Purgatory Mafia - Page 14

On January 05 2012 09:48 Erandorr wrote:
The last time I looked the game was full already, didn't even realize I am in this until now.


The biggest question for me right now is this:

Blazinghand are you WBGs Smurf? Or his long lost brother, maybe?

On December 28 2011 15:40 Zona wrote:
Question answering policy:

The information provided in the game setup information and in your individual role descriptions has been deliberately written to be provide all the necessary information required to play the game. However, it is still possible, due to host error, that certain necessary information is missing or unclear. The host will respond to questions about the game in the following manner:

Before roles have been distributed, players should ask their questions about the game publicly in the thread. If any questions do involve legitimately unclear, or missing and necessary information, the question will be publicly answered in the thread.

Once the game begins (roles have been distributed), players should ask their questions about the game via PM. If any questions do involve legitimately unclear, or missing and necessary public information, the question will be publicly answered in the thread without identifying the person asking the question (the question may possibly be paraphrased). If any questions do involve legitimately unclear, or missing and necessary private information, the question will be privately answered by PM.

In addition, all requests for replacement, concerns about rule violations or inactivity, and questions about possible ZBot errors should be submitted to the host via PM. The host will consider all in-thread posts as in-game posturing and will not acknowledge, respond, or react to any posts made in the thread. If ZBot ever publicly displays erroneous information, the host will make an announcement clarifying any errors once they are discovered.

On January 05 2012 11:42 Bluelightz wrote:
Blast me with questions now im available again! !

On January 05 2012 10:22 Refallen wrote:
Alright, I just woke up, first thoughts:

Why is everyone tunneling the lurkish newbie? He is sooooo likely to flip town instead of scum. Just look at Election Mafia, and XLVIII. In almost every case, the lurking newbie simply turns out to be just that, a newbie, which explains his low-posting. We definitely do not want to be wasting a lynch on him.

On January 05 2012 10:22 Refallen wrote:


This is never a good idea. Even a town who is completely non-contributing serves as an extra KP before LYLO, and for most newbie towns, they will be sheeping the case which most people are already on, in effect letting town have an extra vote. We should never ever ever kill town "because he's useless at it".

I'm not sure what you're going on about having a solid case. How does one make a solid case on someone who has 3 posts and told us they're going afk for a bit on the very first day of the game?

On January 05 2012 15:05 HarbingerOfDoom wrote:
So how would people feel about lynching Palmar or Erandorr if they don't start posting more? Both have posted nothing of worth so far, Palmar was even active elsewhere on the mafia forum today, and both are known for doing very little as scum.

On January 05 2012 15:19 Blazinghand wrote:


Demonstrate to me that Palmar and Erandorr also DON'T do very little on the first 24 hours of day 1 when they are town, and I'm game like venison

On January 05 2012 14:27 Bluelightz wrote:
Okay, ill just give my thoughts on LA-Lurkers

First,

I don't think that lynching lurkers benefit town in any way.
Usually it results in a townie lynched(BByte lynch in student mafia as an example)

Also,

Here's the list of people I want posting

xsksc
Cwave
risk.nuke
Errandor

That is all.

On January 04 2012 17:46 Dirkzor wrote:
Game on!

This setup scares the living shit out of me. So many nuances to keep track of. Anyway...

I agree that Angels appear to be strongest in the beginning with 1/2 KP. But what haven't been mentioned is that Angels can kill the demon for us aswell. If we lynch Angel of Death and Angelic Acolyte we will have to lynch/Demon hunter the Demons. Since I don't know the Demon hunter or how good that person is, he could just aswell kill 3 town people the first 3 nights which of course would not be very favourable for us. It basicly means we would need to do more correct lynches while having a good demon hunter that don't fuck us over with continously town kills.
Demons also have the Twist ability which basicly makes one (1) of their members immune to night actions, rendering the demon hunter to be less useful.

What i wanted to point out that even if we get 3 correct Angel lynches (unlikely) the first 3 nights. The demons are equally capable to fuck us over. That is why I think that killing any angel or demon is good. Not one over the other. If we knew which angel or demon, it would be a different matter.

On January 04 2012 23:29 Dirkzor wrote:
Day 1 seems to be longer then it should be? Zbot claims it ends in 3 days and 10h (aprox. as of writing) when the OP states:

On January 05 2012 18:36 Palmar wrote:
I claimed kite, that's pretty pro-town?

On January 05 2012 19:02 Palmar wrote:
@Syllogism: You seem to be very much against lynching Bluelightz, do you want to explain to me why?

On January 05 2012 20:07 syllogism wrote:

Because people were picking on him for hurrrr not being helpful as scum in Student mafia and then for not posting anything useful within the first three hours of the game, just like everyone else. If he doesn't start posting something useful he might be a decent lynch possibility, but not because he didn't do anything within the first 3 hours. However I still don't see how this is your town play so how about we still lynch you instead. Do you have an excuse for not doing anything yesterday? I've one excuse in mind but I would like to hear it from you.

Other than that, for instance lynching risk.nuke http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=298603&user=76576 appears to make much more sense given that we know how he plays town and this clearly isn't it so far. Grackaroni is another given that his only contribution so far has been to randomly tunnel bluelightz for the aforementioned awful reasons.

The list of worthless people so far: RoL, risk.nuke, cwave, xsksc, Palmar, Jackal, Erandorr, bluelightz

Out of those Palmar is the one least likely to be this inactive as town.

On January 05 2012 20:12 syllogism wrote:
Palmar: do you really believe that "cluttering up the thread" is an issue so far in this game? Do you think it is ever?