Magic: The Gathering Mini Mafia - Page 32

On May 22 2012 04:22 wherebugsgo wrote:
I'm cool with killing nova, since he seems to want to extend joke accusations into real ones for no particular reason. He also isn't using his brain; case in point, this post:



Navillus, if I remember correctly, said he wanted to kill me (whether seriously or not, who cares)

Nova seemingly wants to jump on any person who is getting traction for a lynch. Namely, since I was gone and Navillus voted me, I was a good choice. Note how Nova never once mentions me before this post. He addresses my posts but expressly avoids saying that he finds my advice post indicative of me being scum or anything like that when I react.

On the other hand, people have found Navillus suspicious for his not-so-serious vote on me. While it is a bit suspicious in itself, I find it more suspicious that plenty of people are so willing to kill him based on almost nothing at all. One of those players is nova.

On May 22 2012 05:09 wherebugsgo wrote:
Nova subscribes to the notion that if you accuse everyone in the game, any accusation against him is OMGUS.

If you're town, stop being disruptive and start using your head. Otherwise, you die today.

##vote Nova_Terra

On May 23 2012 04:52 wherebugsgo wrote:
Sorry all, I became really sick overnight. Feeling quite a bit better now, though.

I'm fine with killing Katina, VE, and mold man, in that order.

Katina normally reads the thread and she usually has more than one read. She also at the very least explains herself to townies. It's clear that she's deliberately ignoring my questions, possibly because she doesn't actually believe in her "case" on Nova (i.e she is scum)

By the time I asked Katina the first time how sure she was of Nova being scum I had started to think he was town. Now, it is day 1, and I may be completely wrong about my assessment, but the way the bandwagons have gone today suggest either that both nova and mouldy are town or that one of them is scum. Based on the nova votes just now I'm inclined to think mouldy is scum.

Of course, we'll never know the truth unless they flip. As there's not much time left in the day I think we should kill mouldy.

If anyone else agrees with me that we should kill Katina or VE, let me know and perhaps we can get a vote switch going. I'll be around till deadline.

##unvote
##vote Mouldy Jeb

PS. Anyone notice that Katina says she hates people using the noob card, but hasn't really expressed suspicion of mouldy? (at least, from what I recall)

On May 23 2012 05:12 wherebugsgo wrote:
Katina do you think that a newer scum would post as much as nova has?

On May 22 2012 04:49 Nova_Terra wrote:
I follow guilty until proven innocent
WBG only posted general advice which shouldnt count for crap, defense of said general advice, and half omgus

On May 22 2012 04:22 wherebugsgo wrote:
I'm cool with killing nova, since he seems to want to extend joke accusations into real ones for no particular reason. He also isn't using his brain; case in point, this post:



Navillus, if I remember correctly, said he wanted to kill me (whether seriously or not, who cares)

Nova seemingly wants to jump on any person who is getting traction for a lynch. Namely, since I was gone and Navillus voted me, I was a good choice. Note how Nova never once mentions me before this post. He addresses my posts but expressly avoids saying that he finds my advice post indicative of me being scum or anything like that when I react.

On the other hand, people have found Navillus suspicious for his not-so-serious vote on me. While it is a bit suspicious in itself, I find it more suspicious that plenty of people are so willing to kill him based on almost nothing at all. One of those players is nova.

On May 22 2012 05:09 wherebugsgo wrote:
Nova subscribes to the notion that if you accuse everyone in the game, any accusation against him is OMGUS.

If you're town, stop being disruptive and start using your head. Otherwise, you die today.

##vote Nova_Terra

On May 23 2012 04:52 wherebugsgo wrote:
Sorry all, I became really sick overnight. Feeling quite a bit better now, though.

I'm fine with killing Katina, VE, and mold man, in that order.

Katina normally reads the thread and she usually has more than one read. She also at the very least explains herself to townies. It's clear that she's deliberately ignoring my questions, possibly because she doesn't actually believe in her "case" on Nova (i.e she is scum)

By the time I asked Katina the first time how sure she was of Nova being scum I had started to think he was town. Now, it is day 1, and I may be completely wrong about my assessment, but the way the bandwagons have gone today suggest either that both nova and mouldy are town or that one of them is scum. Based on the nova votes just now I'm inclined to think mouldy is scum.

Of course, we'll never know the truth unless they flip. As there's not much time left in the day I think we should kill mouldy.

If anyone else agrees with me that we should kill Katina or VE, let me know and perhaps we can get a vote switch going. I'll be around till deadline.

##unvote
##vote Mouldy Jeb

PS. Anyone notice that Katina says she hates people using the noob card, but hasn't really expressed suspicion of mouldy? (at least, from what I recall)

On May 24 2012 01:15 wherebugsgo wrote:
If I had a gun, I'd shoot zealos or Tunkeg.

Probably flip a coin really, they're both obviously faking trying to look town.

On May 24 2012 06:56 wherebugsgo wrote:
Having reread everything there isn't much to say...if I live, then we go from there. If I die, then I'll be glad not to have to read/decipher some of the posts from this game.

Zealos and Tunkeg are still good bets to flip scum IMO. Mattchew and Nova are annoying, which could mean anything. VE is sheeping more than normal, which is somewhat scummy. Katina's hard to read but if she's even somewhat transparent and correct about some of her reads then probably isn't scum.

I can't even remember half the names of the rest of you, since you're so unimpressionable. Great if you're scum and obviously terrible if you're town.

On May 24 2012 17:44 wherebugsgo wrote:
Is he gone?

<peeks around a corner>

Anyway if Acid never responds, we kill him.

To make that threat more real, let's turn up the heat.

##vote Acid~

Nova, do you support a lynch of any of Acid, zealos, or Tunkeg?

On May 24 2012 15:50 VisceraEyes wrote:
Guys, this is in the bag. bugs, Nova, bang, bang. Half the scum dead. This is really happening, 2 scum down. We just have to make them die.

Join me.

On May 24 2012 16:26 Nova_Terra wrote:
In fact, i would prefer a Katina lynch

On May 24 2012 14:51 Navillus wrote:

Acid~

My biggest scum-read right now is in fact Acid. Looking through his posts the first thing that jumps out is simply lurking. He has been lurking this entire game, with few posts, even fewer posts of any significant length by him, and even fewer posts in which he is directly addressing or responding to others, something scum love as they get to look like they're making content without ever calling anyone out or putting themselves in a situation where they might get directly called out.

In a similar vein what content he has had has been the same in almost every single post, him tunneling acro/marvel. This tunneling began at the start of the game and hasn't abated, this is very big as it means that he gets to look like he's giving reads the whole time while he's really just repeating the same thing, this thing that also hasn't been the main topic of discussion so he never would end up in the spotlight. The biggest issue in this whole tunneling spree is that then at the end of day one the vote is between NT and Mouldy, Acid had expressed that he thought that NT and Marvel were scumbuddies yet when it's clear that a marvel lynch isn't going to happen and when NT is on the table he doesn't even attempt to move the vote. No he sits content to leave his vote somewhere where it can't do ANYTHING, washing him of any possible guilt for a mislynch of either candidate.

And looking at his most recent post and one of the only posts of his with any reads that aren't marv/NT (maybe the ONLY post) he goes for literally the easiest reads possible, a couple of lurkers who he gives one line on about them lurking and ONE of WBG/VE because it would be too much work to even decide between that.

Finally as if this all wasn't enough,

after looking through Acid's stuff and concluding much of this, I also looked at ET's filter as promised and found something very interesting. Our resident just-killed townie's largest (Okay maybe second largest) post was an accusation of the one and only Acid. Now this post was a night-time accusation so it didn't draw much attention (if it had I suspect ET would be alive right now) which meant that if say, he had been correct and accused scum they would feel okay shooting him for it as no one really noticed the accusation.

I mean look at why ET was killed,

he seemed town and was playing well as far as I can tell and those very probably contributed to his death

but vets are viewed very highly in these games, so much that it's surprising that both of them are alive even by day two, it's strange that the scum didn't shoot one of the two people who as scumhunters would presumably be their biggest threats,

and one thing that could very much have influenced this choice is if someone else who was playing well also hit on a scum with a good case.

Thus - ##Vote Acid~ QED