You're right Sev is very suspicious but the problem is that we have a dozen people just like him, people that are barely active aren't posting many opinions and are generally difficult to get reads on. But you know who stands out? Palmer. I don't know why he's gotten away with this until now but he seriously has like a dozen posts that say nothing but kill DB, normally stepping into the spotlight and accusing someone is very townie but he isn't stepping into the spotlight he's just repeating kill DB and giving one shitty meta argument that basically boils down to "trust me". Well I don't.

##Vote: Palmar

Navillus

United States1188 Posts

August 20 2011 14:38 GMT

#400

I need sleep and can't really think straight but here is the lurker list you all wanted so badly, please, please no need to thank me...

Trotske-2 game related posts
Lucidity-2 Maybe kinda sorta game related posts
Jackal58-1 maybe 2 game related posts (this suprised me, more on it later)
Hiro Protagonist-1 game related post
Munk-E-1 (large) game related post
Darkponcho-NOTHING
Vain-2 game related posts
Kurumi-No posts for 36+ hours

Now this isn't here to try to redirect the conversation we seem to be doing well enough on our own, but the big thing I want noted is I couldn't even start to look for semi-lurkers for the list because there are so many people hardcore lurking right now, this is exactly what I want to avoid because if we keep getting nothing out of 8 people, late game we won't have anything close to a read on them and that's big trouble.

Back to the current discussion I am still very suspicious of Palmer but that lynch doesn't look like it will happen, I'm voting xtfftc because for now quicksilver has convinced me but I definitely will be back in time for the lynch and to get a better judgement myself which leads me to

We need to decide who our 2 main candidates are soon, if we don't have 2 options in time for everyone to vote based on that then we may well see a no-lynch, that is not good.

Last, to palmar, you're suspicious of Brownbear for trying to deflect a lynch, that would naturally imply that the person he's deflecting the lynch from would also be scum, are you still convinced that DB is scum?

Navillus

United States1188 Posts

August 21 2011 00:52 GMT

#570

Dammit I've been busy, but Palmar's right Sev is not scum there was way too little kickback on this vote like 1 person defended him, I'll take a no-lynch over lynching a townie. Bleh I went to sleep at the wrong time ><

Navillus

United States1188 Posts

August 21 2011 00:59 GMT

#574

On August 21 2011 09:54 Trotske wrote:

Show nested quote +

Just curious about the reasons behind your vote on BrownBear. you didn't post anything in the thread.

Btw i'm for a vote switch onto razor

He was tied for the most non-sev votes and was suspicious to me but I'm switching to razor now since he too is very suspicious and more importantly has a shot of getting the vote instead of sev

Navillus

United States1188 Posts

August 21 2011 01:14 GMT

#589

Ok guys, all the scum voting for Sev obviously won't switch their votes, but if you are town and you are voting for sev please switch it's very unlikely that he's scum because he got bandwagoned so easily and when there were plenty of options he was the one bandwagoned, scum wouldn't let that happen to one of their own this will also let us get better reads on the people who leave their votes on sev.

Navillus

United States1188 Posts

August 21 2011 01:25 GMT

#599

Yeah but we all agreed to switch back if we had to to avoid a no-lynch so anyone that doesn't do that and causes a no-lynch is scum.

Navillus

United States1188 Posts

August 21 2011 01:27 GMT

#600

that was in response to this

On August 21 2011 10:15 wherebugsgo wrote:
Yeah, but the problem is that scum could easily want a no-lynch too.

In fact, wouldn't they prefer a no-lynch? In that case it's equally likely for them to switch, or stay on Sev!

Navillus

United States1188 Posts

August 21 2011 01:54 GMT

#634

Switching

Navillus

United States1188 Posts

August 21 2011 01:55 GMT

#636

I sorta hope Sev isn't mafia or I'd feel like an idiot

Navillus

United States1188 Posts

August 21 2011 02:04 GMT

#645

Super I hope you're not being sarcastic, everyone else I DON'T ACTUALLY WANT HIM TO BE A TOWNIE, I said sorta as in I mostly hope he's mafia but if he is I'm going to feel like a moron, I can guarantee you that if I were mafia I would never post that because I would 1. know what he is and 2. not be dumb enough to post something saying I hope that he's town, especially because I wouldn't need to hope, it wouldn't even make sense to post that if I were mafia

Navillus

United States1188 Posts

August 21 2011 02:12 GMT

#650

That's so sad :'(

Navillus

United States1188 Posts

August 23 2011 13:10 GMT

#1094

Oooooooh boy, this thread exploded... sorry I haven't been posting, I've been really busy IRL and just read up to here, though not extremely in-depth. Bleh... anyway about supersoft, your clame says liquidite not necrophiliac liquidite I don't know if it's standard for millers to know or not know that they're millers but if they do know, are you claiming miller or not? If so why would you remove the necrophiliac part?

Navillus

United States1188 Posts

August 23 2011 13:13 GMT

#1098

All that tells us is he didn't try to make up his own claim but I don't think anyone would given free fakeclaims so... it doesn't really tell us anything.

Navillus

United States1188 Posts

August 23 2011 13:15 GMT

#1099

Also about millers, is it standard for flavor to hint at someone being a miller? For example his says he's a retired serial killer which looks like he would have as the OP says, dead bodies in his closet, is that meant to be relevant?

Navillus

United States1188 Posts

August 24 2011 12:39 GMT

#1503

Hey guys, sorry I forgot to vote and haven't been active, to be honest the thread exploding sorta scared me off for a while but I'm caught up, have free time, and am hunting through everything. To start I need to ask: Palmar I just was filtering your posts and you had quite the change of heart over Mig, you might have already explained it but could you please go over exactly what made you change your mind so heavily about him being scum?

Navillus

United States1188 Posts

August 24 2011 12:41 GMT

#1504

Also thank you GMarshal I really appreciate you not mod-killing me and I promise to stay active from here on out.

Navillus

United States1188 Posts

August 25 2011 02:16 GMT

#1571

##Vote Brownbear

Palmar was town, he clearly was positive that Brownbear was scum, he's smart enough to get accurate reads, and everything foolishness said. This should be a no-brainer.

As to mig I wasn't here when Mig became suspicious and I'm gonna go look for it and through all of his posts but could someone just explain why he's such a big candidate?

Navillus

United States1188 Posts

August 26 2011 19:49 GMT

#1707

I agree with lucidity, also I think there's more information to be gained about how people have been interacting with a BB lynch.

##Vote Brownbear

Navillus

United States1188 Posts

August 27 2011 07:36 GMT

#1776

Honestly I'm having a hell of a time just keeping up with the thread, I've never survived a game this long and I'm frankly really confused.

Navillus

United States1188 Posts

August 29 2011 19:36 GMT

#1977

Ahhhhhhh don't modkill me! sorry I had my power go out the day after the hurricane, ok I didn't miss a vote but give me time to catch up, if the night post is like about to happen then

##Vote Brownbear

just so I have a vote in but really I have to read everything from the last day or so.