EPTAnyone have any issues with this plan?
Also, no one wants to lynch you BM. That would be a terrible move for the town.
Pick Your Power Mafia! - Page 14
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Radfield
Canada2720 Posts
Anyone have any issues with this plan? Also, no one wants to lynch you BM. That would be a terrible move for the town. | ||
|
d3_crescentia
United States4054 Posts
| ||
|
Korynne
Canada990 Posts
Qatol claims he didn't get copy cat. Next. | ||
|
d3_crescentia
United States4054 Posts
| ||
|
Falcynn
United States3597 Posts
On May 03 2010 05:11 JeeJee wrote: also note, so far in this thread, the following people have claimed they don't have a role: korynne - important role (not inv or rb) above him jonny - silly caller - silly falcynn - silly qatol - copy above him opz - comp vig above him i'm wondering why y'all revealed this info, but i imagine some of you are lying as docs or something which also sets up nice mindgames. if you're all telling the truth though then /facepalm While I was skimming through the thread I noticed this post On May 02 2010 08:32 Qatol wrote: *snip* The non-claimants are: L's replacement Falcynn ~Opz~ Amnesia Scamp and assumed somehow that Ace might've posted something revealing who hadn't claimed a role yet, so I was explaining why I didn't claim. Afterward I realized that Ace didn't mention anything about who claimed/who didn't, but I can't edit my post obviously so I just left it. Anyways, is my alignment cop idea really that bad and that's why no one's mentioned it? Or did everyone just miss it? | ||
|
DarthThienAn
United States2734 Posts
| ||
|
DarthThienAn
United States2734 Posts
So lynching someone to figure that out is bad imo. | ||
|
Foolishness
United States3044 Posts
Now we can tell the inventor to give someone bulletproof vests or whatever, but it'll be near impossible to know if he's actually going to do it, since he can invent whatever he wants. And it'll be very unlikely we catch him if he's got his own agenda. Say for example, he's giving guns to people and killing more people during the night. He can blame it on the SK or the Jack (and maybe the jack would counterclaim he didn't, but it'd still be messy). I am not in favor of sacking a person to figure out alignment. First off we don't even know if there even is an alignment cop (it's reasonable to assume there is though). Most importantly, there's only 1 alignment cop in the game. In past mafia games I've seen, when cops didn't know their sanity, plans like this worked well because there'd be multiple cops (3 usually), and they'd all be able to figure out their alignment (or at least get close to it). With only 1 cop, it seems a waste of time to try to agree on someone to lynch in advance. On May 03 2010 06:36 d3_crescentia wrote: Why shouldn't we make Bill and Foolishness claim? Should one of them be the CompVig, we lynch him and put that power into Qatol's hands. Our Medic protect can then go on the remaining guy. The Tracker can then follow Qatol on Night 2 and report if he saw two visits from Qatol. I suppose the Mafia can always refuse to use their NK if Qatol's gunning for them. I think it goes without saying that claiming early always benefits the mafia. Although it's quite easy to read between the lines in this game -_- | ||
|
Ace
United States16096 Posts
Voting ends in ~4 hours. | ||
|
Falcynn
United States3597 Posts
On May 03 2010 07:30 DarthThienAn wrote: Ah I see, guess I just suck at reading comprehension =/Also, we only have one cop who would need to figure out his sanity - the role cop and JOAT are auto-sane. So lynching someone to figure that out is bad imo. | ||
|
Korynne
Canada990 Posts
Now looking at it this way, it feels like Qatol's plan was a terrible idea. Dx | ||
|
Foolishness
United States3044 Posts
On May 03 2010 08:25 Korynne wrote: Inventor and Compulsive Vigilante are NOT easy to keep track of. As in, if Foolishness and BM are not said roles but are instead mafia, they can easily pass the roles to someone else and that person will carry out the roles (as town directs them to). We definitely must check them for alignment. Now looking at it this way, it feels like Qatol's plan was a terrible idea. Dx Did you read my post? How is compulsive vigi not easy to keep track of? If he/she doesn't kill who we vote on, we lynch him. Everyone keeps saying he's deadly in the hands of the mafia but the only way he is is if the town is in a "need to lynch mafia or game is over" scenario (or close to it I guess). Otherwise compulsive vigi is just giving the town a double lynch. Yes, if the compulsive vigi is mafia, we don't have much way of knowing, but there are far worse concerns right now. Inventor can pretty much do whatever he wants. Qatol wants him to give bulletproof vests to people. I'm all for that. However we only get to know the invention, and not specifically how it works. A clever inventor can think up something which may look beneficial to the town, but could be helping the mafia. | ||
|
Caller
Poland8075 Posts
| ||
|
Korynne
Canada990 Posts
| ||
|
johnnyspazz
Taiwan1470 Posts
| ||
|
[NyC]HoBbes
United States803 Posts
1)- It allows the wisdom of the many, and hopefully the wisdom of the not-mafia, to influence these roles, and lessens the chances that they will inadvertently aid the mafia. 2)- it allows us to know immediately if one of these roles is being played by a mafia player, in the case that they do not follow the town's instructions. | ||
|
Foolishness
United States3044 Posts
| ||
|
Caller
Poland8075 Posts
i think he's scum ##fos on d3 | ||
|
sidesprang
Norway1033 Posts
Vote on who the compulsive vigilante should kill, forces a mafia CV to play on our terms or look scummy. A doctor can also block this kill if we feel its needed. Many ppl have supported this idea and there is no drawback in using it. Decide what the inventor should invent, its hard to keep tabs on the inventor but that role is far to powerful to be left completely alone. And since the day post tells us what is invented we can figure out if he is lying. Bulletproof vests sounds awesome, our strength is numbers and reducing hits is a good thing. We should NOT talk about who should get the vests imo as that only makes the mafia not hit that guy. As for who to lynch is there a vote thread or do we just write it like qatol did ? if so ## vote : Amnesia if you check his post he made one post right after getting our alignment and one post right after getting our role where he said nothing of worth. Seems like he follows the game but won't say anything. Might not be too fishy but I don't know what else to go after at this point. | ||
flamewheel
FREEAGLELAND26782 Posts
Frankenstein shall be my first creation~ | ||
| ||
