• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EDT 17:53
CEST 23:53
KST 06:53
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Serral wins EWC 202540Tournament Spotlight: FEL Cracow 202510Power Rank - Esports World Cup 202580RSL Season 1 - Final Week9[ASL19] Finals Recap: Standing Tall15
Community News
Weekly Cups (Jul 28-Aug 3): herO doubles up5LiuLi Cup - August 2025 Tournaments3[BSL 2025] H2 - Team Wars, Weeklies & SB Ladder10EWC 2025 - Replay Pack4Google Play ASL (Season 20) Announced55
StarCraft 2
General
TL Team Map Contest #5: Presented by Monster Energy Clem Interview: "PvT is a bit insane right now" Serral wins EWC 2025 Would you prefer the game to be balanced around top-tier pro level or average pro level? Weekly Cups (Jul 28-Aug 3): herO doubles up
Tourneys
WardiTV Mondays $5,000 WardiTV Summer Championship 2025 Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament LiuLi Cup - August 2025 Tournaments Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond)
Strategy
Custom Maps
External Content
Mutation # 485 Death from Below Mutation # 484 Magnetic Pull Mutation #239 Bad Weather Mutation # 483 Kill Bot Wars
Brood War
General
How do you go up to people? How do the new Battle.net ranks translate? Nobody gona talk about this year crazy qualifiers? Help, I can't log into staredit.net BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/
Tourneys
[ASL20] Online Qualifiers Day 2 [Megathread] Daily Proleagues Cosmonarchy Pro Showmatches [ASL20] Online Qualifiers Day 1
Strategy
Simple Questions, Simple Answers [G] Mineral Boosting Muta micro map competition Does 1 second matter in StarCraft?
Other Games
General Games
Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Total Annihilation Server - TAForever Nintendo Switch Thread Beyond All Reason [MMORPG] Tree of Savior (Successor of Ragnarok)
Dota 2
Official 'what is Dota anymore' discussion
League of Legends
Heroes of the Storm
Simple Questions, Simple Answers Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Heroes of StarCraft mini-set
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread Vanilla Mini Mafia
Community
General
Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine European Politico-economics QA Mega-thread US Politics Mega-thread 9/11 Anniversary Possible Al Qaeda Attack on 9/11
Fan Clubs
INnoVation Fan Club SKT1 Classic Fan Club!
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! [Manga] One Piece Anime Discussion Thread [\m/] Heavy Metal Thread Korean Music Discussion
Sports
2024 - 2025 Football Thread Formula 1 Discussion TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Gtx660 graphics card replacement Installation of Windows 10 suck at "just a moment" Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
TeamLiquid Team Shirt On Sale The Automated Ban List
Blogs
[Girl blog} My fema…
artosisisthebest
Sharpening the Filtration…
frozenclaw
ASL S20 English Commentary…
namkraft
The Link Between Fitness and…
TrAiDoS
momentary artworks from des…
tankgirl
from making sc maps to makin…
Husyelt
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 610 users

TL Mafia XLIII

Forum Index > TL Mafia
Post a Reply
Normal
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 01 2011 02:23 GMT
#7
WHY PM'S WHYYYYYYYYYYYYY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!



/IN
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 01 2011 20:25 GMT
#103
EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEERECTIN A DISPENSER.
confirmed.

Dayvigs even if your shot isn't up for debate or negotiable, still claim your shot before you use it, give the player getting shot a chance to say his last words, give suspicions etc...

As always hatters probably shouldn't plac their bombs n1 unless they have near confirmed scum. the last thing we need is a hatter dying and bringing 2 townies with him.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 01 2011 20:32 GMT
#105
Does the sniper shoot by typing ##shoot in the thread like the soldier if he wants to use his day shot?
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 01 2011 21:26 GMT
#113
iirc r1ch banned coag from pm'ing once cuz he sent out so many.

and Varpulis doesnt speak for me..
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 01 2011 21:39 GMT
#118
not doing that too much work/complicated...
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 01 2011 21:53 GMT
#121
I really dont think vig should shoot day 1. We can't all be redff.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 01 2011 23:04 GMT
#139
On August 02 2011 07:32 Drazerk wrote:
Also I agree with Sand's plan. The sooner we have confirmed town players the better.

The sooner we have random dead townies the better too i guess? Dayvig if you are going to shoot call your shot and let town discuss.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 01 2011 23:46 GMT
#158
...lol post the irc chat please, that is not a decent reason. Regardless, have any of you guys a scum saying he's a vig and figuring out who the other shots are at? or a scum saying he's a medic and finding out who's protecting who? I've played games where everyone has claimed to a "confirmed townie" and scum have raped and taken advantage of this, so please don't tell me the plan is faultless. If a vig is willing to use his shot as a lynch then it's ok. But I'm really not sure that day 1 is the best time to have a double lynch. Yeah the day when we have the least information and most likely to lynch town is when we should double lynch!

There, that's my opinion if you think it's scummy then vote me. Draz post what was scummy in the irc chat please.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 01 2011 23:54 GMT
#163
On August 02 2011 08:51 Curu wrote:
Huh? I don't understand your post. The confirmed Townie tells the player who he is going to shoot or protect, he doesn't tell all Medics what every Medic is doing.

Since we know how much KP Mafia has I very much doubt any of them are going to be able to claim Vig.

So you want one townie conducting every single vig hit/medic protect/hatter bomb?

k here's an example.

Mafia-I will be protecting player x
Confirmed townie-no someone else is protecting him.

now mafia know's to not hit player x.


I would be more open to this plan day 2 or 3. But all i see is 2 townies getting lynched and losing a dayvig and that person most likely dying the next night.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 02 2011 00:01 GMT
#170
On August 02 2011 09:00 Curu wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 02 2011 08:54 redFF wrote:
On August 02 2011 08:51 Curu wrote:
Huh? I don't understand your post. The confirmed Townie tells the player who he is going to shoot or protect, he doesn't tell all Medics what every Medic is doing.

Since we know how much KP Mafia has I very much doubt any of them are going to be able to claim Vig.

So you want one townie conducting every single vig hit/medic protect/hatter bomb?

k here's an example.

Mafia-I will be protecting player x
Confirmed townie-no someone else is protecting him.

now mafia know's to not hit player x.


I would be more open to this plan day 2 or 3. But all i see is 2 townies getting lynched and losing a dayvig and that person most likely dying the next night.


No, it goes like this:

Mafia-I will be protecting player x
Confirmed townie-stfu I choose who you protect, you'll be protecting player y
Mafia-Okay...

I'm not comfortable with having 1 townie direct all of the blue actions. What if the townie is wrong about things/terrible? then we are screwed...
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 02 2011 00:03 GMT
#172
k drazerk left out part of the conversation. read the whole thing and decide if i'm scum+ Show Spoiler +

[7:30pm] Lucidity:
does dochelvetica ever use punctuation?
[7:31pm] Lucidity:
I find myself out of breath reading his posts
[7:39pm] alanismorisette:
...
[7:39pm] alanismorisette:
lol
[7:42pm] Curu joined the chat room.
[7:42pm] Curu:
redFF made no jokes at the start of PTP
[7:42pm] Curu:
and he was Town
[7:42pm] Curu:
COINCIDENCE?
[7:43pm] alanismorisette:
...
[7:43pm] alanismorisette:
didnt i make jokes?
[7:43pm] alanismorisette:
i did
[7:44pm] alanismorisette:
give me the wand imo
[7:44pm] alanismorisette:
that was one
[7:44pm] alanismorisette:
and i kept tlpdizing everything
[7:44pm] alanismorisette:
thats why lanaia
[7:44pm] mig__:
great jokes
[7:45pm] mig__:
red are you actually trying to defend yourself on whether you made jokes or not?
[7:45pm] Drazerk:
Red is so scummy >.<
[7:45pm] alanismorisette:
...
[7:45pm] alanismorisette:
how
[7:46pm] alanismorisette:
is ptp over yet?
[7:46pm] Drazerk:
not yet
[7:46pm] mig__:
its weird that you seem to be actually trying to defend yourself when people are clearly fucking around with you
[7:46pm] mig__:
concerning the jokes
[7:46pm] Drazerk:
also the fact that your opposing sand's plan
[7:47pm] Lucidity:
opposing with no reasons
[7:47pm] Lucidity:
opposing is fine tbh
[7:49pm] alanismorisette:
well
[7:49pm] alanismorisette:
im not opposing
[7:49pm] alanismorisette:
im just saying that vigs shooting day 1
[7:49pm] alanismorisette:
is not necessarily amazing
[7:49pm] alanismorisette:
u gain a confirmed town
[7:49pm] alanismorisette:
but u may lose a town too
[7:49pm] Drazerk:
not if we are doing it how sand proposes
[7:50pm] Drazerk:
in that case it would just be the same as lynching a townie which is much worse
[7:50pm] alanismorisette:
yeah
[7:50pm] alanismorisette:
i guess
[7:50pm] Curu:
you also had no problem shooting on like page 1 of your other game as day vig
[7:50pm] alanismorisette:
i dunno if today is the day i wanna double lynch
[7:50pm] alanismorisette:
but that time i shot the gf
[7:50pm] alanismorisette:
he was obv
[7:51pm] alanismorisette:
its different when there arent obvscum
[7:51pm] Curu:
this time we might too ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
[7:51pm] Curu:
didnt you shoot him cause he made some pump up town post
[7:54pm] alanismorisette:
well
[7:54pm] alanismorisette:
kita random voted
[7:54pm] alanismorisette:
and he was like
[7:54pm] alanismorisette:
you shouldn;t do it this early in the game, town has lost games recently and we need to pull ourselves together. etcetc
[7:55pm] alanismorisette:
then he made another post
[7:55pm] alanismorisette:
telling everyone to read his vigi guide
[7:55pm] alanismorisette:
and then he made another post attacking someone for a joke
[7:55pm] alanismorisette:
plus there was one guy defending him who looked scummy too(and was the rb)
[7:55pm] alanismorisette:
so i shot him
[7:55pm] alanismorisette:
hey draz
[7:56pm] alanismorisette:
reasonless votes not good
[7:56pm] alanismorisette:
post the irc chat
[7:56pm] alanismorisette:
s
[7:56pm] alanismorisette:
so people can see ur reasoning
[7:56pm] alanismorisette:
Drazerk:
[7:56pm] Drazerk:
want me to copy the IRC for you then?
[7:56pm] Drazerk:
I will do it lol
[7:57pm] alanismorisette:
yeah
[7:57pm] alanismorisette:
please
[7:57pm] alanismorisette:
if you're gonna vote
[7:57pm] Rinku left the chat room. (Ping timeout)
[7:57pm] alanismorisette:
show people the evidnece
[7:57pm] alanismorisette:
also
[7:57pm] alanismorisette:
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=249971&currentpage=8#147
[7:57pm] alanismorisette:
that is why this plan on day 1 double lynch is terrible
[7:57pm] Drazerk:
I am not jumping on a bandwagon
[7:57pm] alanismorisette:
the day when we are most likely to lynch town is when we should double lynch!
[7:57pm] alanismorisette:
yay!
[7:58pm] Drazerk:
we have actually got a decent track record day 1 at the moment
[7:58pm] Drazerk:
when we kill you
[7:58pm] Drazerk:
we will have a even better one
[7:59pm] alanismorisette:
Drazerk: pleaes tell me why im scum
[7:59pm] alanismorisette:
please
[7:59pm] alanismorisette:
just make one post
[7:59pm] alanismorisette:
on the thread
[7:59pm] alanismorisette:
outlining why i am scum
[7:59pm] sandroba left the chat room. (Ping timeout)
[7:59pm] alanismorisette:
you have no reasons apart from opposing a flawed plan with perfectly reasonable reasons
[8:00pm] alanismorisette:
and from me pointing out that it is in my meta to joke day 1
[8:02pm] alanismorisette:
Drazerk:
[8:02pm] alanismorisette:
why am i scum
[8:03pm] Drazerk:
wishy washy play - Hating a very good town plan when "Oh noes we may accidencently kill a scummy town player" and the whole fact you are defending yourself this hard over a joke and a pressure vote
[8:04pm] alanismorisette:
.....
[8:04pm] alanismorisette:
k
[8:05pm] alanismorisette:
it is not a "very good town plan"
[8:05pm] alanismorisette:
it wasnt defending myself hard over a joke
[8:05pm] Drazerk:
II'd rather kill a useless towny than lynch a useless towny
[8:05pm] alanismorisette:
curu made a statement and i responded
[8:05pm] alanismorisette:
now ur saying im a useless townie?
[8:06pm] alanismorisette:
chill with the insults and twisting my words dude
[8:06pm] Curu:
what
[8:06pm] Curu:
i never asid you were useless townie
[8:06pm] alanismorisette:
no
[8:06pm] alanismorisette:
drazerk is
[8:06pm] Curu:
oh
[8:06pm] Drazerk:
I never said you was a useless townie - I was refering to the plan
[8:06pm] Drazerk:
Your a very bad scum membet
[8:06pm] Drazerk:
member*
[8:07pm] alanismorisette:
drazerk
[8:07pm] alanismorisette:
i've played like 10x more games then you
[8:07pm] alanismorisette:
stop calling me bad
[8:07pm] alanismorisette:
also
[8:07pm] alanismorisette:
the plan is bad
[8:07pm] alanismorisette:
because
[8:08pm] alanismorisette:
we will most likely lynch 2 townies and then mafia will double stack the dayvig tonight
[8:08pm] alanismorisette:
how is that a good plan?
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 02 2011 00:39 GMT
#189
I don't see why i am being fos'ed for opposing this plan.

Why would we want to enforce a double lynch and use a dayvig shot day 1, when we can use it later game when we have a far higher chance of hitting mafia. All this plan will most likely do is kill 3 townies and lose us a dayvig shot which can be far more useful later on. Idk what the fuck is going on when its a good idea to double lynch day 1. It seems to be the proponents of this plan are just like LETS KILL TOWNIES FASTER!!!!1111ONEONE!!!

If anything it's scummy to defend this plan and then just call whoever is against it scum with zero reasoning. We lynch today, vigs for the most part should hold their shots, and we win this game by scumhunting, not by some kooky plan Sandroba made up in 5 minutes.

Pros
1. get a confirmed townie
2. Every blue claims to this townie??

Cons
1. Double lynch on the day when we are most likely to lynch town.
2. Mafia can infiltrate pm circle
3. One townie directing all blue actions
4. Confirmed townie will most likely be shot
5. We lose a dayvig shot early when it can be put into far better use later on in the game.

Someone please put forward a convincing argument as to why this plan is good aside from pulling a Drazerk and going "lolscum"
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 02 2011 14:24 GMT
#229
On August 02 2011 16:26 youngminii wrote:
fairly certain redff is scum
he's playing exactly like that other game where i was scum with him
i'm sorry red but your scum play is so obvious

On August 02 2011 19:35 Lucidity wrote:
Haha, I guess I was still in the Asylum mindset with mass blue everywhere - somehow thought that all 7 blue roles listed would be in the game. ~4 blues make sense and we're very unlikely to have 2 medics in that, so a plan to coordinate them this early isn't actually that great.

I think the only time that we should be claiming is if Mafia only have 1 KP left or if a Day Vig hits a Vet, leaving us with 2 confirmed townies. One of them will survive the night and be able to pass on info~

redFF, forever RED?

to shitty fos's with absolutely no reasoning. This is funny...
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 02 2011 20:09 GMT
#275
What's this about Kenpachi?

Anyways, this discussion is quickly devolving into spam/insults. The plan has been shown to be flawed and I think at this stage it is out of the question for now.

Also Varpulis-role fish much? Dayvigs don't claim lol.

If you are a dayvig you have to think, do I use my shot now and probably hit a townie and then die? Or do i wait and kill a mafia with a BOSS DAYKILL later in the game?

I'm still waiting on both YM, Drazerk and Lucidity to tell me why I am scum.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 02 2011 20:32 GMT
#297
on Lucidity.

On August 02 2011 08:11 Lucidity wrote:
So we've already found 2 scum in redFF and DoctorHelvetica who are opposing the plan without any real reasons? Good stuff.

A confirmed townie coordinating blues is brilliant. The only problem I can see is if scum impersonates medics. That could give away blue roles/leave our soldier vulnerable. Solution? Just have all medics protect the soldier for night 1. 1 Night of coordinated abilities is quite powerful and we'll have more info on Day 2.

Apparently because people opposed a plan which has very real and obvious faults and holes makes someone scum... Although at this stage he could be just a dumb/inexperienced player not thinking. But calling me and DrH scum because we disagree with the plan is pretty funny.


On August 02 2011 09:01 Lucidity wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 02 2011 08:46 redFF wrote:
...lol post the irc chat please, that is not a decent reason. Regardless, have any of you guys a scum saying he's a vig and figuring out who the other shots are at? or a scum saying he's a medic and finding out who's protecting who? I've played games where everyone has claimed to a "confirmed townie" and scum have raped and taken advantage of this, so please don't tell me the plan is faultless. If a vig is willing to use his shot as a lynch then it's ok. But I'm really not sure that day 1 is the best time to have a double lynch. Yeah the day when we have the least information and most likely to lynch town is when we should double lynch!

There, that's my opinion if you think it's scummy then vote me. Draz post what was scummy in the irc chat please.

How will he figure out who the other vig shots are aimed at? How will a fake medic find out who the other medics are protecting? Who said the plan is faultless?

I think I'll take your advice and vote for you!

##vote redFF



If there isn't a great candidate for day vig I agree with heist's Day 2 proposal. We don't really want to use our vigi's and hatters on Night 1 anyway, do we? Confirmed townie might be more effective on Day 2. The only problem is the risk of losing him on Night 1...

So he see's a vote for me and thinks he can start an easy bandwagon on someone because at that stage in the game the plan had a lot of support. My point was a scum could be like-protecting this guy and if the confirmed townie said don't the scum could infer that that guy already had medic protection. We've already established the plan has major flaws esp on day 1 so i won't go back into that.

The vote though doesn't really have any reasoning apart from attacking the plan, the points i was making were valid imo.

Also he didn't actually vote for me in the thread, which I find pretty funny. That just seems like mafia trying to kick off a bandwagon and the turning around and looking at the votes and calling people scummy when i flip town...


On August 03 2011 05:20 Lucidity wrote:
If it's such a waste of time why are you dedicating any time at all to it anymore? I don't think there has been serious majority support for the plan for long now, so there's no reason for you to talk about it. Every Day 1 has to start in some useless way before there's something to discuss. Why not use the posts that have been generated by this plan to start some discussion which you think might be useful?

Ok then don't ask other people to do it just do it. This post is complete shit, all it does is ask other people to contribute when he hasn't even contributed himself.


##Vote Lucidity
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 02 2011 20:48 GMT
#299
Also nowhere in the op does it say that all the roles listed are the only roles in the game. Technically we could have a mafia dayvig :O.


Are all possible roles listed in the op?
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 02 2011 21:29 GMT
#308
On August 03 2011 06:13 Lucidity wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 03 2011 05:32 redFF wrote:
on Lucidity.

On August 02 2011 08:11 Lucidity wrote:
So we've already found 2 scum in redFF and DoctorHelvetica who are opposing the plan without any real reasons? Good stuff.

A confirmed townie coordinating blues is brilliant. The only problem I can see is if scum impersonates medics. That could give away blue roles/leave our soldier vulnerable. Solution? Just have all medics protect the soldier for night 1. 1 Night of coordinated abilities is quite powerful and we'll have more info on Day 2.

Apparently because people opposed a plan which has very real and obvious faults and holes makes someone scum... Although at this stage he could be just a dumb/inexperienced player not thinking. But calling me and DrH scum because we disagree with the plan is pretty funny.


On August 02 2011 09:01 Lucidity wrote:
On August 02 2011 08:46 redFF wrote:
...lol post the irc chat please, that is not a decent reason. Regardless, have any of you guys a scum saying he's a vig and figuring out who the other shots are at? or a scum saying he's a medic and finding out who's protecting who? I've played games where everyone has claimed to a "confirmed townie" and scum have raped and taken advantage of this, so please don't tell me the plan is faultless. If a vig is willing to use his shot as a lynch then it's ok. But I'm really not sure that day 1 is the best time to have a double lynch. Yeah the day when we have the least information and most likely to lynch town is when we should double lynch!

There, that's my opinion if you think it's scummy then vote me. Draz post what was scummy in the irc chat please.

How will he figure out who the other vig shots are aimed at? How will a fake medic find out who the other medics are protecting? Who said the plan is faultless?

I think I'll take your advice and vote for you!

##vote redFF



If there isn't a great candidate for day vig I agree with heist's Day 2 proposal. We don't really want to use our vigi's and hatters on Night 1 anyway, do we? Confirmed townie might be more effective on Day 2. The only problem is the risk of losing him on Night 1...

So he see's a vote for me and thinks he can start an easy bandwagon on someone because at that stage in the game the plan had a lot of support. My point was a scum could be like-protecting this guy and if the confirmed townie said don't the scum could infer that that guy already had medic protection. We've already established the plan has major flaws esp on day 1 so i won't go back into that.

The vote though doesn't really have any reasoning apart from attacking the plan, the points i was making were valid imo.

Also he didn't actually vote for me in the thread, which I find pretty funny. That just seems like mafia trying to kick off a bandwagon and the turning around and looking at the votes and calling people scummy when i flip town...


On August 03 2011 05:20 Lucidity wrote:
If it's such a waste of time why are you dedicating any time at all to it anymore? I don't think there has been serious majority support for the plan for long now, so there's no reason for you to talk about it. Every Day 1 has to start in some useless way before there's something to discuss. Why not use the posts that have been generated by this plan to start some discussion which you think might be useful?

Ok then don't ask other people to do it just do it. This post is complete shit, all it does is ask other people to contribute when he hasn't even contributed himself.


##Vote Lucidity


I wasn't saying you're scummy for opposing the plan. Your reasons provided were horrible, which I found suspicious. This isn't worth thread space as it's quite obvious, but if you're interested read the spoiler.
Show nested quote +
On August 02 2011 06:53 redFF wrote:
I really dont think vig should shoot day 1. We can't all be redff.

Oppose with troll. You seemed to do this in AA also.
I joke in most games lol am i scum for joking? you and drazerk must have been doing some taking :O

Show nested quote +
On August 02 2011 08:46 redFF wrote:
Regardless, have any of you guys a scum saying he's a vig and figuring out who the other shots are at? or a scum saying he's a medic and finding out who's protecting who?


Horrible. How would they ever figure this out?
By saying they are protecting one person and the confirmed vig telling them not to...
Show nested quote +
On August 02 2011 08:46 redFF wrote:
I've played games where everyone has claimed to a "confirmed townie" and scum have raped and taken advantage of this, so please don't tell me the plan is faultless.


The plan doesn't involve a "confirmed townie". It would be a real confirmed townie. No one ever said the plan was faultless.
In the other game the player was a confirmed townie but mafia fakeclaimed to him and he believed them and ended up losing town the game.

Show nested quote +
On August 02 2011 08:54 redFF wrote:
On August 02 2011 08:51 Curu wrote:
Huh? I don't understand your post. The confirmed Townie tells the player who he is going to shoot or protect, he doesn't tell all Medics what every Medic is doing.
Since we know how much KP Mafia has I very much doubt any of them are going to be able to claim Vig.

So you want one townie conducting every single vig hit/medic protect/hatter bomb?

k here's an example.

Mafia-I will be protecting player x
Confirmed townie-no someone else is protecting him.

now mafia know's to not hit player x.

This would never happen. Terrible reason.
If i was a blue role i would not have a random confirmed townie tell me what to do i would do what i think is correct. Also same point you made about the post above this one, try harder please.
Show nested quote +
On August 02 2011 09:01 redFF wrote:
On August 02 2011 09:00 Curu wrote:
On August 02 2011 08:54 redFF wrote:
On August 02 2011 08:51 Curu wrote:
Huh? I don't understand your post. The confirmed Townie tells the player who he is going to shoot or protect, he doesn't tell all Medics what every Medic is doing.

Since we know how much KP Mafia has I very much doubt any of them are going to be able to claim Vig.

So you want one townie conducting every single vig hit/medic protect/hatter bomb?

k here's an example.

Mafia-I will be protecting player x
Confirmed townie-no someone else is protecting him.

now mafia know's to not hit player x.


I would be more open to this plan day 2 or 3. But all i see is 2 townies getting lynched and losing a dayvig and that person most likely dying the next night.


No, it goes like this:

Mafia-I will be protecting player x
Confirmed townie-stfu I choose who you protect, you'll be protecting player y
Mafia-Okay...

I'm not comfortable with having 1 townie direct all of the blue actions. What if the townie is wrong about things/terrible? then we are screwed...

Show nested quote +
On August 02 2011 09:39 redFF wrote:
I don't see why i am being fos'ed for opposing this plan.

Why would we want to enforce a double lynch and use a dayvig shot day 1, when we can use it later game when we have a far higher chance of hitting mafia. All this plan will most likely do is kill 3 townies and lose us a dayvig shot which can be far more useful later on. Idk what the fuck is going on when its a good idea to double lynch day 1. It seems to be the proponents of this plan are just like LETS KILL TOWNIES FASTER!!!!1111ONEONE!!!

If anything it's scummy to defend this plan and then just call whoever is against it scum with zero reasoning. We lynch today, vigs for the most part should hold their shots, and we win this game by scumhunting, not by some kooky plan Sandroba made up in 5 minutes.

Pros
1. get a confirmed townie
2. Every blue claims to this townie??

Cons
1. Double lynch on the day when we are most likely to lynch town.
2. Mafia can infiltrate pm circle
3. One townie directing all blue actions
4. Confirmed townie will most likely be shot
5. We lose a dayvig shot early when it can be put into far better use later on in the game.

Someone please put forward a convincing argument as to why this plan is good aside from pulling a Drazerk and going "lolscum"

The pro is coordination and a voice for blues.
Avoiding possible death before he uses his shot.

2. There wouldn't be any PM circle.
3. If the townie is super bad it would be bad, but we'd still have the benefit of coordination.
4. Confirmed townie will be shot whether we use the plan or not.

2.Yes there would this whole plan proposes a pm circle surrounding this confirmed townie.
3. Exactly, blues should do what they think is correct, not follow the advice of this random dayvig who actually followed through with this retarded plan.
4. If we don't use this plan we won't have a confirmed townie because the dayvig won't have shot..


The only decent points you raised seemed to be parroting others.

Anyway, now you're defending your horrible reasoning again? Your points weren't valid for the most part, except for those that you adopted from others... There's no shame in making mistakes, but trying to defend bad posts' reasoning so that you seem "clean" indicates that you're scared to be wrong.

You seemed overly anxious to defend any accusations thrown your way, which is similar to what I experienced as your scum partner in AA.

And lol, you're right I forgot to vote for you in the voting thread. I actually find Varp the best scum candidate at the moment after that post I highlighted earlier. But don't worry, I'll vote for you first so that the voting record shows it "when you flip town" (hahaha?)

As for the last quote, you might have noticed that I was talking to others who were perma complaining about the plan being a waste of time. I never said the discussion was a waste of time. How is it complete shit? Terrible man ;p

My response in bold. In this post you didn't even say why im scum, and you still haven't provided good reasoning. And yes this post
On August 03 2011 05:20 Lucidity wrote:
If it's such a waste of time why are you dedicating any time at all to it anymore? I don't think there has been serious majority support for the plan for long now, so there's no reason for you to talk about it. Every Day 1 has to start in some useless way before there's something to discuss. Why not use the posts that have been generated by this plan to start some discussion which you think might be useful?

is fucking terrible. You keep bringing up the plan but then you say stop talking about and make a call for pro-town discussion and analysis, but don't actually do any yourself. that's a fucking typical easy scum post.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 02 2011 22:16 GMT
#321
Is GF elected or assigned by the host?
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 02 2011 22:21 GMT
#325
On August 03 2011 07:14 OriginalName wrote:
BIG IRC LOG POST INCOMING
+ Show Spoiler +
[16:49] <@Kurumi> ok ok
[16:49] <youngminii> not that anyone cares
[16:49] <@Kurumi> hm
[16:49] <CUru> hey munk e
[16:49] <@Kurumi> dropbear would care
[16:49] <@Kurumi> but he isn't playing
[16:49] <CUru> who do you think is scummy?
[16:49] <Munk-E> Mainly mig
[16:49] <Munk-E> but i'm also analysing varp
[16:49] <Munk-E> and lucidity
[16:49] <youngminii> oh look syllogism told mig that we're talking about him and now mig is here
[16:50] <Lucidity> lol
[16:50] <youngminii> /talkingoutofmyass
[16:50] <Munk-E> Oh snap when did he get here?
[16:50] <mig__> just got here I was just in irc until I had to disc like 15 min ago lol
[16:50] <mig__> maybe longer
[16:50] <OriginalName> it was like
[16:50] <OriginalName> an hour ago
[16:50] <OriginalName> when you dced
[16:50] <mig__> k
[16:52] <CUru> ym why would you want to lynch mig day 1?
[16:52] <CUru> he has a ridic track record of finding scum
[16:52] <DoctorHelvetica> i agree with curu
[16:52] <youngminii> oh that's fair enough reason to not lynch him actually
[16:52] <DoctorHelvetica> wait on mig
[16:52] <youngminii> yeah
[16:52] <CUru> scum would be much more afraid of him than town
[16:52] <syllogism> mig was mean to him so he started tunnelling the most active player in a game where the thread is pretty dead, standard
[16:52] <youngminii> ok unvoting
[16:52] <CUru> if hes scum then we can tell when he doesnt find any scum
[16:53] <youngminii> splendid work syllogism, as usual
[16:53] <syllogism> it's true
[16:53] <OriginalName> So
[16:53] <OriginalName> are we down to Varpu/Lucidity
[16:53] <OriginalName> for likely suspects?
[16:53] <youngminii> what, the fact that your backseat sheeping is splendid?
[16:53] <syllogism> what am I sheeping
[16:53] <OriginalName> On Mig
[16:54] <syllogism> on what
[16:54] <OriginalName> when he could theoretically be perfectly wrong
[16:54] <OriginalName> and your just not doing any of your own thinking
[16:54] <youngminii> on literally everything he has done this game
[16:54] <OriginalName> on his lynches
[16:54] <OriginalName> Syllogism
[16:54] <youngminii> i'm not even kidding, you're just following his every single thought
[16:54] <OriginalName> you are not mig
[16:54] <syllogism> i've been talking to him and a few others all game on skype
[16:54] <OriginalName> think for yourself
[16:54] <youngminii> you mean on quicktopic?
[16:54] <syllogism> you apparently dont know me very well
[16:54] <syllogism> if you think i dont think for myself
[16:54] <OriginalName> but you havent shown that yet
[16:54] <OriginalName> at all
[16:54] <OriginalName> ._.
[16:54] <syllogism> in thread yes
[16:55] <OriginalName> THEN SHOW IT IN THE GOD DAMNDED THREAD
[16:55] <OriginalName> THATS WHERE IT MATTERS
[16:55] <youngminii> you haven't shown it in irc either
[16:55] <OriginalName> I dont give a fuck about your private behind closed doors shit
[16:55] <syllogism> it's a channel with 15 people
[16:55] <OriginalName> i want to see it
[16:55] <syllogism> not exactly ideal
[16:55] <youngminii> so you're showing it in your PMs to mig
[16:55] <@Kurumi> I like turtles
[16:55] <OriginalName> Because afaik your just sheeping
[16:55] <syllogism> what am I sheeping, you still havent said
[16:55] <OriginalName> Kurumi are you trying to troll me cause of WaW2?
[16:55] <Lucidity> how is it more ideal to show to 1 person syllogism?
[16:55] <Lucidity> lol
[16:55] <OriginalName> ._.
[16:55] <syllogism> all i've done is argue against bad logic by YM
[16:55] <youngminii> wtf
[16:56] <youngminii> you can't see what you're sheeping
[16:56] <youngminii> oh my god
[16:56] <syllogism> Lucidity: it's not one
[16:56] <youngminii> oh my god
[16:56] <youngminii> i can't
[16:56] <youngminii> handle this
[16:56] <@Kurumi> I am not trolling anyone
[16:56] <@Kurumi> _^_
[16:56] <@Kurumi> I am hosting a game
[16:56] <@Kurumi> this is serious
[16:56] <@Kurumi> _^_
[16:56] <youngminii> syllogism's got to be the biggest troll
[16:56] <OriginalName> ._.
[16:56] <@Kurumi> but
[16:56] <@Kurumi> what happened
[16:56] <OriginalName> no
[16:56] <OriginalName> the turtle things
[16:56] <@Kurumi> I am not paying attention
[16:56] <OriginalName> shit
[16:56] <@Kurumi> aa
[16:56] <@Kurumi> I just like turtles
[16:56] <@Kurumi> _^_
[16:56] <OriginalName> mmk
[16:56] <Lucidity> is it just me or does
[16:56] <Lucidity> ( OriginalName ) So
[16:56] <Lucidity> ( OriginalName ) are we down to Varpu/Lucidity
[16:56] <Lucidity> 02,02 12,00 2302:125302.1234 02,02   02( OriginalName 02) for likely suspects?
[16:56] <Lucidity> scream scum?
[16:56] <OriginalName> because
[16:56] <Lucidity> lol
[16:56] <OriginalName> we want a solid lynch
[16:56] <OriginalName> not just
[16:56] <OriginalName> herp derp everyone off doing their own shit
[16:57] <OriginalName> Dont even try that scum shit on me
[16:57] <Lucidity> we're still 24 hours away from lynch
[16:57] <OriginalName> so what
[16:57] <OriginalName> we tookj
[16:57] <OriginalName> 24 hours
[16:57] <Lucidity> what possibly reason is there to start tunneling now
[16:57] <Lucidity> haha
[16:57] <OriginalName> to get that plan away
[16:57] <OriginalName> its gonna take 24 hours
[16:57] <youngminii> LOL
[16:57] <OriginalName> to get our shit together
[16:57] <syllogism> tunneling is fine if it creates discussion
[16:57] <OriginalName> Im starting early
[16:57] <DoctorHelvetica> no it doesnt scream scum lol
[16:57] <Lucidity> That's just asking, "Hey guys, who are the 2 candidates I can tag on to without upsetting shit?"
[16:57] <DoctorHelvetica> have you read
[16:57] <DoctorHelvetica> vers town guide
[16:57] <DoctorHelvetica> tunneling isnt a scumtell
[16:57] <DoctorHelvetica> jesus
[16:58] <DoctorHelvetica> town is more likely to do it than mafia
[16:58] <DoctorHelvetica> mafia want to plays afe
[16:58] <DoctorHelvetica> they go where the town goes
[16:58] <DoctorHelvetica> has no reason to tunnel
[16:58] <DoctorHelvetica> as long as mafia doesnt get lynched it doesnt matter lol
[16:58] <OriginalName> And i cant tunnel as scum
[16:58] <Lucidity> which is exactly what ON is doing?
[16:58] <OriginalName> i tried it once
[16:58] <DoctorHelvetica> what motivation would ON possibly have as scum
[16:58] <Lucidity> roflll
[16:58] <DoctorHelvetica> to tunnel you
[16:58] <DoctorHelvetica> because youre bad
[16:58] <DoctorHelvetica> if it was
[16:58] <alanismorisette> wow after that syllo now looks redic scummy
[16:58] <DoctorHelvetica> BC
[16:58] <OriginalName> it fucking
[16:58] <DoctorHelvetica> id understand
[16:58] <OriginalName> failed
[16:58] <Lucidity> I'm not saying he's tunneling he's scum
[16:58] <DoctorHelvetica> what
[16:58] <DoctorHelvetica> thats exactly what you said
[16:58] <DoctorHelvetica> wow
[16:58] <OriginalName> Lucidity
[16:58] <Lucidity> I'm saying he's asking the town for 2 safe candidates
[16:58] <DoctorHelvetica> lol
[16:58] <DoctorHelvetica> jesus
[16:58] <OriginalName> just
[16:58] <OriginalName> just
[16:58] <OriginalName> wow
[16:58] <OriginalName> ffs
[16:58] <Lucidity> ?
[16:59] <OriginalName> No
[16:59] <OriginalName> i give up
[16:59] <@Kurumi> wanna a replacement
[16:59] <@Kurumi> the next in the line is..
[16:59] <@Kurumi> Bill Murray
[16:59] <OriginalName> no
[16:59] <@Kurumi> so how about that?
[16:59] <OriginalName> Im not a ragequit
[16:59] <@Kurumi> kk whatever
[16:59] <OriginalName> im giving up on explaining
[16:59] <OriginalName> why I said that
[16:59] <youngminii> if bm was next in line
[16:59] <DoctorHelvetica> lucidity its normal if people have a suspicion to tunnel it
[16:59] <Lucidity> You think we found the scum
[17:00] <youngminii> i'd give my spot just to see him play
[17:00] <youngminii> again
[17:00] <DoctorHelvetica> because the towns goal is to kill a scum
[17:00] <Lucidity> in those 2 candidates?
[17:00] <DoctorHelvetica> if you think someone is scum
[17:00] <DoctorHelvetica> you tunnel them lol
[17:00] <DoctorHelvetica> thats the pro town thing to do
[17:00] <OriginalName> i think those two candidates
[17:00] <OriginalName> have the highest chances
[17:00] <OriginalName> of being scum
[17:00] <youngminii> i don't
[17:00] <Lucidity> with so little info out
[17:00] <OriginalName> From what i have deduced in the thread
[17:00] <OriginalName> Ok then
[17:00] <Lucidity> rofl
[17:00] <DoctorHelvetica> there is a lot
[17:00] <OriginalName> put more info in then
[17:00] <DoctorHelvetica> to analyse
[17:00] <DoctorHelvetica> already
[17:00] <DoctorHelvetica> lol
[17:00] <alanismorisette> wow@heist
[17:00] <DoctorHelvetica> we dont have flip info
[17:00] <DoctorHelvetica> but
[17:00] <Lucidity> There is a lot more to analyse
[17:00] <Lucidity> l
[17:00] <Lucidity> o
[17:00] <Lucidity> l
[17:00] <OriginalName> Lucidity
[17:00] <DoctorHelvetica> whats so funny
[17:00] <OriginalName> The OMGUS from that
[17:00] <OriginalName> doesnt help you
[17:00] <DoctorHelvetica> you know what i would do if i ws mafia id say
[17:00] <OriginalName> btw
[17:01] <DoctorHelvetica> "ignore the day 1 discussion ther eis no info nothing to analyse move on lol"
[17:01] <OriginalName> DrH is prob town
[17:01] <OriginalName> YM is meh
[17:01] <youngminii> ignore the day 1 discussion ther eis no info nothing to analyse move on lol
[17:01] <Lucidity> OMGUS?
[17:01] <OriginalName> I want to see more from BC
[17:01] <OriginalName> oh my god you suck
[17:01] <Lucidity> rofl
[17:01] <OriginalName> someone accuses
[17:01] <Lucidity> I know what it means
[17:01] <OriginalName> then you shout back
[17:01] <Lucidity> where did I do it?
[17:01] <DoctorHelvetica> when you said on is scum after he said youre scum
[17:01] <DoctorHelvetica> lol
[17:01] <DoctorHelvetica> jesus
[17:01] <Lucidity> no
[17:01] <OriginalName> [16:56] <Lucidity> ( OriginalName ) So
[17:01] <OriginalName> [16:56] <Lucidity> ( OriginalName ) are we down to Varpu/Lucidity
[17:01] <OriginalName> [16:56] <Lucidity> ( OriginalName ) for likely suspects?
[17:01] <OriginalName> [16:56] <Lucidity> scream scum?
[17:01] <Lucidity> You're completely misrepresenting
[17:02] <DoctorHelvetica> yes
[17:02] <@Kurumi> hey guys, just do what Ace recommended in Mini
[17:02] <DoctorHelvetica> that looks like omgus
[17:02] <@Kurumi> RANDOM LYNCH
[17:02] <Lucidity> It's scummy because he's asking the town for safe candidates
[17:02] <@Kurumi> jk jk :3 play mafia
[17:02] <Lucidity> not because i'm one of the 2 suspects
[17:02] <Lucidity> rofl
[17:02] <@Kurumi> now brb
[17:02] <DoctorHelvetica> its not scummy hes seeing if people agree
[17:02] <DoctorHelvetica> thats normal to do
[17:02] * chaos13_ is now known as chaos13away
[17:02] <DoctorHelvetica> no matter what side youre on
[17:02] <OriginalName> Its called checking your work
[17:02] <OriginalName> making sure im not completely off my rocker
[17:02] <Lucidity> horseshit
[17:02] <Lucidity> roofl
[17:02] <OriginalName> ...
[17:02] <OriginalName> fuck it
[17:02] <Lucidity> what work?
[17:02] <OriginalName> Lucid is soooooo scum
[17:02] <Lucidity> You haven't posted anything
[17:03] <OriginalName> ...
[17:03] <OriginalName> oh
[17:03] <OriginalName> my
[17:03] <OriginalName> god
[17:03] <OriginalName> ...
[17:03] * OriginalName facedesks
[17:03] * OriginalName facedesks
[17:03] * OriginalName facedesks
[17:03] * OriginalName facedesks
[17:03] * OriginalName facedesks
[17:03] * OriginalName facedesks
[17:03] * OriginalName facedesks
End of relevant conversation


Im going to point out the arguement between Lucidity and Me. Take what you will from it, but I think hes definitly up there on the scum leaderboard.

I think what's far more interesting there is syllogism's part. I encourage everyone to read this btw.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 02 2011 23:12 GMT
#336
I went through sandroba's games to see kooky plans.

PTP1-kooky plan(town)
On May 31 2011 05:29 sandroba wrote:
Alright, I have a sugestion to make. Everyone should state which player they designed the role for. We don't know how much KP mafia actually has, so after today things might get confusing. This way we can implement LAL more effectively. I would also like to sugest that any person who claims before having any IMPORTANT (that lead us to scum) info or are very close to being lynched to be policy lynched. Only time it's ok to claim without meeting the above conditions is when town decides it's time to massroleclaim. Failing to claim at mass roleclaim will also result in a policy lynch.

WaW2-kooky plan(town)
On July 05 2011 14:58 sandroba wrote:
Okay I have a fucking plan!
We are going to treat all days as being 24 hours (We could consider starting this day2, up for discussion). Every day we vote for who to lynch in the first 24 hours and that player will claim how many lives he has (town player has no reason to lie and if he does he gets lynched anyway) and we will fire that amount on him. If a player claims unkillable by nukes like coag we launch 2 and if he's not dead we lynch him. Those will be the only nukes fired every day and it's safe to assume world radiation will not be reached this way. Every player has at least 1-2 nukes and the op says the radiation level needs to be "fairly high" for the conspirator to win. If anyone else fires a nuke he gets auto lynched NOT nuked back.
If we follow this plan we will have 2 lynches every day for every night kill axis has. Needless to say this is extremelly advantageos for us since:

1) Prevents conspirator from winning the game. We can stop using this tactic any time when the game gets tilted in allies favor.

2) Gets us 2 lynches everyday and prevents people from random killing other players.

XLii-kooky plan (town)
On June 14 2011 12:55 sandroba wrote:
Ok, so I have an idea. We try to use pm's to our advantage and coordinating blues is extremelly advantageous to town.
I propose a DT that has a number on the player list lesser or equal 15 to check me this night. He then pms me my role and I post in the thread that I got checked, of course not revealing his ID.
Everyone that has a blue role mansons me.

A medic who has a number inferior or equal 10 protects me this night. This should keep mafia guessing, because no one knows how many medics, if any, there are in the first 10 numbers. This can make mafia waste many kp on me or let the plan work.

I will not reveal any roles to ANYONE so there are no possible leaks, and will single handly coordinate all the blue force, of course taking into consideration all lists posted in thread and sugested to me via pm's.


Possible scenarios:
1) I'm GF, then town is pretty much screwed, but you guys can lynch me if many blues are dead after day1 if you think that's the case. That's the worst possible scenario and a pretty huge loss for town, but I assure I'm not.

2) I'm mafia goon or miller. If I'm mafia I'm pretty dumb proposing this plan, but either way of course the DT will not manson me. If I'm mafia I can lie and tell you guys that a DT has checked me and confirmed my role, causing many blues to roleclaim to me, but then I would risk that there was a DT in the first 15 numbers that can instantly out me as scum randomly mansoning another player and using him as mouth. So it doesn't work well if I'm mafia. If I'm miller I'll of course say in thread that no DT has messaged me (because he won't) and the plan has failed, we can proceed to go by our business and ignore the plan.

3) I'm any other town aligned role (most likely scenario and the real one). If there's a DT who pm's me I'll say so in thread and other blues who have night actions role claim to me. Town proceeds to rape mafia miserably. If no one checks and pms me we ignore this plan and move on.

Why this plan is good: First I'm experienced and intuitive enough to make good reads and calls, but not "well known" enough to have a high chance of being mafia GF. Making another praised veteran take this role raises the chance he's the mafia godfather.
Second, it has a very slim chance of needlessly tieing up many of our blue roles, since I've limited the possible DTs/Medic protects using the player list.
Third, it's pretty hard to make a secure blue coordination center without previously determining a player to be checked or outing the DT, so this is the best I could come up so far.

Any criticisms and sugestions are welcome. Let's make this plan the best we possibly can. Cheers.

Paranoid Mafia-no kooky plan(scum)
Closed casket-no kooky plan (scum)
xxxix-no kooky plan (town)
Merc Mini-no kooky plan (town)
So what does this show us? Sandroba often does silly plans as town, but never as scum. Small sample pool yes, but something to consider. I have Sandroba down as town even though his plan was shit. I was bored btw so don't go asking me why i did this.

T.T now he's getting replaced wtf. The meta read still stands.

redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 03 2011 00:12 GMT
#339
[image loading]
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 03 2011 13:31 GMT
#377
Drazerk is scummy I agree. Here's something interesting I found.

On August 02 2011 07:32 Drazerk wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 02 2011 05:52 heist wrote:
Loving the TF2 theme.

I'd just like to say that it's highly recommended to post somewhat actively in the thread and not just disappear into solely IRC or PMs. We don't want an atmosphere where RED Team can just sit back, consort amongst themselves, and generally be inactive in the thread.


While a good thread presence is needed I still think you can do most of the legwork in IRC / PM. My only issue will be if people just vote for no reason and say - IRC discussion. If your going to vote / spout accusations you make all your posts clear in thread and don't use PMs as an easy method to bandwagon.

Anyone who is scared of PMing / joining in IRC discussion should be put under the spot light it is actually one of our greatest tools as town and avoiding them gives scum a huge advantage.

Also I agree with Sand's plan. The sooner we have confirmed town players the better.

Notice the bold.

On August 02 2011 08:41 Drazerk wrote:
##Vote RedFF

Opposing sand's plan with no real reasons while defending himself like a mad man in IRC when he has no real reason to defend himself yet.

LOLWUT.
My only issue will be if people just vote for no reason and say - IRC discussion. If your going to vote / spout accusations you make all your posts clear in thread and don't use PMs as an easy method to bandwagon.

Massive contradiction within first 2 posts of the game...


That said, I find BC's post scummy too

On August 03 2011 11:32 BloodyC0bbler wrote:
At the moment I am not feeling either Varp lynch or the lucidity lynch. Factor in both at the moment are being more active than most players in the game, I would be more inclined to at least let them live another cycle. I however don't like when players come in to hop on bandwagons or attempt to start them then vanish. It irks me completely. As such, until Drazerk comes back into the thread to at least play / explain his inactivity I suggest we move our lynch to him.

I would rather lynch someone appearing scummy / useless than someone who is being linked as scummy and is active. Their activity will help clear / damn them whereas inactivity doesn't give us dick all to work with.


He's not giving real reasons why he doesn't like the Varp or Lucid lynch, just vague like they are kind of active.

Then he just that we move our lynch to Drazerk, because he's lurking/useless. Once again no real reasoning.

The most damning thing here tho imo is that he hasn't even voted for Drazerk, yet subtly started a bandwagon on him that 2 people have now jumped on and voted him. This makes me anxious of BC because it's exactly the kind of thing mafia would do.
FOS
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 03 2011 21:00 GMT
#411
On August 04 2011 03:34 BloodyC0bbler wrote:
shinbi had no scum leanings, then in 10 hours without posting serious reasons he sheeps onto something I say to try and force a bandwagon on a player? Not only that, rather than push said bandwagon with any conviction, he makes his move then vanishes from the thread completely since.

As such, until he reappears to explain his actions I am throwing my vote there.

vote jeejee

k so you subtly suggest that we should swing a lynch off of one player onto another, but don't actually vote for the person you suggest lynching. Then you vote for the first person who, giving reasons, votes for the person you suggest? Am i missing something here?
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 03 2011 22:06 GMT
#419
On August 04 2011 07:04 Lucidity wrote:
!@#$

You know you can just say fuck right?
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 03 2011 22:12 GMT
#423
nice check BC please. I'm almost certain he's scum.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 03 2011 22:50 GMT
#440
On August 04 2011 07:21 ghrur wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 04 2011 07:19 youngminii wrote:
On August 04 2011 07:18 ghrur wrote:
Wow, towns are getting better at Day 1. :O

or scum is getting worse


Don't be a pessimist. I support the shooting of JeeJee

why?
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 03 2011 22:51 GMT
#441
On August 04 2011 07:50 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 04 2011 07:48 Mig wrote:
BC/sandroba/syllo/myself/curu were all in a skype circle.

BC is the mafia maybe curu

Well Curu brought it up to be fair
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 03 2011 23:05 GMT
#445
Ghrur is scum :O
On August 02 2011 08:50 ghrur wrote:
Okay, so we weight the benefits of confirmed townie vs possibly hitting a townie.
Confirmed townie is definitely better. Have you heard how Ace talked about Masons in that Mafias #1 targets thread? It's because they're confirmed so easily. A confirmed townie is valuable, and that's just 1 person less to shoot at.

Furthermore, even hitting a townie can give us a lot of information for our first official lynch. It also gives us new information to re-evaluate our thoughts.

If he dies because mafia stacks, all the better. This means, if we miss, we killed 1 extra townie day 1, but also saved 1 extra townie night 1. Pretty even. If the Day Vig doesn't shoot, there is a chance that he gets sniped night 1, especially with all the talk about him.

I think it's beneficial to have him shoot. The problem is... is there a Day Vig? o.O

K so he's for the plan, but he WANTS TO LYNCH FOR INFORMATION. NEVER LYNCH FOR INFORMATION HOLY SHIT.

He also say's that it's good that the confirmed townie will die...which was the whole issue with the plan.

On August 02 2011 09:08 ghrur wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 02 2011 09:00 Curu wrote:
On August 02 2011 08:54 redFF wrote:
On August 02 2011 08:51 Curu wrote:
Huh? I don't understand your post. The confirmed Townie tells the player who he is going to shoot or protect, he doesn't tell all Medics what every Medic is doing.

Since we know how much KP Mafia has I very much doubt any of them are going to be able to claim Vig.

So you want one townie conducting every single vig hit/medic protect/hatter bomb?

k here's an example.

Mafia-I will be protecting player x
Confirmed townie-no someone else is protecting him.

now mafia know's to not hit player x.


I would be more open to this plan day 2 or 3. But all i see is 2 townies getting lynched and losing a dayvig and that person most likely dying the next night.


No, it goes like this:

Mafia-I will be protecting player x
Confirmed townie-stfu I choose who you protect, you'll be protecting player y
Mafia-Okay...


Yup, and if Mafia shoots player Y, and player Y dies, then clearly the medic isn't a medic but is mafia. :/ So if mafia tries to be medic, it effectively hurts them.

Still supports the plan, but here he actually makes a nonsensical point. Nobody was suggesting the mafia would claim protecting someone and then shoot them instead...

On August 03 2011 17:35 ghrur wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 03 2011 12:42 JeeJee wrote:
actually screw it let's get the ball rolling.
anyone disagree with drazerk as a candidate?


Yeah, I do. I played with Drazerk AA and he acted the same way. If I recall, it was basically a "Lynch Wiggles" post and then afk.

I'm down for either varpulis or Kenpachi.
I don't get why sandroba's supposed to have seemed town. I mean, looking back on the plan, I realize it's incredibly bad.
and this post by sandroba
docH, how is the simple fact that it's no longer day1 is going to make lynches more acurate down the line? If we can speed up the process and basically skip night 1 how is it possibly bad for town?

What? He knows better than this. So the plan basically becomes let's out the dayvig and give mafia a free blue. :/

This is his very next post. Disagrees with a Drazerk lynch, and gives fucking awful meta reason to do so. This is not like AA at all lol.

Here is the most important thing though. His last 3 posts were all behind the plan 100%!!! But now, with no explanation apart from, the plan sucks. He comes out and calls Sandroba scummy and says the plan is terrible. Did your mafia buddies tell you to do this in the QT????
On August 04 2011 07:21 ghrur wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 04 2011 07:19 youngminii wrote:
On August 04 2011 07:18 ghrur wrote:
Wow, towns are getting better at Day 1. :O

or scum is getting worse


Don't be a pessimist. I support the shooting of JeeJee

He hasn't mentioned JeeJee at all before, yet posts saying he wants him shot with NO REASONING.

also

SCUMSLIP ALERT SCUMSLIP ALERT SCUMSLIP ALERT

He says Don't be a pessimist in response to YM saying that scum is getting worse. Actual "scumslips" are very rare, but i'm fairly certain I just found one.



VIGIS ON THIS GUY PLEASE. It's fine if no tho but I will be trying to get this mofo lynched tommorow.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 03 2011 23:20 GMT
#451
https://docs.google.com/document/d/10jA3MmX1xqqIfA0dbFV2x_2ABuzcbCX6IKcXlx_oFF0/edit?hl=en_US

here is the irc convo mig sent it to me and i hosted it on a google doc. Take from it what you will, you can just ctrl+f redff to find the stuff about me i guess.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 03 2011 23:23 GMT
#455
On August 04 2011 08:19 ghrur wrote:
Redff:
Yes, I understand lynching for information was bad. I was making the point that losing 3 townies is losing 3 townies until I realized day-vigis get 2 shots so we still effectively lose a vigi, and later shots are more accurate. Why did I change positions? I argued with DrH about this in Mafia IRC and reconsidered my position.

Show nested quote +

Still supports the plan, but here he actually makes a nonsensical point. Nobody was suggesting the mafia would claim protecting someone and then shoot them instead...

Neither was I... I was stating how fake-claims by mafia would hurt them under the plan... Like, do you not understand that that was a continuation of thought from what Curu said? >_>

Also, you're tunneling by the third "point." Did you not read "looking back?" I re-evaluated my position. Would you like to hear why I realize it's a bad plan?
A. It lures out a confirmed townie and ends up with him getting shot.
B. We lose a vigi shot early with the opportunity cost of getting a better shot later on.
C. Vigis get 2 shots, so even if Dayvig dies, it's not a confirmed townie that dies, but a confirmed blue.
D. Instead of ending up with 3 greens dead if mafia stacks, we end up with 2 greens dead and 1 blue dead. Much worse.
So what does this effectively do? Lure out a blue for mafia to kill! Why would Sandroba suggest such a plan then! Why was I stupid enough to support it? Because I was stupid.

I never mentioned JeeJee before... except in IRC and talking about it to TAA. Guess what? I also find Munk-E scummy but I've never mentioned him before in thread either. I don't post everything I think.

lol ur scum
I got called scummy for talking about stuff on the public irc channel, your talking about all your reads in pms to a couple of people. that is scummy as fuck.

Please post your thoughts on both JeeJee and Munk-E. you have 10 minutes because if you already talked about it to other then i assume you will be able to post about it..
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 03 2011 23:49 GMT
#463
[8/1/2011 3:02:00 PM] james: im liking redff
[8/1/2011 3:02:03 PM] james: more and more
[8/1/2011 3:02:12 PM] james: for the cannon fodder
[8/1/2011 3:02:12 PM] james: shot
[8/1/2011 3:02:23 PM] Charles Suo: yes thats the easy early one
[8/1/2011 3:02:26 PM] Charles Suo: hes also nto going to be contributing at all the game
[8/1/2011 3:02:35 PM] james: well
[8/1/2011 3:02:38 PM] james: hes against
[8/1/2011 3:02:39 PM] james: day vigiing
[8/1/2011 3:02:39 PM] Charles Suo: well actually idk he died on the first day/night
[8/1/2011 3:02:42 PM] james: and against encrypting of posts
[8/1/2011 3:02:45 PM] Charles Suo: both games i was in with him
[8/1/2011 3:02:57 PM] james: like hes against two things
[8/1/2011 3:03:04 PM] james: that are pro town
[8/1/2011 3:03:15 PM] syllogism: i'm somewhat skeptical about him saying that as scum though
[8/1/2011 3:03:24 PM] syllogism: the encryption part especially
[8/1/2011 3:03:26 PM] james: eh, it means
[8/1/2011 3:03:27 PM] james: hes good
[8/1/2011 3:03:30 PM] james: day vigi
[8/1/2011 3:03:33 PM] james: shot
[8/1/2011 3:03:41 PM] james: already being counter productive
[8/1/2011 3:03:47 PM] james: i can understand not wanting to encrypt shite
[8/1/2011 3:03:54 PM] james: but against getting a day 1
[8/1/2011 3:03:58 PM] james: confirmed
[8/1/2011 3:03:59 PM] james: player?

OK WTF IS THIS

On August 02 2011 08:59 BloodyC0bbler wrote:
*yawn* So out of drH and redff there is a clear difference between the two of them. Both are arguing against this plan. First of all, a lot of drH's concerns are legit. A lot of questions based around this plan that makes it "solid" received not so good responses from the mods. IE not exploitable.

I see the advantages of the plan, and if we could actually think of a target for day 1 to day vig it would be fine, however. This is a game with 4 mafia, 1 gf and 1 rber in the mix most likely. The next issue is a simple bit of knowledge of qatol and ver helped balance the game. Very few KP will be in this game. Counting on a day vig for all our hopes seems...shortsighted. If we have one, awesome, however we should have 2 kp at most given the setup. 1 med and 1 vet, or 2 vets, would be a likely blue setup for night survival and 1 dt if we are lucky. As this is speculation based on how to not make a game horribly OP for town I would guess no day kp as that would make town confirmable.

However, if this plan can be made to work then thats fine and good. My issue now stems from DrH and redFF. DrH has been arguing against it in thread. He has been on the bad side of this sort of situation before, and I can see where he might have learned from that. I have no issues with him doing so primarily because he is doing it here, in thread. Redff however has been arguing this on irc. If he was so sure of his stance he should have taken it here in thread. Massive FoS by excluding info from thread.

So apparently BC says that thinks that arguing against the plan and getting a confirmed townie is scummy. But then he says in the thread that the concerns are legitimate.

Notice how BC doesn't even really take a stance on the plan. He also says that it's a massive FOS for excluding info from the thread, when in that skype convo(https://docs.google.com/document/d/10jA3MmX1xqqIfA0dbFV2x_2ABuzcbCX6IKcXlx_oFF0/edit?hl=en_US) he says very important stuff he doesn't say in the thread. LIKE THE FACT THAT HE THINKS I AM SCUM AND A GOOD DAYVIG SHOT AND HE THINKS THAT ARGUING AGAINST THE PLAN IS ANTI-TOWN.

Here's what we know. We know that someone in that skype convo is scum. And we already know that BC has been scummy before. Vigs on BC please for the love of god.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 03 2011 23:53 GMT
#465
alanismorisette:
ghrur ur mafia too stfu
[7:57pm] alanismorisette:
post that analysis
[7:57pm] alanismorisette:
its not bullshit if you have already discussed it with people
[7:57pm] alanismorisette:
just post what you talked about with them
[7:57pm] alanismorisette:
quick!
[7:57pm] ghrur:
It's been past 10 minutes
[7:57pm] ghrur:
My deadline is gone
[7:58pm] ghrur:
and I wanna play basketball
[7:58pm] alanismorisette:
...
[7:58pm] ghrur:
Besides, I already said
[7:58pm] chaos13 joined the chat room.
[7:58pm] ghrur:
I didn't save the chat log
[7:58pm] alanismorisette:
doesnt matter
[7:58pm] ghrur:
Ask TAA if he has it
[7:58pm] alanismorisette:
just post the gist of ur position on them
[7:58pm] alanismorisette:
easy
[7:58pm] alanismorisette:
just do that for me
[7:58pm] ghrur:
Sure, I'll do it
[7:58pm] ghrur:
But I'd rather play basketball
[7:58pm] alanismorisette:
...
[7:58pm] ghrur:
I'll post it afterwards kay?
[7:58pm] alanismorisette:
do it please
[7:58pm] alanismorisette:
no
[7:58pm] alanismorisette:
now
[7:58pm] ghrur:
No, real life > mafia
[7:58pm] alanismorisette:
im sorry but everyone is seeing this right
[7:59pm] alanismorisette:
it will take
[7:59pm] alanismorisette:
like 5 minutes
[7:59pm] alanismorisette:
dude
[7:59pm] youngmin:
i'm laughing my ass off
[7:59pm] alanismorisette:
you could have finished it by now
[7:59pm] ghrur:
??? YM?
[7:59pm] ghrur:
Cya later
[7:59pm] ghrur:
<3
[7:59pm] alanismorisette:
but instead you are gonna go think about it
[7:59pm] ghrur:
I'll post it after
[7:59pm] youngmin:
lolololol
[7:59pm] alanismorisette:
then post it
[7:59pm] alanismorisette:
...
[7:59pm] ghrur:
Yes, I didn't need to think about my defense
[7:59pm] ghrur:
<3
[7:59pm] ghrur:
Cya
[8:00pm] alanismorisette:
...

fuck this guy
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 04 2011 00:27 GMT
#469
On August 04 2011 09:21 Curu wrote:
I'd prefer the Vig on JeeJee/Munk-E and the DT on BC. Medic on Mig.

why medic on mig? A medic on ON or DrH is wayy better.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 04 2011 00:27 GMT
#470
VIG BC
VIG BC
VIG BC
VIG BC
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 04 2011 01:05 GMT
#474
I think On is tbh but w/e
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 04 2011 01:06 GMT
#475
On August 04 2011 09:33 Barundar wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 04 2011 09:27 redFF wrote:
On August 04 2011 09:21 Curu wrote:
I'd prefer the Vig on JeeJee/Munk-E and the DT on BC. Medic on Mig.

why medic on mig? A medic on ON or DrH is wayy better.

Mig was the one starting the case on varpulis, posting the initial analysis and pressuring him through the day. I consider ON and DrH town as well though. As a side note Trotske is most likely town based on Varpulis' FoS.

I wouldn't DT check JeeJee or BC, if mafia they are most likely to be the godfather.

For all we know Varp knew he was getting lynched so decided to attack trotske and they could be both scum? Also please read the thread gf is random.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 04 2011 02:33 GMT
#501
I have a town read on sveryn from this btw
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 04 2011 02:43 GMT
#503
He seemed to be doing a post-by-post style analysis (which btw, is bad)

Ghrur then goes on to do a pbpa on jeejee
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 04 2011 02:45 GMT
#505
On August 04 2011 11:37 ghrur wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 04 2011 11:33 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
really you pick munke over sevryn or bc


Idk what BC's up to to be honest.

YEAH U DO UVE BEEN TALKING IN UR QT FOR 2 DAYS
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 04 2011 02:54 GMT
#509
btw so ghrur lied about playing basketball so he could have time to make up fos's on 2 people he told me he had fos's of already. RIIIIIIIIIGHT
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 04 2011 16:37 GMT
#520
On August 04 2011 17:17 Drazerk wrote:
Meant to post this at the day post but I fell asleep...

Basically I've been using myself as a scum magnet, ( Yes I discussed this with other people before I started doing it ) I made myself an easy bandwagon target once I knew town had found a decent lynch candidate that I thought was scum knowing they would need a safe scapegoat to lynch. ( Ok my attacks on RedFF wasn't exactly part of this plan but they did allow me to do it easier )

Varp was being lynched and they didn't think lucidity would of worked so they went after the next best thing - a lurker who made a bad FoS at the start of the game ( Ok sorry red ).

So now we have three scum found who all have ties with Varp in defending him while pushing my lynch.

JeeJee and chaos 13 are basically the same person in this game. Defend Varp while pushing for my lynch when actually a vigilante shot would of been much better for the town as it does not waste a lynch. If you want to kill a lurker the best thing to do is shoot and ask questions later these guys just wanted an easy, safe lynch that would not raise much suspicion when I flipped blue.

Now here is something you may not have noticed. BC was the first person to actually propose a lynch on me but he didn't do it, rather when someone did vote me he instantly voted JeeJee. The only reason he would do this would be if he actually 100% knew I was town and thought the lynch had a chance of actually going ahead to buy him town cred by apposing the lynch. His play is very wishy washy and has been acting like scum in a variety of different ways throughout the game.

So here is your scum team:

Varp
Chaos13
BC
JeeJee

Lurking just won us the game... or it could be that the scum all sucked.

LOL YOU GOTZ THEM YOU GENIUS
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 04 2011 17:08 GMT
#524
On August 05 2011 02:00 Trotske wrote:
scum mcscumscum

...
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 04 2011 21:15 GMT
#527
ghrur am i scum for not voting varp?
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 04 2011 21:25 GMT
#528
Drazerk has been posting actively in ptp2 and has barely touched this thread, i dont like that sir, not one bit.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 04 2011 21:27 GMT
#530
.
.
.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 04 2011 21:28 GMT
#531
holy shit active lurking much lol
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 04 2011 21:34 GMT
#537
...
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 04 2011 21:38 GMT
#540
see now ew have something to discuss. Would you say without a doubt that those 3 are scum? I mean i thought you were scummy too lol am i mafia? Also I doubt both JeeJee and BC are on scumteam. Aren't they the 2 most experienced players in the game?
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 04 2011 22:04 GMT
#552
trotske most likely a vig hit?
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 04 2011 22:05 GMT
#553
On August 05 2011 07:03 Mig wrote:
I was shot btw

champion!

Nice read btw YM. SCREAMING SCUM

vet or protected?
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 04 2011 22:07 GMT
#557
On August 05 2011 07:07 syllogism wrote:
Mass claim to mig

erm no
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 04 2011 22:13 GMT
#560
On August 05 2011 07:11 syllogism wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 05 2011 07:07 redFF wrote:
On August 05 2011 07:07 syllogism wrote:
Mass claim to mig

erm no

Err yes, unless you think his plan was to bus his teammate 1, shoot a random and not use the other shot just so he could get town cred. It's a completely ridiculous scenario

wtf is it with new players and mass claiming lol. He isn't confirmed town so we will not be mass claiming to him.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 04 2011 22:30 GMT
#566
Ghrur is scum :O
On August 02 2011 08:50 ghrur wrote:
Okay, so we weight the benefits of confirmed townie vs possibly hitting a townie.
Confirmed townie is definitely better. Have you heard how Ace talked about Masons in that Mafias #1 targets thread? It's because they're confirmed so easily. A confirmed townie is valuable, and that's just 1 person less to shoot at.

Furthermore, even hitting a townie can give us a lot of information for our first official lynch. It also gives us new information to re-evaluate our thoughts.

If he dies because mafia stacks, all the better. This means, if we miss, we killed 1 extra townie day 1, but also saved 1 extra townie night 1. Pretty even. If the Day Vig doesn't shoot, there is a chance that he gets sniped night 1, especially with all the talk about him.

I think it's beneficial to have him shoot. The problem is... is there a Day Vig? o.O

K so he's for the plan, but he WANTS TO LYNCH FOR INFORMATION. NEVER LYNCH FOR INFORMATION HOLY SHIT.

He also say's that it's good that the confirmed townie will die...which was the whole issue with the plan.

On August 02 2011 09:08 ghrur wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 02 2011 09:00 Curu wrote:
On August 02 2011 08:54 redFF wrote:
On August 02 2011 08:51 Curu wrote:
Huh? I don't understand your post. The confirmed Townie tells the player who he is going to shoot or protect, he doesn't tell all Medics what every Medic is doing.

Since we know how much KP Mafia has I very much doubt any of them are going to be able to claim Vig.

So you want one townie conducting every single vig hit/medic protect/hatter bomb?

k here's an example.

Mafia-I will be protecting player x
Confirmed townie-no someone else is protecting him.

now mafia know's to not hit player x.


I would be more open to this plan day 2 or 3. But all i see is 2 townies getting lynched and losing a dayvig and that person most likely dying the next night.


No, it goes like this:

Mafia-I will be protecting player x
Confirmed townie-stfu I choose who you protect, you'll be protecting player y
Mafia-Okay...


Yup, and if Mafia shoots player Y, and player Y dies, then clearly the medic isn't a medic but is mafia. :/ So if mafia tries to be medic, it effectively hurts them.

Still supports the plan, but here he actually makes a nonsensical point. Nobody was suggesting the mafia would claim protecting someone and then shoot them instead...

On August 03 2011 17:35 ghrur wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 03 2011 12:42 JeeJee wrote:
actually screw it let's get the ball rolling.
anyone disagree with drazerk as a candidate?


Yeah, I do. I played with Drazerk AA and he acted the same way. If I recall, it was basically a "Lynch Wiggles" post and then afk.

I'm down for either varpulis or Kenpachi.
I don't get why sandroba's supposed to have seemed town. I mean, looking back on the plan, I realize it's incredibly bad.
and this post by sandroba
docH, how is the simple fact that it's no longer day1 is going to make lynches more acurate down the line? If we can speed up the process and basically skip night 1 how is it possibly bad for town?

What? He knows better than this. So the plan basically becomes let's out the dayvig and give mafia a free blue. :/

This is his very next post. Disagrees with a Drazerk lynch, and gives fucking awful meta reason to do so. This is not like AA at all lol.

Here is the most important thing though. His last 3 posts were all behind the plan 100%!!! But now, with no explanation apart from, the plan sucks. He comes out and calls Sandroba scummy and says the plan is terrible. Did your mafia buddies tell you to do this in the QT????
On August 04 2011 07:21 ghrur wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 04 2011 07:19 youngminii wrote:
On August 04 2011 07:18 ghrur wrote:
Wow, towns are getting better at Day 1. :O

or scum is getting worse


Don't be a pessimist. I support the shooting of JeeJee

He hasn't mentioned JeeJee at all before, yet posts saying he wants him shot with NO REASONING.

also

SCUMSLIP ALERT SCUMSLIP ALERT SCUMSLIP ALERT

He says Don't be a pessimist in response to YM saying that scum is getting worse. Actual "scumslips" are very rare, but i'm fairly certain I just found one.


On August 04 2011 08:19 ghrur wrote:
Redff:
Yes, I understand lynching for information was bad. I was making the point that losing 3 townies is losing 3 townies until I realized day-vigis get 2 shots so we still effectively lose a vigi, and later shots are more accurate. Why did I change positions? I argued with DrH about this in Mafia IRC and reconsidered my position.

Show nested quote +

Still supports the plan, but here he actually makes a nonsensical point. Nobody was suggesting the mafia would claim protecting someone and then shoot them instead...

Neither was I... I was stating how fake-claims by mafia would hurt them under the plan... Like, do you not understand that that was a continuation of thought from what Curu said? >_>

Also, you're tunneling by the third "point." Did you not read "looking back?" I re-evaluated my position. Would you like to hear why I realize it's a bad plan?
A. It lures out a confirmed townie and ends up with him getting shot.
B. We lose a vigi shot early with the opportunity cost of getting a better shot later on.
C. Vigis get 2 shots, so even if Dayvig dies, it's not a confirmed townie that dies, but a confirmed blue.
D. Instead of ending up with 3 greens dead if mafia stacks, we end up with 2 greens dead and 1 blue dead. Much worse.
So what does this effectively do? Lure out a blue for mafia to kill! Why would Sandroba suggest such a plan then! Why was I stupid enough to support it? Because I was stupid.

I never mentioned JeeJee before... except in IRC and talking about it to TAA. Guess what? I also find Munk-E scummy but I've never mentioned him before in thread either. I don't post everything I think.


K, so first of all he said he re-evauluated his position, but at the time gave no reasons why, just "realized it was a bad plan" After i call him out on this though he regurgitates a bunch of reasons already made multiple times in the thread. GJ DUDE.

K apparently he's been doing lots of scumhunting and has thought about JEEJEE and MUnk-e but is not posting it in the thread. I SWEAR GUYS IVE BEEN ACTIVELY SCUMHUNTING AND THINKING ABOUT PLAYERS BUT I WONT POST MY THOUGHTS IN THE THREAD.

This is ridiculous, here's where it gets really awesome.
Then i posted this

On August 04 2011 08:23 redFF wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 04 2011 08:19 ghrur wrote:
Redff:
Yes, I understand lynching for information was bad. I was making the point that losing 3 townies is losing 3 townies until I realized day-vigis get 2 shots so we still effectively lose a vigi, and later shots are more accurate. Why did I change positions? I argued with DrH about this in Mafia IRC and reconsidered my position.


Still supports the plan, but here he actually makes a nonsensical point. Nobody was suggesting the mafia would claim protecting someone and then shoot them instead...

Neither was I... I was stating how fake-claims by mafia would hurt them under the plan... Like, do you not understand that that was a continuation of thought from what Curu said? >_>

Also, you're tunneling by the third "point." Did you not read "looking back?" I re-evaluated my position. Would you like to hear why I realize it's a bad plan?
A. It lures out a confirmed townie and ends up with him getting shot.
B. We lose a vigi shot early with the opportunity cost of getting a better shot later on.
C. Vigis get 2 shots, so even if Dayvig dies, it's not a confirmed townie that dies, but a confirmed blue.
D. Instead of ending up with 3 greens dead if mafia stacks, we end up with 2 greens dead and 1 blue dead. Much worse.
So what does this effectively do? Lure out a blue for mafia to kill! Why would Sandroba suggest such a plan then! Why was I stupid enough to support it? Because I was stupid.

I never mentioned JeeJee before... except in IRC and talking about it to TAA. Guess what? I also find Munk-E scummy but I've never mentioned him before in thread either. I don't post everything I think.

lol ur scum
I got called scummy for talking about stuff on the public irc channel, your talking about all your reads in pms to a couple of people. that is scummy as fuck.

Please post your thoughts on both JeeJee and Munk-E. you have 10 minutes because if you already talked about it to other then i assume you will be able to post about it..

On August 04 2011 08:25 ghrur wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 04 2011 08:23 redFF wrote:
On August 04 2011 08:19 ghrur wrote:
Redff:
Yes, I understand lynching for information was bad. I was making the point that losing 3 townies is losing 3 townies until I realized day-vigis get 2 shots so we still effectively lose a vigi, and later shots are more accurate. Why did I change positions? I argued with DrH about this in Mafia IRC and reconsidered my position.


Still supports the plan, but here he actually makes a nonsensical point. Nobody was suggesting the mafia would claim protecting someone and then shoot them instead...

Neither was I... I was stating how fake-claims by mafia would hurt them under the plan... Like, do you not understand that that was a continuation of thought from what Curu said? >_>

Also, you're tunneling by the third "point." Did you not read "looking back?" I re-evaluated my position. Would you like to hear why I realize it's a bad plan?
A. It lures out a confirmed townie and ends up with him getting shot.
B. We lose a vigi shot early with the opportunity cost of getting a better shot later on.
C. Vigis get 2 shots, so even if Dayvig dies, it's not a confirmed townie that dies, but a confirmed blue.
D. Instead of ending up with 3 greens dead if mafia stacks, we end up with 2 greens dead and 1 blue dead. Much worse.
So what does this effectively do? Lure out a blue for mafia to kill! Why would Sandroba suggest such a plan then! Why was I stupid enough to support it? Because I was stupid.

I never mentioned JeeJee before... except in IRC and talking about it to TAA. Guess what? I also find Munk-E scummy but I've never mentioned him before in thread either. I don't post everything I think.

lol ur scum
I got called scummy for talking about stuff on the public irc channel, your talking about all your reads in pms to a couple of people. that is scummy as fuck.

Please post your thoughts on both JeeJee and Munk-E. you have 10 minutes because if you already talked about it to other then i assume you will be able to post about it..


What? I talked about it in the public IRC channel except for TAA whom i just talked in IRC privately.

And to be honest, I don't really care. Lol. I'm not gonna bullshit an analysis in 10 minutes to protect you so you can tunnel me harder.

It wouldnt be bullshit if you have already discussed these players in length outside the thread would it? Stalling for time mr.scum....
On August 04 2011 11:32 ghrur wrote:
+ Show Spoiler +
On August 04 2011 08:53 redFF wrote:
alanismorisette:
ghrur ur mafia too stfu
[7:57pm] alanismorisette:
post that analysis
[7:57pm] alanismorisette:
its not bullshit if you have already discussed it with people
[7:57pm] alanismorisette:
just post what you talked about with them
[7:57pm] alanismorisette:
quick!
[7:57pm] ghrur:
It's been past 10 minutes
[7:57pm] ghrur:
My deadline is gone
[7:58pm] ghrur:
and I wanna play basketball
[7:58pm] alanismorisette:
...
[7:58pm] ghrur:
Besides, I already said
[7:58pm] chaos13 joined the chat room.
[7:58pm] ghrur:
I didn't save the chat log
[7:58pm] alanismorisette:
doesnt matter
[7:58pm] ghrur:
Ask TAA if he has it
[7:58pm] alanismorisette:
just post the gist of ur position on them
[7:58pm] alanismorisette:
easy
[7:58pm] alanismorisette:
just do that for me
[7:58pm] ghrur:
Sure, I'll do it
[7:58pm] ghrur:
But I'd rather play basketball
[7:58pm] alanismorisette:
...
[7:58pm] ghrur:
I'll post it afterwards kay?
[7:58pm] alanismorisette:
do it please
[7:58pm] alanismorisette:
no
[7:58pm] alanismorisette:
now
[7:58pm] ghrur:
No, real life > mafia
[7:58pm] alanismorisette:
im sorry but everyone is seeing this right
[7:59pm] alanismorisette:
it will take
[7:59pm] alanismorisette:
like 5 minutes
[7:59pm] alanismorisette:
dude
[7:59pm] youngmin:
i'm laughing my ass off
[7:59pm] alanismorisette:
you could have finished it by now
[7:59pm] ghrur:
??? YM?
[7:59pm] ghrur:
Cya later
[7:59pm] ghrur:
<3
[7:59pm] alanismorisette:
but instead you are gonna go think about it
[7:59pm] ghrur:
I'll post it after
[7:59pm] youngmin:
lolololol
[7:59pm] alanismorisette:
then post it
[7:59pm] alanismorisette:
...
[7:59pm] ghrur:
Yes, I didn't need to think about my defense
[7:59pm] ghrur:
<3
[7:59pm] ghrur:
Cya
[8:00pm] alanismorisette:
...

fuck this guy

HAHAHAHAHAHA, sorry red. xD No, I really did go play basketball, hahaha. I didn't mean any ill will. Hahahaha. I'm glad YM had a good laugh though. Besides, 10 minutes had passed and nothing happened.

Anyway, down to business. Why Munk-E?

+ Show Spoiler +
+ Show Spoiler [monk-e's analysis] +
On August 03 2011 07:21 Munk-E wrote:
Below is some analysis of varpulis' posts i'll do more people later.


Show nested quote +
Alright guys, it's game on. I'd like to start with a suggestion. It's very basic, but very vital.

Vig's, be you day or night, holster your gun and try to ignore the itch of your trigger finger. This holds true in every game, but it's especially important in this one. Look at the role list, and see how much kp we potentially have in the game. Every vig role has two shots, half of them can shoot during the day. That's a lot of kp that will be a lot more useful later on.

Dayvigs: If you must shoot, claim and let us discuss. If you're willing to shoot, make sure that you've got approval from the town. Gut shots are wrong as often as they're right.

Hatters: You guys are special, because even if the scumbag mafia doesn't kill you, your bob-ombs will still go off. You also can't move them, so I don't think it's a smart idea to place them from the get go. Wait a day/night cycle, at least. It's for the good of everybody.

With that said, let's get to the game and kill us some scum. As an aside, i'm currently very dissapointed that Kurumi didn't give me my favorite class, though I guess it can't be helped, he wasn't in the game anyways.


Here he says to not shoot day 1, unless you want to that is, then just reveal your plan forcing you to shoot anyways because you're gonna die, because you revealed your role. I don't see his opinion, because he keeps changing it in this post. at the beginning he says to not shoot, as always and it is especially important in this game, followed by him saying it's okay for dayvigs to shoot.
Furthermore he tells them to claim before shooting! Claiming is a death sentence, and it means they'd have to shoot to take people down with them, because they're gonna die anyway.

As an aside, does anyone know what his favorite role is?

Show nested quote +
My only real qualm about the plan is the possibility of 2 dead townies day 1, but I don't see a huge problem with setting up a town circle around a confirmed dayvig.

People shouldn't be expecting shitloads of blues though. If we have a medic, which we might not, (21 players, remember) they will be tied up making sure the only confirmed player doesn't kick the bucket.

Nothing should be shared in IRC that would not be shared in thread, by the way. If our confirmed town wants to direct blues or if people want to claim to him, do it in PMs, for the love of god, and don't start talking in thread or irc like you're a confirmed blue.

The only one who should know is the confirmed townie. Information leaks kills blues in PM games.

Should we use the plan, I suggest a very simple system: vote normally. Whoever has the most votes dies.


So, here he fully supports the plan again despite his own extra important rule of not shooting day 1. He first says no shooting, then says maybe IF you make sure your going to get yourself killed, and finally now he's all for it!

Show nested quote +
Anybody who is publicly known to be controlling the blues/leading the town is going to get shot eventually, especially if they've got kp.

I'll eat my hat if we've got more than 1 medic in a 20 player game.

Here he will eat his hat if his plan that he loves so much which goes against his extra important rule actually works...
Show nested quote +
hmm, it's a good point actually.

A serious question: Do you guys think we'll have a better chance of killing scum if we do this day 1?

If we can kill scum it's worth it (durr) but otherwise I have a safer suggestion:

Why don't we wait until there are only 2 mafia left. That way they can't doublestack and we don't lose a blue role night 1.

this is after being asked why he likes the plan after he gave his own piece of evidence against it (above)! He gives no answer. Instead, he reverts to a compromise of his beloved plan. and no varpulis, it's a 20% chance. I'm not willing to take that risk, especially because it's roughly the same odds we'll hit a blue.



Show nested quote +
I'm fairly sure that i'm not scum, unless I have a serious problem with reading pms.

RedFF I'm not so sure on. I'm leaning scum because he started off his "no plan" campaign without evidence or an argument, and then just picked up DrH's and copied it, it seems.

That said, I don't disagree with DrH. Our confirmed townie will be dead night 1, and we'll be back to square one, possibly with 2 dead townies. Again, the plan is really good, but only if we wait for mafia to not have enough kp to override the medic protect we will most likely be able to slap on the confirmed townie.

To address Mig's accusation: In irc sandroba didn't explain his plan entirely. I read it as "double lynch day 1" period. That in itself is very bad. The good part of the plan is the confirmed townie. When he posted and explained that point, It sounded good.

Then I realized that mafia can double stack and just kill the confirmed townie, it sounded bad again, until i figured out a solution.

Is there a real reason that we need to use the plan right now? With patience, it will work better, i guarantee.


Here his is accusing redff for taking the position of the argument HE'S taking! (Maybe he lost track by now!) It seems like he's just trying to accuse someone for the sake of accusing!

Wishy-washy doesn't even begin to explain this. He just won't make up his mind! While I'm not sure this indicates him 100% as being scum, it is VERY suspicious. Unfortunately however, I don't think it's possible to brand him as scum from JUST this. but he's certainly quite possibly scum.



+ Show Spoiler [missed post] +
On August 03 2011 07:34 Lucidity wrote:
I think you missed one of Varpulis' important posts Munk-E:

Show nested quote +
On August 03 2011 03:23 Varpulis wrote:
On August 03 2011 02:43 Mig wrote:
Varp every post you make screams wishy washy to me. Where is the confident Varpulis I have played with in the past? Every opinion you give you list the pros and cons and then you end up taking a pretty neutral stance. I haven't seen you have a strong opinion of anything yet.

If you had to vote for someone right now who would it be for and why? Do you find anyone besides red scummy?

I got called out for wishy washiness in PTP (day 1) as well. Day 1 nothing is solid, there's rarely anything to base arguments off of until late in the day, and I'm usually focused on proving my activity, not calling people scum. I haven't taken a stance because I don't have a really strong feeling about anybody yet.

By the way, if we're going ahead with the plan, could we have a soldier/sniper claim? If there are none we need to reevaluate.




Well, in his analysis of Varpulis, notice first that he misses an important post which Lucidity points out. He seemed to be doing a post-by-post style analysis (which btw, is bad), yet misses that important post? Why? To hid Varpulis's scumminess. To be nicer to his teammate.

Also notice in this analysis how adamant he is with the attack on Varpulis. He uses multiple exclamation points, capitalization for emphasis, and even calls him VERY suspicious. BUT WAIT! He backs out of it. Notice:

I'm not sure this indicates him 100% as being scum

but he's certainly quite possibly scum.


Certainly quite possibly scum. LOL. I have never seen more wishy-washyness than that. Hahaha, god. That's just backing out of it completely man. Oh, and notice how there's no vote until nearly the end of the day, probably to bus. Oh, and he never votes in the voting thread (booooooooooo).

Now, on Munk-E's next analysis, his style totally changes! Someone in Loonybin pointed this out:
Munk-E's posts go like this - 1. Stuff about plan. 2. Play-by-play "analysis" 3. Normal, concise analysis. How does one person's posting style change that much? I don't know, seems like he has a team behind him.

Look at his arguments as well. Are they new? Are they original? Or are they just parroting OriginalName? Yeah, they're just parroting ON's analysis that Varp was wishy-washy.

Note this remark too.
On August 04 2011 03:53 Munk-E wrote:He seems VERY eager to get everyone's opinion on everyone, he PMed me asking my opinion on chaos and varp, to which i responded blandly and generically.
I don't get why that's bad. It's good that Mig is trying to get people's opinions out and into the open. It's also good that he's pressuring people and using PMs well. Calling that scummy is just trying to stifle PMs and opinions.

On August 04 2011 03:53 Munk-E wrote:I don't see why activity is a "town" thing to do. and why lurking is a mafia thing really, especially if being a lurker makes them suspected as being mafia. (Meta, huh?) Anyway, i might vote for him depending on if i think lucidity is more scummy or not


Activity is of course good for town because this means we get more to analyze. Stifling activity and supporting lurking is just trying to ruin the town atmosphere. Mig did nothing wrong, even with his words, yet he's attacking him randomly. Why? Why is he also jumping from person to person and throwing out random accusations that don't even make sense? Why doesn't h vote for either of the people he analyzed? To get the town in chaos. To get votes off of Varpulis. Also, if he suspected Lucidity, why doesn't he analyze HIM instead? Now, keep this in mind when you read this:

On August 04 2011 06:33 Munk-E wrote:
TBH, It would have been a toss up between varp and lucid for me, but I haven't done proper analysis of lucid, so voting for him would look VERY suspicious. I think both are scum anyway.


Where is Mig in this equation? Why wouldn't he mention Mig if he did a full blown analysis calling him suspicious? That makes no sense... unless he did it just to seem town. If he found Lucid suspicious, he should've analyzed Lucidity first instead of going after Mig. Unless he's just trying to cast doubt, out one of our top scumhunters, seem town in the process through analysis posts, and end up not voting for them until the end of the day. :/ Yeah, seems about right.


Now, onto JeeJee.

+ Show Spoiler +
On August 03 2011 01:41 JeeJee wrote:
pressure votes are stupid, where did this trend come from? you know when you say "yeah this is a pressure vote", that's pretty much equivalent to "idk who to vote so i'm voting you, but i'm not actually suspicious of you because all you need to do is say something and i'll remove my vote from you".
nobody can seriously feel threatened from a pressure vote, so there's no 'pressure' it's just a throwaway vote


Okay, this post was stupid. yes, pressure votes are bad. No, you do not need to point them out. If the person being pressured doesn't know this, they might slip up. Now that he knows this, the chances are lessened. Why would you post this? It provides no benefit to town, and only serves to help mafia. I'm not arguing against the logic here, but the purpose. It serves no good purpose.

i see re-evaluation there, not wishy-washiness. do you see otherwise? random fos are just as useless as pressure votes. sandro and varp are both bad in that department as far as i'm concerned. by itself though, it doesn't mean much, and there's nothing else yet.

as for me, i don't have scum leanings on anyone. town leans yes, scum leans no.

Defense of Varp, and aside from that, no information really. I mean, he seems to suspect YM at this point, but doesn't say anything about it. Not even a scum lean? Really? Hmmmmm, Idk.

still not voting, but i'll be here before the deadline tomorrow, no worries.

Wishy washyyyyyyyyyyy. Yeah... why would you call someone scum and then not vote? I don't know.

On August 03 2011 12:42 JeeJee wrote:
actually screw it let's get the ball rolling.
anyone disagree with drazerk as a candidate?

Why would you ask if other people disagree? Who cares if other people disagree? You still push them anyway. They'll voice their disagreements anyway. Do you need town's permission or something? No! So why all the caution? Serves no purpose.

On August 04 2011 05:14 JeeJee wrote:
i still think the case against varp is terrible. it's pretty much equivalent to redff's case, which is equally bad. drazerk is still deliberately avoiding this thread while posting in others but sadly not enough people care. seems to be off to a wonderful start.


This is just saying, yes, you lynched a mafia, but you're still not off to a good start. It doesn't mean much. Well, why wouldn't it? We lynched scum, we have voting records, and we have defenses. He defended Varp. He's trying to justify it in this post. He's trying to throw off suspicion. I don't like it. He also shifts the attention off the Varp lynch and onto Drazerk again. Why do that? The lynch means a lot since a red just died. Focus on it. :/ Seems like he's throwing doubt around with that remark.

After waiting a couple of hours to actually make analysis's of these 2 players. He basically regurgitates what others (BC) have said about jeejee and then calls pbpas bad and does 2 lol. All his points about other players being scum come down to them being "wishy washy". Shitty post. Shitty analysis.
On August 04 2011 11:37 ghrur wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 04 2011 11:33 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
really you pick munke over sevryn or bc


Idk what BC's up to to be honest.

More evidence as to how these guys are scumbuddies.
On August 05 2011 02:52 ghrur wrote:He also calls him out for being wishy-washy, against meta, and scummy. Meanwhile, he says Drazerk's meta doesn't fit his scum. Idk why a vote wasn't placed on Varp by him unless he is scum.

That's literally the only way you scumhunt and all the reasons you use for calling people scum and then you call someone else out on it.

Please read and reread this this bitch be mafia broz


##Vote Ghrur
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 04 2011 22:33 GMT
#567
Here's what i think of taa.
i think taa is just cocky shitty town. he thinks he played well in arkham so now thinks he is BOSSMODE and is trying to do some retarded shit because he thinks he is the greatest mafia player in the world. Town read imo. LaL isn't good when its fairly clear its just some newbie who thinks he is hot shit.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 04 2011 23:02 GMT
#573
barundar

On August 04 2011 04:43 Barundar wrote:
Activity level has been so low all day, and varpulis defense so bad, that I don't think he can be scum. Of luci drazek and JeeJee, JeeJee seems like the scummiest to me.

#Vote JeeJee

That is not a good reason to vote.

On August 04 2011 09:33 Barundar wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 04 2011 09:27 redFF wrote:
On August 04 2011 09:21 Curu wrote:
I'd prefer the Vig on JeeJee/Munk-E and the DT on BC. Medic on Mig.

why medic on mig? A medic on ON or DrH is wayy better.

Mig was the one starting the case on varpulis, posting the initial analysis and pressuring him through the day. I consider ON and DrH town as well though. As a side note Trotske is most likely town based on Varpulis' FoS.

I wouldn't DT check JeeJee or BC, if mafia they are most likely to be the godfather.

why because you know one of them will come back as mafia???

talk more please.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 05 2011 01:06 GMT
#581
On August 05 2011 09:55 Drazerk wrote:
##vote: JeeJee

Reasons stated earlier in the thread.

Going to bed keep posting IRC discussions.

nope you dont get to do that why are you voting shinbi?
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 05 2011 01:39 GMT
#601
On August 05 2011 07:33 redFF wrote:
Here's what i think of taa.
i think taa is just cocky shitty town. he thinks he played well in arkham so now thinks he is BOSSMODE and is trying to do some retarded shit because he thinks he is the greatest mafia player in the world. Town read imo. LaL isn't good when its fairly clear its just some newbie who thinks he is hot shit.

This is what TAA is, not scum.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 05 2011 01:59 GMT
#607
The Lucidity case is based on JeeJee flipping red IMO, since if he wasn't actually Mafia trying to save Varpulis then it's a null tell.

Can we actually stop saying this. Nobody is scum/town because any other person flipped scum/town. All that leads to is wifom.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 05 2011 15:32 GMT
#624
On August 03 2011 09:12 redFF wrote:
[image loading]

redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 05 2011 19:32 GMT
#644
On August 06 2011 03:44 Mig wrote:
I was going to wait for chaos and sevryn to show up before I posted this but half way through and they are still awol so gonna post it so everyone can discuss.

One of JeeJee/Bc is pretty much guaranteed scum.

DrH, BC, JeeJee have all claimed medic to me. I talked with BC, ON and DrH who have experience hosting and the odds that there are 3 medics 1 vet in a 20 man game, even with 2 rbers, is virtually none. I trust DrH so I am fairly confident he is telling me the truth. So we can almost guarantee that one of BC/JeeJee is lying. The case against JeeJee is much stronger I believe. He A) defended Varp right after I made the first case against him B) he put virtually 0 effort into contributing analysis and scum hunting, yet when people call him out he comes in and defends himself strongly. So the current plan should be to lynch JeeJee and if he flips red we can try to work out the best plan for the medics, probably something like one defends me one defends the other medic.

Assuming JeeJee flips red then the other 2 scum are very likely between YM/Chaos/Sevryn/Lucid

Ok yeah then i'm fine with a JeeJee lynch. Was their any reason to out all the medics tho?

Also JeeJee who did you protect?
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 05 2011 21:19 GMT
#664
On August 06 2011 06:17 Barundar wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 06 2011 04:51 Sevryn wrote:
On August 06 2011 03:44 Mig wrote:
I was going to wait for chaos and sevryn to show up before I posted this but half way through and they are still awol so gonna post it so everyone can discuss.

One of JeeJee/Bc is pretty much guaranteed scum.

DrH, BC, JeeJee have all claimed medic to me. I talked with BC, ON and DrH who have experience hosting and the odds that there are 3 medics 1 vet in a 20 man game, even with 2 rbers, is virtually none. I trust DrH so I am fairly confident he is telling me the truth. So we can almost guarantee that one of BC/JeeJee is lying. The case against JeeJee is much stronger I believe. He A) defended Varp right after I made the first case against him B) he put virtually 0 effort into contributing analysis and scum hunting, yet when people call him out he comes in and defends himself strongly. So the current plan should be to lynch JeeJee and if he flips red we can try to work out the best plan for the medics, probably something like one defends me one defends the other medic.

Assuming JeeJee flips red then the other 2 scum are very likely between YM/Chaos/Sevryn/Lucid

I'm sorry I'm catching up on the thread how am I connected to these people?

Sevrin the problem is you are the most invisible poster in the thread, I can't remember anything of your stances or posts, neither good or bad. If you are town you should try and be more active and involved.

For an example you could look into YM and chaos13?

reminds me of someone
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 05 2011 23:40 GMT
#666
On August 06 2011 00:50 Kurumi wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 06 2011 00:32 redFF wrote:
On August 03 2011 09:12 redFF wrote:
[image loading]


Amazing . Just like the warning You got .

............................................________
....................................,.-'"...................``~.,
.............................,.-"..................................."-.,
.........................,/...............................................":,
.....................,?......................................................,
.................../...........................................................,}
................./......................................................,:`^`..}
.............../...................................................,:"........./
..............?.....__.........................................:`.........../
............./__.(....."~-,_..............................,:`........../
.........../(_...."~,_........"~,_....................,:`........_/
..........{.._$;_......"=,_......."-,_.......,.-~-,},.~";/....}
...........((.....*~_......."=-._......";,,./`..../"............../
...,,,___.`~,......"~.,....................`.....}............../
............(....`=-,,.......`........................(......;_,,-"
............/.`~,......`-...................................../
.............`~.*-,.....................................|,./.....,__
,,_..........}.>-._...................................|..............`=~-,
.....`=~-,__......`,.................................
...................`=~-,,.,...............................
................................`:,,...........................`..............__
.....................................`=-,...................,%`>--==``
........................................_..........._,-%.......`
...................................,
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 06 2011 01:52 GMT
#676
Ok it seems like Jeejee is gonna be lynched. I don't wanna waste half a day so lets move on to other suspects. What do people think of my case on Ghrur? What do people think of lucid? What do people think of Chaos13? Of munke? Of ym? i dont want this thread to die.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 06 2011 03:00 GMT
#686
On August 06 2011 11:34 ghrur wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 06 2011 11:19 youngminii wrote:
ok so when jeejee flips green can we kill bc?


You do realize no matter what he flips we're going to kill you right?
Like, how can any townie be so sure of another person's role/alignment so as to say he'll DT check green and flip green? At best, it's mafia trying to gain town cred. At worst, it's just mafia trying to protect the godfather.

no...
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 06 2011 03:01 GMT
#687
On August 06 2011 12:00 redFF wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 06 2011 11:34 ghrur wrote:
On August 06 2011 11:19 youngminii wrote:
ok so when jeejee flips green can we kill bc?


You do realize no matter what he flips we're going to kill you right?
Like, how can any townie be so sure of another person's role/alignment so as to say he'll DT check green and flip green? At best, it's mafia trying to gain town cred. At worst, it's just mafia trying to protect the godfather.

no...

to elaborate this post seems like
"if he flips green we will mislynch again!"
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 06 2011 03:16 GMT
#691
btw green=town not vt is how ive always understood it. so saying someone is green implies town aligned not just vt.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 06 2011 03:25 GMT
#692
he was sure jeejee would come back green as a dt check because he thinks jeejee is town. is that so hard to understand?
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 07 2011 00:31 GMT
#753
Oh cool lol. Gj everyone. I'm thinking last 2 scum are within munk, ghrur, chaos, ym and lucid.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 07 2011 00:47 GMT
#755
On August 07 2011 09:31 Munk-E wrote:
Wait... I just realized the mafia still has a RB... this means that 1 medic is sure to die.

By just realized you mean you looked at your role pm right?
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 07 2011 02:26 GMT
#758
doesnt matter all it would do is provide a hefty chunk of wifom
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 07 2011 14:53 GMT
#769
The whole point is that jeejee was gf tho
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 07 2011 18:58 GMT
#796
well looks like the plan worked sorry i doubted you lol, mafia seem to be dumber then we think...
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 07 2011 23:16 GMT
#842
Sorry how is syllogism confirmed veteran? For all we know he could be lying about it.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 07 2011 23:19 GMT
#843
AHAHAA WAIT MUNKE WAS A VET? LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOL
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 07 2011 23:19 GMT
#844
Mig i would like your reasoning to treating syllo as telling the truth and munk-e as lying scum.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 07 2011 23:42 GMT
#845
Yup so here's a question. If Munk-e was scum for claiming vet and it was unreasonable there were 5 vets when munk-e was alive. How come now hes dead and flipped vet are we not looking at the other claimed vets. And before you say they counterclaimed jeejee, no they didnt. Jeejee claimed medic, not vet. So from a mafia perspective claiming vet/medic would have been fine. I'd like to ask that we dont majority lynch again, as it leaves us with very little vote discussion. This game is not as won as some of you may think.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 07 2011 23:51 GMT
#847
On August 02 2011 21:04 syllogism wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 02 2011 09:20 chaos13 wrote:
DrH has the right idea here. Yes, confirmed townies are excellent. However, mafia can easily fake claim a role like medic or vig, and then we would need to waste our DT checks in order to confirm those claims. Not only that, but we have no idea who the day vig actually is. If it's in the hands of a weaker player, that could lead to complete and utter disaster. Having one player coordinate all the actions of the blues is never a good thing. There is far too much room for error in such a situation, especially since mafia are able to PM and influence the game as well. Ultimately, however, it is up to the individuals with the roles to decide what to do. Discussion about this is very good, but I would rather not waste all day with it. Just something to keep in mind if we're still arguing about it in 24 hours.

Vigis, because there are probably a lot of you in here: Do not shoot unless it is at confirmed scum. If you feel you must shoot anyway, take out lurkers and liars. This sort of common sense is all too often ignored, and results in dead town. Even take DT claims with a grain of salt. If analysis points to a player being town when a claimed check has shown red, proceed with caution. It could be a miller or a scum's fake claim in order to waste a vig shot, especially if the claimed DT player has been under suspicion.

No one is confirmed scum until they flip. You even go on to say red checks can be millers or the DT fake claiming; vigs should be shooting at people they believe are likely scum. Overall I'm not a huge fan of this post as you joined the anti-sandroba plan wagon quite late, you cover all the angles without really taking a strong position and the part about DTs fake claiming feels a bit forced.

On August 08 2011 03:51 syllogism wrote:
Not much to add. 5 vets would be absurd even with 2 RBs

##vote Munk-E

So then one of the remaining claimed vets is scum then right?
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 07 2011 23:52 GMT
#848
Has anyone claimed being blocked today?
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 08 2011 00:03 GMT
#849
On August 08 2011 05:37 OriginalName wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 08 2011 05:36 Barundar wrote:
Lulz. Can we lynch YM?


yes.

YEAH FO'SURE LETS MISLYNCH AGAIN.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 08 2011 00:07 GMT
#850
we shouldnt majority lynch tommorow, we should go back to regular lynches and here analysis and cases instead of retardedly lynching ppl off of "scumslips"
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 08 2011 03:45 GMT
#854
On August 08 2011 12:32 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 08 2011 12:07 chaos13 wrote:
wtf is going on here.

So we unexpectedly have majority lynch and a shortened phase and Munk flipped vet? Well then we really need to start looking at those other vet claims

I feel like this is some weird medic/vig/dtless setup, with just a bunch of vets. Continue lynching based on post analysis, town outnumbers mafia so greatly that we can afford to do that. If we hit a dead end, come back to the mig circle (mig/me/bc/syllo) and start doing some digging.

I agree, lets have some ym/chaos13/lucid/whoever you think is scum analysis people.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 08 2011 07:12 GMT
#858
On August 08 2011 16:08 Barundar wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 08 2011 08:42 redFF wrote:
Yup so here's a question. If Munk-e was scum for claiming vet and it was unreasonable there were 5 vets when munk-e was alive. How come now hes dead and flipped vet are we not looking at the other claimed vets. And before you say they counterclaimed jeejee, no they didnt. Jeejee claimed medic, not vet. So from a mafia perspective claiming vet/medic would have been fine. I'd like to ask that we dont majority lynch again, as it leaves us with very little vote discussion. This game is not as won as some of you may think.

Let's have a look:

DrH: Pushed varp then godfather. Claimed hit last night.
BC: Voted for godfather day 1. Claims roleblock last night.
Mig: Lead the varp lynch. Claims hit night 1.
Syllogism: Has clearly been working closely with Mig day 1. Has been pushing for both Varp and JeeJee. I trust Mig's judgement on this one.

How is any of them not confirmed?

Then we have lucid claiming. He is by no means confirmed, but the timing of his claim makes no sense from a scum perspective. If he just learned about Munk-E being vet, claiming vet himself would be the stupidest thing to do. It's way more likely that he just saw a problem with the logic that let to the Munk-E lynch, aka: 5 vets is stupid, lynch liar lol.

Anyway mafia can kill anyone they want tonight with roleblock + kp combo. Mig I hope you give all information to one of the other confirmed towns.

YM+chaos13 still seems by far the most likely scum combo.

Explain this statement!
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 08 2011 16:49 GMT
#870
On August 09 2011 00:44 Mig wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 08 2011 08:19 redFF wrote:
Mig i would like your reasoning to treating syllo as telling the truth and munk-e as lying scum.


3 things

1) I claimed vet to syllo before n1. So he could have rbd and killed me but instead I was just shot.

2) he knew about the fake plan and it succeeded.

3) he knew about all the vet claims before JeeJee claimed. So he would have warned JeeJee not to claim medic most likely.

Do any of these things 100% prove syllo is town? No. But combined the odds that he did all 3 as scum are very very low.


On August 09 2011 00:47 Mig wrote:
DrH did tell me that he told YM that he was a vet day 1. So that confuses things a bit. He may have believed Doc was just lying to him tho, I can't say for sure.

Either way YM is still a good candidate but Chaos/lucid are both very good candidates as well.

So they both knew about the fakeplan, and it succeeded. K thanks, more stuff on ym please this aint enough.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 08 2011 17:00 GMT
#872
But ym had still been told drh was a vet.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 08 2011 18:59 GMT
#892
lol
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 08 2011 22:59 GMT
#918
LOL
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 09 2011 05:27 GMT
#930
On August 09 2011 13:20 Curu wrote:
Well Town, let's get off fucking IRC where everyone just talks about FF6 and cooking and dead RedFF is the MOST ACTIVE PERSON. I mean when a person who can't say anything about the game is the most active in the IRC it's clearly useless.

It's true, im lonely.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 12 2011 18:32 GMT
#1116
ahahhaahah poor kenpachi
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 12 2011 18:33 GMT
#1117
Also i dont think a host should ever let town majority lynch unless its specifically stated in the rules at the beginning of the game, it gives town an unfair advantage.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 12 2011 18:45 GMT
#1119
Not in this case. Regardless that isnt even the issue, the issue was you did it on day 3 when it wasnt part of the rules when people signed up. I'm fine when its lategame and people do that, but there wasnt even confirmed scum and kurumi still set it as majority.
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 12 2011 19:57 GMT
#1129
Yeah i think the key issue was changing the rules midgame though. Don't do that please
redFF
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States3910 Posts
August 12 2011 20:02 GMT
#1131
You're the host you shoulda told them to STFU
Normal
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
Next event in 2h 7m
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
UpATreeSC 162
Nathanias 151
StarCraft: Brood War
Larva 439
BeSt 271
ggaemo 221
firebathero 149
Mong 47
Dota 2
capcasts373
Pyrionflax132
Counter-Strike
fl0m2418
Stewie2K1176
byalli448
Foxcn231
Super Smash Bros
PPMD80
Mew2King55
Liquid`Ken37
Other Games
Grubby5255
shahzam526
KnowMe170
ZombieGrub68
C9.Mang051
Sick44
Organizations
StarCraft 2
Blizzard YouTube
StarCraft: Brood War
BSLTrovo
sctven
[ Show 20 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• davetesta196
• StrangeGG 56
• musti20045 53
• Kozan
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• sooper7s
• intothetv
• IndyKCrew
• LaughNgamezSOOP
• Migwel
StarCraft: Brood War
• FirePhoenix8
• Eskiya23 6
• Pr0nogo 2
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
• BSLYoutube
Dota 2
• masondota22463
League of Legends
• Doublelift4739
• TFBlade872
Other Games
• imaqtpie1938
Upcoming Events
OSC
2h 7m
WardiTV Summer Champion…
13h 7m
WardiTV Summer Champion…
17h 7m
PiGosaur Monday
1d 2h
WardiTV Summer Champion…
1d 13h
Stormgate Nexus
1d 16h
uThermal 2v2 Circuit
1d 18h
The PondCast
2 days
WardiTV Summer Champion…
2 days
Replay Cast
3 days
[ Show More ]
LiuLi Cup
3 days
uThermal 2v2 Circuit
3 days
RSL Revival
4 days
RSL Revival
4 days
uThermal 2v2 Circuit
4 days
CSO Cup
4 days
Sparkling Tuna Cup
5 days
uThermal 2v2 Circuit
5 days
Wardi Open
6 days
RotterdaM Event
6 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

ASL Season 20: Qualifier #2
FEL Cracow 2025
CC Div. A S7

Ongoing

Copa Latinoamericana 4
Jiahua Invitational
BSL 20 Team Wars
KCM Race Survival 2025 Season 3
BSL 21 Qualifiers
HCC Europe
IEM Cologne 2025
FISSURE Playground #1
BLAST.tv Austin Major 2025
ESL Impact League Season 7
IEM Dallas 2025

Upcoming

ASL Season 20
CSLPRO Chat StarLAN 3
BSL Season 21
BSL 21 Team A
RSL Revival: Season 2
Maestros of the Game
SEL Season 2 Championship
WardiTV Summer 2025
uThermal 2v2 Main Event
Thunderpick World Champ.
MESA Nomadic Masters Fall
CS Asia Championships 2025
Roobet Cup 2025
ESL Pro League S22
StarSeries Fall 2025
FISSURE Playground #2
BLAST Open Fall 2025
BLAST Open Fall Qual
Esports World Cup 2025
BLAST Bounty Fall 2025
BLAST Bounty Fall Qual
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2025 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.