That being said I feel like I should have pushed harder for an NT lynch D1. Whatever criticisms i may have of him he DID do a good job of dodging the noose so far somehow without ever contributing

Blazinghand

United States25563 Posts

May 13 2012 19:31 GMT

#1362

NT if your really a townie, do what layabout did. Die with hobor. Make cases abd reads with your last moments alive-- if nothing else at least help us in your final moments.

Or just keep whining like the scum you are.

Your call brometheus

Blazinghand

United States25563 Posts

May 13 2012 19:32 GMT

#1363

By hobor i mean honor. Posting via phone so there you have it

Blazinghand

United States25563 Posts

May 13 2012 19:45 GMT

#1368

More imporyant than reads are cases. Ad someone noted "appeal to autbority" is not valid. Try to post case and reasoning. Supplement and link/quote existing cases

Blazinghand

United States25563 Posts

May 13 2012 19:50 GMT

#1371

I think you still have 70 minutes

Blazinghand

United States25563 Posts

May 13 2012 21:37 GMT

#1377

Dt/track: target someone who will be alive tomorrow, who scum wont shoot. Either od them could be sending in the NKs so track dont assume a "no visit" means innocence.

Doctor: they wont want to shoot me until were close to lylo. Consider saving someone else since tmr isnt lylo

If you think ur gonna die and we wont find ur crumbs claim just before daybreak. Dont claim now though.

Any other thoughts on blue actions? Tmr we are one day from mylo

Blazinghand

United States25563 Posts

May 13 2012 21:38 GMT

#1378

Also doc sonce uve definitely not saved anyone DO NOT claim to.ight.

Blazinghand

United States25563 Posts

May 14 2012 00:44 GMT

#1382

On May 14 2012 09:24 l10f wrote:
Since marv hates grush so much, I doubt they're both scum. It's probably Eiii + one of the two for scum team. I don't think we have a DT on our team, and probably not a medic either.

You have really no way of qualifying that second sentence. A tracker or DT could easily have shitty results due to flips and modkills, and isn't ready to claim yet. Granted, there have been several NKs none of which have been medicced, but it's also totes possible that N1 the medic just whiffed or medicced someone who was modkilled, and N2 or N3 he could have been mediccing me, a confirmed town player, whereas scum was shooting to hit blues rather than townies.

I once played as a Doctor and didn't save anyone all game due to being roleblocked. We know there are still 2 scum alive, and one of them doesn't have to send in the NK. he could be a roleblocker.

In my eyes, the fact that so many of the flips so far are VTs only drastically increases the chance that the remaining players in the game are power roles.

Blazinghand

United States25563 Posts

May 14 2012 00:46 GMT

#1383

That being said, we can't rely on some DT to step forward with awesome results and somehow deliver us to victory, because 1) it's bad play and there may not be a DT and 2) fake claims. scumhunting is always #1

Blazinghand

United States25563 Posts

May 19 2012 21:09 GMT

#1525

GG everyone! Thanks to Kurumi and Barundar for the hosting. Mad props to Marv, I really thought you were town. Sorry Palmar for shooting you.

Blazinghand

United States25563 Posts

May 19 2012 21:19 GMT

#1532

Also, although I wasn't as active or as helpful as I could have been, I'd like to personally express my displeasure with

Grush
NT
PPanda
Eiii

Eiii was inactive for 24+ hours leading up to May 7 0343 forum time
PPanda was inactive for 36+ hours leading up to May 7 0343 forum time.
NT was inactive for 24 hours leading up to May 7 0343 forum time.
Grush was inactive for 24+ hours leading up to May 10 0401 forum time.
Eiii was inactive for 24+ hours leading up to May 13 0602 forum time
Grush was inactive for 24+ hours leading up to May 13 0602 forum time

Now, I understand we all got things to do. Hell, I was inactive for decent periods of time when I had my exams going.

However, of the 4 of you, NT and Grush both contributed to town mislynches. Eiii was NKed since he picked up the pace later in the game, and PPanda, you were in such a bad position you had to fakeclaim blue as a townie in order to not get lynched.

I could have done more to save the town while I was alive. I SHOULD have done more. But I believe we could have worked to exonnerate ourselves, as townies, better this game, ladies and gentlemen.

Please don't lurk. It lets scum lurk. Froggy got away with lurking and I put SOME pressure on him, but imagine if he was the only lurker? He would have had to play more aggressively. He was smart and played passively because he COULD.

because we let him.

We can do better, town. We must.

EDIT: I'd just like to note that you guys didn't break any rules or anything with your lurking, but you were inactive and we really really needed to not be inactive this game.

Blazinghand

United States25563 Posts

May 19 2012 21:27 GMT

#1534

As an aside, I really liked the setup of this game. I think very small number of power roles really focuses a game on scumhunting and non-night-action play, and it's fun. Well, when it works. Thanks again to Kurumi and Barundar.

Blazinghand

United States25563 Posts

May 19 2012 22:10 GMT

#1538

Much respect to Frog and Marv for sticking with it after the 3 modkills btw. It must have been very demoralizing, but you guys pulled through.

Blazinghand

United States25563 Posts

May 19 2012 22:19 GMT

#1540

On May 20 2012 07:09 marvellosity wrote:

Show nested quote +

you played terribly, look at yourself.

Let's take it easy, this is a teachable moment. Grush, how would you characterize your own play this game?

Blazinghand

United States25563 Posts

May 19 2012 23:03 GMT

#1549

On May 20 2012 08:00 grush57 wrote:
Didn't matter if I played terribly, there were other 20 townies who failed too. Besides I have mystical powers.

It does matter if you played terribly, because if everyone had that attitude they'd never improve. I repeat my question: how would you characterize your play this game?

Blazinghand

United States25563 Posts

May 19 2012 23:10 GMT

#1552

Right, but the fact that the other townies failed isn't relevant to the fact that you played like unacceptably poor greasy pudding. At least you're aware of that fact. Are you aware of how you could have played better with even the slightest application of effort?

Like, I'm not sure you're aware of this but you got lynched at LYLO and scum basically kept you alive because they knew this would happen. The "other players played poorly" is not an excuse to play poorly.

EDIT: In any case, I'm glad you're aware of the shortcomings in your play (as I am aware of the shortcomings in mine) and I hope that, going forwards, we can both strive to be better players.