|
On January 25 2011 10:39 Jackal58 wrote:Show nested quote +On January 25 2011 10:31 Pandain wrote:
Yeah, so at the very least what do we find out:
Keeping in mind its day 1, meaning I'm only 60-75% sure he's town, meaning theres still a chance he's mafia. And at the very least a useless townie.
Keeping in mind that if BC, who i thought was green, died, then it would be as if we started off a townie down, and mafia got a free hit.
Keeping in mind that its better at the very least to lynch than not lynch, when a modkill won't gurantee us any information...
I don't see why you're so insistent on believing I'm mafia. Either your scum or tunneling, and need to think. A lynch puts us into an almost immediate lylo on day 2. Why would a townie do that?
Okay I'm sorry I don't have knowledge in hindsight to aid me.
You can tell the atmosphere of panic, there wasn't much time to think. What your saying is what would've been "ideal". Just because I didn't do that, and keep in mind no one even mentioned not lynching, so it was on NO ONE's mind. So why do you think I am to blame?
This is why I am a sad panda sometimes. Because I'm the most active, I get the blame for everything.
|
On January 25 2011 10:47 Pandain wrote:Show nested quote +On January 25 2011 10:39 Jackal58 wrote:On January 25 2011 10:31 Pandain wrote:
Yeah, so at the very least what do we find out:
Keeping in mind its day 1, meaning I'm only 60-75% sure he's town, meaning theres still a chance he's mafia. And at the very least a useless townie.
Keeping in mind that if BC, who i thought was green, died, then it would be as if we started off a townie down, and mafia got a free hit.
Keeping in mind that its better at the very least to lynch than not lynch, when a modkill won't gurantee us any information...
I don't see why you're so insistent on believing I'm mafia. Either your scum or tunneling, and need to think. A lynch puts us into an almost immediate lylo on day 2. Why would a townie do that? Okay I'm sorry I don't have knowledge in hindsight to aid me. You can tell the atmosphere of panic, there wasn't much time to think. What your saying is what would've been "ideal". Just because I didn't do that, and keep in mind no one even mentioned not lynching, so it was on NO ONE's mind. So why do you think I am to blame? This is why I am a sad panda sometimes. Because I'm the most active, I get the blame for everything.
Your activity hasn't been an issue. But the day 1 lynch can only be explained in 1 way. Well 2 but option 2 doesn't seem to fit. If I'm wrong it's only because you pulled an exceptionally bonehead play at the end of day 1 that guaranteed 3 dead town at the start of day 2. What else am I supposed to think?
|
On January 25 2011 11:02 Jackal58 wrote:Show nested quote +On January 25 2011 10:47 Pandain wrote:On January 25 2011 10:39 Jackal58 wrote:On January 25 2011 10:31 Pandain wrote:
Yeah, so at the very least what do we find out:
Keeping in mind its day 1, meaning I'm only 60-75% sure he's town, meaning theres still a chance he's mafia. And at the very least a useless townie.
Keeping in mind that if BC, who i thought was green, died, then it would be as if we started off a townie down, and mafia got a free hit.
Keeping in mind that its better at the very least to lynch than not lynch, when a modkill won't gurantee us any information...
I don't see why you're so insistent on believing I'm mafia. Either your scum or tunneling, and need to think. A lynch puts us into an almost immediate lylo on day 2. Why would a townie do that? Okay I'm sorry I don't have knowledge in hindsight to aid me. You can tell the atmosphere of panic, there wasn't much time to think. What your saying is what would've been "ideal". Just because I didn't do that, and keep in mind no one even mentioned not lynching, so it was on NO ONE's mind. So why do you think I am to blame? This is why I am a sad panda sometimes. Because I'm the most active, I get the blame for everything. Your activity hasn't been an issue. But the day 1 lynch can only be explained in 1 way. Well 2 but option 2 doesn't seem to fit. If I'm wrong it's only because you pulled an exceptionally bonehead play at the end of day 1 that guaranteed 3 dead town at the start of day 2. What else am I supposed to think?
Wtf?
How am I in charge of LSB's death?
How am I in charge of BC's deatH?
I'm not even in charge of Shockkeys death, I didn't even want that.
Furthormore, Shockkey was going to be lynched BEFORE I did anything. In fact, I only ALMOST saved him.
|
If I was mafia, by your logic, I should've just let shockkey die.
Why, one hour beforehand, would I change.
Some people have said because I wanted to "kill a more active townie" but really I just wanted to save shockkey.
|
You were aware that there was going to be a mod kill plus a night kill. Why add a lynch? The names aren't important. The numbers are.
|
So how does the night kill affect me?
The mod kill just left us with a townie dead and no info. It's as if we started off a day late.
You're missing the point of day1:information. That's really the main thing about day 1. And lynches provide a crucial part.
I didn't want Shockkey to be lynched, I wanted LSB to be lynched(who I was wrong about on day 1). I tried to save shockkey an hour before(why would i do that as mafia). However, because I didn't want us to end up in the "one day later" scenario, I voted shockkey so at least in the 30-40% chance he was mafia, we would gain info. And in the scenario that he was town, we would still be instutituing the "no lurking" policy.
I'm sorry that I didn't realize it brought us to lylo. But as I'm going to point out again, no one else did.
And really, if you don't even acknowledge the possibility of what I'm saying is true, I give up  -
|
btw if hesmyrr is modkilled town loses me thinks
|
FREEAGLELAND26781 Posts
Vote Tally for Day 2
Nemesis (3): Pandain, GMarshal, Barundar
Pandain (3): Nemesis, Jackal58, Chaoser
Jackal58 (1): GGQ
Hesmyrr needs to vote or will face the lightning. You have about thirty minutes.
|
FREEAGLELAND26781 Posts
Hesmyrr has been replaced by kitaman27.
|
Bzzz, Pandain/jackal you guys are just repeating the same thing over and over again -.-
|
Again we are faced with a tie. Mod kill has apparently been averted.
I'm going to be brutally honest and say that towns best interest atm is to allow the tie to go forward.
|
On January 25 2011 11:43 Nemesis wrote:
Bzzz, Pandain/jackal you guys are just repeating the same thing over and over again -.-
Sorry. I've tried to stop but I'm like a moth to the flame.
|
kitaman27
United States9245 Posts
Trying to read through the thread real quick......if someone wants to summarize the current situation that would be helpful ^_^
|
On January 25 2011 11:43 Jackal58 wrote:
Again we are faced with a tie. Mod kill has apparently been averted.
I'm going to be brutally honest and say that towns best interest atm is to allow the tie to go forward.
Back from class. I concur, lets let it tie, it buys us a day and lets us have better chances at finding mafia.
|
On January 25 2011 11:46 kitaman27 wrote:
Trying to read through the thread real quick......if someone wants to summarize the current situation that would be helpful ^_^
Me- No You
Pandain- No You.
|
On January 25 2011 11:46 chaoser wrote:Show nested quote +On January 25 2011 11:43 Jackal58 wrote:
Again we are faced with a tie. Mod kill has apparently been averted.
I'm going to be brutally honest and say that towns best interest atm is to allow the tie to go forward. Back from class. I concur, lets let it tie, it buys us a day and lets us have better chances at finding mafia.
I'm willing to admit that if I'm wrong on Pandain town loses. If we only lose one to NK we are still in control of our destiny with a much higher percentage of a righteous lynch tomorrow.
|
And where the hell is ggq?
It doesn't seem like he's going to show up until last minute like last time :/
|
He voted for me earlier today.
|
Pandain instead of WIFOMing all this time about why you are NOT scum.
Maybe, you should follow your advice and scumhunt.
|
United States22154 Posts
do you guys all want to switch our votes to ggq now? 
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
