Responsibility Mafia! - Page 2

On December 22 2011 11:51 Jackal58 wrote:

I know. And when you were town this is not how you played.

On December 22 2011 11:55 VisceraEyes wrote:
No LSB, you fucking flip today bro. Stop trying to derail the wagon in the eleventh hour. You've had all fucking game to play with us - don't pretend to start now.

On December 22 2011 11:59 VisceraEyes wrote:
Sheth I swear to Christ if you don't put your vote back on LSB something horrifying is going to happen to you overnight.

On December 22 2011 11:59 VisceraEyes wrote:
Sheth I swear to Christ if you don't put your vote back on LSB something horrifying is going to happen to you overnight.

On December 22 2011 12:04 bumatlarge wrote:
I like GM's clam much more then I like LSBs. I like that we have a day 1 CC scenario. I think it's pretty clear that leaving them both alive is not an option. Chances are, some ambiguous garbage will happen and we will say "should have lynched you yesterday."

We take our (at worse) 50/50 for a day 1 lynch and play the game from there. There isn't much to dispute.

On December 22 2011 12:10 wherebugsgo wrote:
Why the fuck are people unvoting LSB? He got counterclaimed. He got counterclaimed by the second scummiest person of the day, which means that it is practically guaranteed that one of them is scum.

We kill LSB today, and if he flips town and if a scum is not shot tonight then GM dies tomorrow. Of course, if a scum dies then GM is spared.

If GM is town he's obviously shooting tonight. We give him the target, he claims it before the night is over. If he's wrong, he dies, if he's right, we get a scum.

This is a no lose situation, either way we get a scum, so lynch the fuck out of LSB.

On December 22 2011 12:12 wherebugsgo wrote:
Oh I should mention, GM is clear if LSB is scum.

So we lynch LSB. If LSB is town GM is not clear and we make him shoot.

On December 22 2011 12:16 wherebugsgo wrote:


someone tell me what the fuck that is if that isn't claiming scum?

On December 22 2011 12:16 VisceraEyes wrote:


Sheth we're freaking out because there's no way to mobilize all the votes. If we falter here, a no-lynch occurs. This is the worst possible case scenario because that gives us no information either way. Please, you're bucking the wisdom of 9 of the best players in TL Mafia, plus me. Get back on board guy. This is NOT an order, this is a plead. PLEASE don't let them no-lynch us. If you need an example of why this is bad for town, please go take a gander through XLVIII...scum won because we no-lynched town to death.

On December 22 2011 11:52 LSB wrote:
If I do end up being lynch, GM has some explaining to do. By explaining I mean shooting.

So, I'll put up the Who is telling the truth plan

We have two people who claim to be suicidal vigs, night 1, both people will shoot someone, right before day 2 is called, they will announce in thread.

If the person they shoot is still alive, they will have lots of explaining to do
If the person they shoot is town, they are lying
If the person they shoot is mafia, they are probably town.

Even if one of the two people gets lynched (me), I advise you all to carry out the plan, with the remaining person (GMarshal). I can prove to you all my innocence tonight, just let me get my hands on the gun

On December 22 2011 12:21 wherebugsgo wrote:


that's not a bus!

a bus is one scum killing another scum, his teammate. So why are you telling me I'm ignoring the possibility of a bus?

The only way your wagon can be a bus is if you are scum and at least one or more of the people on your wagon is scum.

On December 22 2011 12:23 wherebugsgo wrote:


why do you keep avoiding the question?

You essentially just claimed scum by saying I'm ignoring the possibility of a bus. Fuck that, you're dying for sure now.

On December 22 2011 12:36 bumatlarge wrote:
Hmmm, that would be a neat punishment, to punish voting based on two people having slightly different roles, I'll give that LSB. But our lynch was founded before that. This discussion seems like more of an after-thought. We can review GM's case after you die. I can't really pin anything wrong with his claim. But I still don't believe you, and would be pretty surprised to see you flip blue.

On December 22 2011 12:36 kitaman27 wrote:
If LSB and GM are indeed the same role, it doesn't make sense for them to shoot each other. That's a waste of a vig shot. If that is the route town decides to take, we should have one shoot the other and one shoot the scummiest player of our choice. That way we have the same result, with a net gain of one vig shot.