Acme Mini Mafia, Inc - Page 66

On November 08 2012 13:10 Release wrote:
On a day on which no one dies, occam's razor says that those who have kill roles will not claim to be RBed. It would lead to that line of reasoning ,"no one dead, this guy RBed, this guy has killing role"

On November 08 2012 13:26 mkfuba07 wrote:
I'm back. My vote was up in the air in the beginning, because I was pondering over possibly voting kush. I'll stick with draz for now, since now that I've got confirmation bias out of my system, I can't confirm my theory until one of them flips.

##Vote drazak

@Release: I think it's likely that someone with a kp who was roleblocked would be more inclined to report it, because then there's a roleblocker out there who knows you haven't told the truth.

But on that note, the fact that you appear to have not thought of that makes me think you're town.

Edit: saw I was ninja'd. Wanted to comment anyway.

On November 08 2012 08:19 Acrofales wrote:
Yo Kush, what do you think of the newly claimed roles?

I have a sneaking suspicion it's Innocent Wabbit. It just feels more bugsy.

Yo risk, are you scum?

On November 08 2012 20:43 kushm4sta wrote:
i guess
nice bus dp

##unvote
##vote drazek

On November 08 2012 12:37 Acrofales wrote:

Ok, convince me. Make a case on Kush that explains some of the following.

Kush is an extremely unlikely SK. I tried making a case for him and couldn't. The problem is that voting behaviour. It's not something an SK would do. SKs don't pull stupid voting shenanigans, because they don't give a crap about the lynch, as long as it's not their head on the line. Do you feel lime that was all an elaborate act? To what purpose? Is kush even the kind of player who can pull that off? Imho you have to be Ace to even come up with that kinda stuff, let alone pull it off convincingly. And then, what's it all for?

Kush is also unlikely scum. We already had the green check. We now have a roleblock claim. As far as I can see, the only way of this happening is if scum deliberately didn't roleblock (or roleblocked Prom) and took advantage of the missing block to claim RB'd themselves. Two problems here:

The first is that the claim doeqsn't feel like a lie. It has frivolous details like the "I got a PM". That is too much effort for a lie: It describes a process. People lieing don't imagine the full scenario, just the relevant stuff, which would be "I was RB'd", without the extras.

The second is that Kush already has the green check AND he claimed VT. Why have him claim RB'd, rather than his scumbuddy?

This together makes him unlikely scum, but if we find a framer, I will reconsider this second part.