Boardwalk Empire Mafia: Pick Your Power - Page 79

On April 08 2013 12:55 Mocsta wrote:

Im here hunny, and changed my mind.

Its assassin.

Imm sure gonzaw woulda told us who he was hitting anyways (if NRA)

On April 08 2013 12:57 Sharrant wrote:


That's twice you've forgotten he actually would have had to write it into the thread, even though you mentioned it just a few minutes ago on the opposite side of the argument.

On April 08 2013 12:57 Keirathi wrote:
So yea, Mocsta is (kinda) right.

America, Russia, and Day-Vig are ruled out.

I don't see Assassin gambling his power on gonzaw unless he found a lock tight crumb. And, if there is a solid crumb, that (maybe?) opens up the possibility of a BloodC0bbler too.

NRA would make some sense, but gonzaw was claiming that he wasn't shooting even as the shot post came up. And who knows how long ago the shot was actually sent in and it took BC to get here and post the death.

Meh.

Looking back through filters a bit.

On April 08 2013 12:54 Mocsta wrote:

Yeah im not getting that.

Closest I could find was:
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=403766&currentpage=76#1518

Thing is, he describes the KP as one-shot.
Which reduces role to Day-Vig/Jack.

He was also commenting freely about town vigging at night; as if he knew town had night kp (instead of assume).

I think you're right; scum if role hunting, could have surmised with enough confidence gonzaw was jack.

So assassin in play; i suggest no more roleclaims.

As we dont know if BC is in play too.

I suspect only Geript is a potential kill then, as he has rolecliamed.

On April 08 2013 11:12 gonzaw wrote:


Hmm, not that convinced right now.

If he's town that'd be better than a misslynch though....
...but if that's what should happen, it'd be better to let him live until D2 at least...and maybe shoot him there

I won't shoot anybody that hasn't had a chance to "redeem" themselves yet. Sno being so damn awful could be tied to IRL stuff. I mean, he hasn't even voted yet, he may even get replaced/modkill.
BC was seeking a replacement in the "Player Replacement" thread, and so far it seems Snoman is the one fitting that bill.
He damn sure looks scummy though, but I'd wait until he shows up to do any shit and analyze what he does, or for his replacement to get here and analyze what he does (knowing that his predecessor was scummy as fuck)

We can just vig him at night, either he if he just comes here to avoid modkill and does shit all, or his replacement if he gets replaced.

I can save my day KP to D2, and there shoot guys that don't do shit. Seems the ability is more useful that way.

I hate scummy guys replacing though
Something like that game can happen, where Ver was scum, got replaced, and his replacement acted in a way that made him survive until end-game or something. That sucks.

On April 08 2013 13:03 Keirathi wrote:
Oh hmm. I guess you are right Sharrant. It specifically says that Jack skills are bound by the same rules as its regular counterparts.

I honestly hadn't thought about it, and assumed that Jack sent in day kills silently, since his night vig kills would be silent.

On April 08 2013 13:04 Mocsta wrote:

Keirathi,

pls comment on my reversal of sharrant, where he knew that the assassin was the logical choice.

Yet didnt even know how day-vig worked etc.

On April 08 2013 12:46 Mocsta wrote:

Day-Vig requires something typed into thread.

The thing is.. so many roles have day vig

america
russia
dayvig
jack

i dunno. i find it unlikely the assassin was willing to risk getting the role wrong.. (cos that will make the power void)
i might look through gonzaw filter for crumb.

because right now.. i suspect NRA is much higher

the question then becomes.. who did he try to kill... artanis or VE

On April 08 2013 13:03 Sharrant wrote:
This is the post where I knew with 100% certainty that he was the Jack. Scum should've known right then too. He's confident he can save his shot for tomorrow even having already said he could day vig. If I were in his position I'd be 100% sure that I don't live to see tomorrow. He's 100% confident that the town has at least 1 night vig shot. Jack is the only KP role that would let him live the night, and let him day vig. It was the only thing that fit how he was playing.

On April 08 2013 12:31 gonzaw wrote:
Well...technically I could just shoot Artanis and we could lynch VE.
It is an option. I doubt I'll do it (specially since I may not be here until the deadline).

I'd like some explanations from VE, or alternatively....him showing up at all ya know?

On April 08 2013 13:10 Sharrant wrote:


I feel like you're trying to put suspicion on me, there's a reason I asked in the thread if day vig had to claim his shot. I was unaware of that restriction so thought dayvig could have been in play, but you said it couldn't have been because of the claim. So when Keirathi showed you were indeed correct, it showed that there was only one possible way he could have died, and you had enough information to know that too but you came to the wrong conclusion. Perhaps it was an earnest oversight on your part, but you should have known immediately.

The fact you had referenced it so recently but failed to take it into consideration is suspicious. That you're trying to turn this around on me like that makes it doubly so to me.

On April 08 2013 13:04 Mocsta wrote:

Keirathi,

pls comment on my reversal of sharrant, where he knew that the assassin was the logical choice.

Yet didnt even know how day-vig worked etc.

On April 08 2013 13:10 Sharrant wrote:


I feel like you're trying to put suspicion on me, there's a reason I asked in the thread if day vig had to claim his shot. I was unaware of that restriction so thought dayvig could have been in play, but you said it couldn't have been because of the claim. So when Keirathi showed you were indeed correct, it showed that there was only one possible way he could have died, and you had enough information to know that too but you came to the wrong conclusion. Perhaps it was an earnest oversight on your part, but you should have known immediately.

The fact you had referenced it so recently but failed to take it into consideration is suspicious. That you're trying to turn this around on me like that makes it doubly so to me.

On April 08 2013 13:13 yamato77 wrote:
It doesn't matter what killed him, it matters why.

Gonzaw was killed because he was obviously town and people were forming around him. What did he advocate? Killing artanis. Let's murder him.

On April 08 2013 13:13 yamato77 wrote:
It doesn't matter what killed him, it matters why.

Gonzaw was killed because he was obviously town and people were forming around him. What did he advocate? Killing artanis. Let's murder him.

On April 08 2013 13:03 Mocsta wrote:
Now anways, lets get this show back on track.

Gonzaw was a good scum hit; the timing is what is interesting.

Are they trying to force us onto VE, because it happened when we were talking about him?

hmmm.. for now, i want to maintain the legacy Gonzaw started.

We keep the lynch on Artanis[Xp]

On April 08 2013 13:14 Bill Murray wrote:
Mocsta, I haven't fully caught up. What is the case on Artanis? You look really town right now, so I don't mind sheeping you.

On April 08 2013 13:13 Keirathi wrote:
But that's mostly irrelevant. The bigger question is why were you thinking so hard about what gonzaw's role was in the post you quoted?

On April 08 2013 13:14 Bill Murray wrote:

OK
##vote artanis