TL Mafia XXXV - Voting Thread

On December 28 2010 01:00 annul wrote:


what is the point of this post? acting as if he is mafia to create the impression he is not mafia? WIFOM surely, but think about it



what is the point of this? instant attempt to form a wagon on someone who hasnt even posted yet and the game had just started?





two posts to seem active and he answers his own question a minute later. point of this?



"should we lynch an inactive?" <-- probably knows mafia is most likely to at least pay attention to the thread enough to evade being labeled inactive. probably knows even if there are mafia inactives, he can choose any other town inactive and maintain the aura of "hey im helping out town"

the rest of this is informative sure, but common sense? but the line "We should therefore push to lynch an inactive day one." worries me. much better to hit an active scummy person and LSB should know this.

"DO NOT CLAIM" is good advice, and i would like to say obvious, but given current history and shit it isnt =\






1 and 2 are fine, 3 is not - you don't claim here, you just admit to being hit - preferably to town circle if you know where it is. 4 is a catch-all sure, but claiming day 1 to a "super awesome plan" is a horrible idea.

that said though, LSB is providing pure information (some of which is sketchy) and no analysis. this early it is usually fine but consider it in the light of his earlier postings? it is like he wants to be active but isnt contributing valuable stuff.




common sense information




fair question!



?



more "hit inactives" crap - this is bad. also maybe a blue fish?





wants to write a day post. uh huh. keep this in mind with the "try to appear active but not" lens.



HEY something of content, cool. sort of defense of pandain and blatant defense of mr. wiggles. sadly the rationale of "inactives instead!" is scummy.




dunno how to analyze this -- information that isnt common sense (or meant to filibuster) is fine, and even i didnt know this one. id say this gets a pass




yes, lets lynch people with zero meaningful posts. LSB, you up?

or yes lets lynch a modkill target because those are almost certainly going to be town and we want to lynch towns, yes.



you too.



good idea, i like this, but why sign up and then insta modkill on purpose? if youre replaced its not like you can consider any potential wins by the mafia as wins for you -- you are considered not to have even played the game. seems like something nobody should ever do on purpose and if they do, metagaming at its finest.

buuuut then we haaaave.....



"DONT WORRY ABOUT BEING INACTIVE LOL" after his entire campaign day 1 was "kill the inactives" -- whaaaat? what is this inconsistency?



yes coagulation got a 14 day ban on purpose to "help" his mafia team day 1, this makes perfect sense.




*****************

in conclusion, LSB has been making pure nonposts and/or pure informative posts without analysis, with the two exceptions being his insistence on the "kill inactives" theme and his defenses of pandain and mr. wiggles. yet he has like 30 posts up while saying almost absolutely nothing.

my vote is on LSB now.