A Game of Thrones Mafia - Page 55

On March 22 2012 03:29 Zealos wrote:
On the topic of Wherebugsgo, I'd love to completely ignore him if possible, though I doubt that will end up happening....

On March 22 2012 03:57 Zealos wrote:
I think our best bet in regard to WBG is to completely ignore his posts, unless he gives us damn good reason not to.

On March 25 2012 23:36 Zealos wrote:
Risen seems to be the hot topic, so I'll start with him
I'm calling him as Mafia
My biggest reasons for this is that he consistently switches topics to talk about wbg, even though it is widely agreed that we should just be ignoring him

On March 27 2012 03:04 Zealos wrote:

Most of this argument is explained in easy to understand terms by WBG:

On March 26 2012 06:42 Zealos wrote:

Exactly my argument.

On March 26 2012 05:21 Zealos wrote:
Risen first, when he inevitably flips vanilla scum we can move on.

On March 27 2012 02:35 Zealos wrote:
My argument against risen is not that he isn't playing well, but that he is lying. Lying is either mafia, or a town that is detrimental to the town atmosphere. Either way - Lynch.

On March 23 2012 04:43 Zealos wrote:
@Acro
Matthew is... Weird. He makes some perfectly valid points, but also seems to make some rather moot ones. Although looking at the filter, he makes a LOT of accusations, without having all that much reason. For instance






He seems to constantly switch targets, and it seems like he wants to stir up confusion. Although he almost seems too obvious in the way he does it, which could just be bad town.

Summary: I would certainly say suspicious, but not 100% mafia yet, but should no better targets appear, would be a reasonable day 1 lynch.

On March 23 2012 04:44 Zealos wrote:
Not to mention him being incredibly anti Acrofales.

On March 27 2012 04:03 Zealos wrote:
Ok, I was going to wait until tomorrow, however, his most recent post just tipped me over the edge.
Mattchew is the 2nd mafia, and my lynch choice for tomorrow.
He very rarely makes useful posts, and right from the start has posted a ton of spam and filler.
Examples:
+ Show Spoiler +
When was the last time he made a decent case against anyone? He appears to stir up controversy and limit discussion wherever he goes.
He's also one of the only people really defending Risen, so there could be a possible link there. However, this will be much more apparent should Risen flip mafia tonight (Assuming lynch)

On March 27 2012 20:56 Zealos wrote:
Mattchew, can you make a good case instead of posting annoying 1 liners designed to stir up controversy, or should I just vote for you now?

On March 28 2012 01:11 Zealos wrote:
I'm split between Acro and Matt for lynching tomorrow, but at the moment Risen flipping DT is just too great an evidence to ignore, so I'll be voting Acro for now.

On March 28 2012 02:35 Zealos wrote:
But a disrupted town atmosphere aids mafia, not town.
I have suspicions toward you, though I am more inclined to say you're just an annoying townie.
I'll post a better answer to that question when the day starts, I wanna have a good read over the thread/filters to decide.

On March 28 2012 02:37 Zealos wrote:
I would also say that I'm not 100% sure acro is scum, though he is by far the best lynch for tomorrow.

On March 22 2012 04:12 Zealos wrote:
#Original Name
Lets try to get him talking

On March 23 2012 04:58 Zealos wrote:
Well, my vote was to provoke a post like that, which is good enough for me.
##unvote

On March 22 2012 22:17 Zealos wrote:
My thoughts:
Acro:
Why have you still not given some definitive thoughts? I asked a couple of pages ago and there is still nothing, are you just avoiding the question? The only people you say should be lynched atm are Lurkers, of which I am one, even though I have been fairly active. You made a point against gumshoe but haven't really elaborated or spoken of it since. I want to see you actually follow through on what you are saying.
So overall, so far, my Lynch list would be:
1. Acro

On March 22 2012 23:46 Zealos wrote:
I think it is good that you have made an argument against someone using substance, however, it is somewhat less poignient given the substance of his latest post. However, you have constructed a more useful post and formed an opinion, so although I am still a little susipcious, as you basically back down from your own argument, I will change my vote for the time being.

On March 27 2012 01:31 Zealos wrote:

It's pretty simple. If you are sure someone is mafia, then checking them isn't useful.

On March 27 2012 05:19 Zealos wrote:
Perfect, new person, fresh perspective. Top 3 lynch tagets Jitsu?

On March 27 2012 21:36 Xatalos wrote:


Could you make an actual case against me instead of throwing a one liner at me every time I say something? The way I see it, you just panicked after I made my initial lynch vote for you and started throwing baseless one liners at me to somehow make yourself look "less suspicious" by making me look "more suspicious". All this seems like a scared counter-pressure to shift the attention away from yourself. Frankly, I can't think of a reason why a townie would be tunneling so hard on me after I merely made an analytic decision to vote for you (although I switched to gumshoe after I saw his newer posts). The only conclusion I can think of is that you are a Mafia player trying to get me lynched (not very skillfully, I might add), only because I suspected you.

I see you made some sort of a "case" against me right after I voted for you, which revolved around me being a bit unsure on who to lynch. This is my first game game of Mafia (in a forum), so of course I wouldn't be 100% confident and decisive in my first posts, but I've been trying to improve and I think I'm a lot more confident in my skills now (there aren't many veterans here either, so it's not really necessary to trust other people's opinions...). And what of it if I use smilies every now and then?

Please, make a good case against me or stop that useless spam!

On March 27 2012 23:00 Xatalos wrote:


I'm not saying you are a blue, I'm saying I'm 50/50 on whether you are a Mafia pretending to be a blue or an actual blue. There's no way you're a green townie, with your breadcrumbing pointing at a specific role. I don't personally think you're the best lynch target either, but since most people seem focused on lynching you tomorrow, vigi shooting you would save day 3 from being wasted on your lynch (no matter if you're Mafia or town).

(I have to say though, if Risen hadn't flipped DT, you would seem like the more convincing blue so far. But if day 3 is going to be wasted on your lynch anyway, there's not much point to leave you alive for tomorrow...).