Harry Potter Mafia!

On December 11 2010 10:48 Beneather wrote:


But realistically then what's the point of being MoM if your just going to allow people to choose to vote. I trust in the MoM to make the correct decision. Everyone is going to say I will lynch the person you all tell me to lynch what else can you bring to this table since we need an good MoM that we can trust.

On December 11 2010 11:27 LSB wrote:


Pick Your Power Mafia 2!: I picked traitor.

On December 11 2010 10:42 zeks wrote:
If I get selected Minister of Magic you guys can just vote for whoever and I'll lynch the person with the most votes regardless of situation. So basically everyone gets a say in who dies first.

Since the Minster of Magic is essentially the same as everyone else after the first lynch if elected I'll gladly step back down. I'm asking for your votes to ensure the most democratic way of deciding first lynch.

On December 13 2010 06:50 LSB wrote:

For the list of Death Eaters
I think it's pretty obvious that Parvati Patil and Padma Patil are either Siblings or Masons.

On December 13 2010 09:29 CubEdIn wrote:


From all these 5, I'd have to pick either ilovejonn or aidinai. I already stated why I find ilovejonn suspicious. And if he flips red, we can go for deconduo as well.
And as much as I don't like LSB's play, his argument on Aidinai seems decent, and when he attacked deconduo he said I voted for him "nonchalantly", when I was pretty clear of my motives.

So either one would be fine with me.

On December 13 2010 10:32 LunarDestiny wrote:
Again, I don't have a clear lynch choice. But I want to ask Aidnai if he can prove his innocence with his role. If he can and promise to do so within maybe a day of game time, then we should give him the chance to prove himself.

Pandain's sudden post after Meapak calling him out as a lynch possibility is weird. Pandain in all other mafia games tends to be more talkative.

On December 13 2010 11:50 GGQ wrote:


Snape may be mafia with a town-sided alternate win condition? Perhaps to keep Harry alive or something along those lines? I just can't see any of the other characters as mafia.

Gildetroy Lockhart seems more like a third party to me, as well as Moaning Myrtle (if there's a fool or village idiot in the game, I'd bet it's her). If they win with town then I'm sure they have alternate winning conditions.

We were told to pay attention to the last line of annul's posts. I believe that this time we are supposed to get a hint from:



This suggests that each day in this game is going to be equivalent to a year in Harry Potter world. If Day 1 was Philosopher's Stone then Day 2 will be Chamber of Secrets. This also suggests that character's loyalties may change over time. Characters who were significant in Chamber of Secrets were Gilderoy Lockhard, Moaning Myrtle, Nicholas de Mimsy-Porpington, and Colin Creevey. One or more of these characters may have some sort of agenda for next day.

if draco wins by any manner, and is alive when he does so, both lucius malfoy and narcissa malfoy also win. you are not allowed to tell anybody (even your parents) about this ability until dawn of day 6

On December 14 2010 09:44 kitaman27 wrote:


Will those who are hit even be informed that they were hit?

On December 14 2010 12:39 LunarDestiny wrote:

This gave me a thought. Annul say that we can not name claim. But what if those who are in mini-groups group/house claim. Lets discuss if group claiming is a good choice.

On December 14 2010 10:10 Amber[LighT] wrote:
i took a hit last night. (1 of 2 lives)

If a medic protected someone else it would be a very good idea for them to contact that person to start a mini-circle.