RED Team's Prize - Page 8

On March 30 2013 13:56 Keirathi wrote:
EBWOP: Also, ignoring Smurf for a minute, what do you think about the points I laid out for why I think Acro is scum?

On March 27 2013 04:30 sinani206 wrote:


Really?
Generally I wouldn't bring suspicion back this far, but if you have a three post filter at the beginning of day 1 and then ninja-vote halfway through the day, that's pretty suspicious. You could be in the middle of writing some really long analysis, but it's already been 40 minutes, so that's doubtful. What's up, man?

On March 27 2013 06:22 prplhz wrote:
@Nisani201 How do you feel about that sinani206 guy?

On March 27 2013 06:28 sinani206 wrote:


Question for you: what's your problem with me?

On March 28 2013 06:18 sinani206 wrote:
OO ninja vote with 40 minutes left in the day ok.

On March 29 2013 06:48 sinani206 wrote:
Hapa, please stop encouraging people to post vital information at night time. We have 48 hours to discuss the next lynch.

On March 30 2013 15:33 Hapahauli wrote:
Fwiw, acro made his case after I expressed very strongly that Yamato needed to die today

On March 30 2013 15:52 Keirathi wrote:

I'm not trying to "win". I just want you to recognize the point that I was making.

So, you looked over the filters. Now, where did Acro get the "I had a quick look at Sinani's town meta (think I only ever played with him as scum) and he seems more useful" sentiment from? Because I just don't see it.

As far as Acro and Smurf being scum together...that's a harder one to answer. Yea, a mutual double bus is uncommon. But it is not completely unheard of (in recent memory, VE and Snarfs went after each other hard on day 1 of Nomination, iirc). There are some mitigating circumstances that make me think it is a possibility here, though.

**isclaimer: everything I'm about to say is in a hypothetical land where Acro and Smurf are both mafia.***

So day 1 ends and night 1 starts. Thread sentiment is turning pretty heavily against Smurf. How should Acro react? Does he try to save his buddy, or does he hard bus for the town cred? Remember, Acro hasn't really been under any major suspicion up until this point. The biggest thing against him was how hard he was pushing for the Nisani mislynch, which isn't alignment indicative in itself.

So, lets say Acro decides to bus. He throws the case out there after everyone is already calling Smurf mafia. Now, if Smurf realizes that he is more than likely going to die (hell, he has me, marv, Hapa, and now his scumbuddy Acro all pushing his case), what should he do in reaction? What helps the scum team out the most? Attacking the townies who are attacking him, attacking a random townie, or attacking his scumbuddy? It seems to me that it wouldn't be a bad play at all for him to OMGUS onto his scum buddy, because when Smurf does flip mafia, the people he spent a ton of time attacking inherently look better because of it.

***End disclaimer***

I'm not saying that is 100% how it happened or anything, but I think it is a reasonable line of thought.

The alternative is so take one of them out of the vote today and wait for flips, but I'm honestly not sure which one I would take out, and who I would replace in. And I'm almost positive that there is at least one scum between the two of them.

On March 30 2013 22:02 Oatsmaster wrote:
Also whats with all these confirming townies.....

OO confirmed marv.

Dandel confirmed OO.

What.

On March 30 2013 22:04 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Maybe they are all scum?