|
On January 21 2013 04:02 Vivax wrote:
@JieXian
Why do you suspect exactly debears out of all lurkers? Cause austin already mentioned him?
Would you still vote for gonzaw as mayor?
@ Clarity
When will you be dropping your promised reads? I am taking back the support until I see something good.
I'm asking for toad's professional vet opinion about somebody so I can read better
|
Sandroba is allegedly the best town here, why don't you sheep him in lynching yourself if you need help at reading?
Isn't he "professional" enough?
That's not an answer to why you picked debears out of all lurkers by the way. Did you read the whole thread or do you just hook up to the closest case?
|
(Sorry for not consolidating)
Do you have any other 'reads" besides debears?
|
I'm not sheeping anybody, I'm getting different POV about a vet who isn't appearing, whom townie toad would know about. Why is asking someone a question sheeping?
No, I do not have a strong scumread on anyone yet.
|
Hi.
Is there anyone currently running on the platform of lynching prplhz? As far as I could tell, the answer to that is no.
Since it seems no one is interested in that, let me propose that we vote someone into mayor who will lynch prplhz today. I'm willing to be that person if need be.
|
On January 21 2013 04:39 DearestSnot wrote:
Hi.
Is there anyone currently running on the platform of lynching prplhz? As far as I could tell, the answer to that is no.
Since it seems no one is interested in that, let me propose that we vote someone into mayor who will lynch prplhz today. I'm willing to be that person if need be. Any reason to believe he's the Magical Disappearing Scumprplhz?
|
On January 21 2013 04:39 DearestSnot wrote:
Hi.
Is there anyone currently running on the platform of lynching prplhz? As far as I could tell, the answer to that is no.
Since it seems no one is interested in that, let me propose that we vote someone into mayor who will lynch prplhz today. I'm willing to be that person if need be.
Sandroba actually is, except for the fact that he's not running.
|
I might just vote for gonzaw if he promises not to write and endless stream of text walls and try to stick to the point.
@gonzaw Who would you lynch? How do you feel about my Chezinu lynch idea?
|
@DearestSnot I don't like the idea of lynching me. Why do you want to lynch me?
|
Okay I'm here. I'm reading the thread now, will come back shortly
|
On January 21 2013 03:20 Stutters695 wrote:Show nested quote +On January 21 2013 00:31 austinmcc wrote:You also asked for scum reads. In terms of people I'm looking at: stutters - a few very short posts. Nothing much of substance. Asks some questions to Toad here but never follows any of that up. Easy questions to participate, without really going anywhere with the answers. Mildly scummy for now. debears - slightly worrisome in the same way. Drops that he won't vote vivax, supports chezinu, gives a short answer when asked "why chezinu" and then dips. Along with stutters, he reads like he showed up because he thought he should make posts, made some posts, lumpY I also remember debears being generally interested in the game, and would expect ... more involvement when he was here, or at the very least more answerage. Given that this game started Friday night, that we have a couple players we haven't seen ANYTHING from, and a decent number of players we've seen very little from, those are my top reads. Right now I'm not dealing with everything else. Short posts yes, but it was like two hours into the game. I dropped the questions on toad because he answered and the discussion in the thread cleared it up pretty well for me. I'm catching up on the thread now.
Where's this "catching up" you were doing now Stutters, huh?
The point is not you just "asking questions because it's 2 hours into the game". The point is you trying to blend in in the background with those questions.
You appear so "soft" by asking "irrelevant questions" (although to be honest I don't remember them much they may be relevant), and just....disappear in the meantime.
Now you "promised" (indirectly) to post your thoughts about what happened once you end up "catching up the thread" but it's been 2 hours since and nothing from you.
|
Annul mind telling us some of your thoughts? You're one of the preferred guys to vote for me but you're not really giving me anything to go with...
On January 20 2013 12:57 annul wrote:
fuck you toad; you would rather vote someone who does not even want the candidacy instead of me? =( funny, yet useless post
On January 20 2013 22:51 annul wrote:Show nested quote +On January 20 2013 19:44 Vivax wrote:
Three people so far have expressed concerns about my activity: gonzaw, Axle and JieXian.
{...}
Who would be happy with a JieXian lynch? I would be!
blatant OMGUS? FOS vivax not funny, but still useless post considering it's you.
Other than that there's only your first post of the game to go by.
So far gonzaw is the only one of the people running who is willing to post a decent amount, which doesn't meant crap because he's very much like I am when playing mafia...
Though what he's posting isn't necessarily bad.
|
@Vivax: You being AFK after your candidacy post was weird because I'd think a townie would post his candidacy and hang around for a while to respond to questions. You going afk seemed too sudden as well.
If you say you were sleeping, then I guess that's null and there's nothing we can do about it, since it's most likely true regardless of your alignment.
I'm not enjoying this "aggressiveness" you are showing Vivax, seems too needlessly provocative.
Although you running for mayor in the first place (while being considered "not-vet" by most of us) doesn't really seem like something you'd do as scum, and maybe this "aggressiveness" stuff just means you are getting over-excited or something.
Meh, certainly not enough to make any call other than leaning slightly town on you (gut feeling) so I'll let that pass.
I do have to say that I agree with austin that JieXian's 1st post wasn't as "scummy" as many people (you+sandro) pointed out, it's null at worst.
I think the 1st posts from many other people would be "far" more scummy (in relation, not objectively at least), like our guy Stutters' up there, and maybe other's like FiveTouch, or maybe even debears.
Why did you give Jiexian so much flak Vivax? Why did you instantly want to lynch him instead of other's (based on their 1st post as well)?
Speaking of those, 5's first post is somewhat suspicious:
On January 20 2013 21:36 FiveTouch wrote:Show nested quote +On January 20 2013 21:21 Oatsmaster wrote:
I dont feel confident lynching JieXian off 2 posts...
He has expressed delight in 2 players for mayor and hasnt expanded or anything. Regardless, Isnt it quick to vilify him so quickly? This is an extremely odd defence of JieXian. Why are you making it? ##Vote: austinmcc
First statement in the whole game and it's just to cast doubt on someone random from the thread. Of course not mentioning the unfounded vote on austin...which to be honest is more of a null tell than scum tell since I can't really see much benefit to do so as scum, other than the usual "create chaos/wifom" strategy.
He doesn't come in to post his thoughts on any current discussion, nor to be part of any discussion/etc. That's what townies usually do, to try to establish a nice town atmosphere, get info, and establish their innocence.
Reminds me of JingleHell's first posts in Aperture Mafia 2 (where he was scum and i called him out for basically the same thing).
There's not much about debears other than a "derp" start, so let's just wait and see what he does when he comes back.
|
On January 20 2013 18:32 sandroba wrote:
What questions are those? About not wanting to run? I don't have a satisfatory answer, I simply decided this pre game and has nothing to do with alignment.
Well.........*sigh*
I kind of feel this is "obvious scum sandroba", but obviously until he actually has the time to do something useful to town we can't do much about it :/
What kind of makes me "mad" about the "obvious scum vets" in games, is how people always let them be.
Like, this happened with scum Foolishness in like 2 consecutive games where he lived until D5 or something. Either people ignore them, or say "meh, he could be town and thus could be an asset".
These kind of people are so "obvious" scum (in a matter of speaking of course) when they roll scum and nobody does anything about it :/
I'd said sandro is one of those (maybe Palmar as well, although slightly less), based on the games I've obsed with him being scum (and Liar Game of course, where he lived...wait for it...until D5).
I get the "if he's actually town he can be an asset" idea many people have.....but if he's just screaming scum at your face you can't try bullshitting your way out of that.
|
I'm on gonzaw for now. I like his most recent post for several things. Mostly talking about stuff I picked up as well, mostly stuff I agree on, mostly stuff I'm not sure mafia-gonzaw would pay enough attention to, to come to the same conclusion as I as well did.
So ##vote Gonzaw
Still would like to hear more from other people like Sandro, prplhz and annul.
|
On January 21 2013 05:38 Toadesstern wrote:
So far gonzaw is the only one of the people running who is willing to post a decent amount, which doesn't meant crap because he's very much like I am when playing mafia...
Though what he's posting isn't necessarily bad.
You mean I always get caught as scum on D1? 
(that's actually not a joke, I always get caught as scum on D1 just look at my last 2 scum games lol)
|
On January 21 2013 05:50 Toadesstern wrote:
I'm on gonzaw for now. I like his most recent post for several things. Mostly talking about stuff I picked up as well, mostly stuff I agree on, mostly stuff I'm not sure mafia-gonzaw would pay enough attention to, to come to the same conclusion as I as well did.
So ##vote Gonzaw
Still would like to hear more from other people like Sandro, prplhz and annul.
gawd gonzaw in a posting frenzy. I was referring to this post: + Show Spoiler [click me!] +On January 21 2013 05:43 gonzaw wrote:@Vivax: You being AFK after your candidacy post was weird because I'd think a townie would post his candidacy and hang around for a while to respond to questions. You going afk seemed too sudden as well. If you say you were sleeping, then I guess that's null and there's nothing we can do about it, since it's most likely true regardless of your alignment. I'm not enjoying this "aggressiveness" you are showing Vivax, seems too needlessly provocative. Although you running for mayor in the first place (while being considered "not-vet" by most of us) doesn't really seem like something you'd do as scum, and maybe this "aggressiveness" stuff just means you are getting over-excited or something. Meh, certainly not enough to make any call other than leaning slightly town on you (gut feeling) so I'll let that pass. I do have to say that I agree with austin that JieXian's 1st post wasn't as "scummy" as many people (you+sandro) pointed out, it's null at worst. I think the 1st posts from many other people would be "far" more scummy (in relation, not objectively at least), like our guy Stutters' up there, and maybe other's like FiveTouch, or maybe even debears. Why did you give Jiexian so much flak Vivax? Why did you instantly want to lynch him instead of other's (based on their 1st post as well)? Speaking of those, 5's first post is somewhat suspicious: Show nested quote +On January 20 2013 21:36 FiveTouch wrote:On January 20 2013 21:21 Oatsmaster wrote:
I dont feel confident lynching JieXian off 2 posts...
He has expressed delight in 2 players for mayor and hasnt expanded or anything. Regardless, Isnt it quick to vilify him so quickly? This is an extremely odd defence of JieXian. Why are you making it? ##Vote: austinmcc First statement in the whole game and it's just to cast doubt on someone random from the thread. Of course not mentioning the unfounded vote on austin...which to be honest is more of a null tell than scum tell since I can't really see much benefit to do so as scum, other than the usual "create chaos/wifom" strategy. He doesn't come in to post his thoughts on any current discussion, nor to be part of any discussion/etc. That's what townies usually do, to try to establish a nice town atmosphere, get info, and establish their innocence. Reminds me of JingleHell's first posts in Aperture Mafia 2 (where he was scum and i called him out for basically the same thing). There's not much about debears other than a "derp" start, so let's just wait and see what he does when he comes back.
and not the one above my original. In fact I haven't even read that one yet :3
|
Hmm, it seems funny to me that SO many people "voted" in this thread, yet there are like only 3 votes in the voting thread :/
This applies to Clarity, JieXian and others who put "##Vote: xxx" in here.
Is it that hard to find the Voting thread in the main page?
|
Well...it seems i have the habit of posting here when nobody else is around to respond back (or post about other things) so I like quadriple post lol
.....maybe I'm doing that intentionally as scum! :O :O >_>
|
On January 21 2013 05:53 gonzaw wrote:
Well...it seems i have the habit of posting here when nobody else is around to respond back (or post about other things) so I like quadriple post lol
.....maybe I'm doing that intentionally as scum! :O :O >_>
has something to do with the fact that I try to consolidate my posts because I've been told I'm a mess when posting while you don't give a crap about that and just keep on going full LI on us with 10515816ß16apm while we're (I'm assuming there's more than just me here) still reading.
Chill down a bit, take your time and check back in in 30 minutes or something like that. As much as I want to read more from people I don't want you to to post more than you're already doing.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
