So, for what it's worth I did not at any point think of Geript as mod-confirmed town. After living through like 20 nightkills it should have been clear something was up.

Also, BC choosing to hammer without giving it at least a few days in IML to think about it is profoundly unwise.

Specifically what happened with Marvellosity is that he and Geript (who, as a hydra, are always provided a hydra QT regardless of alignment) were communicating in a different QT. I wanted them to use the QT I provided, but Marv flamed me a bunch and I decided that it's okay for them to use their own QT. I even edited my rules to allow them to do so. After I informed them of my decision, Marv continued to flame me so I modkilled his head of the hydra.

Marv then posted in the game thread, post modkill, complaining about his modkill and claiming (falsely) that I had done so because he and Geript were posting outside the regular QT and I had edited my rules to not allow them to do so, when in fact I had done quite the opposite and been quite accomodating.

I will be requesting a 2-game ban for Marv, not for the flaming (perhaps under better circumstances i would not modkill him for this) but for posting after his modkill knowingly and willfully about things currently going on in the game. When I was modkilled and thought it was unjust about a year ago, I shut up because it's the host's game, and I contested the ban in the Ban Thread AFTER the game was over. I did not try to ruin the game for others because my ego couldn't stand being modkilled.

Marv is a nice guy and I like him, but this is a lesson he must learn-- other people's play experience matters.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

May 17 2013 23:24 GMT

#5911

what the fuck BC?

Blazinghand

United States25560 Posts

May 17 2013 23:26 GMT

#5912

As an aside, Ace played amazingly well, and were he an SK instead of an SP he might have pulled it off. He got very unlucky being roleblocked repeatedly, and SP's only advantage, which is that it's easier to hide the kills since 2 mafia NKs and a lynch happen between the shot being fired and it landing, wasn't much use when he couldn't shoot at all. He played quite well.

I think town hit a real slump starting with the Ace lynch. The choice of Geript to bus GigyaS was entirely reasonable, but he hammed it up a bit too much during the last night, made it weirder he was alive.

VisceraEyes

United States21171 Posts

May 17 2013 23:26 GMT

#5913

IT WAS SO OBVIOUS BOTH PALMAR AND BC WERE TOWN WOFNAOIVNAOEVNAEOIRN AEOIRNAREOINBAOIRNBAOINAEN OAO IARN OA NAO INAO INAOIEN AOIE N AOIN AOIANNAOI NAOIN O NOIN

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

May 17 2013 23:27 GMT

#5914

On May 18 2013 08:11 Ace wrote:
BC you and Palmar need to take a break from Mafia for a while :/

Why?

VisceraEyes

United States21171 Posts

May 17 2013 23:27 GMT

#5915

SO OBVIOUS BRO SOOOOOO OBVIOUS

Ace

United States16096 Posts

May 17 2013 23:27 GMT

#5916

Palmar...if geript is modconfirmed town why the hell is he alive for so long? come on you KNOW this - the worst thing for Scum is confirmed town. Going into LYLO and he is STILL alive?

good job to geript though. Played everyone for fools with it and just sat back letting you guys argue.

VisceraEyes

United States21171 Posts

May 17 2013 23:27 GMT

#5917

VisceraEyes

United States21171 Posts

May 17 2013 23:28 GMT

#5918

Gerpit damn man....GG.

Blazinghand

United States25560 Posts

May 17 2013 23:28 GMT

#5919

Oh yeah Geript and GigyaS played quite well. many kudos to them for not giving up despite having a very rough start

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

May 17 2013 23:28 GMT

#5920

On May 18 2013 08:27 Ace wrote:
Palmar...if geript is modconfirmed town why the hell is he alive for so long? come on you KNOW this - the worst thing for Scum is confirmed town. Going into LYLO and he is STILL alive?

good job to geript though. Played everyone for fools with it and just sat back letting you guys argue.

Didn't I try to get him lynched two days in a row now?