|
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On March 17 2013 01:47 slOosh wrote:Show nested quote +On March 17 2013 01:40 Oatsmaster wrote:On March 17 2013 01:37 slOosh wrote:On March 17 2013 01:35 Oatsmaster wrote:On March 17 2013 01:34 slOosh wrote:
I eventually conceded marv was town given that everyone else in town thought so too. You can see this because when Foolishness comes in with his big post I get all excited (hey I'm not the only one!) and same when supersoft initially came in. It is incredibly difficult to mentally decide that you are correct and everyone else in town isn't. My confidence in my play isn't at that level.
The biggest information from the night kills was that Foolishness is town and that the bulk majority of his effort was directed at marv, and that cora was almost certainly town given the high KP.
Marv admits himself that he looks terrible if cora flips town. Well cora did flip town but marv made up stuff to say otherwise. I felt strongly against that, but again, everyone else in town thought so too. What are you saying here? That everyone sheeped marv so his play is invaild? huh? I'm not commenting on marv's play here, I'm commenting on my own. So how in any way is this related to marv alignment? You want to get him lynched, you got to put in the work. Lol ok Oats is scum too. I was never using the explanation to push marv. He wants me to put in work to get marv lynched but he himself isn't pushing for anyone's lynch. At LYLO. Lazy scum busted.
So are you going to deny that you went back and re-read everything and agreed with all the points you said you did?
|
On March 17 2013 01:47 prplhz wrote:Show nested quote +On March 17 2013 01:46 Acrofales wrote:On March 17 2013 01:36 prplhz wrote:
yes you have, a roleclaim will make me reconsider. do you have any reason not to roleclaim? Why? What about Marv's roleclaim is going to make you reconsider? Actually there is one thing: Marv claimed he was protecting DI, yet DI ended up dead. Either someone shot Marv despite it being completely obvious DI had some form of protection on him (and scum therefore guessed correctly about exactly how DI's role worked), DI was doublestacked and there were 6!!! shots fired last night, or DI was not protected. Marv, can you explain what you did last night? why wouldn't i reconsider in face of new information?
Because Marv's roleclaim is already 90% in the thread. He's VE the pre-announcing JOAT.
If he's mafia do you really think he can't invent some believable actions for his JOAT role so the claimed actions make sense?
I really don't see what a roleclaim will help. However, I DO want to hear what happened with Marv's save of DI and why Marv thinks DI died despite his claim.
|
On March 17 2013 01:47 slOosh wrote:Show nested quote +On March 17 2013 01:40 Oatsmaster wrote:On March 17 2013 01:37 slOosh wrote:On March 17 2013 01:35 Oatsmaster wrote:On March 17 2013 01:34 slOosh wrote:
I eventually conceded marv was town given that everyone else in town thought so too. You can see this because when Foolishness comes in with his big post I get all excited (hey I'm not the only one!) and same when supersoft initially came in. It is incredibly difficult to mentally decide that you are correct and everyone else in town isn't. My confidence in my play isn't at that level.
The biggest information from the night kills was that Foolishness is town and that the bulk majority of his effort was directed at marv, and that cora was almost certainly town given the high KP.
Marv admits himself that he looks terrible if cora flips town. Well cora did flip town but marv made up stuff to say otherwise. I felt strongly against that, but again, everyone else in town thought so too. What are you saying here? That everyone sheeped marv so his play is invaild? huh? I'm not commenting on marv's play here, I'm commenting on my own. So how in any way is this related to marv alignment? You want to get him lynched, you got to put in the work. Lol ok Oats is scum too. I was never using the explanation to push marv. He wants me to put in work to get marv lynched but he himself isn't pushing for anyone's lynch. At LYLO. Lazy scum busted.
OMGUS.
Put your vote on me then?
I want a multitude of people lynched. Currently thread sentiment is in the way of cross.
And im happy.
So that works, no?
If you think we are gonna lose the game. What are you gonna do? sit and whine?
|
On March 17 2013 01:49 marvellosity wrote:Show nested quote +On March 17 2013 01:46 Acrofales wrote:On March 17 2013 01:36 prplhz wrote:
yes you have, a roleclaim will make me reconsider. do you have any reason not to roleclaim? Why? What about Marv's roleclaim is going to make you reconsider? Actually there is one thing: Marv claimed he was protecting DI, yet DI ended up dead. Either someone shot Marv despite it being completely obvious DI had some form of protection on him (and scum therefore guessed correctly about exactly how DI's role worked), DI was doublestacked and there were 6!!! shots fired last night, or DI was not protected. Marv, can you explain what you did last night? yes. I got distracted by Fool's flip. I was roleblocked. What you see in the thread is what you get. There is literally no way for me to change my night action other than posting in the thread.
Why claim roleblocked so late :S
|
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On March 17 2013 01:51 Acrofales wrote:Show nested quote +On March 17 2013 01:49 marvellosity wrote:On March 17 2013 01:46 Acrofales wrote:On March 17 2013 01:36 prplhz wrote:
yes you have, a roleclaim will make me reconsider. do you have any reason not to roleclaim? Why? What about Marv's roleclaim is going to make you reconsider? Actually there is one thing: Marv claimed he was protecting DI, yet DI ended up dead. Either someone shot Marv despite it being completely obvious DI had some form of protection on him (and scum therefore guessed correctly about exactly how DI's role worked), DI was doublestacked and there were 6!!! shots fired last night, or DI was not protected. Marv, can you explain what you did last night? yes. I got distracted by Fool's flip. I was roleblocked. What you see in the thread is what you get. There is literally no way for me to change my night action other than posting in the thread. Why claim roleblocked so late :S
Pretty sure I just said. I was shocked by Fool's flip and haven't thought about it since.
|
On March 17 2013 01:51 Oatsmaster wrote:Show nested quote +On March 17 2013 01:47 slOosh wrote:On March 17 2013 01:40 Oatsmaster wrote:On March 17 2013 01:37 slOosh wrote:On March 17 2013 01:35 Oatsmaster wrote:On March 17 2013 01:34 slOosh wrote:
I eventually conceded marv was town given that everyone else in town thought so too. You can see this because when Foolishness comes in with his big post I get all excited (hey I'm not the only one!) and same when supersoft initially came in. It is incredibly difficult to mentally decide that you are correct and everyone else in town isn't. My confidence in my play isn't at that level.
The biggest information from the night kills was that Foolishness is town and that the bulk majority of his effort was directed at marv, and that cora was almost certainly town given the high KP.
Marv admits himself that he looks terrible if cora flips town. Well cora did flip town but marv made up stuff to say otherwise. I felt strongly against that, but again, everyone else in town thought so too. What are you saying here? That everyone sheeped marv so his play is invaild? huh? I'm not commenting on marv's play here, I'm commenting on my own. So how in any way is this related to marv alignment? You want to get him lynched, you got to put in the work. Lol ok Oats is scum too. I was never using the explanation to push marv. He wants me to put in work to get marv lynched but he himself isn't pushing for anyone's lynch. At LYLO. Lazy scum busted. OMGUS. Put your vote on me then? I want a multitude of people lynched. Currently thread sentiment is in the way of cross. And im happy. So that works, no? If you think we are gonna lose the game. What are you gonna do? sit and whine?
Maybe next time Oats you will remember to cover all your bases. Maybe.
|
i'm hoping that he can't. i mean your question essentially is "if he's scum do you really think you can catch him?" to which i'm just going to answer "hopefully somehow".
|
Scum chose to roleblock marv and shoot DI instead of vice versa?
|
No chance that any of you are hapa or keirathi smurfing on someone?
|
United Kingdom36161 Posts
Answer my question slOosh. Stop ignoring me.
|
I guess it's believable. Scum doesn't know how DI's protection works. They want Marv dead. Marv claims to protect DI, so they roleblock him and kill DI.
Scum-Marv *could* kill DI just to make it look like this is what happened: it is entirely clear that if DI HADN'T died, then my D3 policy-lynch of Marv would have come roaring into action.
Eh. I think I'm being paranoid. Marv isn't playing like scum. He was just as wrong as me and a whole list of confirmed townies about Foolishness.
Lets kill Xfire. It's lylo and there are 5 scums left. Plenty of time to lynch Marv if he is left alive. Lets get the low-hanging fruit first. Lynch Xfire now.
|
On March 17 2013 01:52 slOosh wrote:Show nested quote +On March 17 2013 01:51 Oatsmaster wrote:On March 17 2013 01:47 slOosh wrote:On March 17 2013 01:40 Oatsmaster wrote:On March 17 2013 01:37 slOosh wrote:On March 17 2013 01:35 Oatsmaster wrote:On March 17 2013 01:34 slOosh wrote:
I eventually conceded marv was town given that everyone else in town thought so too. You can see this because when Foolishness comes in with his big post I get all excited (hey I'm not the only one!) and same when supersoft initially came in. It is incredibly difficult to mentally decide that you are correct and everyone else in town isn't. My confidence in my play isn't at that level.
The biggest information from the night kills was that Foolishness is town and that the bulk majority of his effort was directed at marv, and that cora was almost certainly town given the high KP.
Marv admits himself that he looks terrible if cora flips town. Well cora did flip town but marv made up stuff to say otherwise. I felt strongly against that, but again, everyone else in town thought so too. What are you saying here? That everyone sheeped marv so his play is invaild? huh? I'm not commenting on marv's play here, I'm commenting on my own. So how in any way is this related to marv alignment? You want to get him lynched, you got to put in the work. Lol ok Oats is scum too. I was never using the explanation to push marv. He wants me to put in work to get marv lynched but he himself isn't pushing for anyone's lynch. At LYLO. Lazy scum busted. OMGUS. Put your vote on me then? I want a multitude of people lynched. Currently thread sentiment is in the way of cross. And im happy. So that works, no? If you think we are gonna lose the game. What are you gonna do? sit and whine? Maybe next time Oats you will remember to cover all your bases. Maybe.
I dont see your point, you changed from hard target, marv. To supposed easy target me. But you arent doing anything,
Why sloosh?
Why did you contradict yourself earlier.
You still havent said what you gained from the nuke exercise even though it would be really REALLY useful now.
But nope, just keep the 1 line snipes going.
|
I am officially ignoring marv and oats on the basis I think they are scum and are trying to divide focus and attention.
I am open to talking to anyone else. Also don't let yamato's case get buried.
Have nice day.
|
United Kingdom36161 Posts
Here's how it is slOosh.
supersoft, Dandel, Promethelax, iamperfection, strongandbig and whoever else I'm forgetting believed Foolish to be certain mafia.
You said you went back and reread what I wrote and agreed with what I wrote about Foolish, and agreed with what I said about Corazon.
And you're calling me mafia.
Is this about right?
|
On March 17 2013 02:01 slOosh wrote:
I am officially ignoring marv and oats on the basis I think they are scum and are trying to divide focus and attention.
I am open to talking to anyone else. Also don't let yamato's case get buried.
Have nice day.
Why did this read on me suddenly come up? You showed no interest in me over the first few days, now you think Im confirmed scum?
whut..
I am sensing a whole lotta bullshit here sloosh.
|
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On March 17 2013 01:57 Acrofales wrote:
I guess it's believable. Scum doesn't know how DI's protection works. They want Marv dead. Marv claims to protect DI, so they roleblock him and kill DI.
Scum-Marv *could* kill DI just to make it look like this is what happened: it is entirely clear that if DI HADN'T died, then my D3 policy-lynch of Marv would have come roaring into action.
Eh. I think I'm being paranoid. Marv isn't playing like scum. He was just as wrong as me and a whole list of confirmed townies about Foolishness.
Lets kill Xfire. It's lylo and there are 5 scums left. Plenty of time to lynch Marv if he is left alive. Lets get the low-hanging fruit first. Lynch Xfire now.
In all seriousness, we kill Crossfire (or DP) today, they flip mafia, it's still lylo tomorrow and i'm left alive. What then?
|
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On March 17 2013 02:01 slOosh wrote:
I am officially ignoring marv and oats on the basis I think they are scum and are trying to divide focus and attention.
I am open to talking to anyone else. Also don't let yamato's case get buried.
Have nice day.
Since when do you ignore your scumreads that you're trying to get lynched? :/
|
you're getting roleblocked anyway, why wont you claim?
|
it's not like you have any hidden surprise powers if you have to claim everything in advance
|
On March 17 2013 02:05 marvellosity wrote:
In all seriousness, we kill Crossfire (or DP) today, they flip mafia, it's still lylo tomorrow and i'm left alive. What then?
This stinks. You're a more-than-solid mafia player. You know that. You enjoy that. But yet you are saying that you're town, going to finally start lynching mafia, and then they will leave you alive tonight? This isn't the marv that I know, who should have been assuming that every night from N1 he was going to be killed.
I have tried to be the police. That hasn't worked. So let's try something else. austinmcc wright, thread lawyer.
OATS - Have you ever played in a game with scummarv before? If so, which? If so, on a scale of -10 (Modconfirmed scum) to +10 (Modconfirmed townie) how did you read him?
WHOLE THREAD - Was anyone roleblocked N1?
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
