|
On September 22 2011 01:58 Lucidity wrote:
##unvote
##Vote Curu
I don't mind lynching either Jackal or Forumite or Curu today. None of them have been hunting scum. They all have the ability to do it, but they're not. Curu only appears when his name is mentioned. Jackal is 100% hiding in the element mess. I thought you were really good on Day 3? HeHE. Forumite should have been the one to die on Day 1. Jackal and Forumite forced the no lynch.
STOP PUSHING FOR THE LYNCH OF DERPING MISTAKES. We should NOT lynch Nisani for claiming honesty. That would have been the most retarded scum gambit in the history of this game. Honesty was already claimed. Nisani actually HAS a stone. Explain the scumgenda here?
Curu send me your element of kindness.
And what do you want me to look at. Since I posted day 2 regarding what tnkted did with his shard every post in this entire game consists of people screaming NO YOU!!!!! Bugs vs Nisani, Forumite vs Cure, You vs everybody else. The only difference I have seen between any of you is the 3 that didn't claim anything. Now Curu has. Do I believe him? I don't fucking know yet. Forumite, WBG, and tnkted all passed on their pieces. Currently awaiting to see if Nisani did the same. I don't see that as scum play. Other than the items Cyber_Cheese has given jack shit to this game. He's posting regularly in LOTR but nothing here. That's where my vote is going and that's where it is staying.
|
Curu, you have shown no desire to combine your element and reap the rewards. Is this because you're scum and you don't really care for name checks and vet powers? All you care about is that we don't have those powers to protect us against scum.
|
On September 22 2011 02:21 Lucidity wrote:Show nested quote +On September 22 2011 02:20 Curu wrote:
Actually hmm, reading over the OP that any Pony can be any alignment and considering my strong suspicion that there are exactly 0 power roles in the game (all powers come from items) confused could very well mean Mafia. What use is a simple namecheck in a game with no likely powers where name does not imply alignment?
Dun dun dunnnnnn. Are you saying tnkted lied about his Roleblocker ability?
Hm, I'd like tnkted to elaborate on that actually. Everyone so far has flipped green and I'm pretty sure the CMC members are vanilla too (cept Forumite the scum).
|
On September 22 2011 02:24 Lucidity wrote:
Curu, you have shown no desire to combine your element and reap the rewards. Is this because you're scum and you don't really care for name checks and vet powers? All you care about is that we don't have those powers to protect us against scum.
lol way to twist my words. I have shown no desire to give you the element and let you reap the rewards. Mister confused.
|
On September 22 2011 02:22 Curu wrote:
It's a oneshot that tells you the name when name does not imply alignment. Sounds like a completely useless item to me.
The confused part has to be significant.
And yet it wasn't significant for chaos13's Rarity... And why is 1-shot not considered a special power? I have NO special powers. Are you playing bad on purpose?
|
|
|
On September 22 2011 02:26 Curu wrote:Show nested quote +On September 22 2011 02:24 Lucidity wrote:
Curu, you have shown no desire to combine your element and reap the rewards. Is this because you're scum and you don't really care for name checks and vet powers? All you care about is that we don't have those powers to protect us against scum. lol way to twist my words. I have shown no desire to give you the element and let you reap the rewards. Mister confused.
You haven't proposed that I give it to you either.
You only claimed to have an element when Jackal pointed out that scum was likely hiding any they had.
You haven't tried to combine it at ALL.
The fact that you're not willing to give it to me is only one part of your disinterest in the item.
|
On September 22 2011 02:27 Curu wrote:
wat
chaos13's rolename was
Rarity, the Fashionista.
I am
Derpy Hooves, the confused pony.
It's most likely just flavour . . . . . . . . . .
|
tnkted, did it specifically bold the confused part in Lucidity's name or did you just do that yourself?
You're obviously not going to give it to me so why would I bother asking you? And you're right, getting scum Forumite lynched is more interesting to me than spending another 10 pages talking about items like derps. Lynching scum > items circlejerk.
|
Is Cyber_Cheese posting like a clown in LOTR as well?
|
Hard to tell. Everybody is.
|
HMM HMM HMM I GOTTA RETHINK SOMETHING
HOLD THE HORSES
|
EBWOP: Hold the Ponies I mean
|
Hey Lucidity why were you all like "sup guys lynch WBG for messing up his PM time on his items then today you're all like "sup guys don't lynch Nisani for messing up his PM name on his item."
|
A name is not the same as a time.
I had to double check my element name before I posted as well.
There's no way I wouldn't know that I got an item AT THE START OF THE GAME.
On September 19 2011 11:17 Curu wrote:
Some things I learned from this game:
-Until sinani starts seriously trying to play this game I am going to be pushing hard for his policy lynch no matter what in future games (I have to shamefully admit that half the reason I replaced into GMarshal's Pony game was to get sinani lynched).
So pro town.
|
On September 22 2011 00:28 tnkted wrote:Show nested quote +On September 22 2011 00:21 wherebugsgo wrote:On September 22 2011 00:18 tnkted wrote:
Bugs, what about this aren't you getting? We're about to find out if he was lying or not. We are putting your theory to the test. How is that not a good thing for town? I just explained to you why him giving you a piece is not an indicator of alignment. Think about it from a mafia perspective. He's been caught lying, fake breadcrumbing, and not reading the thread. His only chance not to get lynched is to take another gambit and send you the piece. I would say the worst, in fact, is the not reading the thread. That means he has no vested interest in scumhunting, just THINK about that before being so ready to believe his claim just because you receive a piece from him. Yes, but if the piece he sends me is truely the element of generosity, then he wasn't caught lying, fake breadcrumbing, OR not reading the thread. He was caught making a mistake. YOU DID THE SAME THING EARLIER THIS GAME, HOW CAN YOU GIVE HIM SHIT FOR IT?! Am I out of my mind? What the hell is happening? Am I not explaining this correctly?
Him sending the piece to anyone doesn't confirm anything!
Let's go over it all again (god it's annoying to be repeating myself like this)
Start by looking at his actions and mine from town and mafia perspectives.
1.) As town, you have a piece. It's been publicized for over a day that there are pieces out there, that you should claim if you have a piece, and you should give them to tnkted or Jackal.
Why would a townie breadcrumb in this instance? There's no reason to keep people guessing about what you have when pieces have been traveling for a full day. Breadcrumbing at this point creates confusion when you can just be direct.
Compare this to what I did. I breadcrumbed because it was not completely obvious what Jackal and tnkted were doing. I had reason to breadcrumb instead of outright claim since it wasn't publicized and no one was town confirmed. It would've been a stupid idea to claim but a great idea to breadcrumb.
The exact opposite holds true now. It's retarded to breadcrumb now that everything is out there unless you have an ulterior motive and are attempting to appear town.
2. His breadcrumb made no sense and established the fact that he has not read the thread.
Why on earth would anyone claim honesty when both Forumite and I sent our pieces to tnkted? You'd have to not read the thread to make a mistake like that. This fts with Nisani's lack of contribution. He can't contribute anything when he's not reading the thread, and the only thin he's added to the game is chaos.
He has no will to contribute. This slip confirms that, and that's extremely pro-mafia.
3. He OMGUSes any pony who suspects him. He's flip flopped his votes a few times today already and when he sees that/is called out on it he goes back to his terrible and unfounded tunnel on me.
4. This is not his first contradiction in this game. It's just the worst. Forget looking at this mistake by itself and start looking at it in the context of everything else he's done. He has a 6 page filter full of one liners that say absolutely nothing. He's a detriment to the town and I can't believe I need to fight you thick ponies this hard to get him lynched.
|
I breadcrumbed because I did not know if there was a specific person who was told that they needed the element. If I said HEY GUISE I GOTZ DA ELEMENT WHO WANTS IT HURRRR, then scum might ask for it. But breadcrumbing it would only make sense to the person who needed it (however obviously this got severely messed up because I was breadcrumbing the wrong element).
Mind explaining my other "contradictions"?
|
Nisani is unreadable and imo has done pro town and stupid things, not pro-scum.
LET'S FOCUS OUR ATTENTION ON FORUMITE, JACKAL AND CURU.
Causing no lynches. Lynching for lolz. Completely avoiding hunting scum.
LYNCH LYNCH LYNCH
|
On September 22 2011 03:34 Nisani201 wrote:
I breadcrumbed because I did not know if there was a specific person who was told that they needed the element. If I said HEY GUISE I GOTZ DA ELEMENT WHO WANTS IT HURRRR, then scum might ask for it. But breadcrumbing it would only make sense to the person who needed it (however obviously this got severely messed up because I was breadcrumbing the wrong element).
Mind explaining my other "contradictions"?
The stupid thing you did was breadcrumbing for an element that noone knew anything about. Every element in the game has since worked differently.
Honesty, 2 pieces
Loyalty, 2 pieces, holders may PM eachother until it´s combined.
Generosity, allready combined, activates only when given away to another pony.
Kindness, 2 pieces
Because noone has any idea what Generosity does, breadcrumbing that you have it does absolutely nothing. For the others at least one other player knew the other element was in play and how to activate it, so breadcrumbs actually works if the right person see it, but Generosity was an unknown, so breadcrumbing for it does nothing at all, except draw nightkills to you.
That being said, I´m just waiting for the piece to turn up before unvoting. It was a stupid mistake, but it´s not something a scum would do on purpose.
|
On September 22 2011 03:12 Lucidity wrote:
A name is not the same as a time.
I had to double check my element name before I posted as well.
There's no way I wouldn't know that I got an item AT THE START OF THE GAME.
Setting the facts straight: I got my piece of Honesty with the Day 1 post, not with the rolepost, it was around a realtime day between those.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
