TL Mafia LXI - Page 206

On May 02 2013 07:26 ObviousOne wrote:
We are simply not lynching palmar today. Anyone who has seriously suggested that we do so needs to take a break, step back, think about why, and prove to me he's the best lynch today.

Cop claim? Probably true
Broken cop? Definitely
Lazy? Tautology (see also n. Palmar)
Wants to kill BC? Isolate his reasons outside of his check. I wanted to kill BC d1 too for being sort of a jerk. From what I remember, because it would be fun? It totally would.

Today Palmar is my ally in lynching BC. I have demonstrated a scum mindset on BC's behalf that no one has proven to be demonstrably false.

We are running out of objectively scummy shit to lynch for.

On May 02 2013 07:24 GiygaS wrote:
Just catching up, and still on only page 120 of the re-read due to sleep + school. However, we should NOT lynch Palmar. He has a huge town read for me as his first finger pointing for mafia was Clarity on day 1, along with BM. Both of them can not be scum in my eyes for that reason, unless one of them straight up slips.

On May 02 2013 07:52 WaveofShadow wrote:

Devil's advocate time, as I mostly agree that Palmar shouldn't be lynched today. Did you read my case on Palmar Guygas?
Notice how I am able to use this same evidence as a scumtell due to him pointing out Clarity as a possible early bus since Clarity was already gone for a while by that point?

On May 02 2013 08:01 GiygaS wrote:

My counter point being that this was day 1 (page 54) that Palmar initially called Clarity scum (a simple "sup scum"). This was only 3 pages after Clarity posted his case on Sharrant. Clarity was not already gone for a while by that point, so this is straight up false.

On April 23 2013 21:44 Palmar wrote:


don't even care if you're scum. throwing suspicion on your emperor should be punishable by death.

On May 02 2013 08:59 TheRavensName wrote:





"oh oats was always gonna flip town. I didn't really care much for reasons best left unexplained."

Scumslip mixed with the whole stupid reason he basically voted for oats. This is something I would like to see someone argue against please.

On May 02 2013 09:37 GiygaS wrote:
I thought he was paraphrasing, since he didn't use an actual quote (like the quote function). My bad. Anyway, I'm pretty sure that's Palmar being Palmar. A lot of his posts looked like this at that point in the game.

On May 02 2013 09:37 ObviousOne wrote:
Listen to Scumcast 3, really actually listen to it don't just play it in the background. Palmar talks about D1 lynches. It totally fits with everything he said in the cast. Oats was a good D1 lynch even though Oats was town. You cannot apologize for lynching town D1, and since you are usually going to hit town you have to make it a GOOD D1 lynch. A GOOD D1 lynch gives you information without lynching for information. You have people take sides, you see who flies in the face of logic, reason, how people escape the noose. Accept the fact that D1 lynches tend to hit town, accept that he understands and embraces this, and use the information constructively. His slip isn't a scum slip, it's his actual mindset.

On April 29 2013 10:06 Palmar wrote:


The reasons best left unexplained have now been explained. I was actively trying to be useless/awful without sabotaging town. I usually say it's a terrible idea to change your play when you roll blue... but my normal play gets me shot night 1 almost every damn game, so I decided to give it a shot.