Newbie Mini Mafia XXIX - Page 15

On October 25 2012 17:40 Inigmaticalism wrote:
I personally feel like Rad has explained himself in a decent (although strange) way, and am concerned when it seems like debears is trying to shove a sword through Rads monitor to clear up opinions on policy issues. And as for the scum hunting, you and him have done pretty much the same amount given the few hours the games been running, and more than most everyone else (including me). I say get him to clear up his stances better and then get everyone else to talk, and then come back and see if he follows through on what he says. If Rad can't explain himself, Ill be more willing to actually vote for him.

Also, I found Mr. Cheesecakes to be interesting. No town or scum tell; I just want to read more of your posts.

On October 25 2012 22:10 sylverfyre wrote:
@ Dandel Ion - you've basically said something anti-policy and pro-policy at the same time. What?

How exactly does opposing Lynch a Lurker policy give off a town read? For me it gives off a 0.1% scum read to oppose a reasonable, but not infallible, Day 1 strategy. And if we get to the end of the day and there are still people who have only made the minimal of posts despite people accusing them (example: Roco if we were close to lynch time), then I think that's a perfectly solid lynch candidate.

On October 25 2012 18:40 Djodref wrote:


I don't know already if you are town or not. I've spoken too fast because I was thinking of our last game where you were town. It was a slip, but not a scumslip

Regarding Roco, I understand your hunch but he reminds me your first weird posts last game. He is suspicious but he doesn't deserve red bold font yet imo ^^

On October 25 2012 22:15 sylverfyre wrote:
Let me also be clear: Opposing a policy and opposing the specific instance of a policy being enacted are two entirely different things. Just because I'm not opposed to Lynch a Lurker doesn't mean I think we should invoke it automatically. But if we were closer to lynch time, and Ini and Roco still only had the posts they have... I'd vote for one of them. By not responding adequately to accusations made against you, you give the town very little to work with.

I don't really agree with debears vote on rad, but I think debears is playing an aggressive game, which is clean to me.

On October 25 2012 22:43 Djodref wrote:
As for now, the only guy I would like to lynch right now is Inig.

On October 25 2012 22:48 Dandel Ion wrote:

On what do you base that?
All I see is he made no contributions. So did other people. Some didn't even post yet.

If it's what he said, why do you see him as scummier than Roco?
Because I don't, so I'd like to know where this is coming from.

On October 25 2012 21:43 Mr. Cheesecake wrote:
Just woke up fella's, have a few moments to read this over and give my thoughts. In the name of brevity, I'll keep it short.

On Debears-Rad incident: Debears came out of the gate swinging; reminiscent of DP from the last newbie game. Personally, I don't like this style of hot-headed pursuit, but it can work. However, I feel the reasons he's giving for Rad being suspicious are ill-founded. There is all this talk of confidence and policy lynching, and everything seems to be a matter of personal opinion rather than a role shining through to the exterior. There may be something there in what Debears has concluded, but I cannot be sure of my opinion of Rad at this time. I'd much rather vote for a lurker atm because the evidence is just not there.

Djodref: I find him to be exceedingly odd. I first thought his initial comment of my "serious policy lynching" to be weird, but with his recent two posts I find him suspicous.



How do you know he's town???


Why would you specifically ask someone about them being mafia. What do you hope to accomplish??? I find these two statements to be suspicious as hell.

##FOS Djodref

I'll be back in about 6 hours, after my classes.

On October 25 2012 19:25 Dandel Ion wrote:

Please explain this statement.
Why would he 'know' you to be town from his role??

On October 25 2012 22:52 Djodref wrote:


@Cheese

Calling daoud town was a slip, I've already explained it.
Regarding you and your "serious policy lynching", I have asked you a question and your answer satisfied me. I don't think you are 100% for a policy lynch anymore. I misinterpreted your post.
Regarding my question "are you mafia?", this is a very uncomfortable question to ask to a mafia player, believe me or not. They have to lie to answer such a question and this is the best way to pressure them imo. So I want to see Roco reaction to this question.
I'm not expecting him to admit that he is mafia. I'm going to gauge his reaction to this question in comparison to my own experience as a mafia player.

On October 25 2012 22:48 Dandel Ion wrote:

On what do you base that?
All I see is he made no contributions. So did other people. Some didn't even post yet.

If it's what he said, why do you see him as scummier than Roco?
Because I don't, so I'd like to know where this is coming from.

On October 25 2012 22:59 Dandel Ion wrote:

Uuuuh
Not really.
You just hear "no" as an answer. That's the 'correct' answer for both alignments. I'd imagine you won't be able to interpret much out of those 2 letters.

I know in a post yesterday I semi-seriously pressured Roco to answer that same question, but as I just said, semi-seriously. You seem to really think that's a good strategy, lol.

On October 25 2012 22:59 Dandel Ion wrote:

Uuuuh
Not really.
You just say "no" as an answer. That's the 'correct' answer for both alignments. I'd imagine you won't be able to interpret much out of those 2 letters.

I know in a post yesterday I semi-seriously pressured Roco to answer that same question, but as I just said, semi-seriously. You seem to really think that's a good strategy, lol.

On October 25 2012 23:04 debears wrote:
@djo

But why did you use the wording "I expect you to do your job as town". That statement implies that you know he is town. Theres no wishy washness or "if your town". That's why its very weird

And daud (sry I'm calling you that now). Using logic involving a sk at this point is not good logic.

1) a seri killer wouldnt know if you are town while mafia would.
2) we don't have any idea whether there is a sk. Its best to not worry about it unless there are a pair of nks on any night