Because while people have been accusing prp and I of blindly lynching Time without considering the big picture, I'm accusing you of supporting Time and nobody else without considering the big picture. Time for a filter check.

Timeaisis made his first post on TL in this mafia forum. First game first post, obviously he's new. You believe the dungeon master put him in a scum role?

I don't. I think you're defending Sentinel, like I said you would, just like Bluelightz did, because you're scum too and so is Bluelightz.

This has been proven false, and you're using the argument Time already overused (he's new).

What's he going to say that's going make 6 of us change our votes? I can't think of anything. In my mind he already slipped up and is the most obvious choice for scum.

On a scale of 1 to Fe, how much irony does this statement contain?

I think EchelonTee is the one being emotional. He's been grilling Timeaisis and ONLY Timeaisis this whole game. His "points" he likes to talk about are convoluted. That said I think neither are scum.

I think Sinensis is the one being emotional. He's been grilling me, prplhz and Blue, and ONLY us 3 this whole game. His "points" he likes to talk about are convoluted. That said I think he isn't scum... for now.

Also, Sentinel is going down in threat level to me as time passes, still suspicious though.

You've addressed me as nothing but "scum" this entire page.

You guys are about to kill a townie just because prplhz said "Well it's obviously Sentinel or Timeaisis"

Yes, it's not like we haven't made 20+ posts between the two of us justifying why Time could be scum.

[UoN]Sentinel

United States11320 Posts

February 04 2012 03:07 GMT

#286

EBWOP: Didn't see day post.

[UoN]Sentinel

United States11320 Posts

February 04 2012 03:10 GMT

#287

Toast-

I wouldn't be worried if I were you.

[UoN]Sentinel

United States11320 Posts

February 04 2012 17:26 GMT

#304

On February 04 2012 15:44 Sinensis wrote:
Eight people voted for Timeaisis, four for Bluelightz. There were 9 townies and 3 scum.

Timeaisis (8): [UoN]Sentinel, EchelonTee, prplhz, BaronFel, Nisani201, Vilonis, mderg, Bluelightz
Bluelightz (4): TheToast, Timeaisis, Sinensis, sinani206

1. If TheToast, Me, or sinani206 are scum, it means mafia split their votes between Bluelightz and Timeaisis.
2. I believe that TheToast and sinani206 are town because they were the only other people in this game, aside from me, who didn't just try to kill an innocent person (Timeaisis) based off a fast forming illogical mob of votes against him.
3. Given that I believe TheToast and sinani206 are town, I must also believe that all mafia members voted for Timeaisis.

Illogical? We're giving more evidence than you, and you're not even trying to come up with counterarguments other than "It's not logical" and "These people are scum for voting Timeaisis". And like mderg just said, it was the strongest case of the two (or three if you count Bluelightz)

4. If all mafia members voted for Timeaisis it means they used a strategy of trying to incriminate a noob based on faulty "scum slips," just like prplhz said a more experienced scum would try to. Coincidence?

Umm... that is a common tactic. I'm a noob and I know how to do that. In fact it was so nooby that I suspected Timeaisis of doing that with his vote on me.

5. I am noob too and had a similar bandwagon of votes form against me much earlier, by the same people who went after Timeaisis and got him lynched: prplhz, Bluelightz, and Sentinel.

What was that about you playing a game 2.5 years ago?

TL;DR - With your current set of arguments I'm growing rather suspicious of you.

[UoN]Sentinel

United States11320 Posts

February 04 2012 17:40 GMT

#305

Also, Hammer Mini Mafia is over so I'll try to be more active in here.

[UoN]Sentinel

United States11320 Posts

February 04 2012 21:28 GMT

#308

Do we just tell you "Do [Action] to [Player]" or do we have to send it to Zbot?

[UoN]Sentinel

United States11320 Posts

February 04 2012 23:33 GMT

#311

^^Before I finish reading that, one of your quote tags is broken, it made it seem like half of your post you were arguing with yourself.

[UoN]Sentinel

United States11320 Posts

February 04 2012 23:48 GMT

#313

For clarification, all unlabeled quotes are written by TheToast

Here's a good one. His last statement, in retrospect, does seem awfully like railroading doesn't it? Who made him the ultimate vote decider?

Sinensis made a similar comment.

prphlz also then made a string of very passionate posts defending Sentinel. I am not sure why he did this, but it is the same type of bizzare defense of Sentinel we saw from Bluelightz, suggests (but does not prove) that Sentinel may be scum.

I support prplhz for two reasons -
1) His defense helped me not get lynched, and
2) His logic makes sense.

Now you're helping knock out reason #2.

If he's scum, this is actually a good strategy. He's giving me full support in the hopes that I'm blue (if I had to guess, there are 3-4 blue roles so that's 33%-44% chance of being right, fairly good odds) so that when he gets lynched, I go down with him.

Next up:

but then again a good chunk of town voted for Time too based on ET's short argument

Being that ET's terrible analysis of Time ended with a townie getting lynched, it makes sense that scum would try to swing ET's attention onto another townie. Obviously ET's analysis was convincing

His terrible arguments were instrumental in moving forward the bandwagon on Time

So is it ET or prplhz who got Time lynched?

I'm thinking there is a very good chance he is mafia number 3, but I don't have any conclusive proof against him.

Keep thinking that, see where it gets you

Since I think I am likely to be dead tonight

Don't resign yourself to your fate that easily.

[UoN]Sentinel

United States11320 Posts

February 05 2012 00:37 GMT

#315

Day post is in 2 and a half hours right?

[UoN]Sentinel

United States11320 Posts

February 05 2012 03:11 GMT

#330

Well now I feel that much better about you prplhz.

[UoN]Sentinel

United States11320 Posts

February 05 2012 03:20 GMT

#335

How did you know Sinani was mafia? Can you give me any reasoning behind and of the issues I brought up?

Maybe you were just wrong in your rationale?

[UoN]Sentinel

United States11320 Posts

February 05 2012 04:04 GMT

#340

Well, Sinani's filter doesn't really incriminate anyone.

The only noticeable thing he did was vote for Bluelightz, which would be weird to throw him under the bus when the Bluelightz lynch wasn't being too discussed over.

For now, I'll save my vote.

[UoN]Sentinel

United States11320 Posts

February 05 2012 04:05 GMT

#341

Sinensis, pretty much everything you've said up to this point incriminates me, Bluelightz, and prplhz. Now that prplhz is confirmed townie, and I'm fairly in the green, what have you to say?

[UoN]Sentinel

United States11320 Posts

February 05 2012 04:37 GMT

#345

##Vote: Sinensis

Voting for this idiot.

[UoN]Sentinel

United States11320 Posts

February 05 2012 04:51 GMT

#348

EBWOP before mod catches me: Let my emotions get in the way, sorry about the direct insult.

My vote is because in spite of the overwhelming evidence, until someone else claims vigilante, prplhz is 100% town. Sinensis still thinks prplhz is scum despite this, hence I think his decision is extremely stupid.