EPTLiquid City Mafia - Page 21
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Mementoss
Canada2595 Posts
| ||
|
risk.nuke
Sweden2825 Posts
I never said I thought shady was scummy in the thread. Nor did I claim to have had. So how can you say I'm lying. I stated that I was suspicious of him and I was. I give reasoning for the rest of my actions which I sincerely wonder if you've even read. But your case isn't that you have a problem with my reasoning. You just straight out attempt to misinterpret it to the thread. I said I thought kush was scummier now then then which to me translates into. Kush has done absolutely nothing to redeem himself of my suspicions. On the contrary the posts he's made has only made me more suspicious. But no fucking where do I say that he's my strongest scumread. Leaving out the name calling generalizations of my posts. These are your only 2 actual points against me which are both fucking untrue. And don't think you can claim coming in late bringing not one but three new names to the table and expected it to generate anything but distraction from the other candidates. | ||
|
BloodyC0bbler
Canada7875 Posts
On October 02 2012 07:31 Mementoss wrote: Im going to placeholder vote on shadysands, and then wash the dishes then read the game,so many lurkers (me included) day 1. I'll see what I can dig up tho. I find votes on ones self or votes on someone not likely to be lynched the best placeholders as you don't look like someone jumping onto a bandwagon for the sake of it being a bandwagon | ||
|
Sharrant
Canada543 Posts
I was at work like I said I would be. I did have to cover for someone for an extra hour, that's why I was late getting on here. In response to your earlier question, on Saturday I worked all day, then went to another city for Nuit Blanche, then came back to work despite not having slept because my boss asked me if I could cover for someone who was sick. After that it was Sunday night, I saw that I had a PM, saw it was about this game, and was way too fucking tired to do anything. So I set my alarm early to give myself time to make one decent post in the morning before work. Unfortunately I was so rushed I forgot to actually follow with my vote, and I felt really stupid about halfway into work. I'm a little surprised no one called me out on it. I'm just going to post this part now, the rest will follow in a little bit. Just reading through filters. | ||
|
BloodyC0bbler
Canada7875 Posts
On October 02 2012 07:35 risk.nuke wrote: It's forced because it screams I need to make up a post about someone fast. That's the only possible reason you typed up a shitpost like that. You can't even have had time to properly read through it. And if you did read through it you must have once again felt forced or you would had deleted that shit. I never said I thought shady was scummy in the thread. Nor did I claim to have had. So how can you say I'm lying. I stated that I was suspicious of him and I was. I give reasoning for the rest of my actions which I sincerely wonder if you've even read. But your case isn't that you have a problem with my reasoning. You just straight out attempt to misinterpret it to the thread. I said I thought kush was scummier now then then which to me translates into. Kush has done absolutely nothing to redeem himself of my suspicions. On the contrary the posts he's made has only made me more suspicious. But no fucking where do I say that he's my strongest scumread. Leaving out the name calling generalizations of my posts. These are your only 2 actual points against me which are both fucking untrue. And don't think you can claim coming in late bringing not one but three new names to the table and expected it to generate anything but distraction from the other candidates. I voted for shady because it's down to him versus KingJames. Additionally I agreed and considered Shady being scummy even as I suggested the kush lynch. Those are your exact words you said about shady, yet you never once said you had suspicions of him being mafia. This is a lie. Regardless of big or small it is one. Now, if hes not your strongest scumread, or one of them why the fuck wouldn't you attempt to push him? Why even now, rather than combined defending yourself are you not analyzing kush, why are you not analyzing anyone? As for coming in late and expect to generate anything but distraction? i have discussed them plus the three I named. Only two of which I believe could be lynched today / have far higher a likelyhood of flipping red. If you would look past your understandable annoyance at me for calling you out, you would surely see that the last few pages has at least generated some meaningful discussion that was on new subject matter, and honestly to some degree required. | ||
|
BloodyC0bbler
Canada7875 Posts
On October 02 2012 07:39 Sharrant wrote: @Risk.Nuke I was at work like I said I would be. I did have to cover for someone for an extra hour, that's why I was late getting on here. In response to your earlier question, on Saturday I worked all day, then went to another city for Nuit Blanche, then came back to work despite not having slept because my boss asked me if I could cover for someone who was sick. After that it was Sunday night, I saw that I had a PM, saw it was about this game, and was way too fucking tired to do anything. So I set my alarm early to give myself time to make one decent post in the morning before work. Unfortunately I was so rushed I forgot to actually follow with my vote, and I felt really stupid about halfway into work. I'm a little surprised no one called me out on it. I'm just going to post this part now, the rest will follow in a little bit. Just reading through filters. you have about 1.5 hours to start contributing before you become a person to harass. | ||
|
mkfuba07
United States1151 Posts
On October 01 2012 00:29 austinmcc wrote: Man I missed a fun night. Maybe I need to read some past games of kush's, but this didn't seem as scummy to me as it does to others. Poor reason to vote, sure, but he could have just voted based on "wtf is shady doing/I don't buy this" and not looked odd. Don't see any reason to make himself this visible as scum with a sillyvote when a real explanation is easily at hand. + Show Spoiler + I think we should lynch BM24... On September 29 2012 10:37 BlackMamba24 wrote: game will start with a 24 hr night 0 by the way You'd think that since it was such a "fun night" he would have a lot to comment on, but for over 24 hours all he mentions is how something kush has said isn't as scummy as some people apparently find it. After that he gets trapped in spy-slip land, when that issue can be resolved by reading the OP. He's posted a lot (comparatively) and yet has said little except that he didn't find kush too scummy hours ago. Not sure if scummy or just busy+confused... | ||
|
risk.nuke
Sweden2825 Posts
On October 02 2012 07:39 Sharrant wrote: @Risk.Nuke I was at work like I said I would be. I did have to cover for someone for an extra hour, that's why I was late getting on here. In response to your earlier question, on Saturday I worked all day, then went to another city for Nuit Blanche, then came back to work despite not having slept because my boss asked me if I could cover for someone who was sick. After that it was Sunday night, I saw that I had a PM, saw it was about this game, and was way too fucking tired to do anything. So I set my alarm early to give myself time to make one decent post in the morning before work. Unfortunately I was so rushed I forgot to actually follow with my vote, and I felt really stupid about halfway into work. I'm a little surprised no one called me out on it. I'm just going to post this part now, the rest will follow in a little bit. Just reading through filters. Nope, don't buy it. The guy clearly had insight in what's going on so I'm making the assumption that he's been following the thread. And when a player lurk hard with that kind of first and only post I'm getting pretty damn suspicious he's discussing the game elsewhere. | ||
|
risk.nuke
Sweden2825 Posts
You want to be usefull. Who would you vote for amongst the people with votes. | ||
|
Kreb
4834 Posts
On October 02 2012 07:47 risk.nuke wrote: Nope, don't buy it. The guy clearly had insight in what's going on so I'm making the assumption that he's been following the thread. And when a player lurk hard with that kind of first and only post I'm getting pretty damn suspicious he's discussing the game elsewhere. Are you suggesting a Sharrant vote? Despite you having said you have scum reads on Kush and Shady you still havent voted. Or are you still determined to vote one of those two? | ||
|
kushm4sta
United States8878 Posts
why would you call someone scumshit...they didn't choose to roll scum and you don't have to insult them for it. | ||
|
risk.nuke
Sweden2825 Posts
| ||
|
mkfuba07
United States1151 Posts
| ||
|
risk.nuke
Sweden2825 Posts
On October 02 2012 08:07 kushm4sta wrote: risk is usually like this? why would you call someone scumshit...they didn't choose to roll scum and you don't have to insult them for it. because scum are evil and mafia games gets emotional. | ||
|
Risen
United States7927 Posts
On October 02 2012 07:23 kushm4sta wrote: Um I don't get what is so scummy about austin. He gets hung up on spies. He drops it when an explanation is given. He brings it up again only when someone asks him about it. Can we lynch Risen instead? Wat? | ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36156 Posts
Like, see how he's been posting in that other game he's in and not this one? Not caring about this one? Yeah, scummy as shit, except he did the same thing in rock band as town. | ||
|
Mattchew
United States5684 Posts
also, I could get down with an austin lynch. he doesn't feel like he is hunting scum as much as he is hunting for an easy out to vote. I am willing to ##unvote for the meantime. I am caught up on the thread but don't actually understand some of the arguments. | ||
|
risk.nuke
Sweden2825 Posts
On October 02 2012 08:10 mkfuba07 wrote: How do you feel about austin, risk? I don't know and I'm not planning to go over him tonight. | ||
|
BloodyC0bbler
Canada7875 Posts
On October 02 2012 07:55 risk.nuke wrote: BC not posting my suspicion doesn't mean I didn't have them. It means I can't prove I had them. It's not the same as a small lie which I don't believe for a second you don't understand. You want to be usefull. Who would you vote for amongst the people with votes. understand yes, hell everyone does it without realizing. Not admitting to it once called out looks bad. As for who would I vote for of all the people with votes? mementoss. Hes not even going to get lynched though. Given your reaction I would prefer an austin lynch at this moment however. | ||
|
Kreb
4834 Posts
The case by Talis on VE would seem much stronger had more people jumped in and backed it up he played like his scum-meta. But that didnt happen, rather the opposite. And considering I've got no meta information at all myself on VE I cant really comment on the case itself. But it really doesnt seem to take off, so I have no reason to look at this any further. Then we have BC pointing towards austin and risk. Out of those I'm currently thinking austin over risk. The reason being that risk came into the thread with a very agressive, insulting hard-defense of kingjames. First of all it seems a bit wierd for a mafia to come into a thread with that attitude. But his kind of agressive/insulting posting style has continued which at least to me makes it look genuine and not some kind of forced mafia stunt. Also we have this comment by sloosh: At the same time he [risk.nuke] can be totally lazy so you have to wait for him to generate content then evaluate what he brings. And lazy was pretty much exactly the word I called him when he decided to go for only Shady/Kush in the beginning rather than pushing any read himself. Not saying I have a town read on risk, but less of a scum read than austin. Austin on the other hand indeed had a pretty bad reason to vote for KJ. And his obsession with the spy comment seem a bit..... out of place. Cant say Im feeling super convinced about this either considering how early it is into the game and the length of peoples filters, but meh, gotta place my vote somewhere. As such: ##Vote austinmcc I'll be around for ~20 more min before going to sleep, not expecting something to happen but leaving the possibility open. | ||
| ||
