|
On November 16 2010 06:23 LSB wrote:
WTF. Lynching for information?
Didn't I already tell you that was a stupid idea?
How many times do I have to say this.
Lynching for information only applies to whether to lynch or to not. And right now your saying we shouldn't lynch, which is stupid, because lynching provides us information. Obviously lynching a specific person over another person for information is stupid, but I'm not talking about that.
And screw that whole segondou thing right now. We have only like 30 minutes left here.
|
On November 16 2010 06:28 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
kenpachis posting behavior is consistent with his town play, extremely so. nothing about him says scum to me.
lynch ym imo. if no one thinks he's scummy then I'll put my vote on kenpachi. a lynch is better than no lynch.
I acknowledge that kenpachi has been uncontributive in the past, but that is partly why I'm lynching him over others. Mainly I'm really in the dark as who to lynch, so am just offering analysis of those I think are suscipcious. People say to lynch coag because "hes the worst" but he has been far more helpful then kenpachi.
Also I'm not going to vote YM just because I am unsure as to your alignment, which you should be proud you convince me more so your town. Albeit YM could just be trying to push a Dr. H bandwagon, thinking he certainly has my vote and thinking he only needs to get one more. But right now I'm on the fence as to both of you.
|
On November 16 2010 06:29 DoctorHelvetica wrote:Show nested quote +On November 16 2010 06:25 Pandain wrote:On November 16 2010 06:23 LSB wrote:
WTF. Lynching for information?
Didn't I already tell you that was a stupid idea? How many times do I have to say this. Lynching for information only applies to whether to lynch or to not. And right now your saying we shouldn't lynch, which is stupid, because lynching provides us information. Obviously lynching a specific person over another person for information is stupid, but I'm not talking about that. And screw that whole segondou thing right now. We have only like 30 minutes left here. weren't you the person who first said i should be lynched for information? lol...
That's because I was saying we should lynch for information, and then LSB gave the hypothetical "Say we lynch Dr. H, what information would we get." The most important things being your alignment, but also subtle clues as to others, which still applies. But again, that's not one person over another, that's just lynching in general.
|
|
|
watch he shoots lsb.
that would be hilarious.
|
On November 16 2010 07:27 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
he's probably gonna shoot me and that'll be GG for the town
except it won't be because it'll be 7v2 still.
Actually I'm thinking this would be preffered. Cause then it would be 2 confirmed already, and I know I am(so i guess 3 confirmed for each respective player.)
|
going off your assumption of course, that your town.
|
On November 16 2010 08:18 DoctorHelvetica wrote:Show nested quote +On November 16 2010 08:02 Pandain wrote:On November 16 2010 07:27 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
he's probably gonna shoot me and that'll be GG for the town except it won't be because it'll be 7v2 still. Actually I'm thinking this would be preffered. Cause then it would be 2 confirmed already, and I know I am(so i guess 3 confirmed for each respective player.) Honestly I think mass roleclaim might be the best idea. There will be inconsistencies with 2 of the roles, meaning there will be 4 possible liars. Then we just have to analyse those peoples posting behavior. What do you think?
Then they take over other people, probably the best roles, whilst we have no other idea who is now scum :/
|
You know what might be possible though, just doing it like in the day. Then we'll have at the very least a 50% chance, probably more based on analysis/LSB's list of confirmed.
|
Haha wow.
Way to reveal me LSB. I'm shrink, protected myself.
*sigh
|
On November 18 2010 06:19 Glasse wrote:
ok, i'm actually flash. pandain is a fucking liar rofl.
kthez or coag are mafia
And we caught the second mafia.
|
Rofl Glasse
So, your the "real" flash, but you went against the town consensus and protected yourself night one?
And you immediately roleclaimed, when in the scenario you were the real flash you wouldn't, and at the very least would've waited a bit.
|
|
|
On November 18 2010 06:23 Glasse wrote:
facepalm, please dont believe him :3
who cares if i went against the town consensus, i thought i should protect myself until i know more and not chance having mafia get 3 because their sacrifice didnt actually die
Again, not what a real townie would do. We had already established LSB was innocent, so why would you,if the "real" shrink not protect him?
"Who cares if I went against the town consensus"
"Don't believe him please"
Such great arguments, but sadly its already GG.
|
On November 18 2010 06:27 LSB wrote:
Dude, your night 1 play was smart. As mafia would obviosly not try to convert me.
And Don't play attention to Pandain.
Coagulation and KtheZ can you please claim?
Please glasse, pandain, don't post untill they reply. Lets get all the cards down before we commit to an All In
Please, LSB. Like Doctor H said, your smart. You should realize I'm the real shrink.
1. His reasons for protecting you were that you "weren't confirmed"
2. If he gets me killed, he can just yazuka a random person since there will be no other person. At first I was perplexed why he fake claimed so early, but now I understand that now there will be no other person to stop him from yazuking.
|
And I have full faith I'll be able to get him lynched so we win, since he has already messed up several ways.
1.Keeps suggesting you could be fake, while saying he protected himself because he didn't believe you, and he still doesn't believe you now, yet he "protected LSB second night."
2.He immediately claims he's shrink, which suggests either
1.He's VERY VERY VERY VERY rash. or
2.He's thought this out already, and knows what to do(try to get me lynched)
You tracked me night one, that lends credence to me. What does Glasse have? His word?
|
On November 16 2010 07:15 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
I'm feeling Glasse/Kenpachi right now as the scumteam.
Dr. H accuses him, glasse accuses back and tries to make Dr. H seem less credible.
On November 16 2010 10:25 Glasse wrote:Show nested quote +On November 16 2010 10:22 LSB wrote:
What do you think of the Pandain/Doctor H argument? i think drh is trying much harder than i've ever seen him which makes me believe hes trying to hide something.
And yes, I want glasse to respond to all this.
I'll do an analysis hopefully after I get back from this political group thingamabobber, but until then I'll just be pointing out inconsitincies/proofs.
|
On November 18 2010 06:43 LSB wrote:
Pandain please let it be, I have a way of figuring this out
All I need is Coag and KtheZ to claim
alright...
|
Actually case 2 is impossible. Since Coag already claimed to have protected you, and not glasse, therefore both mafia couldn't have used conversion.
For case 2, I'm not lying, and I've basically shown that Glasse is lying(He hasn't even responded to that.).
For case 3, there is a 33% chance of winning if we lynch Coag. You're saying I have to accurately guess who he will mind control. Leaving it up to that should not be done. Lynching Glasse is safer in that point.
So really, it comes down to me vs. Glasse again. And I've already basically shown why Glasse is lying, and how he has already screwed up.
So your right, either me and coag are mafia, or glasse is the sole mafia remaining. And I agree with the dead Dr. H that its glasse/kenpachi.
Lynching Glasse is actually better.
|
On November 18 2010 10:31 KtheZ wrote:
Hey guys, I'd like to bring the town's attention to the fact that LSB may be mafia.
So this is how the last night went:
Claims:
Pandain protected himself that night.
LSB says kenpachi visited artanis and pandain.
Coag claims doctor, protected LSB.
Glasse = shrink, saved LSB night 2.
Now here is the interesting part.
So we have a disreptancy between Glasse and Pandain's claims.
Now what is extremely feasibly possible is that Glasse is yakuza, and kenpachi actually MCed LSB.
What has made me notice this POSSIBILITY is that we cannot be sure LSB is actually still one of us. What we need to know is if pandain and/or glasse are telling the truth.
So heres how I think we should go.
Lynch pandain. Then, we know if glasse really is the shrink or not.
If pandain flips blue, we immediately lynch Glasse and LSB.
If pandain flips red, artanis and glasse are confirmed.
In LSB's post above me, it is not noted that he may have been converted, instead of pandain.
I think that the best course of action is to lynch pandain. If he flips blue, we immediately take out glasse/LSB.
If he flips red, we got rid of one of the reds, and we have 1 less person to worry about, as well as buying ourselves much more time to find the second red.
##Vote: Pandain
Sorry dude, but if ur town know that your death was not in vain.
impossible. Doctor would have had to protect glasse for that to work. And Coag would therefore have to be lying. And in that scenario there would be 3 mafia(coag, lsb,glasse) when only two could be possibe.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
