Personality Mafia 2 - Page 91

On March 13 2013 02:49 Acrofales wrote:

I thought you were pretty levelheaded and townie at the time, but this post is not making sense to me.

WBG's role was survivor, not scum aligned. His powers were meh. Unless you are talking about Kurumi, in which case he was town aligned, not scum aligned at all.

The impression I got from Yamato is that he knew all along what his power would do. Now, why would scum get a DT check? It makes no sense. Even if it is combined with a dayvig. Either Yamato is lying about how his power works, or he is town. The role makes NO sense for scum.

On March 13 2013 02:51 VisceraEyes wrote:

This describes my feelings too. I've had lingering doubts about Crossfire based on how he was roleplaying early on - then he came back and it looked like he was going to contribute, but then roleplayed some more. Then he came back and was suprsrsmode - and he was on the block.

Like, everyone has a vested interest in not getting lynched, but it just seems to me that we wouldn't have been in a position where Xfire was up for lynch if he'd played the way he was playing at lynch time like, all day.

I'm gonna go peruse those games, let me know your thoughts on his meta (since you seem to be familiar already) while I'm gone.

On March 13 2013 00:45 yamato77 wrote:

It was one of the factors that I considered when I thought of the possibility of him being town, yes. I didn't know his alignment, and thought that even if he was town for this, it was not a great loss because of how he was playing.

You should stop posting because I've said all this before. Fucking read.

On March 13 2013 00:59 Vivax wrote:
Had VE as scumread before the shot, but didn't shoot him.





Proof that yamato is scum



Yamato announces that the problem will be solved when he doesn't know if he gets a check back or Kurumi dies.
Yamato knew Kurumi would die and says he doesn't have to announce the shot in the thread but claimed it on his own - despite not knowing if he'll get a check back he says that "The problem will be solved".

The actual announcement comes later


His reaction after knowing Kurumi would die as town:

On March 13 2013 01:08 Vivax wrote:
Now, aside from the fact that yamato didn't shoot his "scumread", he didn't play as if he expected to get a check back on Kurumi no, he posted as if he knew he would get shot.

What if he had the chance to get a check back from Kurumi (like he should believe), why announce something beforehand when you don't know the outcome?

Let's assume he expected to get a red check back on Kurumi, would he announce it in the thread or wait for the outcome and only claim the shot if he hit green? In case he hit red he could simply push Kurumi or claim the check afterwards. In case of green he could have stayed silent or claimed it or whatever he wanted to, but he chose the stupid way, why? Explanation: For his role to work he had to play the shot like MZ played it.

He had to announce that he would shoot someone in the thread for his role to work, but refuses to admit it. Every other explanation doesn't make sense unless he's a massive derp.

On March 13 2013 01:29 Vivax wrote:


______________________________________________________________________________________________________




He chose to shoot Kurumi for martyring over his "scumread" VE in the arc of 13 minutes.



Bugs was martyring, too but he pumps out a 5 guy list instead of going for Bugs who does the same as Kurumi. Kurumi martyring is a good enough reason to shoot him but Bugs doing that isn't a good enough reason to lynch him over 4 others?

Inconsistent reasons, terrible role usage, indications of him knowing Kurumi's flip beforehand ( + general subjective scumminess).

On March 13 2013 02:56 Vivax wrote:

You were willing to bet a townie life against a check that no one would believe cause it would have been a D1 check.

On March 13 2013 02:58 marvellosity wrote:


Why do you keep saying this? I don't understand it at all.

On March 13 2013 02:49 Acrofales wrote:

I thought you were pretty levelheaded and townie at the time, but this post is not making sense to me.

WBG's role was survivor, not scum aligned. His powers were meh. Unless you are talking about Kurumi, in which case he was town aligned, not scum aligned at all.

The impression I got from Yamato is that he knew all along what his power would do. Now, why would scum get a DT check? It makes no sense. Even if it is combined with a dayvig. Either Yamato is lying about how his power works, or he is town. The role makes NO sense for scum.

On January 12 2013 02:18 Vivax wrote:
Thanks for the compliments folks, if Foolishness didn't say that he wanted me to have 9 pages of filter by start of day 3 I probably would have played differently.

Then I simply tried to play pro-town. I actually made a slip: The one where I said I shouldn't defend townies (while talking of CC).



I also crumbed busy paramedic (even), so it would have been interesting between me and VE if I had to claim.

I think there should be a policy for such slips. I remember Z-Boson saying "it has nothing to do with me being scum" in Hero mini mafia, and he was scum.

If someone makes such a slip as town, then it's his fault, but it should be treated seriously. Scum-Claiming should also be lynchable, just like Palmar derping around.
I can understand why he might have done that: To get killed as late as possible, but him being around still didn't help town much. Not saying you're not good, but this game you weren't exactly shining, majesty.

Congratz to my scumbuddies for managing to stay out of scope so well and being a talkative and active bunch.
I would also like to thank my parents, my manager and my fans for their support.

Dr. Genki

On March 13 2013 03:15 austinmcc wrote:
Was away for a moment, noticed slOosh talk.

I checked Personality 1 because I thought there'd been a role that had to tunnel someone and only post on them. Didn't find it, but maybe skipped over. Is there anyone known for just fighting with MZ every game they're in? I agree with slOosh being a futureproblem, but his activity being ONLY to tunnel made me think that perhaps it's a personality limitation, despite most personalities in this game not coming with the same extreme limitations that they came with in 1.

Couldn't find a particular role, but if there's a player known for fighting with MZ, or a player known just for tunneling, it's a possible explanation (that doesn't say anything about his alignment )

On March 12 2013 13:53 slOosh wrote:
My scum read on yamato is even stronger now. Take out the Kurumi shot out of his filter and what you are left with is a bunch of one liners throwing doubt and pointing fingers at everyone. Not only that, there is absolutely no consistency with his reads at all. Multiple times he calls slOosh and Cora scum and they get left out of his final reads, he bothers to put in a post detailing people he would liked lynched yet doesn't move his vote on WBG, indicating he doesn't really care if crossfire were to die (does yam think he is town? scum? who knows?). That plus the problems I have concerning his role usage => this dude is scum.

People think otherwise about the role usage: I invite those people to look into his filter (aside from the role stuff) and tell me what they think. Marv I think you mentioned his meta - I'm most familiar with town yamato from Nomination, where he carried town at the end. Dunno his scum meta, but clearly he can play decent town (posting wise and whatnot).

I'll be taking this night to review stuff I missed during the day. Still gonna tunnel yamato though unless people can provide more than "yam's balls too small for that". If you want opinions on specific things ask and I'll address them when I can.

On March 13 2013 03:15 austinmcc wrote:
Was away for a moment, noticed slOosh talk.

I checked Personality 1 because I thought there'd been a role that had to tunnel someone and only post on them. Didn't find it, but maybe skipped over. Is there anyone known for just fighting with MZ every game they're in? I agree with slOosh being a futureproblem, but his activity being ONLY to tunnel made me think that perhaps it's a personality limitation, despite most personalities in this game not coming with the same extreme limitations that they came with in 1.

Couldn't find a particular role, but if there's a player known for fighting with MZ, or a player known just for tunneling, it's a possible explanation (that doesn't say anything about his alignment )

On March 13 2013 03:20 marvellosity wrote:


Does anyone else find it weird he talks about himself in 3rd person here? I know people do so occasionally but I've never seen slOosh do it I don't think.