|
On February 06 2011 08:17 DoctorHelvetica wrote:Show nested quote +On February 06 2011 08:16 Node wrote:On February 06 2011 08:05 shannn wrote:
Notice something abnormal?
Chaoser hasn't voted yet. If he were town he'd try to help town by actually voting on himself as the first person by saying he's medic but willing to help town which he'll probably do after my post.
It's as if he wants to be saved from getting lynched.
What the hell? This is just the worst kind of WIFOM. While I agree that we should stick with the plan, are you seriously suggestion that the best reaction of an innocent medic is to vote for themselves? That's kind of ridiculous. i don't think shann has played this game before that's why he is saying dumb things like that
No I haven't played this game before like I actually stated in this thread like page 2 or 3.
On February 06 2011 08:16 Node wrote:Show nested quote +On February 06 2011 08:05 shannn wrote:
Notice something abnormal?
Chaoser hasn't voted yet. If he were town he'd try to help town by actually voting on himself as the first person by saying he's medic but willing to help town which he'll probably do after my post.
It's as if he wants to be saved from getting lynched.
What the hell? This is just the worst kind of WIFOM. While I agree that we should stick with the plan, are you seriously suggestion that the best reaction of an innocent medic is to vote for themselves? That's kind of ridiculous.
No I'm not saying it's the best reaction I find it just abnormal that he hasn't voted yet. He says he's a medic shouldn't he then say I think darmousseh is mafia thus vote for him?
That is the curious thing that I found about him.
Ofcourse voting for himself like Kenpachi did is a sign of willing to help town but he didn't hence I found it curious that he isn't showing any sign of willing to help town. Wouldn't you want to help town when you're sure to get lynched in any case?
If he flips green then sure lynch me first and I'll be prove to town that I'm town. But then lynch darmousseh and drh then because on of them is mafia.
|
Night 3
Miss!
Don't you love the 'flip mechanic'?
Sooo Awesome
Chaoser the Medic was lynched
No clues in this post, day begins in 24 hours
|
United States22154 Posts
Damnit! I was sure he was scum, I guess we are lynching darmousseh then?
|
|
|
On February 06 2011 11:06 GMarshal wrote:
Damnit! I was sure he was scum, I guess we are lynching darmousseh then?
Yep. Then we'll go ahead and lynch shann.
|
wow, alright so node is scum.
|
|
|
On February 06 2011 11:22 darmousseh wrote:
wow, alright so node is scum.
lol
|
Wow node, chaoser had you figured out right at the beginning with that random vote. You bussed the very first mafia in order to get the idea that you are mafia out right from the start. When mr wiggles figured out the clues you quickly agreed with him (in 6 mins) and then proceeded from there. Node you have had absolutely 0 contributions. Go back and read everything he has said.
Also DrH if you are mafia, great idea to keep node alive as long as possible. I'm not 100% confident you are mafia, but you are sure acting like it now. Now that I think about it cubed was right about the clues on day 2 all along. The clues on day 2 don't fit node at all, but they might fit you. Too bad cubed plays so aggressively and scum-like or we might have gone with his clues.
Now that I know node is scum, I get to spend time looking for clues in the day 2 post for the actual person to find that last scumbag.
Based on the clues on day 2, drh and shann had the most evidence against them on that day other than cubed's insane town play, since chaoser didn't say he protected pandain, he is definitely a vet and my previous clue hunting was flawed.
Time to go clue hunting again.
|
Well we'll just have to wait until Day 3 to see what happens. I think we should vote or shann, the clues point toward him on Day 2. What makes you think I'm mafia based on posting behavior?
I think the scumteam is you and shann or node and shann. But I'm most sure of shann so I'll wait until Day 3 to figure out who should be lynched after him. Assuming I live that long.
|
I suppose I should respond, lest people actually listen to darmousseh.
On February 06 2011 11:56 darmousseh wrote:
Wow node, chaoser had you figured out right at the beginning with that random vote. You bussed the very first mafia in order to get the idea that you are mafia out right from the start. When mr wiggles figured out the clues you quickly agreed with him (in 6 mins) and then proceeded from there. Node you have had absolutely 0 contributions. Go back and read everything he has said.
Right, because I did the clue research and wrote that whole post in the space of six minutes. I'm not going to argue that my analysis was better than Mr. Wiggles', or anything of that nature. But is your argument here really that I dashed out something appearing as clue analysis the moment Mr. Wiggles posted what he saw? I hope that the other players can recognize coincidence when they see it.
And of course you're the last person to actually vote for Jackal, long after the vote has been decided. And of course Jackal puts his vote on you, likely in an attempt to distance you two as much as possible. You want to talk about agreeing after the fact? How about this post?
On January 30 2011 02:41 shannn wrote:
Upon reading the rest of the comments I have to agree with Mr. Wiggles and Node. Especially Wiggles's explaination points towards Carlos the Jackal. Similar events and himself being a terrorist as well.
That last part of LSB about gravel does make it sound like it's Gaara but the rest of the story doesn't fit him as it seems it's all about 1 person and the story fits others moreso than him.
But let's not exlude the writer as well. Has that writer any stories which is similar to the situations LSB has written?
For now it seems it's either Carlos the Jackal or the writer.
DrH seems to be advocating that we lynch outside of us two before we make this decision. Doctor, are you really so sure of shann that you think he's more likely to be mafia than a 50/50 between myself and darmousseh? Town can't afford to mislynch. Of course, I know I'm town, so I think it's safer to lynch darmousseh. I agree that shann is suspicious, but I feel we simply have less to go on there.
|
This deserves some post-game commentary by me.
|
On February 06 2011 12:29 Node wrote:I suppose I should respond, lest people actually listen to darmousseh. Show nested quote +On February 06 2011 11:56 darmousseh wrote:
Wow node, chaoser had you figured out right at the beginning with that random vote. You bussed the very first mafia in order to get the idea that you are mafia out right from the start. When mr wiggles figured out the clues you quickly agreed with him (in 6 mins) and then proceeded from there. Node you have had absolutely 0 contributions. Go back and read everything he has said.
Right, because I did the clue research and wrote that whole post in the space of six minutes. I'm not going to argue that my analysis was better than Mr. Wiggles', or anything of that nature. But is your argument here really that I dashed out something appearing as clue analysis the moment Mr. Wiggles posted what he saw? I hope that the other players can recognize coincidence when they see it. And of course you're the last person to actually vote for Jackal, long after the vote has been decided. And of course Jackal puts his vote on you, likely in an attempt to distance you two as much as possible. You want to talk about agreeing after the fact? How about this post? Show nested quote +On January 30 2011 02:41 shannn wrote:
Upon reading the rest of the comments I have to agree with Mr. Wiggles and Node. Especially Wiggles's explaination points towards Carlos the Jackal. Similar events and himself being a terrorist as well.
That last part of LSB about gravel does make it sound like it's Gaara but the rest of the story doesn't fit him as it seems it's all about 1 person and the story fits others moreso than him.
But let's not exlude the writer as well. Has that writer any stories which is similar to the situations LSB has written?
For now it seems it's either Carlos the Jackal or the writer. DrH seems to be advocating that we lynch outside of us two before we make this decision. Doctor, are you really so sure of shann that you think he's more likely to be mafia than a 50/50 between myself and darmousseh? Town can't afford to mislynch. Of course, I know I'm town, so I think it's safer to lynch darmousseh. I agree that shann is suspicious, but I feel we simply have less to go on there.
darmousseh is lying about your post behavior, you were the one to make the case on jackal58 in the first place. he's using deceptive practices and operating under the assumption that we all believe he is town. Why? Because he made a case on pandain like an hour before Pandain got shot to clear darmousseh's name? That's absurd.
Shann's post behavior is atrociously scummy though. I believe the clues from day 2 are pointing toward shann. So I want to wait until day 3 to see who is the scum between you and darmousseh.
|
On February 06 2011 12:31 Incognito wrote:
This deserves some post-game commentary by me.
I'll do some too.
Btw, you willing to do a bit of post-game commentary for XXXVI?
|
On February 06 2011 12:42 LSB wrote:Show nested quote +On February 06 2011 12:31 Incognito wrote:
This deserves some post-game commentary by me. I'll do some to. Btw, you willing to do a bit of post-game commentary for XXXVI?
Sorry, I'm not following that game.
|
Oh shit, I just realized that I pulled a quote from shann in my above post (which certainly doesn't help him, but still, it helps to keep people straight  ). My bad there. Here:
On January 30 2011 03:35 darmousseh wrote:Show nested quote +On January 30 2011 02:03 Node wrote:While I agree that "disappeared in a giant burst of gravel" would seem to point towards Gaara, I don't think the story as a whole fits him that much. I don't know too much about the character, I'm just going by the Wikipedia article. Is there any plot in Naruto that mirrors the events in the day post at all? On January 26 2011 08:50 LSB wrote:
Each day post will be about one mafia. It won't be obvious, but it will be pretty specific once you figure out what is happening.
One idea I have for a day post is a Sherlock Holmes story.
A typical Sherlock Holmes story gives you enough info that you figure out everything that is happening, and then Holmes explains what happens. What if I gave you a Sherlock Holmes story, but killed off Sherlock before he could explain what happened? There's all the information, and its up to you to figure out what happened.
EDIT: The clues will be much more specific than XXXVI. Once you figure it out what the day post is about, it will point to one person, but the problem is figuring it out. This all seems to state that the story as a whole will point to a specific person, rather than there being a small reference slipped in somewhere. This makes me think that Carlos the Jackal is the best fit so far. I mean, it's a string of hostage situations caused by a terrorist organization. Does that sound like anybody else? Obviously I'll be a little biased since my character is gaara, but Gaara used sand and in all cases he always left behind traces of sand and thats it, he never any traces of blood. There was a character in naruto who was like gaara but used rocks, but he didn't have a big role and wasn't related to gaara at all. If the clues are anything like XXXVI, then usually the entire post is reference to the person and there are 5-6 clues which point directly to that person which fit the entire post, not a small portion. Carlos the jackal seems like a very good match so far. Yesterday was the wife's birthday, so today I will have time to read the thread and I'll try to find hints.
|
Could the clues you use reference something semi-related to the character? Such as using the title of a song from a member of a band? Or using a paragraph from a book that someone wrote?
|
One other question The mafia got to choose a godfather. Is his alignment revelead upon death? There is no information in the OP about the godfather other than mafia get to choose one.. I want to be sure we aren't being tricked by any flip so far.
|
On February 06 2011 14:09 darmousseh wrote:
One other question The mafia got to choose a godfather. Is his alignment revelead upon death? There is no information in the OP about the godfather other than mafia get to choose one.. I want to be sure we aren't being tricked by any flip so far.
There is no Godfather
On February 06 2011 13:52 darmousseh wrote:
Could the clues you use reference something semi-related to the character? Such as using the title of a song from a member of a band? Or using a paragraph from a book that someone wrote?
Paragraph from a book is stretching it.
|
On February 06 2011 12:47 Incognito wrote:Show nested quote +On February 06 2011 12:42 LSB wrote:On February 06 2011 12:31 Incognito wrote:
This deserves some post-game commentary by me. I'll do some to. Btw, you willing to do a bit of post-game commentary for XXXVI? Sorry, I'm not following that game.
Foolishness is! I volunteer him for post game commentary of XXXVI!
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/5gf4q.jpg)
