Here is why I'm voting BM over BC:

BM has been given the sheriff role, the strongest town role and has used it as following:

Night one: Jailing Lanaia. He has a red read on Lanaia and explained that he was trying to reduce mafia kp. The problem? It was impossible to reduce mafia kp on day one by jailing a red.

Night two: No jail. On this night, he was a detective + medic, due to the way the kp formula worked. He was instructed to jail L, the mafia godfather, which would have reduced the mafia kp and outed their godfather as scum. Targeting any of the eight remaining mafia would have reduced the kp and outed the target as scum. Targeting a town would have protected them from any potential hits and strongly point towards their innocence if the mafia kp was not affected.

Night three: No jail. BM is on the chopping block and essentially the one thing he can do to redeem himself is to block a mafia kp. Why isn't he jailing a strong town read? For all we know, he could be the one responsible for the hiro roleblock.

He calls prot scum, yet apparently is removing the bomb from him? If BM is the lynch target and mafia has no reason to believe that prot no longer has a bomb on him, why are they shooting prot last night? As for the ggq shot, I think it was pretty clear prot got a green check on him.

hiro, I really don't understand why you would withhold a check if you're an outed dt. They may be clean in your eyes, but you have no idea how things will turn out days from now. You really should be crumbing your clean check before the next day post.

kitaman27

United States9245 Posts

January 23 2012 23:08 GMT

#3898

On January 24 2012 06:36 Jayjay54 wrote:
hey kita / opz. any chance you can post that log?

Page 171.

BrownBear, any reason you haven't said anything this game? You have 15 out of 4000 posts and that's counting the spam and /ins. The things you do decide to comment on are strange, considering all the more important topics. Are you just waiting until you have to argue out of a lynch or do you actually plan to start playing 250 hours into the game?

kitaman27

United States9245 Posts

January 23 2012 23:57 GMT

#3911

Opz wrote:
btw. I was just perusing the thread. Your post on Bill Murray sucks. Or I'm just reading impaired.

I felt this was the weirdest comment made by opz. He calls the following post "bad", but doesn't explain why. I think they seem like pretty legitimate questions. Does he have knowledge that BM will flip town or something?

+ Show Spoiler +

On January 20 2012 07:52 kitaman27 wrote:
Would you please respond to these few remarks BM? Thanks.

Show nested quote +

Uhh, what happened here? He goes from one of your lynch candidates to confirmed town without any reference in between?

+ Show Spoiler +

On January 13 2012 16:25 Bill Murray wrote:
I have a towntell on someone, as well to top shit off

On January 13 2012 16:26 Bill Murray wrote:
I have a legitimate towntell from someone else

On January 17 2012 11:53 Bill Murray wrote:
I have a confirmed town, too, pretty much

On January 17 2012 20:29 Bill Murray wrote:
kita, in regards to your list of lurkers, I view two of them as town for certain reasons

What is the point of these generic "towntell" posts. Do you think they benefit the thread or do they only serve to make you look good?

Show nested quote +

Could you explain your reasoning at this point?

Here is the mafia kp chart:

KP - #
4 - 10
4 - 9
4 - 8
3 - 7

On night 1, there were ten mafia alive. Therefore to lower the kp, you would have to jail three different scum players. I'm pretty sure that's not possible.

Show nested quote +

You clarify it here. So you're protecting her because you thought she was town? I thought it was to reduce the scum kp? Wasn't she on your scum list? Could you please elaborate on your intentions?

Show nested quote +

Why are you so trusting with something as important as the BG names?

So now you're claiming madhatter because you want one more day to live. Who is your bomb on? You can't be roleblocked, so there is no harm in revealing.

kitaman27

United States9245 Posts

January 24 2012 02:41 GMT

#3977

20 minutes

kitaman27

United States9245 Posts

January 24 2012 03:02 GMT

#3988

^_^

kitaman27

United States9245 Posts

January 24 2012 03:07 GMT

#3997

Kinda sucks that the scum lost a kp due to modkills, but I guess it somewhat balances out with the 5 town modkills

kitaman27

United States9245 Posts

January 24 2012 03:12 GMT

#4012

Props to BM for earning himself an extra day of life and causing a mislynch with his silly claim :p

It should be noted that if mafia doesn't have a roleblocker, it is very likely the rb was on hiro, if he is indeed our dt.

kitaman27

United States9245 Posts

January 24 2012 03:13 GMT

#4015

On January 24 2012 12:12 kitaman27 wrote:
Props to BM for earning himself an extra day of life and causing a mislynch with his silly claim :p

It should be noted that if mafia doesn't have a roleblocker, it is very likely the rb was on hiro, if he is indeed our dt.

Err by rb, I mean sheriff jail.

kitaman27

United States9245 Posts

January 24 2012 03:15 GMT

#4018

hiro, can you confirm that your day two dt target is still alive?

kitaman27

United States9245 Posts

January 24 2012 03:28 GMT

#4041

On January 24 2012 12:24 hiro protagonist wrote:

Show nested quote +

nope, I asked FW about this, If someone is jailed, they get a message saying they are incarcerated.
They get a message that they where roleblocked if they are roleblocked.

So mafia still has a roleblocker, as I was told I was roleblocked, not incarcerated.

Is your night two check still alive?