Bang Bang Mafia 2

On June 14 2012 20:58 supersoft wrote:
claim

On June 14 2012 23:27 rastaban wrote:

Don't claim, we don't have any info on you yet though. I would love if you would look over the cases against Zentor and Ceph and give your thoughts and any reads you have coming in fresh. You just subbed in so I know you need time to catch up so start with the current cases if you can and then let us know your thoughts in general on how things are playing out. Were you following before you subbed in? How do you think town should proceed?

On June 15 2012 03:47 Meapak_Ziphh wrote:

I agree that zentor may be an "easy case" but why does that make him a bad lynch?

As I've stated before, I think payl needs to die as well, I just don't want to see people making excuses like this about zentor.

On June 15 2012 03:56 marvellosity wrote:


This wasn't the point, the post was about payl.

On June 15 2012 06:44 supersoft wrote:


Do you have a gun or not?

On June 15 2012 20:11 supersoft wrote:
Zentor is town. You point out bad play. none of this is a scumtell. How could allow Ace that you take WBGs spot.



not necessary if you keep up this play :-(



oh boy please... are you scum or what?

On June 15 2012 22:09 supersoft wrote:


Who is GF if he isn't

On June 16 2012 02:47 Toadesstern wrote:
What happened yesterday:

1. Supersoft asks me what I think about Talis
   
2. I say he is suspicious and scummy
   
3. Supersoft quotes a post from PYP that was done PREGAME, aka before alignments were out
   
4. I tell him "dude, Talis is super scummy but that is the only post in talis filter that isn't scummy because it's a PREgame post, aka it's not alignment indicating because he didn't even have an alignment back then. You can't take that as a reason to consider him scummy although he is scummy for every other post in his filter"
   
5. Supersoft says we should not lynch Zentor / Payl because I am GF bussing Payl and Talis, which apparently makes Payl an incredible bad target for whatever reason and therefore he shoots Talis instead of Payl or me
   
6. I am therefore mafia because I agreed with his read on Talis, just not with his reasoning because he quoted a pregame post and because I am bussing Payl.

Am I really the only one who fails to understand the logic here?
Also so far noone (except for Zentor who did the most ridiculous "case" I've ever seen) explained why I am mafia. Well and Supersoft said I am GF because I think Talis and Payl are mafia, because that's clearly the reasonable explanation here.

On June 16 2012 05:18 Toadesstern wrote:

probably the fact that I am kind of assuming I am mafia in that post to show how it's not making sense?

On June 16 2012 06:14 layabout wrote:
Well i think Toad is making sense.

Zealos can you put the red text aside and give an explanation that relies on more than just a "Vague feeling of oddness"?

On June 17 2012 02:26 Meapak_Ziphh wrote:

No you're not -_-

People need to take a step back for a second, if you kill me you're basically shooting me for the same reasons I shot supersoft, I was scared he was the gf and was gonna get away clean.

I understand you're pissed but let's not let that get in the way of the game. Supersoft gave us a scum list, let's start shooting down that.

Also could someone summarize exactly why I'm scum? All I see is a couple people shouting "gf" and the thread sheeping along.