A Game of Thrones Mafia - Page 39

Which, to me, looks like someone scrambling to discredit me. Then again, someone who is town would be just as freaked out. My vote would still be on him had you not made that horrible, HORRIBLE post. How about instead of saying, oh hey his analysis is weak, you say, oh hey his analysis is weak for X, Y, Z reasons? I'll tell you why, because you're scum just looking to discredit me quickly.

Okay. Fine. I have pointed out exactly why your analysis is weak. At least, in the case of me. Frankly, the reason why I didn't post it in the first place is because there is SO MUCH weak analysis (at this point it hadn't been bad and ficticious like Sinensis/risk.nuke's was): you have 4 pages of filter and it is ALL just as weak as your case on me. Stating reasons for everything would take DAYS and is frankly not worth it. It's not a scumtell to refuse to wade through pages and pages of trash.

Yeah, I shit up the thread with all my posts and should have spoilered them into one post, but you're construing that as mafia play? You're attempting to say that someone who is posting analysis (whether I went about it in the correct manner) is playing scummy? Then what is town to you? Policy lynch someone who is posting analysis that can easily be looked back at day2,3, etc? Or lynch someone who is contributing nothing useful and is just tunneling the shit out of Mattchew (then calling out people who vote for him with "shoddy reasoning" that he never points out)...

NOWHERE did I say that was Mafia play. I said it was BAD play and it ABSOLUTELY 100% IS. I never thought you were scum and to be honest still don't. You're just a terrible horrible atrocious townie. I think it's telling that the newest 3 pages of posts are basically the ENTIRE TOWN telling you you're horrible. I'm sorry to tell you, but it's true (no, I'm not trying to be liked here, just convince you that I am town). Btw, looking back at your pages and pages of dross is not going to help anyone on day 2 or 3.

I was wrong earlier. You don't need to get off Mattchew, you just need to start up the wagon a little bit and then discredit anyone who agrees that Mattchew's play was scummy.

WTFBBQ WHAT AM I READING? I spent the entire first day trying to convince people to vote for Mattchew. How the fuck am I in any position to discredit people who agree his play is scummy. I stand by my conviction that his play WAS scummy.

I think Mattchew overreacted to your focus on him if he's town and he's going to have to be looked at by someone. You can sit back and say, "oh I don't like your reasoning. You're doing that for the wrong reason." etc, etc, etc and bully people off of him and onto another wagon.

Do I really need to point out how topsy turvy this reasoning is? If Mattchew is indeed town and were to get lynched, I would be PRIME SUSPECT numero UNO. I was willing to TAKE THAT RISK, because I thought (I am reconsidering, see my analysis post this night. At the very least Gumshoe has passed him by on the scumometer) he was scum. Why would I try to bully people off his bandwagon. I spent the whole day trying to bully people ONTO his bandwagon. That failed, so I voted Nicolas in the hope of lynching a guaranteed modkill, and went to bed.

So Mattchew, maybe you're town and acro is using you as his "oh I contributed and I'm covering my tracks by calling the other people who vote for him bad" it's an OMGUS waiting to happen (he actually did OMGUS me with his mentioned post). Then again, maybe you're scum and acro's plan for people to get off you isn't going to work out and you're lynched. I don't want to help acro in either of those situations, I want him dead.

WHAT THE FUCK AM I READING?

You list 2 out of the 4 possible cases and build some crock of bull WIFOM around it. You completely ignore the possibility that:

1. Acro is town and has a legit scumread on Mattchew.
2. Acro is town and so is Mattchew and Acro is barking up the wrong tree.
Focusing only on
3. Acro is scum and is blaming an innocent townie
4. Acro is scum and is covering (wtf, where did I cover for Mattchew) his scumbuddy.

ALL 4 cases can be WIFOM'd into the EXACT situation that occured. All I can give you is my word that it is either case 1 or 2. However, the fact that you IGNORE the perfectly viable possibility that I am TOWN leads you to completely false conclusions.

I think mattchew is a prime target for checking tonight, but not for lynching.

Given that he was not lynched, I agree with checking him. I believe I suggested that earlier tonight.

As always, feel free to point out why you disagree with this post with a reasoned analysis. You'll note that I haven't called a single person out in this thread when they were suspicious of me if they had their opinion backed up. I probably messed up somewhere in here, and you can point out where I did so, and I can respond with a reasoned post explaining more thoroughly anything you have issue with. That's how town plays, that's how town wins. We post and post and post and explain ourselves until we see someone who's fucked up their web of lies.

Acro, your posting doesn't have any substance. That makes this an easy decision for me since I never actually placed my vote on Mattchew.

##vote Acrofales

My posts have had MOUNTAINS of substance. For a newbie I think I am doing pretty damned well. I just hope I have managed to convince you not to shoot a contributing townie.

Acrofales

Spain17983 Posts

March 24 2012 23:35 GMT

#763

Christ, I think I just gave myself RSI writing that.

DoYouHas

United States1140 Posts

March 24 2012 23:36 GMT

#764

I have cooled my jets a bit towards Alderan and I now believe that risk.nuke is SCUM (note the capitals).

I wanted to get that out before the day post. I'll expand on it later, but other things are getting in my way of devoting a chunk of time to case building until I get the day post for SNMMIX out there. I'll be sure to finish it before bed tonight, so stay tuned.

Some if-then statements to note.

If risk.nuke is scum then Greymist is likely town.
If Greymist is scum then gumshoe is likely town.

Acrofales

Spain17983 Posts

March 24 2012 23:36 GMT

#765

Btw, I don't give a shit anymore who is town and who is mafia. I am voting for Risen on day 2 on general principle.

Acrofales

Spain17983 Posts

March 24 2012 23:42 GMT

#766

I can't believe he made me reply to all that dross in a rush and isn't even around to read it. I hate him with a vengeance and promise to policy-lynch him from now on in any game we play in together.

Risen

United States7927 Posts

March 24 2012 23:42 GMT

#767

So everyone is out in force to watch the hunger games, and since that's sold out they swapped to the movie I was going to see 21 jump street. I'm back until 7ish now yayyyy. My previous post stands, I just get to be here when I'm shot now.

Risen

United States7927 Posts

March 24 2012 23:43 GMT

#768

On March 25 2012 08:42 Acrofales wrote:
I can't believe he made me reply to all that dross in a rush and isn't even around to read it. I hate him with a vengeance and promise to policy-lynch him from now on in any game we play in together.

Don't worry, I'm here. I read it.

Acrofales

Spain17983 Posts

March 24 2012 23:43 GMT

#769

Hey guys. Anybody know whether the clock is going forwards or backwards tonight? If it's going forwards I should really get to bed.

Acrofales

Spain17983 Posts

March 24 2012 23:48 GMT

#770

On March 25 2012 08:43 Risen wrote:

Show nested quote +

Don't worry, I'm here. I read it.

Okay. Please don't vigi shoot me. G'night.

Risen

United States7927 Posts

March 24 2012 23:51 GMT

#771

On March 25 2012 08:48 Acrofales wrote:

Show nested quote +

Okay. Please don't vigi shoot me. G'night.

If I was a vigi I wouldn't be telling people to lynch you tomorrow. Gnight.

DoYouHas

United States1140 Posts

March 24 2012 23:57 GMT

#772

On March 25 2012 08:36 Acrofales wrote:
Btw, I don't give a shit anymore who is town and who is mafia. I am voting for Risen on day 2 on general principle.

I understand this, I did something similar last game with a lurker who ninja voted. So, if you honestly think that Risen is mafia because of his posting, then go for it. But if you really aren't sure, then I ask you to cool off, keep an open mind, and be constructive day 2. Just because you are in conflict with Risen doesn't mean you can't contribute on other topics.

Risen, please take some of the emotion out of your posts. You are not useful to the town posting as you have been. Take a wider view, be objective.

We have a long day ahead and we are behind more than normal because of that modkill. However, we are far from being in a bad position. With some clear thinking and a few persuasive cases, we can get this town back on track.