Normal Mini Mafia I - Page 5

On February 02 2012 13:33 Sinensis wrote:

I have the same position as Timeaisis. I want to hear everyone say at least one thing before we decide who to kill first... that doesn't change the fact that there are people on this ship who must be killed in the name of the emperor. As of right now we outnumber the scum, killing randomly seems like it will statistically cripple our chances.

On February 02 2012 14:31 Vilonis wrote:
One thing is clear, we must force the traitors among us to speak!

On February 02 2012 13:52 Timeaisis wrote:

Agreed. But if someone remains silent for too long we may have no choice but to choose them.

On February 02 2012 14:42 Timeaisis wrote:
OK, good to know. So basically, if someone speaks once and then is silent, that's a sign. But sounds like inactives are gonna get killed anyway. Good to know. So what is the best strategy, D1? Lynch or no lynch? Its seems both of those are in favor of scum, but I guess we just have to play it by ear.

On February 02 2012 15:27 sinani206 wrote:
hi guys; just saw my role pm going to bed now, gnight

On February 02 2012 15:41 Sinensis wrote:
A day 1 lynch in theory has a 25% chance of killing an enemy of the emperor at random with the numbers we have. The problem a day 1 lynch proposes is who to lynch? Further, who decides who to lynch?

The alternative is not killing the first night while the Chaos scum are allowed time to get comfortable. Will they try to kill in the night? Why wouldn't they? Odds are they'll do terrible terrible damage. Even if they don't they'll have time to fortify and strike twice tomorrow night. Our situation is grim no matter how you look at it, so lets talk choices while we can still make them.

The first decision we need to make is if we're going to kill on the first night, lets take this one step at a time. Please post whether you think we should lynch tonight or not and why.

I'll tell you what I think, it involves a plan and is OBVIOUSLY up for debate/criticism/modification:

We should kill the first night, and I should say who dies. Day 1 in a unique time because no one not you, me, or the Chaos scum knows who anyone else is yet. Anyone's guess is as good as random, and random buys us exactly 25% right now. Since our odds are only going to get worse from here, I say we take them. I will use a random number generator to decide which of this crew is executed.

If you agree with me say so, if you disagree I want to hear why... this will at the very least spur juicy discussion to comb,

On February 02 2012 18:09 Bluelightz wrote:
Sup guys got my role PM anyway,

Here's my take on roles

1 Of the vets(Sinani/prplhz) is SCUM(Not sure about this tho if GM wants to screw with us
3/3 Chaos Followers Remain
?/1 Chaos Cultist(s)
?/1 Chaos Fatespinner(s)
?/1 Chaos Plaguebearer(s)
?/0 Chaos Hedonist(s)

9/9 Imperial Forces Remain
?/5/6 Imperial Guardsmen
?/1?Imperial Priest(s)
?/1? Imperial Psyker(s)
?/1?Imperial Stormtrooper(s)
?/1? Imperial Commissar(s)
?/1/2? Tainted By Chaos

DISREGARD ANY CLAIMS BESIDES THE TOWN ROLES ABOVE.


Also, note to everyone if we have a dt please breadcrumb your results so if you die we can find them

---

Never, NEVER, I repeat never NO LYNCH D1

Anyways to who I think is possibly a traitor among us,



##Vote: Sinensis

No one, should decide who to lynch, people themselves should decide who to vote.

Also: Fluff "I think we should kill first night, I think we should kill first night again"

---

VOTING

How many mislynches till LYLO( including mafia kills, but not delay)

not including possible vig kills/dt checks/medic heals/vet hits

+ Show Spoiler +


Voting Strat:

~Never, never never EVER RNG Lynch(Though there is that 25% chance >.<)

~We should always lynch d1 because without the first lynch we will lack lots of information without it.

~LA-Lurkers, If we don't find a lynch candidate I'm fine with lynching a lurker

---

Lurkers:

Lurkers HURT TOWN, if you are lurking STOP IT.

I will not tolerate lurkers, in Mini Mafia's with not a lot of people Lurkers hurt real bad.

Lurkers, hurt town how?

~Less Information

~Less possibilities for lynching

~Possibly a vote lost to town, because most lurkers sheep.

---

Closing words:

I will tolerate lurkers for the first 24 hours because not all players are awake/have acces to the computer to post.