Team Melee Mini Mafia - Couples Therapy - Page 2

On November 05 2011 01:31 kitaman27 wrote:
You're suspicious of prp's team, supersoft and myself? The three people I'm willing to trust. Either your reads are really off or you're intentially trying to break up any measure of trust that has been established on day one.

On November 05 2011 07:00 kitaman27 wrote:
Are we sure it just hit 5?

On November 07 2011 07:00 supersoft wrote:
ah well. I love to commentate on everyone in such a little game.

1. TEAM SS - (sandroba & Sevryn Deconduo)
I read the current discussion and sandroba doesn't look too bad in the dialogue with wbg.
Mainly because wbg mixes in some things that really aren't reasons to vote anyone.
Seriously bugs, this team switzerland thing. It was a typo. I won't vote any team for confusing the teamnames.
However team SS is #2 at my scumlist. They look really bad if you see the whole picture. I mean it's 5v2 now.
I know I am town, red21 is blue, wbg is very likely town and i have a strong townfeeling towards chaoser. By the process of elimination and the day1 passive behavior of sandro, i think team SS is scum.

2. TEAM CHEZINU - (Radfield & wherebugsgo)
as I said before. It's not useful to accuse people simply because they are "still" alive at day2. probably green

3. TEAM NIPPLE - (Kurumi & RebirthOfLeGenD)
oh well. Kurumis filter looks quite bad.
I reread the post where he proposed the nolynchplan and was curious what he did in addition to that. Besides like 3 apologyposts for inactivity, he says he's "rereading" the thread and "taking notes" and he came to the conclusion that team Viking is the best lynch. lol. #1 scum.

4. TEAM LIQUID - (Crofty & Gmarshal)
Crofty is unseen ever since. GM is busy now. He pushed 2 cases so far, both on townies.
Grey thinks i am too focussed on him but if Sandro is scum and Kuru isn't i am going to push his lynch for sure.
I mean if team SS is scum, GM peeled the public attention away from them perfectly by posting his red21 case.

5. TEAM S&G CONSULTING - (supersoft & GreYMisT)
...

6. TEAM EDWARD - (chaoser & hyshes)
difficult. I don't think they are scum. I hope chaoser comes back in here fast and continues to share his thoughts. I'd like to see some more out of him.

7. TEAM RED21 - (redFF & kitaman27)
these guys are blue. I have no doubt about that.


I wait for Greys opinion on that and if he agrees i am going to vote Kurumi/RoL

On November 07 2011 12:58 wherebugsgo wrote:


I think they're both good lynches, I just think sandro is better.

I don't know how much you've played with sandro, but he's one of those players where, if he starts saying stuff that sounds wrong or is not well reasoned, he's scum. Indeed, his activity this game is atrocious, his logic is terrible, his plan was really bad, he has taken a very passive attitude when it comes to finding scum, and he hasn't been reading the thread to boot.

In addition, his team is rather connected to chaoser's, if you haven't noticed.

Also it's really odd that he keeps saying "I don't like your case on chaoser's team" without actually detailing what parts of my analysis are bad. He says there's a bunch of stuff that makes chaoser look town but doesn't explain that, and says that a lot of my points don't contribute to chaoser being scummy.

Then at the same time, he says he's still suspicious of chaoser+hyshes. He seems to be straddling both sides of the issue without actually taking a stance. A town sandro would take one stance and push it, not flip flop like this.

In addition, I know I'm prone to getting heated and very aggressive, so after the dialogue I had with chaoser I think it's best that the two of them (hyshes and chaoser) are left alone for a bit to see how they will act until lynch tomorrow. Not so impressed with hyshes's comeback to the thread.

On November 08 2011 06:25 sandroba wrote:
1. I posted a controvesial plan that could be argued both ways to get reactions from people. The fact that I think no lynch was indeed optimal day 1 doesn't change the fact that people would most certainly have a strong response to this in one way or another. You ask me then who is mafia from those reactions? I ask you the same. The reactions are there for anyone to see and draw conclusions. As for who I think is mafia you already know that.

2. I acused wbg of being mafia after he dropped his case on chaoser and switched his vote to me due to a typo. Previously I said the fact that rad/wbg were not shot was suspcious, but not enough to assure they are mafia. Now I'm not really sure anymore on wbg anymore, because he could very well believe so much he is right and be completely wrong as proven by XLV, which I read to refresh my memory.

3. I layed a trap for kurumi when saying he was not trolling and thus mafia and he responded in a way that makes me feel very confident he is mafia, as pointed out in my post about his behaviour.

4. The other contributing factor that leads me to believe wbg may indeed be town and misguided is the fact that chaoser is looking worse and worse, sheeping wbg who he previously believed was mafia and voting me. I went against his lynch when wbg was pushing it as loudly as he is pushing mine right now. If he was town he would know that I had to be really stupid as mafia to do that in that spot. Chaoser doesn't share this mentality (which a townie would for sure consider), so I believe he is more likely to be mafia than wbg right now. The fact that he dissapeared the moment the focus shifted away from him and now he is back supporting someone he previously called scum to make sure a townie gets lynched is enough to tip the scale heavily towards chaoser being scum as opposed to wbg.