; 1) Why did you not answer me clearly when i asked you why should TRN point you to his past games? And he never did, why didn't you follow it up in any way, if you think that was scummy from him? 2) Why did you say you were pleased with my answer on the BM matter and later on said your whole case against me is based on that? 3) Why did you not want to find out who my "scumbuddies" are when we were discussing people, and why did you let me drive the discussion? 4) Why did you take TRN's words about my "scum strategy" at face value as at that time he was your scumread? 5) Why did you even discuss your theory about me trying to gain credit from TRN when it had apparently nothing to do with your scumread on me and was based on false premises in the first place which you were too lazy to check out and which came from you scumread? And for the record this is basically everything Sharrant has done this game besides one post where he answers Vivax about Hopeless and couple of posts questioning people with no follow ups at all. I don't see how this is anything near townie behaviour. 1. It's laughable that yous till think that asking for games is a scum tell, but run with it if it makes you happy. He did point me to his games, just not linked them. Not as helpful as I would have hoped he would have been, but he didn't mention any games off site which was the concern. 2. I never stated I was pleased with your answer. I asked you to restate so everyone would see that your answers still did not match up with what you had said earlier in the thread. Pushing that singular point any more would just make the thread more of a mess than it was starting to be, and the whole point would get lost and thus once I had you restate it again clearly there was no more value to be gained from going after you on that point at that time. So instead, I wanted to move you onto topics that would be helpful regardless of whether I was wrong or right about your alignment. 3. The choice of who to talk about is as telling as the choice of who not to talk about, I'll learn more about your alignment from you picking who you want to discuss then I will from giving you the topics I want you to discuss. It tells you too much about how I already lean on those topics, and having you drive the discussion lets me get a better feel for you. 4. I'm really surprised you don't get this part. Lots of newer scum buddy people, especially people that defend them. Here he shows that he's suspicious of the fact that you defended him, regardless of whether the fact he stated was misremembered (apparently someone else in that game had said it) he showed that his thought process went "Hey! This guy has taken up a shield for me" -> "Wait, why did he do that?" When as a new scum scared to be in his first big game would have been more hesitant to put any tarnish on his knight's armour. 5. You're mixing up your time periods so bad that this question is just a jumble of words. Your staunch defense of him got me to check out your filter. His subsequent "Hey, why are you defending me?" moment made him more than likely town. @WaveofShadows I think Oats was a good lynch because of how useless he was being, it's a shame he turned out to be town, but at least he was a non-self aware miller. That said, I think there were better lynches for that day, Clarity and Rayne being two I think would have been better lynches. Yamato is almost definitely town, everything about his posts on the second half of day one scream town yamato in a way I don't think he knows how to replicate as scum. Last time I played with him when he was scum I caught him (but was not able to get him lynched before I was killed) because of how glaring the difference is between him being the townie, headstrong Yamato and him trying to emulate the townie headstrong Yamato. I hope that satisfies your curiousity. If there was one or two things in particular that lead you to have such a strong town read on me, what would they be? I'm going to be around for a while doing some filter diving in, so I'm available for questions. It is very likely that I will be unavailable for Thursday, and possibly some or all of Friday (excepting phone posting which I hate hate hate doing). There will be 0 posts from me between midnight tonight, and Thursday night. For starters just the fact that you cared enough to respond to my buried, 'inane' line of questioning that Rayn and TRN seem to hate so much further cements my townread on you. Also wtf I don't think I read the flip, just looked at the colour---he WAS a fucking miller. I agree with your thoughts on Oats and feel a little better about being wrong. Yes you've definitely satisfied my curiousity. Now you mention a Clarity lynch...I agree that his entry into the thread was very scummy-looking but he just doesn't feel like a good lynch to me for reasons that I can't remember right now. I have a bunch of re-reading to do and an eventual case to post...when is frigging Daypost? | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31494 Posts
Like...why even post? | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31494 Posts
On April 25 2013 01:43 ObviousOne wrote: Syl is not a project for D2 IMO. Grush did starsenses so he is town. But he didn't post starsenses in green font.... I'm going to be looking into a lot of the lurk for D2 personally so I think that would include Syl for me. Shiao looks like he'll be prime candidate for D2 though. I've been beaten to the punch on a case though, so I'll add to it later on. | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31494 Posts
On April 25 2013 01:48 ObviousOne wrote: Oh shit he didn't green it as mentioned in the next post. Fuck. Now I dont know. Yes he has but IDR if he said it without green in that game. I'll see if I can find the reference from LX in my inbox in a conversation with Marv I was half-kidding with that...either way I know better than to bother looking into Grush. If people suspect him let them vig him, otherwise if it comes down to the wire we're fucked with him being one of the last up anyway just like in LX. OO, I like your points on CC and Shiao, (I'm still not sure of VE) but why do you think Giygas is scum? The person who threw suspicion on him was Oats, and despite him being town it was for basically no reason. I will admit his filter has been extremely lacking thus far and I certainly don't have a townread on him. Do you have anything else to back it up? | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31494 Posts
Will be back much later tonight, sorry Sharrant. I think I'm null on Kush? Can't remember I have to go. | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31494 Posts
| ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31494 Posts
Finishing the read now, VEis the suspect now/ What happaneed to Shiaopi and Sylenciua? | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31494 Posts
Oh fuck nvm now I remember BH posted it doesnt start till the day? it's all coming back. Ok. Drinking lots of water B\M Imf ine. I'm not voting for VE rihgt now I need lots more evidence than that 'cause like many others I jsut can't get a fucking handle on him. I'm still up for Shiaopi or Sylencia, not 100% sure on CLarity; something he psoted seemed really town-motivated so I'd ideally want to look elsewhere. The hammer is honestly the worst thing I think shiaopi has going for him (amongst other things) I remember when I hammered in Ego at least I had dropped some suspicion onto Axle at some poitn during the day and discussed it somewhat; why the fuck as town would you hammer blindly like that> | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31494 Posts
On April 25 2013 15:45 yamato77 wrote: Oh, that's right, it was Shiao who dropped that hammer. WOW, I forgot all about that bullshit. I could lynch him just for that. On April 25 2013 11:30 WaveofShadow wrote: Alright ladies I remember reading through earlier and thinking 'it's fucking obvious Vivax masined a scum' who did he mason N1? Oh fuck nvm now I remember BH posted it doesnt start till the day? it's all coming back. Ok. Drinking lots of water B\M Imf ine. I'm not voting for VE rihgt now I need lots more evidence than that 'cause like many others I jsut can't get a fucking handle on him. I'm still up for Shiaopi or Sylencia, not 100% sure on CLarity; something he psoted seemed really town-motivated so I'd ideally want to look elsewhere. The hammer is honestly the worst thing I think shiaopi has going for him (amongst other things) I remember when I hammered in Ego at least I had dropped some suspicion onto Axle at some poitn during the day and discussed it somewhat; why the fuck as town would you hammer blindly like that> Lol even drunk I made a little sense. Reading for real now. Also I may or may not have loled at the reason you don't want to call me scum geript. | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31494 Posts
On April 25 2013 14:00 getmoript wrote: The problem with VE is that he hasn't gotten pissed off at Palmar at all. Ace thinks that Palmar is just doing this for the lulz and that's VE's assumption as well: But VE isn't getting mad. Not whatsoever. He's not responding like he's pissed at all. There are no misspellings in what he's typed. The furthest he's gone is to tell me to fuck off. I'm interested to see how he returns, but how VE's responded reminds me more of how he responded to me in PYP. Plus BM is right, there's not the "intention to kill" in his posts that's there as town. Before getting to reread I felt stronger about lynching Shiao, but right now I much prefer VE. On April 22 2013 02:34 VisceraEyes wrote: Defend against what? Why can't he have a townread on Palmar and know he's not going to be active as town and sheep a townread? I'm going to be in Vegas for 4 days next weekend and I'll be playing in a similar fashion (if I live that long) and I'm town, that seems feasible enough. Has he said he's not going to be active? He's here now and you're not asking him anything. You're whole reasoning is bullshit. | ||
| ||
StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War Sea Dota 2 15505Flash 1486firebathero 624ggaemo  578Pusan  567Nal_rA 471Light 341Last 250Mong 235hero 129[ Show more ] Counter-Strike Heroes of the Storm Other Games singsing2374 B2W.Neo542 Pyrionflax263 Fuzer  247XaKoH  225Trikslyr76 ZerO(Twitch)22 RotterdaM8 DeMusliM0 Organizations Counter-Strike StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War StarCraft 2 |
|
WardiTV Invitational
Fire Grow Cup
Wardi Open
Monday Night Weeklies
PiGosaur Monday
PiG Sty Festival
Replay Cast
Code For Giants Cup
SOOP
ShoWTimE vs Clem
Tenacious Turtle Tussle
[ Show More ] |
|
|
EPT
