"Bluelightz is helpful! He's probably scum! Like in Sum of all Fears Mafia! It's not normal isn't it?! He's scum!"

Even then when I DO try and do it people still insist I'm scum, I break down when people just blob into me.

Bluelightz

Indonesia2463 Posts

September 24 2012 15:37 GMT

#1606

On September 25 2012 00:26 HiroPro wrote:
Ok guys. I seriously don't understand what you're doing. I made a great case and none of you are actually reading it.

Let me put it this way to you. Serial killers have 1 KP. Mafia teams have 1 KP. How many people do you need to kill in order to get rid of the serial killer? Only 1. How many people do you need to kill in order to get rid of mafia? 2.

SO WHY ARE WE NOT KILLING THE SERIAL KILLER MARV!!!

My summary of your case is:

VE coached Marv!

VE had 17 pages of filter as a SK!

Marv had 16 pages here!

They're same!

THEY ARE BOTH SK K?

Don't think that'll convince me.....

Bluelightz

Indonesia2463 Posts

September 24 2012 15:39 GMT

#1608

On September 25 2012 00:39 HiroPro wrote:
Let me add to the list of antitown things marv has done:

- Shut down discussion on himself
- Called people bad without saying they were scum
- Spammed unnecessarily to make himself look town
- No Pictures
- Lots of lists (not like this one, useless stuff)

How's that as a scummy trait Mr.I think your scum but You think your town?

Bluelightz

Indonesia2463 Posts

September 25 2012 15:46 GMT

#1651

On September 25 2012 22:31 Ange777 wrote:
@Bluelightz: So who would be your final scum pick?

Either you or iamP, but I haven't read on iamP yet though.

Bluelightz

Indonesia2463 Posts

September 25 2012 15:52 GMT

#1654

Ange's interaction with HiroPro is rather lacking:

On September 19 2012 01:04 Ange777 wrote:

Show nested quote +

Because? Can't you give a reason when you are suddenly stating town or scum reads?

On September 22 2012 08:37 Ange777 wrote:

Show nested quote +

What?

On September 25 2012 00:05 Ange777 wrote:

Show nested quote +

I should be available and more active in the next days.

Hiro

I could only repeat what has been mentioned by others. No contribution and clear trolling should be more than enough to prove that he is scum. ##: Vote HiroPro

iamperfection

I had a strong scum read on him. Don't think I need to repeat why. The reasons were elaborated more than once. I'm not so sure anymore. His posting is much better than at the start of the game, more open in his thought process. I am leaning null on him right now.

Bluelightz

I seriously don't know how to read bluelightz. While you are free to call my filter small, his is really tiny. It's hard to imagine someone signing up for a game and lurking all the way so that he has a 1 page filter at day3. My problem with it is that I could not read him in GSL as well. Still Scummy.

Mementoss

I am not sold on his town-alignment. I really didn't like the way he nitpicked my filter and tried to accuse me of scummy behaviour when he himself did the exact same thing. I have not read anything that made me think he's townie yet.

On September 25 2012 00:31 Ange777 wrote:

Show nested quote +

Ok, while I don't believe marv to be the serial killer, the logic seems sound. Am I missing something why we should kill scum first before serial killer if we were equally sure/suspicious of them?

They contain only questions, a sheep vote with nothing new to add, and.... that's it. I find this rather scummy (If HiroPro flips scum though, if he flips town this is all irrelevant).

Bluelightz

Indonesia2463 Posts

September 26 2012 12:30 GMT

#1685

On September 26 2012 07:22 Hapahauli wrote:
For everyone not-confirmed town (Ange777, Zephirdd, iamperfection, Bluelightz), make sure you post your reads on each of the other players. The more open you are, the better chance we'll have of nailing the last scum tomorrow.

My reads are:

Ange - Probably last scum because of his 'lack' of interaction with Hiro before the day Hiro got lynched, his sheep vote on Hiro with no additional explanation or why did he believe the reason's other people pointed out.
Everyone else - Town.

Bluelightz

Indonesia2463 Posts

September 26 2012 15:01 GMT

#1700

Zeph, if your basing your scum read on me by process of elimination and meta, could you explain more why Ange, the person being shit on is town, while me, that at least has provided more content my GSL Open me is scum?

"Yes, but my feel with an ange lynch is that the same that happened with bluelightz on GSL will happen here. I don't want to open the thread and see that I lost because he was the scum."

If you think we are going on the wrong way, please argue why Ange is town, and why I must be scum (except process of elimination, I atleast provided some points on Ange).