EPTOn November 21 2011 08:00 Nisani201 wrote:
Palmar is an interesting case. Though many of you have a reason to trust him, we have to realize that part of the reason that he is trusted is because he is Palmar. The other reason is this post:
+ Show Spoiler +
This is his initial analysis on Chaoser. There are 3 points in this analysis:
1. chaoser is voting a lot of people.
2. chaoser is OMGUSing sinani206
3. chaoser is "softclaiming a power role."
The first point is incorrect because this game has a mechanic that is special for voting multiple people.
The second point is wrong because chaoser's vote on Sinani206 is not OMGUS
The third point doesn't even make sense.
Palmar is an interesting case. Though many of you have a reason to trust him, we have to realize that part of the reason that he is trusted is because he is Palmar. The other reason is this post:
+ Show Spoiler +
On November 16 2011 21:49 Palmar wrote:
Actually, I just read Chaoser's filter
##Unvote: Coagulation
##Vote: chaoser
So here's my reasoning chaoser needs to be lynched.
First off, we should establish that chaoser is both analytical and critical as town. His play this game starkly contrasts that idea. He is throwing accusations and votes both left and right without actually doing much to back them up. Now, this leads us to think what would make chaoser throw his votes around like this.
The only sensible reason to do that as town is to apply pressure, but when you are the one being pressured it's actually not beneficial to do this, because no one is going to listen to you anyway. The optimal town play in this situation is to try as hard as you can to build reputation for people to listen to you for. However, chaoser seems not even slightly interested in raising his status in the game, feeling pretty comfortable being not listened to at all. Something only scum is interested in.
This one is particularly interesting. First off, we have to understand how sinani206 works to see if this is legit. Remember, sinani206 hasn't got the greatest track record as town or scum, but he does have his tells like everyone else. This little vote he placed on chaoser seems to be pretty genuine. Like he's not pro enough as scum to realize that doing something like that with his meta as scum is excellent play, and thus the simplest explanation is that sinani206 is town.
chaoser should have understood this, yet he directly OMGUS votes sinani206, even gloating about the fact he's voting multiple people.
So yes, I think chaoser would be an excellent lynch today.
Also, just for future reference:
This is chaoser soft-claiming a power-role. No reason to do it unless you're scum.
If you can't understand how he's soft-claiming a power role, well... you deserve to be punched.
So yeah, let's kill that guy.
Actually, I just read Chaoser's filter
##Unvote: Coagulation
##Vote: chaoser
So here's my reasoning chaoser needs to be lynched.
First off, we should establish that chaoser is both analytical and critical as town. His play this game starkly contrasts that idea. He is throwing accusations and votes both left and right without actually doing much to back them up. Now, this leads us to think what would make chaoser throw his votes around like this.
The only sensible reason to do that as town is to apply pressure, but when you are the one being pressured it's actually not beneficial to do this, because no one is going to listen to you anyway. The optimal town play in this situation is to try as hard as you can to build reputation for people to listen to you for. However, chaoser seems not even slightly interested in raising his status in the game, feeling pretty comfortable being not listened to at all. Something only scum is interested in.
This one is particularly interesting. First off, we have to understand how sinani206 works to see if this is legit. Remember, sinani206 hasn't got the greatest track record as town or scum, but he does have his tells like everyone else. This little vote he placed on chaoser seems to be pretty genuine. Like he's not pro enough as scum to realize that doing something like that with his meta as scum is excellent play, and thus the simplest explanation is that sinani206 is town.
chaoser should have understood this, yet he directly OMGUS votes sinani206, even gloating about the fact he's voting multiple people.
So yes, I think chaoser would be an excellent lynch today.
Also, just for future reference:
This is chaoser soft-claiming a power-role. No reason to do it unless you're scum.
If you can't understand how he's soft-claiming a power role, well... you deserve to be punched.
So yeah, let's kill that guy.
This is his initial analysis on Chaoser. There are 3 points in this analysis:
1. chaoser is voting a lot of people.
2. chaoser is OMGUSing sinani206
3. chaoser is "softclaiming a power role."
The first point is incorrect because this game has a mechanic that is special for voting multiple people.
The second point is wrong because chaoser's vote on Sinani206 is not OMGUS
The third point doesn't even make sense.
1. Voting a lot of people is still stupidly scummy even with the game mechanic, In fact I would say the game mechanic behind the multiple votes would be much more beneficial for scum to abuse.
2. His vote was an Omgus vote
3. Soft claiming a power role is stupid ( Shush I know I did it in this game Palmar but town was stupid and never realized it )
and is normally something scum would do when they are being pressured into a lynch
4. Palmar has claimed being shot and I can guarantee you now that there is another medic in this game so I am more than willing to believe that Palmar is town.
5. Why are more people still not voting for you?
