EPTOn May 13 2012 03:47 Acrofales wrote:
No. You should go read my case and respond to it. I'll even give you a clicky here.
Show nested quote +
On May 13 2012 03:45 A.T.L.A.S. wrote:
His case on my is that I don't care what others think, which is a town trait. Is this your reasoning too?
Bravo my good sir
On May 13 2012 03:43 Acrofales wrote:
No. It's because this:
+ Show Spoiler [Maju's saving grace] +
This reads like a sincere nooby town reason for marrying Mattchew, which, btw, would be a really dumb thing to do as scum if Mattchew is town.
He is also starting to play, unlike plenty of other people in this game and I am actually uncomfortable lynching someone I feel has a good chance of being town and is actually trying to play this game.
You are trying to play this game, but are scum. You will die by my personal royal decree. I've never beheaded a robot before, it sounds like fun.
On May 13 2012 03:37 A.T.L.A.S. wrote:
He sounds worth a second chance just because he made small cases on 5 people, and then voted one, unvoted immediatly, and then voted another?
On May 13 2012 03:32 Acrofales wrote:
Fuck. Maju is starting to sound worth a second chance.
How about we lynch Erandorr, Jitsu or Mr.Potatohead instead?
Fuck. Maju is starting to sound worth a second chance.
How about we lynch Erandorr, Jitsu or Mr.Potatohead instead?
He sounds worth a second chance just because he made small cases on 5 people, and then voted one, unvoted immediatly, and then voted another?
No. It's because this:
+ Show Spoiler [Maju's saving grace] +
On May 13 2012 03:24 MajuGarzett wrote:
I think most of my ideas on potato were fairly novel though I suppose I may have missed similar stuff with the amount of posting going on.
I'm inclined to agree with a lynch on ATLAS though I would rather have it be potato as one of your emperor lynches. One concerning post of ATLAS is particular is
He is trying to get inactive players lynched before possible scum. While in this case it wouldn't matter as I am not scum, the idea that we should be leaving scum to murder and do as they please is not good play and would certainly no be helpful to town.
His vote for BL with a lack of consideration of any other options is also disconcerting. Overall I think ATLAS is quite a reasonable lynch choice.
I'm having a hard time reading Jitsu. His most recent post was good but other than that he's had little contribution after the start of day one. As of now I would not lynch him as I think candidates such as potato and BL have more inditing evidence.
Mattchew has been town like in making attempts to find mafia though I dislike the fact that he has never taken the time to put together a single cohesive post on a candidate. It has all been shorter accusations like he's just trying to add evidence to his cases as he goes along instead of actually being very sure with the initial accusation. There seems to be a pattern of him accusing someone in a one line post and later manufacturing something to support his claim. I think he is scummy but once again I have stronger suspicions. On marrying Mattchew, I could see no disadvantages to it and if he somehow dies before me I would get his duke powers. Also, being able to have open discussion with one of my earliest accusers could be useful if I think I won't be able to change the mind of the general populous. If I managed to get one of the first people who started to accuse me to change their mind others might follow. As of now I haven't tried this since I still hope to change the minds of players by my own posting.
Acro and Carolus to me have been quite open with their reads and have had more structured ideas than those of Mattchew and I believe they are town.
I have to go out places so I might not be able to answer questions for a few hours.
Show nested quote +
On May 13 2012 01:59 Acrofales wrote:
@Mattchew: I would like to see you respond to Bluelightz's case. Your filter IS a load of baseless accusations. The only real case you have built is the one bluelightz which is still failing to convince me.
Also, I clearly disagree with your plan to let Maju off the hook and lynch bluelightz, because I disagree with a bluelightz lynch. If you decide to lynch ATLAS or Jitsu, I will be totally on board with the switch.
@Maju: I have a large "the usual suspects" feel with your post. Not that the usual suspects are bad, just that you are not really bringing anything new to the table. That is a tough spot to be in as town, but I DO need more to let you off the hook.
What do you think of my proposal to lynch ATLAS?
How about Jitsu?
What do you think of Mattchew and Carolus? What do you think of me?
@Mattchew: I would like to see you respond to Bluelightz's case. Your filter IS a load of baseless accusations. The only real case you have built is the one bluelightz which is still failing to convince me.
Also, I clearly disagree with your plan to let Maju off the hook and lynch bluelightz, because I disagree with a bluelightz lynch. If you decide to lynch ATLAS or Jitsu, I will be totally on board with the switch.
@Maju: I have a large "the usual suspects" feel with your post. Not that the usual suspects are bad, just that you are not really bringing anything new to the table. That is a tough spot to be in as town, but I DO need more to let you off the hook.
What do you think of my proposal to lynch ATLAS?
How about Jitsu?
What do you think of Mattchew and Carolus? What do you think of me?
I think most of my ideas on potato were fairly novel though I suppose I may have missed similar stuff with the amount of posting going on.
I'm inclined to agree with a lynch on ATLAS though I would rather have it be potato as one of your emperor lynches. One concerning post of ATLAS is particular is
Show nested quote +
On May 12 2012 01:17 A.T.L.A.S. wrote:
Oh im not worried, they certainly will get their dues
On May 12 2012 01:14 Acrofales wrote:
Don't worry. Inactives will get their due. I prefer to lynch a good scumlead over a random inactive.
On May 12 2012 00:52 A.T.L.A.S. wrote:
Is there a reason people are pusing a Maju lynch over all of the other inactives? From my breif look over I do see a whole lot of nothing, but why him over all of the others in the thread?
Is there a reason people are pusing a Maju lynch over all of the other inactives? From my breif look over I do see a whole lot of nothing, but why him over all of the others in the thread?
Don't worry. Inactives will get their due. I prefer to lynch a good scumlead over a random inactive.
Oh im not worried, they certainly will get their dues
He is trying to get inactive players lynched before possible scum. While in this case it wouldn't matter as I am not scum, the idea that we should be leaving scum to murder and do as they please is not good play and would certainly no be helpful to town.
His vote for BL with a lack of consideration of any other options is also disconcerting. Overall I think ATLAS is quite a reasonable lynch choice.
I'm having a hard time reading Jitsu. His most recent post was good but other than that he's had little contribution after the start of day one. As of now I would not lynch him as I think candidates such as potato and BL have more inditing evidence.
Mattchew has been town like in making attempts to find mafia though I dislike the fact that he has never taken the time to put together a single cohesive post on a candidate. It has all been shorter accusations like he's just trying to add evidence to his cases as he goes along instead of actually being very sure with the initial accusation. There seems to be a pattern of him accusing someone in a one line post and later manufacturing something to support his claim. I think he is scummy but once again I have stronger suspicions. On marrying Mattchew, I could see no disadvantages to it and if he somehow dies before me I would get his duke powers. Also, being able to have open discussion with one of my earliest accusers could be useful if I think I won't be able to change the mind of the general populous. If I managed to get one of the first people who started to accuse me to change their mind others might follow. As of now I haven't tried this since I still hope to change the minds of players by my own posting.
Acro and Carolus to me have been quite open with their reads and have had more structured ideas than those of Mattchew and I believe they are town.
I have to go out places so I might not be able to answer questions for a few hours.
This reads like a sincere nooby town reason for marrying Mattchew, which, btw, would be a really dumb thing to do as scum if Mattchew is town.
He is also starting to play, unlike plenty of other people in this game and I am actually uncomfortable lynching someone I feel has a good chance of being town and is actually trying to play this game.
You are trying to play this game, but are scum. You will die by my personal royal decree. I've never beheaded a robot before, it sounds like fun.
His case on my is that I don't care what others think, which is a town trait. Is this your reasoning too?
Bravo my good sir
No. You should go read my case and respond to it. I'll even give you a clicky here.
Oh ok. So your case on me is that I questioned a quickly growing bandwagon.
Also, i thought your main target was the companion cube. Care to enlighten me of what happened then?
