EPTMy Little Pony Mafia - Page 10
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
GreYMisT
United States6736 Posts
| ||
|
Forumite
Sweden3280 Posts
On September 13 2011 09:06 GreYMisT wrote: I prefer policy posts and "plans" to the spam and trolling it takes to get some games started on day 1. Would you rather I didn't post at all? I feel that at least gets everyone on the same page. Otherwise we don't know where anyone stands on the mechanics of the game, and judging from games I have read on here that seems to muck up later days. Policy sounds good, although there haven´t been much so far. That´s not the problem I had with your post, my problem was that it seemed like you liked how we had played thus far, when it had been just spam and ponies. Don´t congratulate Town on inactivity and lurking. | ||
|
GreYMisT
United States6736 Posts
On September 13 2011 09:15 Forumite wrote: Policy sounds good, although there haven´t been much so far. That´s not the problem I had with your post, my problem was that it seemed like you liked how we had played thus far, when it had been just spam and ponies. Don´t congratulate Town on inactivity and lurking. Ok I see what you mean. How do you feel we should approach this closed setup on day 0/1? | ||
|
chaos13
Canada885 Posts
On September 13 2011 09:30 GreYMisT wrote: Ok I see what you mean. How do you feel we should approach this closed setup on day 0/1? By lynching Jackal58, because he is mafia. Pony mafia. | ||
|
Jackal58
United States4264 Posts
| ||
|
chaos13
Canada885 Posts
On September 13 2011 09:51 Jackal58 wrote: lol It's hilarious how awesome I am at hunting scum, right? | ||
|
wherebugsgo
Japan10647 Posts
| ||
|
Nisani201
United States1400 Posts
| ||
|
Forumite
Sweden3280 Posts
On September 13 2011 09:30 GreYMisT wrote: Ok I see what you mean. How do you feel we should approach this closed setup on day 0/1? It´s closed, so we can´t rely on cops, doctors and vigis. Still, I don´t think the core of the game has changed that much. There might be a 3rd Party, but I don´t expect multiple Scum-families like in Werewolf Mafia, the game is too small for that, and I don´t think GM would turn a Pony themed game into a slaughter like that game. Treating this as a normal games, with a few gimics, then we have talking, pressure and logic, the weapons of Town, and the hope of help from the blues. Personally, I don´t want to lynch lurkers or Jackal. Lynching Jackal for the fun of it is a mistake. Checking the last games, he´s often dead after the second night, mostly after he rolls Town and gets lynched anyway. He could be scum (Like in the CH game  ), but I´m not wasting time pushing to lynch him until he´s shown some real scumtells. Jackal does warrant a cop check though, if we have a detective out there. Voting, remember that it´s a majority lynch rule, the first day we need 8 votes, out of 13 players, to lynch. If we don´t, then noone dies, but scum gets a free night. I don´t want to go into what´s best between not lynching and getting a mislynch, just pointing out that if we want someone lynched, we need to agree as a whole and actively lynch. In this game, not voting on the leading candidate is a vote to save him. | ||
|
chaos13
Canada885 Posts
On September 13 2011 10:13 Forumite wrote: It´s closed, so we can´t rely on cops, doctors and vigis. Still, I don´t think the core of the game has changed that much. There might be a 3rd Party, but I don´t expect multiple Scum-families like in Werewolf Mafia, the game is too small for that, and I don´t think GM would turn a Pony themed game into a slaughter like that game. Treating this as a normal games, with a few gimics, then we have talking, pressure and logic, the weapons of Town, and the hope of help from the blues. Personally, I don´t want to lynch lurkers or Jackal. Lynching Jackal for the fun of it is a mistake. Checking the last games, he´s often dead after the second night, mostly after he rolls Town and gets lynched anyway. He could be scum (Like in the CH game ), but I´m not wasting time pushing to lynch him until he´s shown some real scumtells. Jackal does warrant a cop check though, if we have a detective out there. Voting, remember that it´s a majority lynch rule, the first day we need 8 votes, out of 13 players, to lynch. If we don´t, then noone dies, but scum gets a free night. I don´t want to go into what´s best between not lynching and getting a mislynch, just pointing out that if we want someone lynched, we need to agree as a whole and actively lynch. In this game, not voting on the leading candidate is a vote to save him. Hey, look at this. It's scum thinking my pressure on Jackal was real and not wanting to stand out by ignoring it. What exactly has Jackal done to warrant a cop check? | ||
|
Nisani201
United States1400 Posts
| ||
|
Forumite
Sweden3280 Posts
On September 13 2011 10:19 chaos13 wrote: Hey, look at this. It's scum thinking my pressure on Jackal was real and not wanting to stand out by ignoring it. What exactly has Jackal done to warrant a cop check? Please, you didn´t even attempt to make that pressure look anything but a joke. | ||
|
chaos13
Canada885 Posts
On September 13 2011 10:42 Forumite wrote: Please, you didn´t even attempt to make that pressure look anything but a joke. Answer the question. | ||
|
OriginalName
Canada1140 Posts
On September 13 2011 10:13 Forumite wrote: It´s closed, so we can´t rely on cops, doctors and vigis. Still, I don´t think the core of the game has changed that much. There might be a 3rd Party, but I don´t expect multiple Scum-families like in Werewolf Mafia, the game is too small for that, and I don´t think GM would turn a Pony themed game into a slaughter like that game. Treating this as a normal games, with a few gimics, then we have talking, pressure and logic, the weapons of Town, and the hope of help from the blues. Personally, I don´t want to lynch lurkers or Jackal. Lynching Jackal for the fun of it is a mistake. Checking the last games, he´s often dead after the second night, mostly after he rolls Town and gets lynched anyway. He could be scum (Like in the CH game ), but I´m not wasting time pushing to lynch him until he´s shown some real scumtells. Jackal does warrant a cop check though, if we have a detective out there. Voting, remember that it´s a majority lynch rule, the first day we need 8 votes, out of 13 players, to lynch. If we don´t, then noone dies, but scum gets a free night. I don´t want to go into what´s best between not lynching and getting a mislynch, just pointing out that if we want someone lynched, we need to agree as a whole and actively lynch. In this game, not voting on the leading candidate is a vote to save him. Am I the only who sees this as just a huge pile of fluff? | ||
|
Forumite
Sweden3280 Posts
Jackal is a good player, and if Town don´t lynch him to be safe, then Scum kill him off. We can´t do anything to stop a scumkill, but if he´s up for a lynch, then, judging by earlier results on lynching Jackal, it´s probably better to make a cop-check than lynching him blind. The cop doesn´t have to claim just because he checks, though, if he thinks he can survive to check a night or two more. | ||
|
chaos13
Canada885 Posts
On September 13 2011 10:54 Forumite wrote: Jackal is a good player, and if Town don´t lynch him to be safe, then Scum kill him off. We can´t do anything to stop a scumkill, but if he´s up for a lynch, then, judging by earlier results on lynching Jackal, it´s probably better to make a cop-check than lynching him blind. The cop doesn´t have to claim just because he checks, though, if he thinks he can survive to check a night or two more. So in other words you think he warrants a check because he has an equally good chance at being mafia as any other random person selected from the player list? | ||
|
Nisani201
United States1400 Posts
And before you go all WWM on me, I can confirm that this was in the night post. | ||
|
Forumite
Sweden3280 Posts
On September 13 2011 10:58 chaos13 wrote: So in other words you think he warrants a check because he has an equally good chance at being mafia as any other random person selected from the player list? Hmmm, yeah, sounds about right. Jackal is the player in this game that I most want to know the alignment of. If he´s Town, then he can help a lot, and we definetly shouldn´t do Scum a favor and lynch him, let them waste a nightkill instead. If he´s Scum, then we find him with a check, even if he´s doing his best "confirmed Town" act. Do you disagree? | ||
|
chaos13
Canada885 Posts
| ||
|
wherebugsgo
Japan10647 Posts
On September 13 2011 10:58 chaos13 wrote: So in other words you think he warrants a check because he has an equally good chance at being mafia as any other random person selected from the player list? lol this exchange is pretty funny, especially when you put it like that. Chaos do you think Forumite is mafia? | ||
| ||
