BC's Arkham City

On February 09 2012 05:10 layabout wrote:
i presume that means you are confirming it's existence risk?

On February 09 2012 22:49 Radfield wrote:
I got shot last night.

rgShworz is obviously not Two Face, and in act I'm willing to bet he is not a DT. He claimed a hit, yet no WAY catwoman did not target him last night.

Therefore he is either unkillable by Catwoman, which means he is either one of the vets (Solomon Grundy, Clayface, Bane, and Mr. Freeze) or Poison Ivy; or he himself is catwoman.

Yet he has claimed DT, which means he can only be catwoman out of those options. The Two-Face claim kinda makes sense if he's catwoman, but I can't really wrap my head around it. However his entire role-claim was bizarre(claiming dt out of the blue), which reminds me ALOT of the iGroks early neutral-balrog claim. There was almost no pressure, and he claimed a role which was basically guaranteed to see him killed. If he was bulletproof at night that actually makes sense, as the lynch is the only thing he fears. I still need to think about this, but he's not the lynch today.

We're missing a ton of KP, so it makes sense that if he is catwoman, he might have investigated DocH. Which means it's possible he's not lying, but it sure sounds like bullshit. He should have gotten a role back, not an alignment.

Either way, DocH and Toad seem more than confident enough, and both seem like town. If it comes to name claiming so be it, but I'd rather their identities remain hidden.

---

In other news, I investigated Sheth last night and he is Tyger

This gives us a whole truckload of info from the Day 1 lynch, because Sheth and CC were neck and neck for a while until CC ran away with it. I haven't looked through it yet, but I assure you scum will fall when I do


##Vote Sheth

On February 09 2012 23:50 Palmar wrote:
That wasn't actually me in the QT Toad. And seeing as we've finally got our shit together, I don't see any reason not to allow people to check out the QT. There's nothing of value in there anyway.

On February 10 2012 01:52 rgTheSchworz wrote:
Man, I perfectly understand why you would lynch sheth today.
I m also up for lynching sheth, mainly because he posts fluff and irrelevant stuff.
QT is full of scum. I do not fear getting lynched, anyways I know what to do Night 2.
If im getting lynched because Clayface does not want to claim so be it.

Medics get off me ASAP. Toad doesn t understand I ll be catfood tonight.
When I flip, please lynch this liar= DocH.

I understand that BM got roleblocked. I strongly trust BM at this point, I believe him to be the most town.
So, 2 kills without any prot.
Scum single-stacked Jackal, because they RB BM.
Rad claimed hit, but I don t believe he s a vet since he claims DT.
So, most likely one of our vigs hit him,else hes a Veteran.
Therefore , I m inclined to think CW didnt shoot.
Therefore she DT ed me.
Therefore I die tonight. Bye, Bye, Bye

On February 10 2012 02:39 Palmar wrote:
There exists a possibility you're a miller sheth. However, you were already under suspicion from day one. If it was someone who was being pretty obvious town I'd give it a second thought. But given the fact we have a DT check that we have a reason to believe on you as scum, the only logical play is to hang you.

If you're a miller, tough luck. Only in extraordinary situations should we consider not lynching a red check, and this is not one of them. Hell, there was a chance we'd lynch you anyway, even without the red check.

But I don't really think you're a miller, there's nothing in your play that looks like town play. I think you're scum, I think Radfield is black, and I think town is on a roll.

On February 11 2012 22:46 rgTheSchworz wrote:
Im gonna look at WBG and Kita as they have nt been helpful this game.

On February 13 2012 05:43 Jayjay54 wrote:
alright, I'll be hitting the gym. For now I'll vote nuke. Looking at his filter, he is the most scummiest lurker alongside hiro. Much more scummy than evantrees IMO.

vote: risk.nuke

feel free to step up nuke, my unvote is freely available. Right now, you give me little reason to do so. Same goes for hiro. Without martyring please.

On February 13 2012 05:58 Jayjay54 wrote:


OMGUS much?

what did you contribute? I even said in that post that you can my unvote pretty easily. Not with an OMGUS, but an actual contribution.

On February 13 2012 22:39 Radfield wrote:



Hi Palmar. I think I'm finally starting to figure out whats going on

At first I assumed you could not be Batman, because if you were Batman, I would be dead. I cannot stop an unblockable shot, and neither can any medics. Therefore, despite the fact that your play this game lines up with your third party play to a tee, I had assumed you were just adding an extra dash of troll to your play.

It's apparent now though that you did not actually shoot me, which was my gut reaction at the time. Shooting me Night 1 is dumb, and you are not dumb. It's also possible that you are scum and shot me, and if so you have played an extremely ballsy game as scum(However then you would not know my role, which you obviously do). At this point though I am almost positive you are third party, which explains your play this game.

You have been pushing me since Day 1(either as scum or 3rd party), but never as town, despite the fact that I am a basically confirmed-town dt(who has soaked a hit, and flipped a red), which makes a lot of sense from a third party perspective. Ideal scenario for you is that the sensible strong townies get pushed out early, leaving you free to bully the town around.

I am Calendar Man, and you are the Bat or the Cat. Me bussing Sheth for no reason on Day 1 makes no sense, and calling him out on a red check makes no sense, particularly when he was pretty much out of the fire until I posted my check. I assume you rolechecked me N1, which makes sense if you are Batman given that if I was mafia, there is a good chance I would be the GF(Hugo Strange).

Again, Palmar being scum doesn't really fit because mafia wouldn't have both shot me and rolechecked me. It's possible he just lucked out(it was obvious I am Calendar Man or Azreal), in which case you might be scum.



Hi scum. You seem awfully eager to vote off the confirmed non-scum detective.

I readily admit my play has been a bit lackluster this game, which is due to both lack of time and getting a detective role, not to mention gettng both my dt checks correct. However despite that, my play has certainly not been scummy by any stretch, yet you are ready to vote hand in hand with Palmar's claim that he checked me? That is Bull.

---

We lynch Palmar today. He is almost certainly 3rd party or scum, though probably 3rd party. Normally you do not lynch 3rd party, but here we have an exception. If Palmar is Catwoman, he is certainly shooting into town. If Palmar is Batman, he is certainly shooting Toad tonight. Either way eliminating Palmar eliminates 1 anti-town KP. If he is scum it's even better.

Someone make me an argument why we should keep Palmar alive today?

On February 13 2012 22:48 Radfield wrote:



And it is very possible that Palmar is scum, and very likely that you are too. Normally third party swing both ways, and kill off scum or town. However this game, particularly right now, that is not the case. He is scum or third, which means either way we win. Do you honestly think there is a possibility Palmar will flip town?

I am off to work, but will be on tonight.

On February 14 2012 00:03 Kurumi wrote:
Palmar, I think we both should shoot Radfield.

On February 14 2012 00:05 jaybrundage wrote:
SO i suggest we enforce a Lynch All Liars Policy.

And then proceed to LYNCH THE FUCKEN HELL OUT OF PALMAR!

Comon Layabout isn't this the best plan ever :D

On February 14 2012 23:56 chaoser wrote:


lol...are you seriously implying that they're scum

so fail.

On February 15 2012 07:06 Toadesstern wrote:
I already send in my action. Whos the most scared?

On February 15 2012 22:09 Palmar wrote:
Ok tyrran is scum. Need to find 3 more.

On February 16 2012 06:23 Kurumi wrote:
Go , vote . I will be happy.

On February 16 2012 09:29 Forumite wrote:

Not sure if it´s allowed, but even if it was I don´t see any gain for Town. It´s not used much anymore, nor were all posters truthfull with their names when posting when we did use the thread a lot. Those two scum you mention are dead, so unless there are more scum in the QT, scum will only know what´s been said earlier. Revealing it would in that case give scum more info.

I think I prefer keeping it for a Town-circle tomorrow.

On February 16 2012 20:47 Adam4167 wrote:
We need to take that KP off them before the night phase starts.

Catwoman can random fire into town, but it'll just end the game quicker, giving her less days to figure out where Penguin and Two-Face are.

On February 16 2012 21:33 Adam4167 wrote:
I'm pretty sure I can out the entire scum team now.

With that information, do we still want to waste today's lynch on catwoman, and let her kill townies as we round up the scums over the next 4 days?

On February 16 2012 22:04 Adam4167 wrote:
I think you just need to chillax a bit when you're playing mafia.

The only things that were really nagging at me towards you were all of the outbursts and the belligerent behavior directed at layabout.

On February 16 2012 22:07 Adam4167 wrote:
Great. So:

VisceraEyes
Tyrran
Risk.nuke
Rayzor



And I think I know why Penguins night kills haven't been showing up either.

On February 16 2012 23:35 Adam4167 wrote:
Kurumi, did you shoot at rGTheSchworz at all?

Really kind of important at this point, we flub this and we all lose.

On February 16 2012 23:43 Adam4167 wrote:
I ask because I had HIM marked in my notes as freeze.

We cant have two freeze.

Well, knowing we have a DT, hidden behind a meatshield, you can knock out a lot of the guesswork for the coming days.

On February 16 2012 23:55 Adam4167 wrote:
Hmm, also:

Hugo can disguise himself as anyone, which only batman can see through.

Forumite may not be Freeze at all.

On February 17 2012 00:29 Adam4167 wrote:
I dont think he is Ivy.. at all.

Why kick up all this noise with another crappy claim, try and get us to lynch freeze, if hes ivy?

On February 17 2012 00:48 rgTheSchworz wrote:



Is it the same thing that Joker and Clayface have?

On February 17 2012 02:16 Forumite wrote:

I will after risk tells the truth about what his check gave.

On February 17 2012 05:04 Kurumi wrote:

I'd probably win this way and get removed, because risk surviving another night would be either miracle of foolishness of the scum team.

On February 17 2012 05:14 Kurumi wrote:

We can always replace Your heart with giant baboon's one and ubercharge You.

On February 17 2012 05:24 Forumite wrote:

True dat

Okey, risk is Two-Face DT, and I´m Penguin Vigi. We are both valuable Townies, unkillable for now except by Catwoman. Either we kill CW and have two unkillable blues, or we die during the next two nights. Personally one Town KP might come in handy...

On February 17 2012 07:45 hiro protagonist wrote:
I dont care about dieing, and Im sorry about that, but Im reading current developments at the same time as catching up on the thread, because I have little time to play right now. I promous not to say anything else until I am fully read though.

But my logic still stands, assuming one on me and viscera is scum (99% likely btw) scum will just protect themselves and let town Kp kill the other. ends badly for us. IMO, we should kill one of me or VE TODAY.

On February 18 2012 12:51 VisceraEyes wrote:
Yes, because I've been so confusing and disruptive to town. -.-

Honestly, if anyone is fooled by this idiocy, I don't even know what to say.

On February 23 2012 23:02 Palmar wrote:


Dude, i was hardly reading the thread, some asshole was spamming it so hard it was completely nonsensical anyway